HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

knaik94

2,593 karma · joined September 29, 2015

knaik1994 a.t gmail d(o)t com github knaik twitter @knaikk
submissionscomments
knaik94··on New cognitive skills in the age of AI tailored information
I had a very different experience searching for the same information. It gave me the answer all three times, the first two were on "balanced" and the third was on "precise". Initially I asked it with some context, the same words I would use to do the search myself. It seems pointless to search something I wouldn't do myself. I refreshed and tried your exact query and got a more detailed answer, refreshed and tried again and got the correct complete answer using "precise". The third time included the same links as the second time, I just didn't include them in the picture.

If you prompt it with a better query, you'll get a better response.

The second search it went into much more detail, although I refreshed, it seems like searching the same thing again forces a regenerated longer response.

https://i.imgur.com/CnjCsa6.png

https://i.imgur.com/0ZoapDK.png

https://i.imgur.com/7KH7zIv.png

knaik94··on Sounding the Secrets of AudioLM
The difference between those thought experiments and the LLMs I'm working with, is the fact that I can test LLMs and myself empirically. I don't feel that I can tell apart human and AI writing with more than 70% confidence. As these models get better, I feel it's going to approach 0%. And especially for writing on topics I am not familiar with. Since the simulation hypothesis arguments aren't directly testable, they don't feel scientific. I personally also have problems with the implication of the existence of conscious greater power. And so it doesn't give me the same existential panic thinking about the future of AI generated content does. I never took the time to read the original paper by Bostrom, thank you for the link.

Edit: I should have used the word disprovable instead of testable.

knaik94··on Sounding the Secrets of AudioLM
Cleaning audio data is impossibly harder than text data.
knaik94··on Sounding the Secrets of AudioLM
I think audio model will be much more sensitive to input issues relative to text or art. Humans are very good at picking up the nuances in audio and also process it very quickly. I wonder how far we are from being able to manipulate the emotions of how something sounds. In my opinion, that's the turing test for any audio generative AI. Native speakers will immediately know when something is AI generated or adjusted for the same reason they immediately detect accents.

I am curious what kind of audio repair AI models are being worked to help make outputs sound more natural. This research feels like progress towards that goal as well.

knaik94··on Sounding the Secrets of AudioLM
I think this is off-topic since it's not discussing the content of post. But I agree it's worth discussing.

I don't agree, I think ChatGPT may have been part of the editing process but not in the primary draft. The intro is complex in a way that I haven't ever noticed in ChatGPT output. I have a suspicion that participating in academic-ish/research discussions pushes you to use very specific language. This matches the goal for ChatGPT, to produce neutral and clinical sounding answers.

I had some existential concerns about not knowing whether I was just AI, and read similar sentiment from others in some other AI posts. ChatGPT describes its personality using the same descriptions people used to describe my work in the past. There's no meaningful insight you can gain from that parallel, other than that it's good at mirroring the sentiment of the user. [1]

I put my own past HN comments in the AI detectors from OpenAI and GPTZero, and I got a few false positive where it indicated "possibly" to "completely" written by AI. The comments are from years ago. In case you're curious, I didn't use AI in any part of the process of writing and edit this comment. I'm not using grammerly or even spellcheck, so excuse any mistakes you find. I've been thinking a lot about the 1995 Ghost in the Shell: "What if a cyber brain could possibly generate its own ghost, create a soul all by itself? And if it did, just what would be the importance of being human then?”

1. https://twitter.com/Knaikk/status/1624728297090306050

Those pics are out of order, I asked the house question first, then sharing traits, then about itself, then fictional characters. I didn't intentionally try to guide its answers.

knaik94··on Ask HN: Does Google use the text inside gdocs and Gmail for training AI models?
No it does not, it would be irresponsible to do that on private data. There's a very clear line between data posted publicly and data held privately, especially in terms of copyright. I doubt it will ever be default opt-in for something as sensitive e-mail and docs.

One exception to that is scanning for CSAM and Terrorism and DMCA. And with DMCA, it's automated based on file hash, and you still maintain access to your files, you are just limited from sharing them. Ads in gmail aren't based on content, but other online activity while logged in.

I think the other exception to that is smart compose. AI models do use email content for training data, but the output of those are strictly for use locally while writing emails. I imagine it's also siloed per user.

EDIT: Not a google employee, I apologize if my assertions seem too strong.

EDIT2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federated_learning

"We have always maintained that you control your data and we process it according to the agreement(s) we have with you. Furthermore, we will not and cannot look at it without a legitimate need to support your use of the service -- and even then it is only with your permission. Here are some of the additional measures we take to ensure your privacy: (reference: GCP Terms).

In addition to these commitments, for AI/ML development, we don’t use data that you provide us to train our own models without your permission. And if you want to work together to develop a solution using any of our AI/ML products, by default our teams will work only with data that you have provided and that has identifying information removed. We work with your raw data only with your consent and where the model development process requires it. "

https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/g...

https://support.google.com/mail/answer/6603?hl=en

https://arxiv.org/abs/1906.00080

https://ai.googleblog.com/2017/04/federated-learning-collabo...

knaik94··on Goodbye, passwords (1Password Passkey support)
My threat model accounts for leaked passwords, even if you are able to identify the system I use, you would have to iterate through ~8! possiblities minimum per account. There's no underlying patterns that allow for shortcuts. There's nothing wrong with a system as long as you can't guess the system by comparing multiple leaked passwords. I don't see how it could weaken security significantly if your system includes randomness in some sense. For example, the order in which you might place words and special characters or the letter placements which you substitute.

It's absolutely possible to have a system without weakning security. But that might fundamentally have the same considerations that rolling your own crypto solution would. I was thinking about those very same mistakes when making my system. I expected that a technical crowd like HN would care about stricter privacy, but I continue to be surprised.

The threat model I assume is the reason why I would never use passkeys. From the responses I have gotten, my threat model seems stricter than average. Using a manager generated password feels like security through obscurity. As does using a single point of failure piece of hardware where I can't backup the secret. I don't want to use a "virtual" passkey that is attached to a MS or Google or Apple login, especially for replacing passwords. A secret I don't control isn't my secret, similar to the idea of not your keys not your wallet when dealing with cryptocurrency. In this case, there's a very real price of privacy to pay for convenience.

knaik94··on Goodbye, passwords (1Password Passkey support)
Passwords.google counts 577 but I have a seperate set in firefox. Like everyone else that "knows" this many, there's a system. The major accounts don't have a system, I have around 25 accounts with 2F enabled, plus a few financial accounts that all have uniquely created passwords. I absolutely do use a password manager. I don't need to rely on my system, but I will never use the auto-generated passwords.
knaik94··on Goodbye, passwords (1Password Passkey support)
Choosing unique passwords for your main accounts and then relying on the manager for the insignificant accounts is still an option. They're not mutually exclusive. That's not an option if you go the passwordless route.
knaik94··on Goodbye, passwords (1Password Passkey support)
I know all of my passwords, I don't reuse passwords, and I chose from the very beginning to never rely on auto-generated passwords. I would be fine without any kind of password manager.

You are making a lot of generalizations about how people interact with passwords. I don't have a single Yubikey, I use Aegis on android that allows me to generate codes and self manage backups of my 2FA secrets. It even supports DUO 2F, but I don't mess with DUO accounts because they are hotp and not totp so you will run into sync issues if your aren't careful. I do have the secret key backed up though.

My passwords are something I know. More importantly, even if you use a password manager, your master password is still something you know in the eyes of the law. That covers all passwords that are accessed using a master password as something you know. That's the whole point of multifactor, the second factor is irrelevant without the first. I could surrender all of the 2F secrets and it still wouldn't matter because a password is something I know.

Not knowing your passwords is a choice, which you are free to make, I made the opposite choice. I can understand not wanting to remember every password, but it's worth creating self chosen passwords for the critical accounts like google, microsoft, github, and financials, in my opinion. I use biometrics for my mobile OS, but biometrics are only enabled after first unlocking the phone with the pin/password. I use a traditional password for my pc.

knaik94··on Goodbye, passwords (1Password Passkey support)
Passkeys aren't protected when it comes to laws regarding self-incrimination and searches. Information encrypted and locked behind a password, something only you know, is protected.

Until laws surrounding biometrics are changed, I personally won't move to passkeys. There have been cases where biometrics have been protected under the same category as pins and passwords but there have also been cases where it was not.

https://www.concordlawschool.edu/blog/constitutional-law/fif...

knaik94··on The concept of Impostor Syndrome has become ubiquitous
How much of it do you remember now? How much of it do you care to remember long term? I know you weren't alone, I was one of those kids too, at certain times and certain tests. For most people, it was about pride, being able to say you didn't study or social standing and "coolness". Later in life I learned I have ADHD and that went a long way to explain a lot of my bad habits. I think it depends on the level of curriculum too. 11th and 12th, the last two years of HS for me, six out of my eight classes were AP/college weighted, the only exceptions were english and physical education.

Teachers absolutely tested stuff they didn't teach and they barely assigned homework, there was a lot of self-learning. I think it's relatively uncommon for schools to do this, but in 12th I took AP Physics C, calculus based physics, and we did both semesters over the school year, both Mech and E&M. We matched college pacing, and on both AP test I got 5s. I am so grateful to that teacher for getting that experience before starting college, he had a PhD in theortical physics. My science education was filled with teachers with PhDs while I was in high school.

People absolutely have to study when they are being challenged at an appropriate level. If I was in a non-accelerated curriculum, I think I would have agreed with you, because it would have matched my experience. But I took my first AP class in 10th grade, the second year of high school. There's no way to be successful in a hard science AP class without studying in one way or another. I remember some of my friends used to do the homework from one class in another and then say they didn't study. I am not disagreeing with your experience, I am disagreeing with your generalization.

knaik94··on The concept of Impostor Syndrome has become ubiquitous
You're not strictly describing intelligence, you're also describing symptoms that relate to ADHD. I wonder if there's a bias to categorize someone as more intelligent based on the contrast between someone's ability to focus and their ability to grasp complex ideas quickly. I struggle severly with ADHD and notice it all of the time, in how people's perception of me changes when we end up on a topic I know well and enjoy talking about.
knaik94··on The concept of Impostor Syndrome has become ubiquitous
I was reading the original paper where the idea was first presented and came across a footnote that demonstrated to just how far we've come in the last 40 years.

"The attribution research findings, summarized later, imply that the impostor phenomenon would be found less frequently in men than in women. We have noticed the phenomenon in men who appear to be more in touch with their “feminine” qualities. This clinical observation needs to be researched"

The whole point of feminism is equality, it doesn't make sense to then restrict experiences to a specific gender. I think the idea that "some feminist idea wasn't intended for" you is the wrong takeaway here. These ideas and frameworks are meaningful when they can be applied to improve your life, the intended audience isn't important. Otherwise it feels like it'll induce imposter syndrome for the concept of having imposter syndrome. If you feel that this struggle applies to you, then the idea was intended for you. One of the definitions of toxic femininity is shaming men for not being "manly" enough and more generally policing femininity in others.

That kind of othering is the reason why some people react so negatively to certain kinds of feminism, and it's why I don't call myself a feminist even if I work to promote feminist ideologies. Exclusionary feminism is not popular as a whole, but it is very vocal. I feel classifying resonating emotionally with the female experience as LGBT+ is continuing implicit toxic masculinity and femininity. Implicit bias surrounding these topics is completely dependent on the environment you were brought up in, and it's one of the hardest things to break when you are older. There absolutely is subjectivity in all of this, and there is value in classifying specific things as a feminine or masculine experience. But I dislike how strongly some people work to delineate the two. It feels wrong to intentionally create a minority out of people and behaviors that fit into both categories.

https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&d...

knaik94··on The concept of Impostor Syndrome has become ubiquitous
I feel less charitable. In the last couple of decades, there has been meaningful change in people adhering to traditional gender roles. Especially in the last 10 years, I have seen a huge push to break the cultural acceptance of toxic masculinity. Pretending that men would be less familiar or feel it less intensely, in this day and age, is continuing the underlying themes of toxic masculinity. It's not just disheartening, it's disrespectful. I understand arguing that it affects women disproportionately, but I can't understand arguing that it won't affect men. Even if you are immersed in feminist literature, you have to be aware of the changing gender norms.
knaik94··on The concept of Impostor Syndrome has become ubiquitous
It's related to pride, in my experience tutoring high school and college kids. That was my own experience while growing up as well, there's a sentiment that "natural" smartness and hard-working smartness are two seperate things.

I feel like kids have been moving away from this mindset, but maybe it's changed names. Growing up being a "nerd" was uncool, and studying was "nerdy". After college, I talked to some of the people who were the "naturally" smart kids and I found out they lied so much about how much time they spent not studying. Everyone lies. Part of it, I learned, was that my graduating class ended up with a lot of cut-throat people, they lied about how much work they put in to gatekeep. I don't speak to a single person from my graduating year now even though I am friends with some teachers as well as kids from other years. A similar concept but less isolated to academics has been kind of a popular "insult". I sometimes hear the concept of "sweaty" being uncool among the youngest ages I teach. Sweaty, as in working so hard towards something that you work up a sweat. It's doesn't have to be a physical activity, you can be called sweaty at video games, or sweaty at math.

Education is a weird place to use the word talent, looking back. You can't wake up knowing new information. Everyone has to learn, the people who look talented just learned it earlier than everyone else. I am not sure why hard working is seen as uncool at that age. I wonder if it's different in other parts of the world, I learned that I have a very typical north eastern USA experience.

knaik94··on Google Is Losing Control
I feel like there's some bigger mistake I missed regarding that controversy. People are aware of chatbots making things up. Microsoft had that poor AI Tay where users' adversarial prompts effectively courrupted its working dataset and it became racist. I know AI doesn't have feelings, and yet I still feel some sadness for how much it was attacked. Maybe because I liked the idea and wanted it to be successful.

Regardless of the validity, I think it's still fair to call it a mistake because of the ambiguity. Most people would misunderstand the answer to mean something it doesn't. But there was such a strong reaction in media about it, when I would have assumed most people wouldn't care. Google never promised an AI chatbot never got anything wrong, and no one I knew expected differently. It makes me think about how many other news stories, for things out of my field, are like the Bard situation. I'll just never know because I won't gain expertise in it.

knaik94··on Is A.I. Art Stealing from Artists?
I didn't indicate which way I care for the ruling to go. I think you're giving current AI models much more credit than they deserve. Additionally, it's hard to have enough computational power to run these models even if you have top of the line consumer hardware, and that's for generating a single frame.

NERFs are interesting from a film-making and art point of view. AI isn't going anywhere. Any sort of ruling would have zero impact on this kind of AI. Tech will move forward regardless of the ruling. The issue is about datasets, not the software itself. I expect all of the suits against the underlying technology to be dismissed. If the lawsuit is successful in blocking AI, it would have a lot of negative implications for fair use and be a gross mischaracterization of the underlying math.

I think we need a clear ruling on how copyright should be handled from things generated using AI. Once you modify it in some way, you clear the bar for making a transformative work, but the difficult questions is how and if the copyright of the input dataset applies to raw generated media.

No one is having the same discussion regarding the input and output of ChatGPT. Even the discussion against CoPilot is weak. But a ruling in a case will affect every other one. It's not really possible for laws to differentiate between text and photos, because photos are stored digitally as text. During my research, my PI explained to me that copyright work is fine to test with and make datasets with, but I can't include benchmarks against it or for it in my final paper. But the weights generated from such work is fine. This is only really a problem because these models are being used in commercial ways.

https://theaisummer.com/nerf/

knaik94··on Google Is Losing Control
To give Google some credit, I think people would have been equally upset if they did release an AI that ended up being used maliciously or without proper filters. Google has a habit of shipping things while they are still in beta. Gmail kept the "beta" label after launch for five years. Not releasing unfinished AI products was a calculated move and I think it was an overall good decision, but also an expensive one. I am just worried about the longevity of it, since Google clearly doesn't care to prioritize it. The Bard ad mistake implies a deeper issue about resources being allocated incorrectly.

OpenAI clearly spent a lot time red teaming the chatbot to make sure the outputs were sanitized. Chatbot as a service is an easy monetization strategy from big companies. I wonder if ChatGPT servers will share resources with Bing search servers, I can't imagine they will, but if they do, the paid subscription will be a lot more valuable. I think users will react extremely negatively if Bing AI results embed affiliate links on every response possible. On the other hand, I can see myself clicking links of products ChatGPT recommends if I am intetionally asking about some sort of product, like if I ask it types/differences of climbing carabiners.

Research is very collaborative, so I understand why those at Google stay there. But it seems like MS and OpenAI are prioritizing having a clear pathway for novel AI work to reach users, and it won't be limited only to implementations that will help serve ads better.

knaik94··on Google Is Losing Control
The bottleneck is clearly Google's hesitancy. ChatGPT is better because I can use it right now. I don't care how good the research demos are if I can't interact with them myself. Google has a track record of discontinuing products and having weird user/developer unfriendly policies.

One of the most recent was Chrome's plan to force manifest v3. But many of the features promised to devs from v3 wouldn't have been ready by the time v3 was supposed to release. I would approach Google's AI stuff with similar hesitancy as I would have approached Stadia within the last few months before it shut down. Just like with Stadia, Google very clearly does not care to prioritize this kind of AI tech. Google failed to proofread its own ad about Bard. I can't understand how rushed they would have to be for something like that to happen.

In my opinion, this is why new ChatGPT users are going to stay with ChatGPT, even as the aggressive filtering makes the output slightly worse as time goes on.

knaik94··on Is A.I. Art Stealing from Artists?
I am exhausted form this discussion. Regardless of how well researched and written this specific article might or might not be, the greater discussion is a lot of bad faith arguments from both sides. There's even less room now for respectful discussion than there was 3 months ago. I doubt I am the only one that feels this way. I want a ruling as fast as possible, so we can start having more nuanced discussions.

The more existential question this lead me to ask is, what aspect of art makes it valuable to me. I believe that the most meaningful art comes from someone that is able to communicate an experience to others through an abstract representation of it. I feel most connected to art that invokes really intense emotions and memories. I personally don't understand the value placed in most classical paintings, maybe it's a consequence of growing up with the internet. Art is not as scarce as it once was and while the process of creating art is absolutely valuable, the final piece is how other people will experience it.

But everyone experiences and appreciates art differently, the only universal truth about art is that it's really hard to predict how it will be recieved. I think artists will be the people who would most benefit from AI tools. Similar to ChatGPT, the quality of input directly impacts the quality of the output. I think people that would otherwise sympathize with the other side will get burned out, if they haven't already. I put AI art related keywords in my twitter filter. I realized I get more frustrated from the constant bad faith arguments from either side much more than the underlying issue.

You can create meaningful art using AI, they're not two mutually exclusive things.

knaik94··on David Guetta uses ChatGPT and uberduck.ai to deepfake Eminem rap for DJ set
The rules for live DJ sets is very different from copyright rules that limit published music. This is the same as when artists use samples of meme audio, which otherwise would be copyrighted. Guetta has a long very large body of work and deserves the benefit of the doubt when it comes to the question of Eminem okaying it. He very clearly wants there to be a discussion about this. Celebrity impersonators for singing have been a thing for a long time. This isn’t about one artist in particular.

I was playing with Tortoise TTS and was genuinely surprised by how good it is with just a few minutes of clean audio. It didn’t take me hours to train or fine tune, the generation step is sort of long, 5-7 minutes for 30 seconds, but it feels really similar to stable diffusion where you do quick test with slow samples and iterations to find a decent seed, and then you let it do a more complete regeneration. It’s zero shot generation that ran on my laptop 2070 max q and i7 10750h. It’s not perfect but it’s believable when layered with music.

https://github.com/152334H/tortoise-tts-fast

knaik94··on David Guetta uses ChatGPT and uberduck.ai to deepfake Eminem rap for DJ set
Something like that, lyrics about other artists are often cleared too. There’s a mutual understanding in certain genres, but there’s the infamous example between Taylor Swift and West where the conversation was leaked because West mislead Swift. The candidness of it and the beginning of the line Taylor was willing to let slide was interesting. That wasn’t even AI or a sample, just a reference in a demeaning line.

https://genius.com/Kanye-west-kanye-west-and-taylor-swifts-f...

knaik94··on David Guetta uses ChatGPT and uberduck.ai to deepfake Eminem rap for DJ set
I am not sure what gave you the impression that he didn’t call. I don’t think there’s been confirmation either way. I know people aren’t always familiar with Guetta or EDM, but it’s important to know how prolific and genre blending he and his music is. I would give him the benefit of the doubt. He’s at the top of the list of artists who would do this intentionally, but respectfully to cause a discussion. Guetta has many song collaborations with mainstream artists in R&B and Hip Hop. His full songwriting credits list is huge but just looking at the credits page for who he’s done music videos with should give you a clear understanding of him. He needs to show respect to the artist, but he doesn’t need to defend that he did publicly.

https://m.imdb.com/name/nm1615892/fullcredits

knaik94··on David Guetta uses ChatGPT and uberduck.ai to deepfake Eminem rap for DJ set
This isn't going to be released commercially, as a very successful artist, he knows that better than most. No record label would release songs without clearing things with the relevant artist. Many artists and DJs don't release live sets/remixes because it would be impossible to clear all the samples, I don't see why this would be any different.
knaik94··on Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large Language Models
"What if a cyber brain could possibly generate its own ghost, create a soul all by itself? And if it did, just what would be the importance of being human then?” - Ghost in the Shell (1995)

Having studied some psychology in college, my initial reaction is that most people are going to really struggle to treat LLMs as what they are, pieces of code that are good at copying/predicting what humans would do. Instead they'll project some emotion to the responses, because there was some underlying emotions in the training data and because that's human nature. A good prediction doesn't mean good understanding, and people aren't used to needing to make that distinction.

The other day I had to assist my dad in making a zip file, later in the day he complained that his edits in a file weren't saving. After a few moments, I realized he didn't understand the read-only nature of zip files. He changed a file, saved it like usual, and expected the zipped file to update, like it everywhere else. He's brilliant as his job, after I explained that it's ready-only, he got it. LLMs and how the algorithm behind it works is hard to understand and explain to non-technical people without anthropomorphizing AI. The current controversy about AI art highlights this, I have read misunderstandings and wrong explanations even from FAANG software engineers. I am not sure if education of the underlying principles is enough, because some people will trust their own experiences over data and science.

knaik94··on Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large Language Models
I think that response is a hard coded filter and not a self generated assertion. I imagine it's a stop to make sure people don't project emotions or become attached to it. It responds similarly if you ask it questions regarding the tone/sentiment of the generated text. It responded similarly when I tried forcing it to classify its own personality, however when I asked questions about other fictional AI like Glados from portal, it had no problem answering. This disagreement only indicates that OpenAI spent a considerable amount of energy with adversarial prompts.
knaik94··on Google will blur explicit image results for all users, requires login to disable
You may not have come across this yourself, but Google requries verified ID to watch age-restricted videos on Youtube in EU, EAA, Switzerland or UK. It just hasn't hit US in the same way. Louisiana set a dangerous precedent though, legally.

https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/10070779?hl=en-GB#...

https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/10071085?visit_id...

knaik94··on Google's Bard AI bot mistake wipes $100B off shares
This dip in price isn't a reflection of what was thought about the mistake. Google is supposed to be an AI powerhouse. Google has models that are already much stronger than what's publicly accessible. Google has made a decision to not deploy this kind of AI. Google says they don't feel ready to release AI without safeguards. When there were no alternatives, people just accepted what Google was saying and moved on, but ChatGPT and other OpenAI products show that it is possible and Google is choosing not to prioritize it. My guess is that certain leadership at Google couldn't fathom the cost at moderation and filtering AI output. Youtube moderation makes it clear that Google will automate as much of the content moderation pipeline as humanly possible, that's too big of a risk with something like an AI model.

Searches fit into one of two main categories, searches where you are looking for software/product/services, or searches where you are looking for information. ChatGPT outclasses everything else in the second category. I'm not sure how long it will take for LLMs to also produce meaningful results for the first. This mistake made sure that all of the new user that OpenAI gained are going to stay with OpenAI.

Interestingly the mistake of Bard isn't painting ChatGPT negatively.

https://ai.googleblog.com/2022/04/pathways-language-model-pa...

knaik94··on Google will blur explicit image results for all users, requires login to disable
I agree and while search results are censored already because of DMCA or to remove personal info, it feels really different when the reasoning becomes moral judgement. I understand the goal and I can even believe that is being done with good intent, but it feels like there's a shift in how proactive Google will be in hiding explicit or sensitive results.

Does something like evidence of police brutality count as explicit content? This policy isn't targetting just NSFW content but also NSFL content, like video released of the savage killing of Tyre Nichols by Memphis police and the SCORPION unit. Those videos are extremely disturbing and would easily have been at home on a place like LiveLeak.

If someone searches police brutality without being logged in, will links to the real video be blurred/hidden?

I have a feeling this was a response to the Louisiana ruling on porn and the continued fight by current President Biden to weaken Sec 230. This would make sense if it was in response to a new definition of companies acting in good faith to remove illegal content. There hasn't been anything explicit about Sec 230, a critical court hearing is happening later this month. I hope this isn't a signal that the weakening of Sec 230 is likely going to happen. This kind of censorship will be a direct consequence if it does, and this'll only be the beginning.

https://www.axios.com/2023/02/07/tech-firms-section-230-supr...

← PreviousPage 5 of 23Next →