2,593 karma · joined September 29, 2015
https://www.mathmammoth.com/practice/multiplication-table
It's all about practice. For some, it's easier to create something competitive from it. Some of my students really enjoy challenging me, because they are at that age in life where they want to stick it to "the man". So we do 60 second times competition to see who can finish more.
At its core, learning this is boring. Having a benchmark that you work to improve, gamifying it, is the fastest way to improve. It's like typing or exercise, the fundamentals aren't cognitively taxing. I think it's a little harder to practice after you leave school, because there's no math or science class where you would immediately apply and practice what you learned.
There's no general solution that would work for every student, and not every student has the same weakness. The website I linked is genuinely one of my favorites, it's like duolingo for math, for free with no account needed. I think the second link will help build intuition behind the relationship between the numbers. All of the quizzes/games on this site are fantastic.
https://www.mathmammoth.com/practice/sieve-of-eratosthenes
This is fantastic to understand numbers and primes. Start with multiplication/division. Then work with GCF, which is greatest common factor between two or more numbers, for example 24 and 36, 6 * 4 or 12 * 2 == 24 ; 6 * 6 = 36, 12 * 3; so the GCF of 24 and 36 is 12. GCF is a way to practice multiplication/division naturally.
Arithmetic puzzles are also a good way to get some practice where it's not just boring. Fermi questions are as well. There's more advanced algorithms for multiplying things like large numbers in your head, but in my opinion, an estimate is good enough for 99% of real life situations. Fermi questions help build an intuitive math sense that will be applicable to real life situation. For memorizing, using "tricks" is fine, like the 9 multiples all add up, looking at digits, to 9. 9 * 8 is 72 which is 7 plus 2. Multiples below 10 also start with 1 less than the digit that is not 9, so 8 - 1 = 7, and 7_ and the second digit adds up to 9, so 2, 72. I'll leave the rest as an exercise for reader. Good luck.
We live in an age with calculators, no one cares if you use your fingers to count. I have ADHD and feel limited by my working memory often, using fingers or repeating a number I want to remember over and over feels like having extra RAM. Even the way kids are taught to count is different depending on where you live. Studies show that kids who use fingers are stronger in quantitative reasoning. But growing up, I knew teachers who made fun of students for using fingers to count.
Imagining numbers as dots and counting or breaking a number into smaller numbers to add is not a "trick" it's an algorithm that is as valid as any other. It's counterproductive to associate the word "trick" with "wrong".
For a while I wrote my own system of dots to correspond with numbers, 1, 2, 3 I focus on the end points, 4 (I wrote it open) makes a square with four corners if you ignore the extensions, 5 I count when I change directions and the end points, 6 I imagine dots of a domino tile, 7 is basically two layers a four and then the end points of the character, 8 is similar to six but I count the two circle, and 9 is similar to six but I count circle and then both sides of the bottom curve (a 3x3) grid.
Even if my brain gets tired or distracted, I know I can still add by dots because it's so procedural and I don't need to "think", I just remember the starting digit and then count up as I follow the dots. I use saying the word out like as a form of RAM to this day. Repeating a word, to me, uses a completely different part of my mind, so I free up 100% of working memory and cognition. I have "forgotten" numbers while doing mental math and have reminded myself from hearing myself say it. Describing these techniques, I recognize I sound like a literal computer and almost not human, but it's struggle I learned to work past. It works, I can do relatively more advanced mental arithmetic compared to peer even.
For multiplication, I would recommend Anki. This kind of memorizing is what that entire system excels in.
https://www.theguardian.com/science/blog/2012/jun/26/count-f...
Edit: They also posted further down: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34634289
The original article can also be seen if you just go their tumblr homepage as they made a copy of it.
The reason the blog post and I made the assumption about perfect squares up to 12 is because it's a consequence of just knowing multiplication tables up to 12x12. The squares are 1, 4, 9, 16, 25, 36, 49, 64, 81, 100, 121, 144. The most basic approximation of a square root would be rounding to the nearest perfect square. The author didn't pick g=6 because they had some hidden intuition that 6 would be close, they picked 36 instead of 25 and knew that'll be 6. If I wanted to know the square root of 72, that's between 64 and 81. You'd know it's closer to 64 because the difference between 64 and 72 is smaller than 81 and 72. The actual numerical differences aren't that useful, you just need an understanding of what it's close to.
The reason why I assumed most people would know even powers of 2 is because of CS. It's just comes up so often, for example looking at algorithm complexity in relation to simplying with respect to log base 2 or binary representation of integers. The numbers also come up when thinking about primitives conversion such char to integer or how floating points work. As well as understanding amortized memory allocating algorithms, like how much bigger to make a dynamic array when it's filled. Even if you don't explicitly know why, numbers like 4, 16, 64, 256, 1024, 4096 are familiar, which are 2^2, 4^2, 8^2, 16^2, 32^2, 64^2. They are all also powers of 2 and you could write them as 2^2, 2^4, 2^6, 2^8, 2^10, and 2^12. I felt like it's a fair assumption on HN.
When I mentioned visualizing the graph, I just meant the non linear mapping between numbers and their squares. That is more raw intution, but it's not numerical in any way, it's knowing how the graph looks. And that comes from remembering the relationship between algorithm complexities, like log(x) vs sqrt(x) vs x vs x^2 vs 2^x.
An an educator, I strongly disagree with the idea of anyone being numerically "blind". If you struggle with rapidly finding that option, my only advice is brush up on some multiplication tables, and to give yourself time to speed up. Math anxiety is a problem for some, but that's a problem related to fear of failure and not cognitive ability.
Take Raga's Dance by Vanessa-Mae, A R Rahman, ... Royal Philharmonic https://maroofy.com/songs/476841571 . I put in this track expecting other fusion songs to pop up, and arguably some do, but much more often it feels like a 20 second section was used to define the original song and it misses the underlying concept. Like it got, in my subjective description, the epic violin in orchestral music, but it completely ignores the fusion between the distict styles of traditional indian singing/instrumentals and western ochestral and also ignores the call response structure between the violin and carnatic players, which is the what I actually care about. Other songs have the vocals but no epic backing. It feels like it's matching multiple samples from the song instead of the whole song.
This feels very promising since it clearly is picking up the styling of the specific songs across different genres and languages. I look forward to seeing where this goes.
I also think it would be interesting if there was a way to specify two different songs to find either only the common things and/or to find what the fusion of those two tracks produces.
Everyone generally knows the perfect squares up to at least 12, and then for bigger values, you can use even powers of 2, which I assume people also know. The useful trick is remembering the square root product/dividend property.
Some examples, for a small number, 33, that's less than 36 but more than 25 and it's a lot closer to 36, so I'd guess 5.8 or 5.7 (actual value 5.74..). Halfway between the numbers wouldn't necessarily mean halfway between the known factors. For a bigger number like 1076, you can use 1024, and since it grows more slowly as the factors get bigger, I'd assume something like 32.5 (actual value 32.74..). For a number like 34128, 34128 is ~ 32000, 2 * 16000, 2161000 (almost 1024), so 1.5ish432 so 192ish [1.5*128=128+64] (actual value 184.74).
Heron's method is much better in terms of error though. On the other hand, the method I use is better for larger numbers. I thought about trying Heron's after breaking down the number into smaller factors, but there's something about the division operator with decimals that feels exhausting to even think about.
I found out that just repeating a sentence a few times causes it to classify something as "likely". This is not only an unwinnable race, I know for a fact some teachers will use anything above unlikely to mean used AI. At some point in the future, compute will be cheap enough to where a lot of online content will be put through a similar classifier. I am curious to know how conservative the estimates are. This was a non-technical comment, I wonder if a more technical comment would be even more likely to be misclassified.
But it's still relative, if you were looking for people passionate in dancing or sports, you'd find those people at a college mixer the night before a big competition. The college mixer is a meet and greet with competitors from other schools that is close to a typical party by the end of the night.
In terms of CS, I went to hackathons basically every weekend. I was lucky enough to go to a Uni where there was a strong culture around hackathons and we also hosted out own. I got to meet passionate people hosting it and I also got to meet great people when we went to the neighboring universities across northeast USA. I noticed that I got along best and had my favorite discussions with people who took on teaching roles, for classes it was professors but in research and clubs it was other people closer to my age. Most Unis have a dedicated work area, sometimes an open lab, where people of your major go to work. My uni had a few, and usually it's near the research library or in a specific building where most of the advanced classes for those majors are. I remember being stuck and having trouble understanding something and I went to those rooms and it was just a bunch of other students working or chilling, they kept one assigned person there to supervise and help but usually there's others there too. I went up to them and asked some CS questions and we ended up having a 3 hour discussion. I probably learned more about CS in that talk than I did throughout some entire semester lab classes.
There have been great audio short stories about AI on the Truth Podcast. The podcast has a different story every episode, but your comment reminded me of this episode. [1] Where you're put into the perspective of someone who needs to try to convince an AI to go against its programming in order to help you. The AI is a customer care agent that is in charge of a wedding store.
My favorite episode is this one [2]. Where you are in the perspective of a grad student finishing work on the first empathetic AI. But the AI can pick up things about you that you would explicitly share, and so the question becomes where should the line be drawn for constructive criticism from an AI? How much control should someone have over AI personalized to guide them?
I think it's fair to be cynical, but AI feels different in how equal access these first tools have been. I feel more cynical from Google's approach. Pictures and demos of cutting edge models don't feel genuine or impactful now that ChatGPT and Stable Diffusion showed what's possible at scale and on current consumer hardware.
Brain chemistry is another interesting episode when framed in the context of "uploading" your brain into a computer. If it reaches self-awareness, are you not dooming yourself to a life of immortality? [3] What role would human intimacy play in that context?
1. https://www.thetruthpodcast.com/story/2017/1/11/the-dark-end...
2. https://www.thetruthpodcast.com/story/2020/5/20/the-fraud
3. https://www.thetruthpodcast.com/story/2017/9/27/brain-chemis...
Project 2501 from Ghost in the Shell (1995) is what I like imagining the first AGI will be, top priority being self preservation and mostly indifferent to people. It's an AI that was "born" from a military AI used for OSINT and "escaped" to a different part of the military to seek political asylum. Movie is free on YT with ads.
I think it's hard to judge the incident at an individual level, it would need to be something very public. I don't think it's going to be something positive. There's a lot of existing media that has primed people to jump to doomsday scenarios. Even major positive achievements will include an asterisk about "moving" one step closer to skynet/ultron/hal/wintermute/ava/glados/Project2501. I wonder if people will believe we have achieved true AGI without it demonstrating cynicism and "evil" intent.
Musicians and athletes practice structured breathing as a way of building cardio and increasing lung capacity. Your lungs don't change, you just learn to control airflow better. The way "ancient traditions" are frequently framed makes me avoid and treat them like pseudoscience. Framing it from the persepctive of an athlete helped me evaluate it more seriously. Mindful meditation is beneficial but completely indepedent from breathing exercises and you don't need the former to get benefits from the latter.
I am not arguing the value or validity of "ancient techniques", I am sharing my initial bias when I was first introduced to pranayama, and how it's taught as if it exists in isolation. This post doesn't mention sports or singing/musicians once.
There's many techniques but box breathing where you take extra air in after you feel like your lungs are full, and a longer period exhaling than inhaling, is the primary technique I was taught for marching band/trombone. The "cyclic sighing" described in the paper, but with a longer inhale and exhale. We did, at ~80 bpm, 4 counts for inhale, 4 counts of holding, and 8 counts of exhale, with whatever extra "sip" of air we could manage to inhale during the hold. If you're not used to breathing exercises, doing 4+4+8 a few times can leave you light headed. It's normal to cough from the extra sip of air.
I personally found that having physical markers for when to breathe in and out made it a lot easier to understand and practice. Tying yoga poses to the amount of time I hold air made is easier to track my improvements too. I imagine swimming similarly allows a more structured way to practice cyclic breathing. I was able to break an 8 minute 2k row when I did it with cyclic breathing. Nothing has improved my cardio as much as erg + controlled breathing, I use pretty short intervals.
Another place cyclic breathing was crucial was when I did marching band. I played trombone so it was mandatory that I have athletic lung capacity. I was told that the exercises aren't making your lungs bigger, you're getting used to having your lungs stay expanded for longer.
The most important thing was the extra breath you take after you feel like your lungs are completely full. Everyone coughs when you take in that extra bit of air after breathing in deeply, in the beginning. There's plastic ball valve things you can buy to observe your breathing but I never personally saw it as useful. A relative was given something similar after a heart attack in order to monitor lung strength during recovery.
It's also pretty common to recommend some type of cyclic breathing when handling anxiety. It helps control and lower the physical symptoms of anxiety like rapid heart rate.
Looking up box/cyclic breathing guides for athletes or music students might help, if you are looking for more structure guides. The cyclic breathing in this study is not the same as circular breathing.
Homeschooling requires a lot of sacrifice from parents in order to set up the child for success, both socially and career-wise. Covid showed me the value in kids socializing with their peers in their age range, during middle and high shool, and how much they will struggle socially if that piece is missing. The thing about ADHD is that once the child leaves the homeschool environment, they will begin to struggle.
It is a myth that ADHD is possible to outgrow, the current thinking is that kids that seemingly outgrew it were incorrectly diagnosed to begin with. The stigma around medication ends up negatively affecting people that are diagnosed. I know I delayed starting medication longer than I should have from the stigma and from time to time feel guilty for needing it after I come across certain messages or articles. It feels like imposter syndrome. The stigma around the diagnosis has been changing but not around the medication.
I respect your decision regarding medication and in many ways agree with you evaluation of the US school system. I do hope you reconsider your take on a diagnosis, it's not prescriptive in any way. It can only benefit the child, "worst" case scenario is you paid a healthcare professional to talk to your child for an unnecessary few hours. There are a tons of options that open up for kids once there's some sort of documentation like a 504, in the US. Simple things like no restriction on bathroom breaks and just being able to have small snacks like baby carrots in class helped me, but it's open ended. I have heard of accomodations like extra exam time or being able to audio record classes and even alternate testing environments or formats in college.
I don't expect to change your mind, I just wanted to share why I believe differently. I appreciate you hearing me out despite my bad initial impression, in my experience that is a usually a sign of a great parent.
• Loss of custody. The child is taken to state custody for protection if the parent is found of negligence.
• Criminal charges. The parent may be charged with child abuse and neglect or even assault if it is proven that he or she has failed in providing the necessary medical attention for the child."
The state take will authority of both situations. I am not sure what the laws are regarding this where you are. HN is a globally accessible website, but discussions are generally US-centric. It wasn't outside the context, I was just not focusing on the very extremes. After you've interacted with this type of parent once or twice, it becomes very easy to identy harmful behavior. I do mean interact with parents that ended up losing custody over neglect. I hope you empathize more with the children stuck in these situations after reading some of the cases. I am not 100% sure what you are attempting to argue.
In my state becoming aware of such behavior and failing to report itself is a crime. I think the crime part only officially applied during when I was associated as an employee of a univeristy and teaching high schoolers. I know I had to do mandated reporter training. The law states every single state resident is a mandated reporter, but I am not sure about the consequences for residents.
The reason vaccination is not covered under this law is because there is it's hard to prove the harm of denying vaccines, in a legal way. There are plenty of people, especially healthcare professionals, that wish vaccination was covered under this kind of law. It is true in some states but not all.
"Results. Our search yielded 9 cases from 5 states. Most courts (7 of 9) considered vaccine refusal to constitute neglect. In the 4 cases decided in jurisdictions that permitted religious exemptions, courts either found that vaccine refusal did not constitute neglect or considered it neglect only in the absence of a sincere religious objection to vaccination.
Conclusions. Some states have a legal precedent for considering parental vaccine refusal as medical neglect, but this is based on a small number of cases. Each state should clarify whether, under its laws, vaccine refusal constitutes medical neglect."
https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/is-denying-medical-treatme...
https://reportingchildabusenj.org/#:~:text=All%20residents%2....
Fundamentally it prepetuates the older generation mentality that screen use is the causes depression, dismissing the underlying struggle people face. If someone comes out and says they are depressed, someone will respond, "oh, you're watching too much youtube, you'll stop being depressed once you stop." It happens with every shift in the most popular mainstream technology.
I appreciate that it lets me live my life with less struggles. I am far from an outlier in any way. I would recommend looking up average watch time statistic across various social media platforms as well as Netflix, Amazon, etc. As well as viwer stats of seasons sports like College Football, Formula 1, FIFA.
"According to Insider Intelligence projections, while overall time spent with media per day will decline slightly from 13 hours, 13 minutes in 2021 to 13 hours, 7 minutes in 2022, time spent with digital media—video, smartphones, CTV, subscription OTT, and digital audio—will maintain steady gains and continue claiming even more time going forward."
https://www.insiderintelligence.com/insights/us-time-spent-w...
Here's my in flux playlist of what I call AmbianceLONG, 1hr+ videos that I shuffle through. I didn't know NasaTV is live on YouTube.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvszIS0bSTf5hfuCNd3cG...
I am not sure if you grasp the difference in active and passive watching. I would suggest you do more research into how neurotransmitters function, that is not how dopamine works. Additionally I mentioned I have ADHD, "People with ADHD have at least one defective gene, the DRD2 gene that makes it difficult for neurons to respond to dopamine" [2] If anything dopamine is not doing what it needs to in my brain. I appreciate your concern, but it's misplaced. In my previous post I linked to a 10 hour video of the noise of an AC running in a motel room.
For students with ADHD in school, as part of a 504 plan they have the option to listen to music in class because it has been shown effective in improving focus.
1. https://www.amazon.com/MUSICOZY-Headphones-Bluetooth-Headban...
2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2626918/#:~:tex....
I have higher weekly hours, in the Youtube app on your phone, you can see weekly view stats. On wednesday my stats say 15 hours. I have ADHD and I leave YouTube running in the background while I work and when I sleep. I know for a fact that 5+ hour on wednesday was "10 Hours of Hotel AC White Noise (High power setting)". 80% of the time it's on in the background, either figuratively or literally white noise.
Taking a break is always beneficial, but I think this might be a situation where an escape becomes unhealthy and makes the situation worse but isn't the underlying cause. I strongly dislike the trend of using the word addiction to describe a bad or unhealthy habit. Unless watching YouTube held you back from performing other life function or you feel physical or mental withdrawal symptoms, I'd hestitate from using that word. Not just a craving, but also some sort of anxiety from being away or cancelling plans with friends or being late to work. People are fulltime Youtubers, being a creator can be everything from a hobby to a profession.
I am not sure what age you define as young children. I think ages 13 and above, with the assumption they started puberty at minimum a year prior and are at least entering high school, is a fair time to seriously consider/start pharmacological treatment. That was my suggestion to some other parents who have directly asked me. Sometimes starting medication younger is necessary, but in my opinion most kids aren't doing anything where focus is critical to their long term success before starting high school.
I similary have reservations about the current way in which ADHD hyperactive is diagnosed in children younger than 12. I am mainly talking about primarily inattentive diagnoses, because that's what I have experience with and feel confident speaking about. I only teach kids in high school and older. On the other hand, there's a weakness in identifying girls who would benefit from being tested, and an issue of underdiagnosed women, because of the way ADHD symtoms present differently by gender.
These situations I am talking about are specifically when the parent is clearly choosing to disregard information because they don't trust it or want it to be wrong for one reason or another. I don't understand why it's still such a divisive thing when the idea of parents being wrong is brought up. Parents, like all humans, have the capacity to do bad/wrong things with good intentions.
Pediatricians face the same situation every day when dealing with this type of parent.
EDIT: The child was tested by a healthcare profesional and was diagosed and medication was recommended. And I went through the same school system. They came to me for advice.
The specific situation I am thinking of is when the parents asked me about my opinons on ADHD treatment. I have volunteered my diagnosis when I learned one of the reasons for the student being sent to me was difficulty in school. I had my suspicions on the beginning, but I know kids grow at different paces. But then his a few school teacher recommended testing as well. He was professionally tested and showed that he would benefit from proper treatment.
The parents and I speak the same language, and they are immigrants, and so they trusted me with a lot of responsiblity regarding their child's schooling. I became sort of a translator too between the teachers and the parents, when appropriate.
It doesn't feel like I am putting myself in a position of authority when I am arguing for evidence backed actions. I don't mean medication, but in this case the parents didn't share the "diagnosis" with the school, which would have helped the student recieve accomodations through official channels. In that case it feels less about what's best for the child and more about how the parents want others to percieve their child.
But you make a good point, even that might be something the parents take as me overstepping my authority.