HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kodachrome64

27 karma · joined March 11, 2021

submissionscomments
kodachrome64··on Japan's hydrogen strategy does nothing for decarbonisation: study
A hydrogen fuel cell engine relies on completely different principles than an ICE and would still require complete retooling of their powertrain manufacturing. If anything, their hybrid powertrains are closer in design to BEVs than FCEVs

There are good reasons for hydrogen over batteries, like better range and short refuelling times. I'm not sure why there's a need for some nefarious motive.

kodachrome64··on The Dawn of Everything challenges a mainstream telling of prehistory
I'm about halfway through this book. While it's full of fascinating ideas and information, it's badly in need of an editor. To me, it often reads more like a stream of consciousness than a structured essay. Also, I'm not particularly well-versed in the subject matter, but even I can recognize some of the massive logical jumps that they make based on the evidence that they present.

Had this simply been a book to exhibit new ways of understanding and exploring the merits of prehistoric societies, perhaps it would be more fitting of its title "The Dawn of Everything." I could see this working better in a format more like Charles Mann's 1491. Instead, it attempts to tackle a number of broader questions about modern society while slinging mud at every author in the last five hundred years that's touched upon them. Overall, my impression so far is that Graeber and Wengrow bit off more than they could chew. I want to keep reading for the information they present, but it's been a struggle to stay focused.

kodachrome64··on Is wine fake?
As someone living in an Ontario wine growing region, I can assure you that we bring in plenty of migrant workers every year.
kodachrome64··on The best apples for apple pie
I bought a few of these last year not knowing what to expect, and they blew my mind. Unfortunately, they don't seem to be stocked too frequently where I am.
kodachrome64··on At 4.4 miles, Wyoming team sets new rifle shot world record
The Coriolis effect would be constant and wouldn't affect your grouping.
kodachrome64··on Current guidelines for sun exposure are unhealthy and unscientific – research (2019)
Radiation safety, including UV safety, operates on the As Low As Reasonably Achievable (ALARA) principle - "This principle means that even if it is a small dose, if receiving that dose has no direct benefit, you should try to avoid it." [1] I'd imagine that this is the principle that the American Academy of Dermatologists bases their guidance on. Skin colour has nothing to do with it; radiation = bad.

It's generally a damned good principle to live by. We know for certain that higher UV exposure = higher risk of melanoma. It may be a lower risk for people with darker skin, but where do you draw the line for how dark is dark enough to not need to bother with sunscreen? The article states that it's rare in African Americans, but not nonexistent. In the absence of other evidence, why not avoid UV exposure?

This article presents emerging studies that suggest that UV exposure does have some direct benefits and that avoiding it may be especially harmful to people with darker skin. If there's enough evidence to support the findings, the AAD should absolutely change its advice. That's the scientific process. The article uses the example of margarine to illustrate the point; we've gotten it wrong before.

Given the above, are you certain that the term "racism" is accurate here? What can we attribute to bias that can't be explained by a lack of scientific evidence?

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/radiation/alara.html

kodachrome64··on Diary of a first-time on-call engineer
Not OP, but another manufacturing engineer. Manufacturing has been on a slow decline for decades due to outsourcing and automation. The need to offer a competitive wage and working conditions is not what it is in tech, and company culture can get pretty cutthroat depending on the industry you're working in. You could find a job elsewhere, but it likely won't be much different. In fact, a rotation for being on-call would be an improvement for me, as I've never worked anywhere where I'm not on-call all the time. People even try to call me when they know I'm on vacation, which is one of many reasons I keep a personal phone that they don't know the number for.

I make better money than most people I know around my age, but it's nowhere near tech money and it's not enough for the bullshit. Unfortunately, it is good enough that pivoting into another field and taking a pay cut would be painful.

kodachrome64··on White Castle wants to install robot cooks in 100 new locations
This is what I'm wondering as well. Automation can do all sorts of cool things but my experience in manufacturing has shown me that machines break down all the damn time. When that happens, some poor tradesperson or engineer is under the gun to get it back up and running again because money is being lost by the minute. I'd imagine a machine running in a hot, greasy environment would need pretty extensive cleaning and routine maintenance to be reliable. Those things cost money and require diligent workers, and this is a company looking to lay off people that they're paying minimum wage.
kodachrome64··on Vaccines and Omicron mean Covid now less deadly than flu in England
I've heard "if you get the flu you know it" spread around the internet for years, but given what we know now about the wide range of severity in cases of covid can that really be said with any confidence? Are we certain there aren't people who get the flu and are asymptomatic, or who just end up with mild to moderate cold symptoms?
kodachrome64··on What the Omicron wave is revealing about human immunity
What about when the CDC publishes an article with a title like this? https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-pr...

Critical thinking would mean asking how could a vaccine that simulates part of the virus provide better immunity than recovering from the real thing?

Turns out, it doesn't. But the latest release doesn't have a catchy sound bite for a title. The results are buried in the summary: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7104e1.htm?s_cid=mm...

The same goes with masks back in 2020. While officials were announcing that masks may actually be detrimental for the average person, hospitals were screaming for more PPE. Clearly, something wasn't adding up. As it turns out, that was a lie.

I'm vaccinated, I was a big supporter of lockdowns at the beginning of all of this, but "trust the science" is, ironically, becoming its own religion to some people and I find it repulsive. Especially when it has been shown time and again that science can be wrong and that scientists have no problems with telling noble lies.

kodachrome64··on Meat Loaf, 'Bat Out Of Hell' singer, has died at 74
While you're correct, I think the problem is that the way the line is phrased seems to imply "I would do anything for love, but I won't do that for love." Even knowing Meatloaf's intention, the whole song seems to be suggesting that there's something his lover is begging him to do that he outright refuses. I doubt she's asking him to "forget the way she feels," or "screw around," so it feels like there's a question left unanswered. The Wikipedia article for the song even touches on this ambiguity with the debate between Steinman and Meatloaf over the use of the word "but" versus "and" in the line: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I%27d_Do_Anything_for_Love_(Bu...
kodachrome64··on How to Study Mathematics (2017)
This was probably my biggest gripe with my mech eng degree. Every minute you spent grinding through a difficult topic until you understood it, was a minute that you needed to be studying for another exam or working on a project. In the end I came out with a pretty decent GPA, but a serious case of impostor syndrome as I never really felt like I had absorbed most of the material. Of course engineering is a demanding field, but I've often wondered if students would benefit from having five classes per term.