532 karma · joined March 16, 2019
Just because you haven't wrapped your head around complexity or how good outcomes are produced, doesn't mean only bad things can happen.
The internet does a great job of keeping people feed with problems way above their pay grade for no good reason.
If Paul Graham had taken a course in Education or Pedagogy, his article would have an elaborate note on who should really be reading them. The conclusions you reach are very different once you have experience and done the prereqs.
It's like dropping off your second grader, in a tenth grade classroom for a month. What conclusions about the world is the second grader going to draw at the end of it?
When you have 1 network connecting 2 billion people why get off the network onto some other network to do a transaction. If I want to send cash to a family member in the developing world it's more convenient if the pay button is right there in the messaging app.
As to privacy and Zuckerberg controlling everything, well the banks and telcos already have all my data and keep spamming me day and night based on that data.
Whether the data gets centralized and the number of networks reduce to 1 is less interesting to me, than whether they use the data collected to take advantage of me. We do have road networks where you can drive from one end of the world to another without worrying about who the road owner is and how they might take advantage of you.
What you need depends on what you do. Don't worry about what others are doing, until you run into a Specific problem with your workflow. That's the time you walk into the shed.
Similarly don't spend time paying attention to people who talk about productivity, efficiency and debate which tool is better the whole day. They are nothing but a distraction. When they are useful, is when you hit an specific problem.
If you are getting stuff done you are on the right track. There are still people in the world making bigger impact with a pencil and a paper than anyone with their ironman/jarvis bullshit.
All men are not equal, never have been and probably never will be. So why is that line so famous? Why has it influenced the course of history? Not just in the US. What that sentence, and its effects on history show us, is when people are faced with the Unprovable, they have a choice to sit back, do nothing and accept it OR decide what they want the truth to be. Unsurprisingly its always the latter group that makes change happen. The rest just fall asleep reading Goedel.
Engineers as a breed usually run to mgmt/blame mgmt when they can't get their brethren to do things. So when an engineer shows up, who can get other engineers to follow, then that's one special unicorn you take care off, protect and support.
Heres a quote from Steven Stogratz - "Mathematics is usually portrayed as exact and impeccably rational. It is rational but not always initially. Creation is intuitive. Reason comes later"
Maxwell would not have come up with his equations of electromagnetism if he said what you are saying to Faraday.
Faraday did not understand differential equations or vector calculus. Leave alone know, how to express anything in that language. But it was his book that inspired Maxwell. It was filled with "verbal and visual" intuition expressed in non mathematical language.
Mathematician of the age did not take it seriously using exactly the kind of arguments you are using.
You cannot force/shame people to be more disciplined with their metaphors. It made Faraday hesitant to even to express his findings publicly for many years.
They need to stop showing people the upvote and view COUNTS. Behind the scenes they can still use it to make recommendations.
Those numbers are pseudo signals of quality to people who encounter content they have never encountered before.
Even when they have doubts that are watching something unhealthy the mind goes "well if the rest of the world thinks this dumbass is important I better pay attention..."
If a dumbass hurting people on video gets 10 million views other dumbasses worldwide automatically get triggered looking at the count. "hey I can do this maybe I should run for President..."
Remove the counts and you remove the pseudo signal of quality.
That said I'll be rooting for them.
Policy/decision makers know anytime things get political the issue is never about the data. If someone somewhere has to give up something, try doing it just showing them your data and analysis.
You can run the experiment on HN. Try getting something in the architecture to change based on data, and pitch it to the HN community. See what happens...
You have to walk through a 100 foot gate of granite just to get in. It blows the mind everytime I walk through at the imagination and ambition to build such a thing. And then inside things are even more breathtaking.
It's in daily use for worship and rituals by thousands of people even today. It has seen 8-12 different kingdoms come and go. Not just Hindus but Christians and Muslims administered the area at one time or another.
In addition to Stone what you need is Beauty.
People universally for mysterious reasons recognize Beauty. If it's beautiful it's going to be protected and taken care off. People will happily die to do it.
Here's an example of from Niall Ferguson's book The Square and the Tower - "Formally, the directors of the East India Company (EIC) in London controlled a substantial part of the trade between India and western Europe. In reality, as the records of over 4,500 voyages by Company traders show, ship’s captains often made illicit side trips, buying and selling on their own account. By the late eighteenth century the number of ports in the resulting trade network was more than a hundred, ranging from open emporia such as Madras to regulated markets such as Canton (Guangzhou). In effect, private trading provided the weak links that knitted together otherwise disconnected regional clusters. This network had a life of its own that the Company’s directors in London simply did not control. Indeed, that was one of the keys to the success of the EIC: it was more a network than a hierarchy. Significantly, its Dutch rival banned private trade by its employees. This may help explain why it ended up being superseded"
What works and what doesn't varies a lot from org to org.
There are lots of loud and persuasive people around, but to stay relevant, social/news media selects for the ones that are tireless in performing their routines with robotic efficiency day in day out.
I just can't understand how they plan to inspire Hope and Faith in the future with one retarded timid decision after another. It's like they are scared to lead and want to turn into another irrelevant IBM or HP.
It's not complicated to deal with these kind of robotic decision makers especially in a company that claims to be creative. I hope something shakes and wakes them up soon.
People attacked Faraday for suggesting electromagnetism was a thing, hardly paid attention to Maxwell for doing the Math because it was too complicated, and attacked Oliver Heaviside his whole life, for simplifying the math that everyone uses today. Each of these characters made mistakes and had weaknesses too and its easy to find fault.
That's the way things work. There are always going to be more people who fixate/react to mistakes, than use them as stepping stones to new discoveries.
Without these writers I would have hardly any awareness about these subjects, because these subjects were hardly discussed when I was in school. And it's not even that long ago. They opened the door. History will show that was the role they played.
This was not happening 10 years back.
In my experience the majority of 30 and 40 year olds in Tech today pushing AI code out have no clue who Kahneman, Hariri and Pinker are.
So expect subprime meltdowns/Trump/Brexit type unintended bullshit for a few more years till the psychologist+historian+sociologist coders take over.
Americans and their weird need to turn everything they feel into something marketable more like it...
BS. You give them way too much credit. The world is too complex and dynamic for a queen ant to "create and manufacture" the efficiency of the ant hill.
People who have twiddled about with their own default settings, whether they are in China, America or Congo find different routes to happiness that have nothing to do with what the rest of herd is upto.