HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kolektiv

1,625 karma · joined December 25, 2008

London/Horsham (and anywhere else interesting).

Tech Theory + Practice. I care most about changing the world in meaningful ways through technology. I care very little about yet another X.

Contact me at andrew at xyncro dot com.

irc:kolektiv:irc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kolektiv; my proof: https://keybase.io/kolektiv/sigs/0d5gliRyPmqTUqjf5C4XNh5y1sry6und7d3z4LYWCyo ]

submissionscomments
kolektiv··on Show HN: Bugsnag - Exception tracking app with open source plugins
Well, yes... That's semi-reassuring! Now I don't know what you mean by higher volume accounts. I may well be one, but I don't know that yet. It's like saying that Github will always have a free account - yes, maybe so, but it doesn't do what I need, hence paying $100/mo (as a higher volume user!). Are you different?
kolektiv··on Show HN: Bugsnag - Exception tracking app with open source plugins
Can I just add a general plea to sites like this one which follow a "free while in beta" approach? It's great, and I love free, but I can't choose free without knowing if it's going to become $10/mo or $10k/mo. I'm sure I could probably have a guess at the ballpark pricing that they'll launch this at, but please try and give an indication.

I simply can't commit the time to roll something in to a product or platform which I may have to roll back out again later when there are alternatives that I can plan/budget/account for. There are a few things lately which I've thought "that could be great" but I haven't adopted or tested fully because I just can't know how their costs will scale as my products do. See Bridge for another example, though they did respond with extra clarity after a few people mentioned it.

kolektiv··on /dev/zero has infinite electrons and /dev/null has an infinite appetite for them
I can't help feeling that /dev/zero produces neutrons rather than electrons.
kolektiv··on Show HN: I converted my Backbone/Rails app Cloudedit to Parse in 5 minutes
Very much agreed. From a HN account that isn't immediately associable with the source of the story, this is little more than astroturfing. It's not as if they're unheard of on HN in the first place.
kolektiv··on Redesigning GitHub
Simple does not have to mean featureless. Essentially equating lack of ease with a UI as stupidity is somewhat rude, but worse it's short sighted. Many people have spoken recently about the Github UI - it's much better than what came before in that world, but it can be better, as I'm sure they'd admit.

Your "constant drive to simplify" is better understood as a constant drive to improve. Local maxima are dangerously beguiling, we should always question.

kolektiv··on New Medium Instance, 64-bit bit Ubiquity, SSH Client
Very much agreed. The 64 bit ubiquity move is a solid, sensible step which genuinely makes a lot of lives easier. Nice to see this happening, and it comes at an excellent time for hosting decision I was about to make. Amazon have probably just secured that with this move.
kolektiv··on Big Data + Machine Learning = Scared banks
Disappointingly not. In fact recent government commissioned studies recommended not regulating this further for fear of driving customers to more unscrupulous lenders (presumably ones without flashy offices and good marketing - not actually more expensive ones, which are hard to find).

It's pretty disgraceful. Thankfully it is beginning to be flagged up as more of a problem as some of the better newspapers are beginning to do some proper investigative reporting.

kolektiv··on Messenger.js - dead simple API for multi-server communication in Node.js
Yeah that's fair enough - I'm working with RabbitMQ in Node at the moment, and I've got a simple domain specific wrapper around it, which I find fairly easy. Of course, not everything on it is in Node, which is one reason this wouldn't work for me - but if it works for you, that's great!

I'll be keeping an eye on it anyway - you never know when something like that might solve a problem you encounter.

kolektiv··on Messenger.js - dead simple API for multi-server communication in Node.js
One of the things that RabbitMQ does which this doesn't seems to be much more support for variable topography. This seems to need to know of all receivers when you create a "speaker" which in dynamic networks doesn't seem like such a good idea. Of course you can have each receiver register with some sort of registry and have speakers interrogate that, but then you're back with a single point of (logical) failure.

Discovery and dynamic usage doesn't seem to be covered in many of these projects (cool as they are) which seems to me to be a more challenging and useful extension.

kolektiv··on Like Instapaper, but for Developers
Which if you want people to use it with confidence probably isn't a selling point:

http://blog.pinboard.in/2011/12/don_t_be_a_free_user/

kolektiv··on [dead]
I don't know how successful they are, but if someone did that for my company I can say for sure that I'd certainly give that person some serious time and consideration.

It's also not really an HR thing, IMO. It's almost a "bypass HR" thing - it's so much better to have the devs/designers/whatever coming in to work and saying "there's this great person we should hire". Impress the people you'd be working with - not the ones who work tangentially near them!

Makes me wish I was in the position to offer roles - just the act of getting off their arse and doing something like this is a great start from anyone.

kolektiv··on O2 statement on the mobile number issue
Predictable, nothing too surprising. I think they're going to have a lot of questions to answer around age verification though, seeing as they put in an age verification program without customer request or warning over the last year or so.

From this I'm assuming that the company they used for this (Bango I believe) would have been sent my mobile number in the past if I ever tried to access content they thought should have been verified. There has not previously been any messaging from o2 around this. Disquieting indeed. I would not have agreed to that transfer of information (nothing to hide, but it's MY information).

kolektiv··on O2 (UK) sending mobile numbers with every HTTP request
A little more information - they're sending an X- HTTP header containing the originating mobile phone number. No obfuscation, anything, just a mobile number. I'm on O2 and just verified this from my own mobile.

This is an appalling privacy hole, one which O2 have not publicised at all and from the contents of the tweet discussing, seem to see no issue with.

EDIT: a direct link to a checker by Lewis Peckover which shows this in action if you're on O2 - more verification wouldn't hurt of course. http://lew.io/headers.php

kolektiv··on Copyrights: Feds push a few novel theories in MegaUpload case
I was struck by that as well. I can't imagine that flying over here in the UK (I would hope not, certainly). Legal indictments are supposed to be precise and dispassionate, accurately and succinctly itemising all offences believed to have been committed. I would hope that this kind of prejudicial framing would see the case looked at unfavourably by most juries/judges.
kolektiv··on Startup will wash your car wherever it is located
You and me both, as my surname is Cherry and was supposed to be notified if it ever became available on the market!
kolektiv··on Namecheap to Donate $1 to EFF for Every Domain Transfer on December 29th
I've always used them, and they've been flawless for me. Not "amazing service", but "I haven't needed any service" because everything just worked properly. From what I hear they are responsive when you need them as well. I'd recommend them.
kolektiv··on From South Africa, a faster and easier way to apply condoms
Is the low rate of condom use really related to the time demands of putting one on? I've seen a few things like this and it seems rather more likely that any reason like that is dwarfed by cultural ones.
kolektiv··on The Declining Hotness of Flight Attendants
I don't want to fall in to a Reddit like trap of [citation needed] as a reply, but what in this article leads you to believe that airlines can no longer promote employees for good performance?

I don't know if you're saying it's a bad thing that airlines can no longer fire the recently un-hot, I'll give the benefit of the doubt and assume no. Do you think that the service being better on the airlines you mention has any real link with hotness, or just incidental correlation?

kolektiv··on Are you a programmer with chronic headaches? If so please read
What timing, I went through this process over the last two months. My new glasses will be ready on Thursday. I can read anything, even the smallest type without them. But after 8 hours, it hurts. Hopefully it won't soon.

Heed this advice - just be aware!

kolektiv··on Sell to Teachers
Wow. That sounds a lot more positive than my experience of investigating the market here (UK) - I presume this article is US focused.

Here school IT is generally centrally managed by an IT team who are not generally receptive to ad-hoc software installs. SaaS models fail due to firewalls and network access restrictions. Preferred/accepted bidder lists are rife. Teachers have NO budget for software.

I looked at selling to teachers here and decided that it was more hassle than it was worth - the market barriers to entry and borderline corruption/incompetence just made it a non-starter.

kolektiv··on Is Ubuntu Driving Users Away?
"When someone tells me they have an Nvidia board and ask for help, my first advice is to buy a decent computer..."

Wow. Do you find that many people keep listening to you after this or is this just a strategy to free your time of annoying "people"? The *nix community is generally quite friendly, but it doesn't grow faster because of statements like this. Sure, maybe it's a valid opinion but hell, at least explain why they should care!

kolektiv··on The Secret To Rails OO Design
I had similar thoughts but from the other direction - yes, this is what Ruby (and/or Rails particularly) seemed to want to avoid. "We don't need all of these classes, look how simple this is! It's not like Java with all of these patterns, etc."

But actually I don't think there's much wrong with this. It is OO. It's not domain object oriented, it's just OO. you're creating an object which has a single responsibility - to calculate a sort order, or to take something and present it.

While GoF disciples may well have made many mistakes, this doesn't mean that this kind of OO design which emphasizes separation of concerns is wrong. It may look more complex, and perhaps it's a premature refactoring - we don't know out of context. But these classes are doing more than "just wrapping" something. They're promoting the concept of "displaying" or "sorting" or "calculating a rate for something" to a first class concept in your system, and in the process making it easier to change the implementation and to test in isolation. They're not from the problem domain. But they make sense in your program domain. And that's fine (if not abused).

Edit: (as sibling reminded me of a point to make). Some of these classes could be functions if your language supports that. But they don't have to be, if making them classes makes them easier to work with, test and understand.

kolektiv··on Don't dumb girls down
I loved this. I couldn't agree more. I don't really have any great salient points or anecdotes to add but I would love to live in a world where more people think this way. As a thought experiment though, what would it take to change this? Could this be published advice to parents? Parenting classes, post-natal something? I don't know. Prescriptive stuff is clearly not going to be popular, but in the spirit of the article - if you had a magic wand, what would you do to spread this thinking?
kolektiv··on Making Wrong Code Look Wrong
OK, reasonable point, I had only mentioned that example in another reply because that was the one he used. Do I agree that there will always be semantically wrong bits of code that can't be detected by a compiler (whether as part of a type system or otherwise)? I'm not sure I do. OK, sure, it's probably possible to come up with some contrived examples that fit the case, but generally? No, I think that most problems are more tractable if looked at as a language design issue (be that literal language design, some form of internal DSL, or other) than as a convention issue.

And surely bringing up something like Haskell is germane? The article implies that this is the best/only/right way of dealing with issues like this, when that definitely isn't true for languages with a different/stronger type system, as one case.

Of course, this is pure opinion and supposition on my part - I suspect a proof either way is NP-BloodyImpossible. I do feel like coding conventions such as those he suggests make code harder to read, even if only a little bit. And that's ignoring IDE support as well - I feel the same if I'm in Emacs. If there are enough things in scope that I can't hold in my head the relevant [meta] information about them for that usage, that's a problem for me, probably of quite a different kind.

kolektiv··on Making Wrong Code Look Wrong
As siblings point out, how much work you have to do depends on your language and the available facilities. In Java, this might be a huge pain - Haskell, etc. less so. It's more likely that this is done as part of the framework or libraries generally - how many people are, to continue this example, writing their own web framework? In .NET for example, ASP.NET MVC includes an HtmlString class for similar purposes. Other languages can approach it in different ways. You may find as well that even with something like .NET, not the most expressive of type systems, you could still make life fairly easy by providing appropriate implicit type conversions in one direction.
kolektiv··on Making Wrong Code Look Wrong
Mmmm, but there's more than one way to skin a cat. To take just the point about safe and unsafe strings - well, you could do that with naming conventions, sure. But then you've got a peer review issue. It helps, but it's not great. So the next thing (in a language which lets you use types in this way) is to create a type of UnsafeString, or SafeString etc. And your language doesn't even have to be that great to let you do this - just having a simple type system. And now you change your write method so it doesn't take a String anymore, it takes a SafeString, and only a SafeString. And you make it so that constructing a SafeString can only be done by Encoding at some point.

Now you have something which can still look clean (how clean may depend on your language, type inference, etc.) without bringing in messy pseudo-Hungarian-ness, which stops me doing the most important thing with my code - reading it easily.

Obviously it's only a silly and trivial example, but I'm not sure this article has dated that well in some regards (or perhaps only really applies to certain types of languages - Visual Basic, for example, pretty much forces you to do something like Hungarian to maintain any semblance of sanity long term).

kolektiv··on Show HN: I've created a third place. (for getting to know HNers)
Echoing the Facebook thing. Sounds like a neat idea but until you remove the FB requirement, I won't be trying it. Sorry, I just viscerally don't like tying things like this to things which are at best unrelated, possibly even the opposite in ethos.
kolektiv··on Why designers don’t like A/B testing
Thanks for the clarification - I think to some extent we're arguing on the same side. Points about traffic I would certainly agree with, and to some extent it's as much about attraction as about increasing conversion metrics once obtained.

I'm not sure I'd agree with the last point about time - I think that balancing business generation, expansion and refinement is possible - but perhaps not so much amongst startup size businesses, which is more HN territory. In that case it should certainly be looked at as "is it better to try and get 0.1% more people to click buy or 20% more people to arrive" - or whatever you think your likely ratios are, hence cost/benefit call.

kolektiv··on Why designers don’t like A/B testing
That's actually a valid point with A/B and MV testing - you can get stuck on local maxima. It's why the process still requires manual intervention and design skills. Most flaws with A/B implementations are people/process or misuse.
kolektiv··on Why designers don’t like A/B testing
That's interesting though, because you seem to be implying (forgive me if I'm wrong) that we shouldn't have typewriter fonts, yellow highlights, etc. Or at least that it somehow isn't worth the trade off. But as you say, they do work.

Don't get me wrong, I find those design elements you're talking about to be far from my tastes, but provably I'm not "normal" within the markets under test. At what point what you say to a business "you might make more money like this, but don't do it anyway because it's awful"?

Apologies if I'm reading more in to your statement than was intended. I've seen enough of your work to know that you get both design and business hence I think that statement interesting!

← PreviousPage 8 of 11Next →