HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kolektiv

1,625 karma · joined December 25, 2008

London/Horsham (and anywhere else interesting).

Tech Theory + Practice. I care most about changing the world in meaningful ways through technology. I care very little about yet another X.

Contact me at andrew at xyncro dot com.

irc:kolektiv:irc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kolektiv; my proof: https://keybase.io/kolektiv/sigs/0d5gliRyPmqTUqjf5C4XNh5y1sry6und7d3z4LYWCyo ]

submissionscomments
kolektiv··on Open source needs designers
I think from the designers I know and from my distant former life as a designer before I ended up as a CS guy, it only really comes down to one thing:

What's in it for a designer?

* It's not scratching an itch that they have.

* It's not great promotion (design has worked on a portfolio system for generations, so they have them already - showing someone what you've built is new and revolutionary for development in relative terms, but for design that's just how it is).

* It's probably not much fun (it's a skill to work with designers and to manage a project such that it comes out well - one that most OS projects do not possess if I had to guess).

* It's probably quite thankless (by no means a universal attitude, but plenty of developers think of design as an add-on, or a nice to have - not much of a situation to be in with your work).

So why would designers volunteer for this when they could do work for themselves and their portfolio that they may actually enjoy? How many projects will provide enough exposure to make this a good use of time?

kolektiv··on Instant Company
Well, hosted payment is not a new thing at all - so you iframe or link to a page you don't host which the customer uses - thus ensuring that card details don't hit your servers and don't give you a PCI surface.

This is a fairly logical extension, I would guess that the reason it hasn't caught on more is because a JS requirement has typically been a red flag in e-commerce - 3% of users not being able to pay you once they got to that point of a funnel could be seen as disaster. Interesting, because we're looking at mandating JS in our new developments (background: company I work for does a lot of high end e-commerce - we're specialists).

In theory it's a good idea (that side of it at least) but I don't know how security perception and customer acceptance rates will go.

kolektiv··on Forrst now uses GitHub auth to let developers skip the invite queue
I had a similar thing - just seems to have not really done anything (and there wasn't really any messaging to say "no, that's not good enough" or the like). What is it looking at on Github. A lot of my work on there is either in private repos or as part of Github organisations (also largely private!)

Well, the application is http://forrst.com/i/5fk anyway if anyone wants to vote that in. Maybe it's the fact that I really need to point my site to my actual up to date blog...

kolektiv··on Is there a new geek anti-intellectualism?
I could be wrong, and I certainly don't want to speak for anyone else really, but I think he's talking more in general principle. That you can't assume that more improvement isn't possible, that sometimes it takes a radical change of direction which can't be seen from a position of orthodoxy. I don't think he was suggesting the death of books or similar, more a reflex towards an open mind.

For what it's worth, the conflation of some extreme "post-modern" views such as "Experts do not deserve any special role in declaring what is known. Knowledge is now democratically determined, as it should be.", with some quite distinct and by no means dependent views questioning the value of forms of rote memorization was to me quite insulting. There is a world of possible nuances between views like these.

I am aware that the intention of that particular section was to (in my opinion clumsily) provoke. However to avoid engaging with the issues with intellectual honesty seems to me to be as anti-enlightenment as anything he ascribes to the anti-intellectual movement he apparently sees.

kolektiv··on I will build your prototype
You can, although it's not particularly optimal right now (library sizes, load times, etc. are not ideal). I believe it is a priority for some in the Clojure community to improve this though. But if you're not too worried about the commercial aspects straight away, it's certainly possible.
kolektiv··on Chrome has transcended version numbers
There are software systems which do get updated while running though, but perhaps it requires a change in software architecture more than just (very clever) diff tools. Erlang systems, for instance, can have the concept of hot code swapping baked in to them in a more predictable way because that requirement is part of the base system - application life cycle is built in to the platform, not on top of it. Of course, for systems such as telecoms switching, the complexity and cost of this was worthwhile. For browsers... perhaps not. Cost/Benefit analysis is probably the usual trusted friend. What would we hope to gain (and how would we measure it) by letting browsers never restart?
kolektiv··on HTML5-Powered Web Applications: 19 Early Adopters
"HTML5, rumored as Flash killer, is a brand new web technology that raises a revolution lead by Apple in web application development."

Sorry, I can't really take this seriously after that. And as there's no definition of "an HTML5 powered app" I probably couldn't have done previous to it either. There are some nice apps here, sure, but I'm not sure what value this has over any other list of "cool web apps". Indeed, it's less valuable due to the misinformation.

kolektiv··on In Oracle's fight with open source, the good guys won -- this time
It's an interesting take on it, but there's a lot of assumption here - not least of which is that Oracle somehow did this because it was the "right thing" or a "good" thing to do. Indeed that's founded on the assumption that Open Office is/was, to quote "a very viable and free alternative to Microsoft's bloated, way-too-expensive Microsoft Office". I'm not sure I buy that, for various reasons it hasn't been shown to be viable in the market. Even before Oracle pulled the plug-in stunt (which was shoddy, certainly) I don't think Open Office was gaining huge traction outside of occasional companies and people driven by ideology.

To me it seems more likely that Oracle couldn't figure out a way to make money out of it and got shot of it in such a way that caused least backlash and left the least possible blame attached or Oracle in future - now the community is solely to blame for any future failings.

Just my take of course, but I don't personally feel like "Open Source" has won any fight here - I don't think Oracle would even acknowledge there was a fight.

kolektiv··on Ubuntu AppStore: Like Apple AppStore, but with less Suck
Sigh... I wish Linux (and Ubuntu in this case) were better at UI/UX. But still, it's so clearly designed by programmers (not always a bad thing, but sadly more often than not).

So what's called out here as being good? Well. Subcategories. Average users don't respond well to taxonomy, generally. People are also not good at classifying. So in that example shown, what's the difference between "Arcade" and "Sports"? I've played football games in Arcades. Where should users look?

More: "Some items can be bought, others just downloaded" Cool, where can I filter so I only see free apps? Because it's nowhere in the screen shots, and I will bet money that it's the first thing a sizeable percentage of users want to do. Which would be known, had any user testing been done. I hope it was, but I'm guessing not.

I could be nit-picky - "Get Software" vs. "Installed Software" - they're not even the same tense. Imperative tense is commonly interpreted by users as causing an action to happen, not a categorisation. I could go on too, merrily burning karma as I go, but all I see when I look at this is how far it has to go, not how great it is. Don't get me wrong, the Apple version is by no means perfect, but I bet it performs better in tests with actual users.

Someone needs to get a real UX team together and actually sit down for a real project - not "someone and their favourite futuristic GUI idea for the next version". I would hope that Ubuntu, Red Hat, etc. have the budget to do that, but I see little sign of it.

kolektiv··on How to write a Haskell program
Contrary to some of the other comments appearing, for me this kind of thing is excellent. The biggest mental hurdle I find myself facing when learning new languages and having got beyond the "hello world" stage is "how do I go from here to structuring an app?" An opinionated prescriptive guide is what I need then. When I know more later I can choose to go against the grain if I feel I understand the risks, but structuring projects varies a lot, and being helped to find the idiomatic way is great. It's a whole class of problem I now can ignore and concentrate on the design of my code.

It was a while before I understood how Erlang project structure worked. But I knew where to look. Ditto when I try things like Scala and Clojure (as I'm no longer familiar with Java, really). This is a good and useful step.

kolektiv··on Amazon to offer Library Lending to Kindle through Overdrive
More than simply filtering as well, I'm willing to pay for e-books by writers I like, so they'll carry on being able to write - and write more things that I'll like. Think of it as distributed patronage. There are many more reasons people pay for something than owning a physical copy of it.
kolektiv··on Web development is just broken
Sorry, this might be too pedantic, but I can't listen to someone saying that something "solves the scaling problem" when it doesn't. Both of those examples solve the "having more machines when you need them" problem, but scaling is a) domain specific, and b) a logical problem not a hardware one in general. A million machines and an insoluble deadlock is not a scaling solution.

I'm sure that you know this, but in case anyone out there less well informed takes that at face value I felt compelled to add to it!

kolektiv··on Ubuntu Unity usability testing results and analysis
Windows (certainly 7) handles this perfectly well - try and type a character that isn't allowed in a file name and it pops up a tool tip saying it isn't allowed, along with a quick list of other characters that are disallowed. It also throws that key press away, so it doesn't have to be deleted and can't cause another kind of issue.

This is the difference between products which have undergone long rounds of user testing and ones that haven't. For me this is one of the biggest issues facing Linux based operating systems today, because this is generally not an itch that people working on the project feel like scratching (see: design, documentation, etc.) With commercially backed projects like Ubuntu, it can get there over time, but I would look at a user testing result summary like this and say "we have a LONG way to go" if it was a product that I was leading.

kolektiv··on Startups And Work/Life Balance
Excellent points in here. If you're planning on working until late tonight because you think you have to (not for some specific item), don't. Go home early. Start work tomorrow and try and analyse what went horribly wrong. Chances are, nothing.

There are very few ideas around which will be world beating if done for 15 hours a day, but failures if done for 7.5.

kolektiv··on How to damage your brand in one smooth shot - Way to GoDaddy
NameCheap are an ex-client (obvious disclaimer) back when they were a lot smaller than they are these days. They were a decent bunch and while always on the ball with marketing, I can imagine there being some genuine feeling behind this - they weren't the type to stick branded caps on African villagers, that's for sure.
kolektiv··on JFDI Britain: You don't need a business plan to #startupbritain
Beware confirmation bias. History may be written by the winner, but we could probably learn as much if not more by listening to the loser.

Because you were lucky in this instance does not make that good advice for others to follow. (I'm not saying it's bad advice either, just...)

kolektiv··on JFDI Britain: You don't need a business plan to #startupbritain
In our local HN echo-chamber terminology maybe not, but it definitely does count as one in the world that the original government backed site is targeting. In that case, "startup" is synonymous with "new business" and I personally don't disagree at all.
kolektiv··on Why Women Rule The Internet (by Aileen Lee of Kleiner Perkins)
Hmmm. If by "rule" we mean use/consume, then this seems accurate. However, in terms of creating/leading/shaping the internet that seems to be ignored here. I don't have particularly strong feelings one way or the other, but it seems like it would probably be a good thing if more women were actually driving usage and behaviour and services on the internet.

A better thing than this perhaps, which a cynic might label as "it's easier to monetize women users". But that would be very cynical.

kolektiv··on The Future of Search Can Be Found in Dungeon
This is one of those suggestions which I usually decide to file under the sub-heading "hey, all we need to do is write some software which understands English!".

Right now this matches a definition of "hard" which is very close to "can't be done" despite whatever Jacques may say :)

kolektiv··on Twitter and Me
Hmmm, thanks for the information on that, it makes sense :) It still seems like some of the authoritative aspects of Twitter which provide value would be lost, but I am grateful for the clarification on that.
kolektiv··on Twitter and Me
I don't know about this. I presume you mean she's using something like Google Talk, built on XMPP? While that's true, I'm not sure it has the same requirements. Twitter works because there's no fragmentation - everyone you care about is in one place. A system of loosely federated systems would lose a lot of the "authoritative source" value it seems. Of course, I could be wrong here, that's only an initial reaction, so feel free to correct me!

(I presume on Google Talk it's only commonly possible to speak to other people on Google Talk? I presume you could change the server config or set up your own XMPP servers, etc, but does anyone?)

kolektiv··on Twitter and Me
I thought it was interesting. Made it through to the end and pretty much agree with the points you're making. More people should consider the long term effects of building on platforms where they have no control of direction. Everyone knows the sharecropper story, not enough people consider it.

Also, many congratulations on having a wife who sounds like a saint.

kolektiv··on Ask HN: What would you like to see in Ubuntu 11.10, Oneiric Ocelot?
That's a fair point, I will concede that it's difficult. But a lot of the core things like the file manager (and certainly Unity) is within their control, and could be a lot better. I think that much more could also be done from a technical and cultural leadership perspective in this area. I would dearly love to chat with anyone from Ubuntu about this if they wanted to listen. I'm not a designer (not anymore) I'm a software developer (generally), but I still think that there's an opportunity for huge improvement even with the challenges you (correctly) point out.
kolektiv··on Ask HN: What would you like to see in Ubuntu 11.10, Oneiric Ocelot?
At the risk of being horribly down-voted, I'm going to say that I'd like it to "not look like crap". Unfair with no information, so here's some (of opinion form).

If I look at the screenshots for 10.10 (let's take a tiny example, I could pick on many - http://www.howtogeek.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/sshot23....), the general quality of finish on UI chrome and layout is shocking. The inconsistencies, poor spacing, bad grid, etc. make this jarring and painful. I'm sure people will say this is irrelevant. It isn't. If you're staring at something for many hours a day, this stuff is your subconscious indicator as to quality. It doesn't feel "right". Most Linux user interfaces (and this isn't Ubuntu specific, but you guys are probably most likely to have a go at fixing it) feel "uncanny". They're just a bit wrong. Things don't line up, they're odd sizes, they draw the eye in the wrong way.

In short, they're inelegant and clunky. They feel like non-native Java app interfaces (used) to do (and still do, to greater or lesser degrees). This isn't about visual style or theme, it's a quality case not a taste one.

If I had a little more time (or if anyone thinks this is unfair and actually wants it) I could annotate a screenshot and point these things out directly.

(Please note - if you feel that this is all fixed in 11.x then I apologise, but I will be very surprised)

// Edit: If anyone from Ubuntu would like to chat ever, I'd be more than happy. Contact info is in my profile.

kolektiv··on Don't touch me, I'm British
We have a sales/marketing guy that does this. It's clearly a learned/trained pattern of behaviour (maybe you can hide it better!). Nobody ever mentions it, and acts in a friendly manner. However, when he's not there pretty much everyone comments on how creepy it is and how patronised they feel.

Just something to consider - not saying that's the case with you, but this is a classic area where immediate or obvious reactions are often very different from inward feeling.

kolektiv··on Breakup Notifier Shut Down By Facebook
But the difference is they're not dependent on the Microsoft presence. If Microsoft ceased to exist tomorrow (localised meteor strike, let's say), the code running on .NET, Windows, etc. will still work. If Facebook is down, so are you.
kolektiv··on Homeowner forecloses on Wells Fargo office, becomes folk hero
Haha, yes I am. The point was, as I admitted, pedantic! It perhaps seems rather more amusing to a Brit, where 400 year old houses, though not common, nevertheless are around. A house here described as Tudor is, more likely than not, actually Tudor. Much unkind amusement is also often expressed over here at statements from Americans such as "it's so old! Over 100 years!", but that is simply an old saw. As I say, people missed my point a little, which was out of place snark (though I hoped it would raise a smirk with some). Sadly I learn my lesson! :)
kolektiv··on Homeowner forecloses on Wells Fargo office, becomes folk hero
My point was nothing to do with size or value! Oh dear, my pedantry has been misconstrued. My point was the conflation of hundred year old and "Tudor". I am not one to sneer at anybody for their scale of home, and indeed wish this chap luck.
kolektiv··on Homeowner forecloses on Wells Fargo office, becomes folk hero
I can't resist it. I know pedantry is to be discouraged here, and I apologise in advance. But... "a century old 6 bedroom 3 bath Tudor home" grates against the part of my mammalian hind-brain responsible for breathing, basic motor control and throttling estate agents. Downvotes will be sadly accepted.
kolektiv··on SQL Databases Don't Scale
Well, they don't scale indefinitely, and you do run in to Brewers Theorem at some point. While you're right in saying that if you have enough cash and horsepower to throw at SQL databases you can get a very long way, there is some point where anything which must be consistent is going to have an impact on availability.

This gets especially critical once you stop assuming that data can be centralised. Once your required transactional context needs to scale large areas (geographically or logically) then the overhead of this is mighty. 2PC itself does not scale indefinitely, and while interesting research is being done in alternative transactional approaches, it would be tough to argue that any are acceptable solutions to the problem.

Also your example of banks is perhaps not an ideal one. While banks may indeed run some very large databases, they don't run one HUGE database which is expected to be always consistent. Things like ATM systems etc. run based on eventual consistency and tolerance favouring availability precisely because a simple horespower approach to a transactional database (whether SQL or not) wouldn't currently work in this domain.

← PreviousPage 9 of 11Next →