HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

korantu

227 karma · joined May 11, 2018

submissionscomments
korantu··on China to supercharge uranium race with 150 new nuclear reactors
You cant meaningfully compare prices of something that was not ever done with something that is already done and existing.

South Korea would argue with you on the experience part, as well.

korantu··on China to supercharge uranium race with 150 new nuclear reactors
I have to point out that you neatly avoided main point in the original post - comparing costs of something that never been done (storing energy at national scale) with something with known price and been done before (powering industrial nation with nuclear)
korantu··on China to supercharge uranium race with 150 new nuclear reactors
If anything this can be ascribed to resilience of nuclear generation. The tsunami in question killed (in a first world country, no less) many thousands of people.

The outdated nuclear plant located in the midst of the disaster killed none.

korantu··on China to supercharge uranium race with 150 new nuclear reactors
Fuel is miniscule part of nuclear energy cost. With increased demand it will be profitable to prospect for more, and uranium is not a rare element.
korantu··on Sustainable Energy without the Hot Air (Revised, Community Edition)
Fuel is very small part in cost of nuclear generation; As fuel price start increasing, more sources become viable, including sea water. There is practically unlimited supply once it happens, and this is before accounting for reprocessing. (and reprocessing happens in France, for example)
korantu··on Hardened wood as a renewable alternative to steel and plastic
Thank you for explanation.

It seems then we need to avoid competition with food.

TTrough human history predictions of us running out of resources did not materialize

korantu··on Hardened wood as a renewable alternative to steel and plastic
Does it also mean that using wood at industrial scale is bad idea? Trees need phosphorus too
korantu··on Hardened wood as a renewable alternative to steel and plastic
And even co2-negative, if made with captured co2
korantu··on Hardened wood as a renewable alternative to steel and plastic
you can achieve the same effect by making plastic with captured co2 [1]. Carbon would stay in plastic for very long time.

This way you get to reuse all the (enormous) existing infrastructure, as well.

[1] https://www.mdpi.com/2227-9717/9/5/759/pdf

korantu··on Is nuclear power our best bet against climate change?
I know, I am from Russia. Even Chernobyl did not make much land uninhabitable, let alone Western Europe. Exclusion zone is 30 km.

And unlike natural disasters, chernobyl and others can be learned from, and currently running stations will not fail in such manner.

korantu··on Is nuclear power our best bet against climate change?
Uranium is very common element. From your linked article :

> If one is willing to pay $300/kg for uranium, there is a vast quantity available in the ocean.[63] It is worth noting that since fuel cost only amounts to a small fraction of nuclear energy total cost per kWh, and raw uranium price also constitutes a small fraction of total fuel costs, such an increase on uranium prices wouldn't involve a very significant increase in the total cost per kWh produced.

So countries could build known and will tested reactor types to decarbonize world electricity production.

Further, given weather calamities due to global warming are detected, having dispatchable power less dependent on weather conditions is super important.

Eventually we would need to remove co2 from atmosphere as well, which is requires additional energy

korantu··on Is nuclear power our best bet against climate change?
This is pure fear mongering. There is no way for currently running nuclear power plant to make Western Europe (!) uninhabitable. Worst meltdown is that - meltdown. It stays where it happens.
korantu··on California Scrambles to Find Electricity to Offset Plant Closures
Just to clarify, nuclear power plant waste never harmed anyone, so the concern is quite misguided here. You can safely stay next to a dry cask storage [1].

By opposing nuclear one votes for more solar and wind, which come with fossil fuel support these days.

[1] https://whatisnuclear.com/waste.html#current

korantu··on California Scrambles to Find Electricity to Offset Plant Closures
The more uranium is used, the more it will increase in price, allocating more resources to exploring for new sources.

Increased uranium prices will not significantly affect energy cost, as fuel price is very small fraction of nuclear plant operation.

These days there are ways of getting uranium from sea water [1], basically making the supply practically limitless. This way is currently un-economical, but as current reserves are depleting, it will become viable option as well. (Along with researching for more reserves)

So yes, it was totally possible to decarbonise electricity production long ago.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2016/07/01/uranium-s...

korantu··on Engineer demos how SpaceX is building fracked well gas plant
I understand it is specifically about _space launch_ capability. No other state can launch as efficiently as spaceX. And private citizens get tangible benefits from it, such as internet in remote areas
korantu··on Don't give up on having kids because of climate change
we are human beings on average in the world.

surely some people are worse off than in 1990, but the number of people worse-off is significantlly reducing.

If one had a choice to be born on planet earth now or 1990, much better bet is now.

korantu··on Don't give up on having kids because of climate change
Just putting things in context here, it is quite common to consider that we are worse off now than 20 years ago (Internet was better then, etc). But that's not the case.
korantu··on Don't give up on having kids because of climate change
Globally in the world people are now better off than they ever were in human history. Telling example is extreme poverty rate that declined several times since 1990 [1]

Raising kids is tough, but not raising them because conditions are somehow worse?

Child mortality reduced 3 fold worldwide since 1990 [2] in absolute numbers, even though population continued to grow.

Kids should be personal decision, not climatechangey ones.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/mdg1a-poverty

[2] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/child-deaths-igme-data?ta...

korantu··on The Disneyfication of Atomic Power
'Safer' comes from 'Smaller' here; It is possible to have smaller reactor which is completely underground and user passive cooling, so won't meltdown.

TBH, modern big nuclear power stations are already very safe.

korantu··on The Disneyfication of Atomic Power
Exactly, thank you for bringing this up; Comparison stays true even if we include quite outlandish estimates for Chernobyl.
korantu··on The Disneyfication of Atomic Power
Not the original comment author, but will try and offer a clarification:

Malthus [1] was of opinion that humanity growth/wellbeing is bound to be curbed by wars/famines due to limits of resources.

He was mostly correct up until industrial revolution.

There are, though, people who still subscribe to Malthus idea of impending doom.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Robert_Malthus

korantu··on The Disneyfication of Atomic Power
This is indeed very important question. Nevermind newest technology, if we take existing and dated nuclear technology, and calculate safety in deaths per TWH generated, nuclear is in the same ballpark as Solar and considerably better than Wind [1] ... Gas/Oil and others are disasterous in comparison, let alone Coal.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-p...

korantu··on Klimaticket: All public transport in Austria with a single ticket for 1095 EUR/y
Though if one already have a car, then it might make sense to use it to get better value from tax and insurance
korantu··on Engineers are developing new ways to convert greenhouse gases to fuel
This ton of energy on top what we already consume can be indeed obtained from nuclear [0], without spending a lot of additional material.

[0] https://medium.com/climate-conscious/nuclear-powered-carbon-...

korantu··on Practical Front-End Architecture
I had great experience with Lona framework [0], for smaller projects; You do everything in Python, and have a representation of your UI as a set of python objects. Then changes in python objects are propagated back to web.

- [0] https://github.com/lona-web-org/lona

korantu··on Why has the price of electricity in Europe reached record highs?
Even if we ask South Korea to please build us world of nuclear, it would be long time before uranium would be an issue - it is very small part of overall price.
korantu··on Why has the price of electricity in Europe reached record highs?
South Korea can build nuclear on time and on budget, so it is possible.

And for the sake of the discussion, I think France can be fairly considered decarbonized, even if not really 100%.

Note that TFA refers to decarbonization of electricity generation only, which is the definition I use as well.

korantu··on Why has the price of electricity in Europe reached record highs?
In this case 'proven' means was ever deployed at scale and worked successfully.

Nuclear has track record of decarbonizing entire industrial economy in just 10 years.

We dont have storage solution with such track record.

korantu··on 1960s Mouse Utopias Led to Grim Predictions for Future of Humanity (2015)
It is indeed difficult/impossible to define precisely, but GDP and GDP per capita is a good start
korantu··on 1960s Mouse Utopias Led to Grim Predictions for Future of Humanity (2015)
In last 20 years in the US and other first world countries resource consumption and CO2 emissions flattened or even reversed, whereas economic growth continued almost exponentially. We can now do way more with less resources.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →