HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

laughinghan

2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010

http://twitter.com/laughinghan

http://github.com/laughinghan

submissionscomments
laughinghan··on So you've made a mistake and it's public
I'm not sure apologizing publicly has made anything better for any individual

Sure it has, for example Dan Harmon's public apology to Megan Ganz: https://www.vox.com/culture/2018/1/11/16879702/dan-harmon-ap...

Public apologies, therefore, are the metaphorical equivalent of blood in the water for attracting sharks.

What are some examples of public apologies that met all 5 of these criteria [1], but made things worse rather than better? Would you consider the possibility that maybe the apologies that made things worse were actually done wrong, but they could have helped if they were done right?

More generally, apologies, restorative justice, truth and reconciliation, and related ideas seem to me like the obvious and only way to we can heal from injustice in our society. Refusing to admit fault seems obviously corrosive to society, and to a person's ego.

[1]: https://www.vox.com/identities/2017/12/5/16710430/sexual-har...

[Edit: man, I feel stupid for complaining about downvotes, but I am really not sure how I could have been more constructive with my disagreement in this comment. I cited examples, suggested an alternative explanation for observations my parent described, and didn't criticize anyone. What did I do wrong? I am ready and willing to apologize if I made any mistakes]

laughinghan··on No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This
Thank you for clarifying, makes much more sense.

Because the only way to do price finding is to make an offer and have customers accept it. [...] So selling with a low (or free) price does not give you any moral rights later to say it was too low, give me more.

You're thinking of this in a very narrow way.

If I tell you "here, have this for free, no strings attached", and then after you use it, I jump out of the bushes and say "hey! That thing had value! You're morally obligated to pay me!", of course you are under no such obligation. That seems to be the situation you're thinking of.

What if you open your imagination a bit? What if I say, "if I tried to maximize the amount of money I made, I would have to price out people who wouldn't be able to pay anyway and their lives would be better off being able to use what I built. I don't care about maximizing the amount of money I can make, I'd just like fair compensation, so instead of setting a specific price I just ask you to 'tip' a fair amount if you can."

Am I "morally entitled" to any specific amount of money, if I didn't set a specific price? Not really, no. But it's not like I'm saying "please, have this for free, I don't want anything back, seriously", instead I'm saying "I would like something back, but I'm trusting you to decide on a fair amount".

Here's the more interesting question: if you're not obligated to pay a specific amount, can such a "trust" system work? Can I get fair compensation, and still allow anyone who wants to be able to use my work?

As it stands today, in most cases, probably not. But open your imagination a little. Can it be made to work? Can there be public pressure on major companies to contribute to TideLift and/or OpenCollective? Maybe non-commercial source-available licenses, which still contribute to The Commons, even if they're not the traditional understanding of "open source"?

laughinghan··on No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This
Sure, there aren't enough hours in the day for every person to fix every problem in the world. There are also not enough hours in the day to say everything worth saying about every topic on every forum on the Internet.

But you took time out of your busy day to comment on this thread, out of all the threads on the Internet, about this problem, out of all the problems in the world. You even came back and replied to me.

I am not suggesting you spend every waking moment of your life trying to solve every problem in the world. I am suggesting you divert a portion of the time that you're currently spending on advising people on how to live in this world, and instead spend just a little of it on thinking about how to build a better one.

while the strategy B is about just doing what you like do and hoping that it will somehow bring the desired outcome

Really? The only other option besides accepting the world as it is, is to do what you like and hope that the world changes to your liking, entirely on its own? You can't think of any other options?

laughinghan··on No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This
I have no idea what you're saying. Surely you're not saying "we all agree fast food workers don't deserve to be paid, therefore software developers don't deserve to be paid either"?

Of course fast food workers should feel entitled to be paid for their work, and fast food joints should feel entitled to charge money for the items on their menu. What?

laughinghan··on No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This
You are explaining how a person can deal with the world as it is. But if you think of yourself as a builder, then you really ought to know better than to accept the world as it is.

Are there probably choices available to a skilled software developer where they could make more money than just working on something that they love and that provides value to the world? Sure. But why is that an acceptable world to live in?

If a work adds value to the world, shouldn't the worker rightly feel entitled to just compensation? Sure, not everything in the world is as it should be, and as a responsible adult the worker may have to deal with that, they can't just sit around whining about not getting their fair share and expect everyone else to solve their problems for them.

But are YOU someone who sees problems in the world and says "yep, that's how it is, deal with it, not my problem"? Or are you someone who sees problems in the world as something to be fixed?

laughinghan··on Standing on our own two feet
Interesting point. BTW I love your blog and your work on ShareJS :)
laughinghan··on Standing on our own two feet
The man-in-the-middle can self-sign their own certs and present it to you as the site's own self-signed cert. Unless you have some way to verify self-signed certs out-of-band, they're useless.
laughinghan··on Standing on our own two feet
Did you miss the part where the "universally accepted" root certificate is going to be universally rejected in 10 months?
laughinghan··on Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
I just closed the repo I'm working on to the public and will not be making it Open Source moving forward as I originally intended.

I'm really sorry to hear that, and while it is obviously 100% up to you, I hope you to reconsider.

Every contribution to The Commons furthers the public good. Unlike the busybodies who care more about lecturing people about following the "rules" of "Open Source" to the letter, than about the spirit of fostering contributions to The Commons to further the public good, you clearly understand what actually matters.

Don't let the annoying minority keep you from doing something you know will make a positive difference in the world. If you set clear boundaries and stay matter-of-fact, the public overall will back you.

In the same spirit as the 4 "non-Free-Culture" Creative Commons licenses, I encourage you to check out non-open-source PolyForm software licenses, including a noncommercial license, a free trial license, etc: https://github.com/polyformproject/polyform-licenses#license...

Every contribution to The Commons furthers the public good, regardless of whether it's technically "Open Source" according to the Debian mailing list.

laughinghan··on Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
More important than motive is the real impact caused by the act. And the realistic harm caused by the refusal to ask people nicely for copyright assignment or to rewrite those contributions, other than to this person's own reputation, is pretty insignificant.

This person just wants everyone to go away. It's disrespectful to the community, ill-mannered, and utterly graceless, but I find it hard to call it malicious.

laughinghan··on Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
And what is the malicious act? To get rich off of the highly profitable code in those pull requests?

The "deceit" is saying whatever to get people to go away, not to hurt anyone, or to profit off of anyone else's hard work. The right thing to do is just to ask people to assign copyright (see eg https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24954772 ), but lacking the maturity do what a responsible adult needs to do is just immaturity, not malice.

laughinghan··on Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
Copyright ownership is not a matter of your opinion. It is settled law, mutually recognized by the 179 countries (out of the 195 in the world) who have signed the Berne Convention [1]. Copyright ownership is established as soon as a work is "fixed in a tangible medium of expresssion" [2]—in other words, as soon as the contributor wrote it on their laptop. The "author" entry in the package.json file is irrelevant.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berne_Convention

[2]: https://www.plagiarismtoday.com/2017/10/03/with-copyright-wh...

laughinghan··on Octotree – Proprietary Firefox extension contains AGPL-licensed code
As someone who has over the years participated in and released many an open source project, and still maintains one, I don't like the framing in some of these HN comments of the Octotree maintainer as The Bad Guy.

Obviously, it is unethical and most likely illegal to unilaterally, summarily claim copyright or relicense other people's contributions, and I appreciate the matter-of-fact tone taken by the issue opener and the other commenter.

However, I think it's obvious this isn't a scammer using open source as some kind of get-rich-quick scheme, putting in minimal effort into a fake open source project to attract highly valuable contributions in order to relicense them and make money off of other people's hard work. This someone who in all likelihood put blood, sweat, and tears into their project, gave it away for free on GitHub, accepted code contributions from people who in all likelihood were deriving a lot of value from Octotree (or else they wouldn't have had a pet issue they needed fixed in the first place), and has since grown frustrated by the time and effort costs, and the comparatively paltry returns.

Is their frustration causing them to lash out in a damaging and unproductive way? Certainly. Is it okay to renege on the implicit agreement with contributors that their contributions be under the terms of the AGPL license, and act as if those contributions were of negligible value? Certainly not. Is the maintainer right in their feeling that the value of those contributions is most likely less than the value given away for free to those contributors? I mean...probably.

I must really commend the noncombative, factual tone taken by the issue opener. And I hope the maintainer comes to their senses and deals with this problem the right way, by simply asking people nicely: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24954772

laughinghan··on Wikimedia is moving to Gitlab
Thanks for your detailed response.

I've seen all the projects claiming to have broken ReCAPTCHA—often using Google's own ML services, hilariously—but it's unclear to me how broken image/audio CAPTCHAs are in practice (and the number of GitHub repos doesn't seem like a good measure to me). If they really are completely broken, then why are they still so widely used? If they really are completely broken by ML, how do human CAPTCHA-solving services stay in business?

FriendlyCaptcha optimizes for the end user (privacy + effort + accessibility)

Good point. I am concerned though that burning CPU cycles on the proof-of-work uses battery life if the end-user is on mobile, without getting their getting any choice in the matter. What if, given an informed choice, they would have preferred an image CAPTCHA? (On the other hand, that could use more cellular data. Might be good to run the numbers on this too.)

even with a million users on one IP there won't be tens of users signing up to some forum per minute

I think this is a bad choice of threat model. "Some forum" would likely be better off with simpler measures, like a hidden honeypot textbox: https://dev.to/felipperegazio/how-to-create-a-simple-honeypo...

laughinghan··on Wikimedia is moving to Gitlab
The time being spent on Friendly Captcha is passive and can overlap with time being spent filling out a form.

Great point!

I wonder if an Argon variant would be more appropriate

The creators of Argon2 actually also created a memory-hard proof-of-work function they call MTP (for "Merkle Tree Proof", which is a terrible name, totally un-Googleable; I always have to search for the title of their paper, "Egalitarian Computing"): https://arxiv.org/pdf/1606.03588.pdf

A bug bounty for it was sponsored by Zcoin, which is nice. Zcoin is actually considering moving away from it, but mainly because the proof size of 200kb is prohibitive, which is less of a concern for a captcha system: https://forum.zcoin.io/t/should-we-change-pow-algorithm/477

I'm not surprised to see someone ripping apart a different captcha system

I really don't mean to rip it apart. I just wanted to see some discussion, any discussion, of the well-known flaws with the idea and what ideas OP has to address them.

laughinghan··on Wikimedia is moving to Gitlab
There doesn't appear to be any discussion on your website or on GitHub about why, to be blunt, this is even a good idea in the first place.

A classic 2004 paper, "Proof-of-Work" Proves Not to Work [0], explained that the fundamental problem with proof-of-work bot filters is that attackers will always be able to solve the cryptographic puzzle faster than legitimate users. A touch of security-through-obscurity can help at the margins, but you chose Blake2b, which is used by cryptocurrencies like Zcash, Siacoin, and Nano [1], and as a result there are optimized GPU algorithms (first Google result [2]) and FPGA designs (one of the top Google results [3]). Have you run the numbers on any of those?

The closest to any discussion of these numbers that I saw was a mention on your website that it may take up to 20s on mobile; for comparison, the much-hated image CAPTCHA takes about 6-12s on average for native English speakers, and 7-14s for non-native speakers [4].

In another comment you bring up the idea of starting with a lower difficulty, and increasing it with repeated requests from the same IP address (IPv4, I assume). Unfortunately, access to unique IPv4 addresses is highly correlated with access to more compute power: laptops and desktops in developed countries are most likely to be in a household with a unique IPv4 address, whereas mobile devices on 4G internet and households in developing countries are more likely to be behind Carrier-Grade NAT [5], where thousands or millions [6] of hosts share a pool of a handful or dozens of IPv4 addresses. (The exact same concern applies to IPv6 /64 prefixes.)

This means that mobile devices will face a "double-jeopardy": your service will present them with higher proof-of-work difficulties because the same IPv4 address is shared by more people, and at the same time, the mobile device solves the proof-of-work slower for the same difficulty than a desktop.

Do you have documented anywhere on your website or GitHub how you address these concerns?

[0]: https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rnc1/proofwork.pdf

[1]: https://en.bitcoinwiki.org/wiki/Blake2b

[2]: https://github.com/zhq1/sgminer-blake2b

[3]: https://xilinx.github.io/Vitis_Libraries/security/2020.1/gui...

[4]: http://theory.stanford.edu/people/jcm/papers/captcha-study-o...

[5]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrier-grade_NAT

[6]: Yes, millions. RFC 6598 reserved a /10 for them, which is 4 million unique IPv4 addresses: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6598

laughinghan··on Wikimedia is moving to Gitlab
This doesn't use a blockchain, it uses a Hashcash-style proof-of-work function (an idea that predates the Bitcoin by decades): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashcash
laughinghan··on Suicide Linux (2009)
Sounds like the ultimate Snowflake Server: https://martinfowler.com/bliki/SnowflakeServer.html
laughinghan··on My friend starts her job today, after learning to program in prison
It's apparent that you've found in your life that it's been "not that hard" to not break the law.

Have you considered that not every person in the world has had the exact same life experiences as you?

laughinghan··on They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]
There's nothing exotic about it, you just need an OLAP rather than OLTP database schema: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OLAP_cube
laughinghan··on They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]
Yeah, unfortunately in some cases if you didn't plan for it from the beginning it's not easy to tack on later.

In my opinion, it's usually worth it though. You only hear from the folks asking you to restore things from backup—you won't hear from the folks who experience unnecessary friction and tell their friends or coworkers "it's okay, it works, it's kind of annoying to use though, I can't put my finger on anything specific".

laughinghan··on They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]
I don't think that would be much better than a confirmation dialog that makes you wait 10 seconds before you can click OK. It's often only after clicking around and seeing the resulting changes that it sinks in that a mistake was made, and they reach for Undo. And that would add just as much friction to the happy path.
laughinghan··on They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]
Let's be much, much more specific about the counter-point to your counter-point. We have concrete, hard evidence they aren't doing enough to protect their users: they're massively, enormously profitable.

If they were struggling to stay afloat under the weight of that metric crapton of abuse, then maybe I would take that excuse seriously. But they aren't. Every dollar they line their pockets with while allowing their users to be abused is a dollar exploited.

laughinghan··on They're deleting my channel, but they don't know why? [video]
It sounds like you found the solution, you just made it really cumbersome: undo.

All confirmation dialogs should be replaced with undo. The happy path has lower friction, and in case of a mistake they'll heave a huge sigh of relief. When possible, it's better in all cases for all users, whether novices or power users.

And many things that at first blush seem like undo isn't possible, are actually easy to make undoable with a simple tweak: deleting data? Don't actually delete it until 24 hours later. Sending an email? Wait 10 seconds to actually send it, similar to Gmail's Undo Send.

laughinghan··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Opens for Business
That's an interesting idea, but in practice surely shareholder voting power has negligible influence on company management compared to share price incentives?
laughinghan··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Opens for Business
all the incentives of the companies listing, and existing holders, are aligned to long term

Are they? In what way?

The only difference from a normal exchange appears to be that companies are "required to publish a series of policies". Why wouldn't that incentivize saying "the right things" in those policies but then otherwise behaving exactly the same as companies listed on a normal exchange?

it sounds like voting power is tied to how long you've held

This is not actually a requirement for companies listed on the LTSE, but even if every company implemented it, in practice surely shareholder voting power has negligible influence on company management compared to share price incentives?

laughinghan··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Opens for Business
This reminds me of an article on HN from earlier this year by a reviewer of grant proposals, about how often they receive applications that clearly describe the problem the applicant wants to solve, but don't describe an idea with which to solve it: https://billwadge.wordpress.com/2020/02/10/im-good-enough-im...
laughinghan··on Accidental Pinhole and Pinspeck Cameras (2014)
Did you see Figure 16?? The camera is pointed at the back of a playing card (like, from a 52-card deck), and the front is faintly reflecting light onto a book, and they're able to reconstruct a shockingly clear image of the front of the card (King of Hearts, spoilers).
laughinghan··on Ninth Circuit rules NSA's bulk collection of Americans' call records was illegal
I don't think SCOTUS in its entire history has ever directly ordered anyone jailed, only upheld lower court rulings jailing someone or overturning opinions that concluded someone shouldn't be jailed. So at most that's recourse within the judicial system failing, not lack of recourse; obviously, pardon power can "fail" as recourse too, if anything, not providing recourse to injustice is the normal operation of pardon power.

If my choices were status quo and status-quo-except-pardon-power-is-abolished, I would probably prefer the status quo, because law enforcement overreach is currently a bigger problem than abuse of pardon power. But you made a much stronger statement: "There's no choice in a democracy but to have something like the pardon power." I disagree with that, I could easily imagine a much more just and fair democratic system where all recourse to judicial overreach still involved a decision by a judge at some point.

laughinghan··on Ninth Circuit rules NSA's bulk collection of Americans' call records was illegal
The President and VP are specifically exempt from the Hatch Act: https://osc.gov/Services/Pages/HatchAct-Federal.aspx
← PreviousPage 2 of 27Next →