2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010
http://github.com/laughinghan
I'm not sure why becoming a political issue is relevant—if Alice is generally kind to people but refuses to be kind to Bob not because of something Bob did wrong, but because the particular instance of kindness is a political issue, I don't think Alice is a kind person.
The point about grammar doesn't make much sense to me. Someone says "actually I'm not John, I'm Mary", you think it would be more grammatical to start referring to them as Mary, but continue to use he/him?
I don't know how fair it is to suggest that people who have a section in their presentations on pronouns are just trying to "signal that they're woke". It makes sense to me that someone who is personally sensitive about them or has a close personal connection with someone who is personally sensitive about them would do so out of conscientiousness, not disingenuousness.
Thanks for your perspective, I totally agree that it doesn't deserve much cognitive load. Adding pronouns to a slide that had people's names on it would take up less space than most surnames, and while shaming someone if it doesn't occur to them to do so is undeserved, it baffles me when people vehemently resist and spend incredible cognitive resources arguing that it's an enormous burden they can't possibly bear.
What is there to buy into about pronouns? If my first name is Stan, named after my dad also named Stan, and my middle name is Jason, and my dad abandoned my family when I was young so I prefer people to call me Jason, you'd have no problem calling me Jason and be understanding that calling me Stan is a sore point, right?
What if I don't want to explain my personal issues with my father and childhood family situation to coworkers? If I just say that I really strongly prefer Jason and that it genuinely upsets me if you call me Stan, would you demand an explanation?
So if I claim, without explaining, that I strongly dislike being addressed as "she" and strongly prefer "he", isn't that the same amount of work? What is there to buy into, an explanation about personal struggles with gender dysphoria? That seems like a pretty personal thing to expect from a coworker, does it not?
What am I missing?
Buzzfeed News, unlike Buzzfeed, is generally considered credible and has won multiple journalism awards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BuzzFeed_News#Awards_and_recog...
Paying someone $90 million to leave after allegedly assaulting someone [0] isn't something that happens "constantly", and seems like a pretty reasonable thing to have strong opinions about. And there's nothing "performative" about successfully rolling back mandatory arbitration [1], which studies have found is stacked in favor of employers and muzzles employees [2], and which the ABA now recommends against [3].
[0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/25/technology/google-sexual-...
[1]: https://www.theverge.com/2018/11/8/18075780/google-sexual-as...
[2]: https://www.vox.com/2018/8/1/16992362/sexual-harassment-mand...
[3]: https://www.americanbar.org/groups/law_practice/publications...
I don't think "just ask" is misleading at all. The fact that most people will happily complain about their business processes but won't have ideas to solve them doesn't make it "tricky", it makes it an opportunity.
There might be fields of endeavor where identifying solvable problems is incredibly hard, maybe in academia or politics, but business processes? Execution and, if you want to get rich, scaling up are hard. But identifying solvable problems with people's business processes is totally one of the "easiest [things] in the world".
See also: http://www.paulgraham.com/schlep.html
> WHY IS THE LANGUAGE SO NEGATIVE/PUNITIVE? THIS'LL TAKE THE FUN/CASUAL ATMOSPHERE OUT OF MY EVENT. THE PEOPLE ATTENDING ARE MY FRIENDS, I'LL VOUCH FOR THEM. ISN'T IT OBVIOUS/COMMON SENSE WHAT'S ACCEPTABLE? WE'RE ALL ADULTS HERE, WHY CAN'T WE SAY "BE EXCELLENT TO EACH OTHER"?
Not everyone understands what is unacceptable behavior, especially when we are talking about a group of people that is mostly homogenous and has very little interaction with people different than they are.
We focus specifically on what isn't allowed and what violating those rules would mean so there is no gray area, no guessing, no pushing boundaries to see what will happen. "Be nice" or "Be an adult" doesn't inform well enough about what is expected if one attendee's idea of niceness or professionalism are vastly different than another's. On top of that, "be excellent to each other" has a poor track record [link, now broken, previously described a real-world situation where people holding grudges tried to weaponize a community's sole "be excellent" rule against each other].
You may have been running an event for a long time and many of the attendees feel they are "like family", but it actually makes the idea of an incident happening at the event even scarier. If someone is new and not part of "the family" will they be believed? Will they be treated like an invading outsider?
Remember that everyone who has harassed or assaulted someone is a parent, sibling, child, or friend to someone else. We don't always know people as well as we think we do.
Isn't the problem the binary consequence, complete removal or completely left alone?
Instead, a continuous incentive gradient can push people away from the line. For example, comments on HN and Ars Technica that are downvoted are displayed grayed-out so they're harder to read and more likely to be skipped over when skimming; on Ars Technica, if a comment is sufficiently downvoted, its contents are collapsed into a stub, and you have to click the expand button to read it.
Besides pushing people away from the line, another advantage of a continuous incentive gradient instead of a discrete punishment is that because the stakes are lower, subjective disagreements are less divisive. If a comment straddles the line of violating the rules, and what's at stake is whether the comment is removed or shown, then community members will argue much more vehemently with each other and with mods than if what's at stake is whether the comment should be more or less gray, or whether the comment should be completely removed or merely collapsed.
(Zuck has discussed similar ideas about "borderline content": https://www.facebook.com/notes/mark-zuckerberg/a-blueprint-f... )
a) The company's reason for firing the guy was the content of the password, not the behavior of harassment, and jedberg was outright lying in claiming otherwise. If so, what basis do you have to believe this? What do you know about the company or the guy that jedberg is talking about other than what jedberg has told us?
b) The company's reason for firing was the harassment, but somehow the unsavory password is a complaint of harassment that cannot be disproven. This makes no sense. The content of the password cannot be disproven, of course, because it's in the computer system and so is a plain fact to all observers, but the existence or nonexistence of harassment can of course be disproven, which they checked by asking the officemate (unless you believe jedberg outright lied to us). Hence the officemate's complaint was necessary for the guy to be removed, and going to management about the password couldn't "almost guarantee someone is going to get fired".
2. The only way in which jedberg's story is self-serving is gaining imaginary points on the Internet, unless you have reason to believe jedberg stands to gain money or something else from writing his story the way he did. If your story is not self-serving because it merely helps you gain sympathy and anecdotally substantiate your argument about how the term "creep" can be used, then neither is jedberg's.
That's your job. Develop hypotheses about what the underlying problem is and ask them questions to try to falsify them. Develop hypotheses about solutions and build mockups or proofs-of-concept and have them try them out to falsify them.
No one will hand you a business idea on a platter. But problems to solve are the easiest thing to find in the world.
You're confused about the point your parent was making. Let me try to explain the context to you:
Top of thread: we think this way in Denmark (a country in Europe)
Reply: we think this way in America
Reply: "This is such blatant and obvious nonsense. ... That is a supremely American way of looking at the world."
Your parent: actually this way of thinking comes from Europe
Your parent is not saying this way of thinking is correct, only that your grandparent is silly to call this way of thinking "supremely American" and imply that it's inferior to European thinking.
"Some people profess difficulty at finding applications to write. I have never understood this: talk to people. People have problems — lots of problems, more than you could enumerate in a hundred lifetimes. Talk to a carpenter, ask him what about carpentry sucks. Talk to the receptionist at your dentist’s office — ask her what about her job sucks. Talk to a teacher — ask her what she spends time that she thinks adds the least value to her day."
https://www.kalzumeus.com/2010/03/20/running-a-software-busi...
2. "maybe we just sent a weird password to HR, and they did the default thing and fired the guy"
You just acknowledged in the prior paragraph that an actual complaint was necessary.
"years later we remember the justification that he must have deserved it because he's gone. (Details? Sorry, can't!)"
To be clear, you have already said you have no basis whatsoever to believe that he made up the details that justified the firing.
Just like I could suggest, with no basis, that you actually dumped your ex-girlfriend in a mean and nasty way over her struggles with addiction, and while distraught over the breakup she expressed her displeasure with you in conversations with mutual friends. You weren't actually present at any of these conversations, but you're sure she called you schizophrenic, satanic, and a creep, details you made up because it's easier on your conscience. You were the only person who ever perceived her as "frenzied", her job never did and neither would the cops, but it's easier on your conscience to say the only reason you didn't get a restraining order was to keep her out of jail.
All that would be entirely consistent with the facts you've told us, if I wanted to view you in the worst possible light with no basis whatsoever. Just like you're doing to jedberg.
I think you're right. I thought Vanguard or my bank did, but no, it's email or SMS plus personal info like SSN, birthdate, zipcode (LOL, information that no one has on me, thanks Equifax!).
> Could I really not fax or mail a government ID to Google to get access to my account?
To what address? Just plop it down at 1600 Amphitheatre Pkwy? I've never heard of Google offering any account support whatsoever for a free private Gmail account, have you?
I do personally know people who have just given up on accounts they lost access to (they claim they didn't forget the password) and just created a new Gmail account. Not the most technically literate person, but still, that's who support is supposed to be for. But it's a free service, so.
> then we have to be comfortable with ... going through a complicated recovery process involving government IDs
What? The whole point I've been trying to get across is that unlike TOTP or email, you can get your phone number back through a "complicated recovery process involving government IDs", which as an advantage. That's not a tradeoff to be comfortable with, that's an upside.
> I lose access to my password and email.
Why would we design for this? Unless there's a particular reason to think password and email are likely to be lost simultaneously (which I can't think of, unlike say, smartphone TOTP app + phone number), then we should either design for losing any combination of 2 auth methods, or not worry about combos.
By contrast, to me it could make sense to design a system so that you can lose any 1 of 3 things but still be able to log in with the remaining 2 makes sense (e.g. password, email, phone number). But you're right that most services are effectively just email 1FA, and many are SMS 1FA too which we all agree is utterly broken.
2. Someone sexually harassing his coworker and saying something sexual about her in his password seems magical and unlikely to you? You don't believe the hundreds of corroborated stories about men saying stuff like that openly? Or you think people are less likely to do that in something semi-private like a password than openly?
What leads you to believe this? You are aware, I assume, of the existence of "wrongful termination" lawsuits, many of which have cost companies millions of dollars?
> Can you think of a crackable-length passphrase that would make a normal, level-headed person suspicious
"rape Karen fun"
> fired in the worst way possible
What about this sounds to you like the worst way possible to get fired? Here are some ways to get fired that sound way worse to me:
"several frightening, anonymous calls that came into his work phone. One caller told him that [...] he wouldn’t live to see the weekend. Another said that the “fancy blue tie” he was wearing that day might wind up turning red. [...] an effort by the [company's] attorney to discredit him by falsely claiming he’d had a romantic relationship with [coworker he was standing up for]. Shortly afterward, [his employer] fired him."
"only two weeks after her hire, while she was in the passenger’s seat of [male employee]'s car returning from a business meeting, he exited the 101 freeway, stopped his car on a side street, and pulled his erect penis from his trousers. With the doors and windows locked from the driver’s side, he reached over “and pushed her head on his erect penis in an attempt to force her to orally copulate with him,” according to her complaint. He then ejaculated.
[her] horrifying depiction of sexual assault went on for pages. There was the ride back to the office after a client visit two days later, when [male employee] again tried to force her to touch his penis and “almost careened into a commercial eighteen-wheel vehicle.” Another time in the car, this time in standstill traffic, he took his erect penis out of his trousers and shoved her left hand back and forth on it, again ejaculating. In the complaint, she says she tried to free her hand but “was unable to overcome his strength.” In another incident, he called her into his office, locked the door behind her, and tried to force her to have sex. That time, the complaint says, she “managed to escape his grasp.”
A month after that frightening incident, [she] was fired by [him], purportedly for “an attitude problem, aversion to directions, resistance and resentfulness.” She told the office supervisor about [his] assaults and suggested that the “attitude problem” [he] had referred to was her resistance to his assaults. The supervisor told her that sort of workplace conduct was considered “normal”"
https://theintercept.com/2019/10/07/metoo-wall-street-sexual...
Do you believe it has not been tested in the courts that cameras in bathrooms are illegal? Do you believe that if you polled office workers about whether bathrooms are private and whether they expect cameras to be in there, you would get any result other than widespread belief that bathrooms are private and there cannot be cameras in there?
Do you believe it has not been tested in the courts that anything you write on a work computer is the property of the employer? Do you believe that if you polled office workers about whether they think what they do with their work computer is audited or private to them, you would get any result other than widespread understanding that employers own everything you do on your work computer?
At this company, it was public knowledge that IT will crack your password.
At the vast, vast majority of companies, it's public knowledge that they are looking at your data and email as well. If you are under the impression that your employer doesn't, you should double-check because you are almost certainly wrong.
Do you see how I took you at your word and extended sympathy, rather than questioning whether you're misrepresenting the situation? Is there something you know about the facts of jedberg's situation that lead you not to do the same?
> Twitter [...] So if you consider email to be a weak link in identity verification/2FA, adding SMS verification as a secondary option alongside email still doesn't do anything to increase your security.
I agree, and your comment's parent (my comment's grandparent) specifically went out of its way to agree: "as you said, many big tech companies say they have 2FA, when they really are just giving you two ways of logging in, where one of those ways is incredibly insecure."
> switching your number to Verizon only requires information that you know (account numbers, a SSN) [...] hacking two accounts is often harder than hacking one, and in practice, I suspect breaking into someone's Gmail account is harder than stealing their phone number
I think the number of people who go to the trouble of using like, a Yubikey or something for their Gmail but won't use it for anything else is vanishingly small. People opting for password + SMS 2FA (NOT the SMS 1FA that let @jack get hacked) are probably using the same thing for their email.
I'm sure it's true that it's easier to steal someone's phone number than break into their Gmail account, but afterwards you can go into Verizon's physical store with your physical government-issued ID and get your phone number back. That's not an option with a Gmail account.
No one is saying any of these are perfect, and everyone agrees SMS is less secure than email. The question is whether password + SMS 2FA is less secure than email 1FA, or whether password + email 2FA with no account recovery pathway is workable—doubtful, and definitely not.
Let's agree that out of password + SMS 2FA, password + email 2FA, and email + SMS 2FA, the first one is the weakest link, because SIM-jacking is terrifyingly easy and people choose terrible passwords. Just for account recovery, though, email + SMS 2FA still provides security benefits over email 1FA (you can guarantee a second factor, even if it's a weak factor, whereas you actually have no idea how strongly or weakly their email account is protected, you're just assuming) and usability benefits over email + TOTP apps/Yubikeys/paper backup codes.
Doubtless many, many other apps have also made that same mistake, yet I highly doubt it has made the difference between success and failure for even a single one of them.
All of those OS features were introduced to help people, because people wanted them, some even needed them. I don't think we live in a worse world for having them, and I believe that dealing with features like those would actually be even harder in a world without the Web.
For the vast majority of people, that's a dealbreaker, in spite of SMS being deeply flawed, as the comment you originally replied to said.
Also, you're specifically talking about SIM-jacking. The vast majority of people have upgraded phones, or broken or lost and then replaced a phone, far more times than they have been SIM-jacked. What do they do about their TOTP tokens in those scenarios?
I mostly agree with the other points (although I don't think I'm the only one with Wi-Fi calling and SMS, even abroad).
What do they do when their smartphone dies? The phone company makes sure your new phone has the same phone number, but you lose 2FA tokens in apps.
And I have no idea where the recovery codes that I printed on paper are since I last moved.
> even users who don't have a smartphone would be better served by getting codes delivered to their email
But then isn't that just one factor instead of two factors, because both their password for the service and their email password are just "something you know"? I'm assuming if they have no cell phone, they don't have a second factor to secure their email either.
Whenever people introduce any of those things, like when iOS was introduced, they had to decide how to port all the existing content and interactions and widgets to mobile and touch interfaces. As a result, if an entrepreneur or hobbyist makes an app on one platform and wants it to be at least minimally usable on another platform, the Web way, way lowers the barrier to make that jump.
(It doesn't seem to have occurred to that author to try reducing the brightness of the images, or reducing saturation with the saturate() instead of grayscale(), but those also seem worth trying, brightness in particular.)
Apple's Smart Invert is even simpler, it just leaves media like images and video as-is, only inverting colors of other things.
I suppose for diagrams that you know are black-on-white, inversion is nice, but it should be opt-in.