Although in principle, if a charity were to spend 80% of its budget on fundraising, but per-dollar donated that charity gets the best results for saving children from dying of malaria or whatever, you really would refuse to donate to it?
2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010
http://github.com/laughinghan
Although in principle, if a charity were to spend 80% of its budget on fundraising, but per-dollar donated that charity gets the best results for saving children from dying of malaria or whatever, you really would refuse to donate to it?
The problem is, those overhead tasks don’t disappear just because you don’t spend money on them. Someone has to monitor the accounts, find new donors, calculate taxes, organize the holiday party. Centralizing these tasks in dedicated departments, hiring specialists, getting good at them, that would have looked like bureaucracy. So instead, we spun them out to the entire staff ... No one had any expertise in writing grant proposals, conducting impact assessments, or managing high-maintenance funders like the European Commission—training courses would have counted as overhead spending.
https://newrepublic.com/article/120178/problem-international...
Overhead is only inefficient if the charity isn't getting results. And charities that have low overhead but still don't get results are by definition still inefficient. Don't worry about overhead, focus on results.
If someone publishes a link between my address and my name, or my address and an online handle of mine or something, in order to remove that link I would have to prove that I am the person with that name at that address, or that I am the person with that online handle or whatever, but there's no fundamental reason I would have to further identify myself in any way. There's no conflict between anonymity and control here. Their having that information about me has hurt my anonymity, but controlling that information in no way further hurts my anonymity.
The possibility of corporations being anonymous is not an example of a tradeoff between anonymity and control either. If the operator of a company had the option of being anonymous, that would be giving them more control over information about them. More control = the option of more anonymity, because there's no tradeoff or conflict, they're two aspects of the same thing.
Everyone knows no one reads terms of service, but even if people did, they don't generally specify location, just that they collect "information about your visit". Or they might mention that they collect your IP, but most people don't know what an IP address it is, much less have an intuition for how specific of location information it reveals (some probably think you can backtrace the IP and send the cyberpolice after them).
That's why ad targeting profiles shouldn't be built on that kind of incidentally-provided behavioral data. As per the Six Fixes, ads should only be targeted to the content of the page I'm looking at, just like a dead-tree newspaper.
Note that this can be achieved either technically, i.e. anonymous browsing, or legally, e.g. requiring my permission to track me to build an ad targeting profile. That's not a conflict, that's anonymity and control over data about me as two sides of the same coin.
Btw I highly recommended Maciej Ceglowski's other works, e.g. https://idlewords.com/talks/haunted_by_data.htm
I am 100% not okay with HN doing anything at all with my location information. Why would they have that information in the first place? Why would they keep it?
The discussions I frequent are more of a gray area; I favor Maciej Ceglowski's Six Fixes a lot: https://idlewords.com/six_fixes.htm
But all of this is irrelevant to the thread you're replying to, because my user id is anonymous.
I didn't suggest not storing any logging data, actually. I suggested deleting it. Old, stale logs are unnecessary for operation uptime or debugging and low-value for usability or security investigation.
They also cumulatively presents risks to customers. A gay blogger in Russia who used LiveJournal in 2004 might regret their decision now, even though in 2007 when LiveJournal sold to a Russian company, few reasonable people would have foreseen the country's turn towards homophobia later. If LiveJournal had, for example, replaced all IP addresses with cities in historical, pre-2007 HTTP logs, they would have lost nothing of value to them while their customers would be that much safer. If they had gone so far as aggregated statistics of requests and unique visitors per tuple of (user agent, city, timestamp truncated to 15-minute intervals), and then deleted detailed all HTTP logs older than 90 days as suggested by Maciej Ceglowski [1], can you think of anything of value they would have lost?
But of course I'm sure they didn't, because they weren't required to put that much thought into the data they stored.
I'm saying we should be required to.
As for the use of photos of me that are owned by other people, I'm pretty certain that neither CCPA nor GDPR cover those. The EU might have some relevant privacy laws, but they're not relevant to the "dichotomy" you brought up, because no one expects to be unidentifiable in a photo in which their face is identifiably visible.
I'm saying that the thought they put into anonymizing the data they surfaced through their UI, that same amount of thought should be put into the data we all store.
If the data can't be clustered in a way that preserves anonymity, it should be deleted (after the desired aggregate statistics are computed). Emplify probably isn't required to, and so they probably don't. I'm saying they should be required to.
Emplify, for example, makes it a point not to reveal averaged responses for subgroups of size less than 5, for similar reasons: https://intercom.help/emplify-insights/en/articles/1731829-c...
We should be making an effort to take such care with all customer data, even just when storing it. Mistakes are inevitable, of course, so small gaps that are soon fixed should be let off with a warning, with any fines proportionate to the amount of exposure and negligence involved. How would we do that? Maybe have an agency of experts tasked with determining the fines, and allowing companies to appeal those fines in open court. Like what GDPR does.
I'm a software engineer who works for a SaaS data analytics startup that has to comply with GDPR. It's not cheap, just like it's not cheap complying with all the laws restricting pollutants emitted by my car, but it's still completely worthwhile.
(My employer is not Emplify, although we are a customer of theirs. Good service.)
YES YES YES YES YES.
Are you not already doing this for passwords, credit card numbers, and social security numbers?
Such a request is essentially NP-complete.
I think you mean undecidable, or equivalent to the halting problem, or subject to Rice's theorem. NP-completeness is irrelevant. I think you'll find that HN is the last place you'll win arguments by inaccurately using technical terms in the hopes that it will go over other people's heads, Legally Blonde-style (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8rNVaY7Stt4).
To anyone who knows what they're talking about, this an obviously nonsensical argument. It's similarly undecidable to verify whether the data that you expose publicly contains customer data, or customer passwords, or your own passwords, but you do it anyway, by restricting your engineers to only write and deploy code that they understand.
> Businesses can, however, offer “financial incentives” for being allowed to collect data.
The change is from opt-out to opt-in.
necessarily there needs to be a way for that business to confirm your identity and link you to that data
Why would linking you to that data require confirming your identity? My password links my HN account to me and me alone, while revealing nothing about my identity.
There's no conflicting views. They're two, completely compatible aspects of the same view.
One is how much or how little data each service gets about you. The other is how much control you have over what those services do with the data they do get.
That's why technical and legislative solutions work in tandem, reducing the former (amount of data) and increasing the latter (control over data). That's also why technical solutions are preferable: there's no need to legislate control over data that services are unable to collect about you in the first place.
Given that propane is about 5% of US home's primary heating fuel whereas electricity and natural gas together are 80%, that seems likely: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=18131
I'm confused. Every source I can find says that with diabetes, saturated fats are worse for you and unsaturated fats are better for you (same as without diabetes):
https://www.webmd.com/diabetes/diabetes-understanding-fat
https://ucdintegrativemedicine.com/2016/09/diet-diabetes-sat...
https://www.joslin.org/info/5-common-food-myths-for-people-w...
https://www.diabetes.org.uk/guide-to-diabetes/enjoy-food/eat...
https://consumer.healthday.com/encyclopedia/diabetes-13/diab...
Why do you believe that because of your diabetes, the saturated fat in beef is better for you than unsaturated oils?
First of all, as others have mentioned, the main reason people go vegan or vegetarian is ethical concerns with animal cruelty, not health:
https://vomadlife.com/blogs/news/why-most-people-go-vegan-20...
https://faunalytics.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/Fundament...
And this is a worthless criticism of plant-based meat:
has comparable caloric and fat levels as its meat-based counterpart ... more calories, more fat and more sodium than the meaty original
Different fats vary wildly in how unhealthy they are. "In fact, some fats actually help promote good health." [1] Saturated fats (mainly found naturally in meat) is much less healthy than unsaturated fats (mainly found naturally in plants) and Omega-3 fats (mainly found naturally in fish) [1].
This doesn't mean it's as simple as meat fats = unhealthy and plant fats = healthy: trans fats are mainly made synthetically from unsaturated plant fats, but are widely considered as unhealthy or worse than saturated meat fats [1]. Coconut oil, even though it comes from a plant, is actually a saturated fat, and the evidence we have suggests it is less healthy for you than other, unsaturated plant fats, although the same evidence also suggests that it's healthier than typical meat fats like butter and lard [2].
[1]: https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-h... [2]: https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/coconut-oil
To be sure, government-funded academic research in such national security realms as cybersecurity and bioterrorism is justifiably sensitive. Likewise, academic research conducted in collaboration with U.S. companies — a principal target of most unlawful technology transfers — leads to commercial innovations that warrant protections. Universities have an obligation to comply with existing security protocols, identify sensible ways to bolster them, and cooperate fully with law enforcement authorities and corporate research partners if clear acts of espionage are suspected. To the extent we are falling short in any of these areas — and yes, there have been isolated incidents of academics sharing sensitive intellectual property with foreign governments — we can and must do better.
At odds? Aren't they perfectly complementary? The closer things are together, the faster it is to get between them.
That comment even lists a city where they've been successful: Paris
[1]: https://www.sightline.org/2016/11/29/inclusionary-zoning-the...
The US mainstream media and the Chinese state media both engage in propaganda, but they're completely, fundamentally different.
I have my quibbles with that USA Today article (which I actually found quite biased, presenting the views of 3 different Hong Kong or Chinese government offices but just one single protestor viewpoint). I have quibbles with NYT and WP coverage of Hong Kong too. But fundamentally, they're written with good-faith intent to inform. Though I perceived a bias in USA Today's coverage, they still did report on the woman shot in the eye by Hong Kong police with a less-lethal round. Chinese state media, by contrast, is reporting that she was hit in the eye by a fellow protestor, and even claims that "Internet sources" say she's in charge of paying protestors to demonstrate: http://m.news.cctv.com/2019/08/12/ARTIZFDwhpv8u9PFBzzWbYhP19...
That's not good-faith intent to inform. That's bad-faith intent to deceive. That's completely, fundamentally different the kind of "propaganda" that US media engages in.
I bet there are also internal emails calling liberals "snowflakes" and that they shadowban and demonetize liberal voices. Are you telling me you believe that never happens? They've never internally criticized a liberal or banned a liberal video?
If we agree that they both happen, where's the evidence of bias, rather than just tons of mistakes due to scale?
Interesting, what leads you to believe this is the case?
I've heard of this happening; I've also heard of the exact opposite happening, e.g. this post which cites examples of specific people and pieces of content that were banned as well as the specific dates and times and durations of the bans: https://medium.com/@thedididelgado/mark-zuckerberg-hates-bla...
I'm sure it is true that there are conservatives who've been banned and self-proclaimed "progressives" who've done as bad or worse things who haven't. Hopefully you also agree that the examples in that post, of progressives being banned while racists who should have been banned but weren't, probably really did happen.
Due to scale, it wouldn't surprise me that all of those examples could be true without there being any systemic bias on their service. What leads you to believe that such a bias exists?
From what I've read, there's actually some reason to believe the exact opposite bias exists: https://www.propublica.org/article/facebook-hate-speech-cens...
Again, I think all those examples are probably true. But I think they could be consistent with a bias in any direction, due to scale.