HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

laughinghan

2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010

http://twitter.com/laughinghan

http://github.com/laughinghan

submissionscomments
laughinghan··on Information operations directed at Hong Kong
there's nothing legally preventing mainland-Chinese from choosing to live in HK

This is completely wrong.

Mainland-Chinese may only move to Hong Kong to reunite with family, and they have to apply for a One-Way Permit, which has a "quota of 150 people per day and the waiting time for spouses is currently 4 years": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/People%27s_Republic_of_China_P...

To even visit Hong Kong requires applying for an Entry-Exit Permit in person, and duration is typically limited to 7 days: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit-Entry_Permit_for_Travelli...

laughinghan··on Information operations directed at Hong Kong
The mainstream media were all, in orchestrated unison, arguing loudly for the war.

This is plainly false.

The New York Times featured e.g. then-Senator John Kerry arguing against war in Iraq: https://www.nytimes.com/2002/09/06/opinion/we-still-have-a-c...

They also had e.g. news pieces about the UN chief chemical and biological weapons inspector contradicting the US government's claims of WMDs: https://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/31/world/threats-and-respons...

This Atlantic cover story opposed war in Iraq: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/11/the-fif...

In the UK, only The Sun unequivocally supported the war, and The Daily Mirror and The Independent both strongly opposed the war: https://www.theguardian.com/media/2002/sep/25/pressandpublis...

Washington Post columnist Katrina vanden Heuvel always opposed war in Iraq, although she's a weekly columnist so I don't have the time to scroll through her archives to find a Post article, but to prove she's not like Trump (who claims to have been against the war, but actually publicly supported it before it started and didn't publicly oppose it until after it started): https://www.thenation.com/article/powell-fails-make-case/

Sure, the US mainstream media broadly supported the war and failed to challenge the government's claims, when they should have been much more skeptical. I've seen estimates that, for example, the opinion section of the Washington Post was 91% in favor of going to war. But being duped or foolish is a world apart from being coerced, as the media is in China. Can you find even a single word in a single mainstream Chinese outlet in favor of Hong Kong democratic demands? 9% is completely different from zero. It's not even comparable.

laughinghan··on Twitter is blocked in China, but its state news agency is buying promoted tweets
it's also worrisome that a single company has the power to shut down an entire government trying to spread its ideas

To be clear, that's not what Twitter is doing. They specifically state:

"Affected media entities are free to continue to use their Twitter account(s) to organically participate in public conversation"

What they're doing is blocking paid ads by governments and deceptive practices by everyone. But they're fine with governments spreading their ideas on Twitter the old-fashioned way, by tweeting things under their own name and getting lots of likes/retweets.

And, obviously, Twitter has no power whatsoever to shut down governments spreading their ideas the old-fashioned way off of Twitter.

laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
Dang. I wonder if either there could be an anonymous feedback channel to the supervisor, or a meeting could be arranged (with the supervisor's knowledge, so they don't feel like it's behind their back) that specifically excludes the supervisor where people could discuss what changes they would like, including to the supervisor's behavior, that would conclude with the group agreeing on someone to explain to the supervisor what changes they collectively want.
laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
Thank you for explaining, that makes a lot more sense, I see how you could interpret it that way. But no, I think you're misinterpreting. For example, if I said "why are you being so slow?", that could seem like an insult, since "slow" can mean "stupid". However, if the context is that we're playing a game and you keep taking forever on your turn, then "slow" isn't an insult, it's a literal observation.

In this case, compare the thread to a normal conversation. A normal conversation consists of a long chain of alternating messages by two people, comparing and contrasting their two different points of view. This "conversation" consists of a long chain of the original poster expressing their point of view and then a different "FC Ambassador" replying each time, all expressing the same contrasting point of view.

Compare that conversation to the first 1 minute of this clip: https://youtu.be/ZsBz_Q62hHk?t=10

It's just a literal observation, not an insult.

(Technically that's Unity from Rick & Morty; I couldn't find a clip of the original Borg from Star Trek doing this.)

laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
Yes. I see you actually did understand that after all.

Are you calling it "muddy", then, because socioeconomic mobility exists? America's socioeconomic mobility is among the lowest of developed nations and getting worse since the 80s, but regardless, in order to even study such a thing requires defining it. Its definition is not muddy, it's widely accepted and studied.

I am genuinely happy for you that you were able to achieve it. I am incredibly grateful my parents were able to achieve it. But such achievements don't mean it's not still a problem.

laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
"really like? cause your workers are liars?" is not an ad hominem attack, it's contradicting you by pointing to evidence. Eyewitness testimony, by your workers contradicting you, is evidence.
laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
Wow, that's terrible.

What exactly happens to the supervisor, and what exactly does he do to all of you?

What do you think could be done to make this situation better?

I wonder if something different, maybe more serious needs to happen to the supervisor for getting a low rating? Or I guess the issue is, he gets to retaliate for a whole quarter and your opportunity to ding him further won't be until 3 months later. Maybe there needs to be an avenue for immediately reporting this kind of retaliation, with clear consequences for him? If the higher-ups don't have the kind of trust it would take to create such an avenue, I dunno what can be done. I guess that's what unions are supposed to be for, but the situation already sounds so broken. I guess if a union already existed and was trusted, it could serve as such an avenue of last-resort.

laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
> If you have to muddy the definition to make it fit

They're not muddying the definition. You're ignoring part of the definition.

Everyone has been consistent about what the definition is, and you have consistently pretended that part of the definition isn't there.

laughinghan··on I feel like im talking to the borg
Company A: "We believe in xyz."

Twitter B: "You are an <insert insult>."

But that's not what happened. "really like? cause your workers are liars?" is not an insult, it's pointing out that your workers contradict you.

laughinghan··on Flat Earthers Nearly Derailed a Space Photo Book
He did.

> He learned that he could tell Facebook whom he did — and did not — want to reach. “We specified we didn’t want conspiracy theorists and lunar landing deniers and flat earthers,” he said.

laughinghan··on Await in Rust
One of the problems with async is that it's viral. Make a function async and your entire call graph has to be made async, unless they handle the future manually without await. Async introduces a new "colour" to the language.

Not in Rust. Or C#. Or any language except JavaScript.

In Rust, a synchronous function can call and block on an async function with executor::block_on(). C# has Task.Wait() and Task.Result(). Python 3 has asyncio.run(). Scala has Await.ready() and Await.result(). Kotlin has runBlocking {}.

laughinghan··on Await in Rust
Sounds like you might prefer Erlang or Go.

But to be clear, "it'll block Node's single thread!" is not the reason for explicit await. The reason for explicit await is to guarantee that after calling a function foo(), only the state that foo() changes could have changed. Whereas after awaiting on an async function bar(), or any other promise, literally any state-mutating code in the entire application might have run.

Obviously plenty of languages have this problem and deal with it, usually with locks like in Go and Java, or by banning shared mutable state entirely and only allowing message-passing for communication between concurrent "lines of logic" like in Erlang. (As far as I understand Go basically tries to get the best of both worlds by strongly encouraging message-passing, with locks intended only for advanced situations like custom concurrent data structures.)

But there's no way for Node to change to either of those models without breaking every single nontrivial piece of code ever written in it. And apparently Rust intentionally chose not to go with those models because they require a runtime and make compatibility with C very difficult, well-known advantages over Go.

laughinghan··on Await in Rust
But when all those IO functions are rewritten to be async, their public names can be different. The sync versions needn't change names, so none of the callers would need to change. Nor would the sync versions need to duplicate code, because they can just be thin wrappers that call and wait on their async counterparts. (Note that this wouldn't be possible in JS.)
laughinghan··on Ebola Is Now Curable
Yes, if you "peek" at the results of an A/B test before it's done in order to decide whether to stop early, the numbers you "peeked" at have much lower statistical power than if you foreswore stopping early. Obviously, failing to take that into account when drawing conclusions about the effectiveness of the treatment is a colossal mistake.

However, the decrease in statistical power is still quantifiable, and with the right math you can still calculate an accurate 95% confidence interval on the effect size (which will be much wider than the wrong math where you naively don't account for the "peeking"). And of course, it's totally possible that the treatment is so effective that even the accurate calculation shows that the lower bound on the effect size is so much higher than the control group that the responsible thing to do is to stop the trial early.

Here's some the math on how much lower the statistical power is if you "peek": https://www.evanmiller.org/bayesian-ab-testing.html

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
What in the world are you talking about?

Of course the world is not black and white, there are shades of grey. That is completely orthogonal to subjectivity vs objectivity. Just because a situation is grey and no one can agree on which shade of grey it is, doesn't mean the situation doesn't objectively have a shade. It can just mean humans are fallible and can't see perfectly, so we're all wrong to some degree about the correct shade. But there could still be a correct shade.

Separately, every single example you brought up is black-and-white. If a "knife-wielding maniac" were in the process of killing random innocents and police don't have a way of nonlethally restraining them, then of course the police are justified in killing them. If a cop in the USA or anywhere was in mortal danger and had no way of nonlethally restraining their attacker, then killing their attacker is justified regardless of the mental health of their attacker. If an innocent isn't following contradictory commands and isn't threatening anyone's life, of course it isn't justified to kill them, what are you talking about?! There is nothing grey about the fact that failing to follow contradictory commands by police should clearly not be punishable by death?!?!!

I'm sure there are tons of Han Chinese on the street who think concentration camps for Muslims in China is acceptable, just like there are tons of Americans on the street who think concentration camps for Muslims in America is acceptable, just like there were tons of Americans on the street who thought that internment camps for Japanese-Americans were acceptable, tons of Palestinians who think all Jews are invaders who should be wiped out, tons of Jews who think all Palestinians are suicide-bombers who should be wiped out.

Those people are wrong. Those examples are not shades of grey and not subjective, lots of people disagree because lots of people are wrong.

I'm also wrong about lots of things, I should not be dictator of the world, and neither should anyone else. That's why we need a system with rules set up so that the more wrong ideas shrink in influence and the less wrong ideas spread in influence.

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
If a mosque openly fostered extremism in spite of arrests and multiple massacres, you'd have a problem with their landlord refusing to continue to rent to them?
laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
Yes, and part of that system can be a culture among those in power of tolerating anything but intolerance.

My comment was an explanation of why advocating such a culture, as part of this system, is not an "evil [...] far worse [than "kill the jews"]".

laughinghan··on A Framework for Moderation
In the same breath that the owner of 8chan made that claim (literally the same breath, he made the claim in a video), he also claimed that the gunman uploaded the manifesto to Instagram first. Instagram says that's false, the gunman's Instagram account hasn't been active for a year. I'm inclined to take Instagram's word over the owner of 8chan: https://www.cnet.com/news/8chan-owner-says-el-paso-shooter-d...

Also, that claim was by the owner, not founder, of 8chan. The founder of 8chan now disavows it and celebrated on Twitter when Cloudflare took it down.

laughinghan··on A Framework for Moderation
I don't see a problem here. The more people think the Nazi's speech is harmful, the smaller the Nazi's reach is. This is exactly the incentive gradient we want. You're describing the free market of ideas working excellently.
laughinghan··on A Framework for Moderation
China's Great Firewall is run by the state. By law you're not supposed to circumvent it.

There is no law that says you have to use Cloudflare and if they ban you, you're not allowed to be on the Internet. It just costs you time and effort, possibly money, hopefully reach.

What leads you to believe that the person they're responding to doesn't simply wish more private entities would exercise their legal right to listen to their conscience on who is too hateful to do business with? That's not censorship of important information, that's the free market of ideas at work.

The Stratechery article explicitly discusses this phenomenon and endorses it. What leads you to believe that the person they're responding to disagrees with the article on this point?

laughinghan··on A Framework for Moderation
Moderated. Not regulated.

You could spread your message further by printing lots of posters and putting them up in your city, but it would obviously not be comparable in reach to the Internet. Newspapers that do have reach comparable to the Internet all choose to exercise their legal right to decide for themselves what is too hateful to spread. Cloudflare has now chosen to exercise that same right, to a tiny extent.

laughinghan··on A Framework for Moderation
I'm confused by your stance. Is it your position that ISIS recruitment videos don't work? They spend a huge amount of effort on online recruitment, but 100% of the people that go join them would all have voluntarily done so anyway?
laughinghan··on Amazon Is a Monopoly
What does "Amazon won't accept" mean? Doesn't Amazon just show the lowest price of all its current suppliers, and if the current lowest-priced supplier runs out, it shows the next lowest price?

(No fan of Amazon here, just trying to understand what you're saying.)

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
Mosques have a responsibility to reject extremism and report dangerous individuals to the FBI. And they do: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/mar/20/fbi-informant

A mosque in America that openly fostered extremism like 8chan did would of course get shut down.

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
> "But the point is: who's to judge which ones are right and which one are wrong?"

I address this. In fact, I explicitly say I agree. No one can be trusted to make that judgment. Hence, the need for a system that doesn't place absolute trust in anyone.

> "we want a system such that [...]" [...] I wouldn't really say this is guaranteed either

What? You wouldn't say what is guaranteed? You wouldn't say it's guaranteed that we want such a system?

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
What are you talking about? We can and do arrest, charge, and convict "evil islamic imams" that "preach radicalization", and don't let them operate mosques. We tolerate and welcome mosques because they ban radicals and report them to the FBI:

"Monteilh eventually so unnerved Orange County's Muslim community that that they got a restraining order against him. [T]hey also reported Monteilh to the FBI"

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/mar/20/fbi-informant

You do know that Homeland is a TV show and not real life, right?

A mosque that openly fostered extremism like 8chan did would of course get shut down. By contrast, 8chan has not been shut down. Its operations have been disrupted, but it hasn't shut down, anymore than Cloudflare has shut down just because they had a site outage last month.

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
As a fellow math enthusiast, I would love to grab a coffee or beer with you next time I'm in NYC and hear about this journey. Care to email me? laughinghan@gmail.com
laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
You're pointing out that people disagree about what's "reasonable", the takeaway being that since "reasonableness" is subjective, a rule based on whether something is reasonable won't work "because the world is not made up of a bunch of you:s".

But just because people disagree about something doesn't mean it's purely subjective. Some things have an objective truth value but people will still disagree on it, because people get things wrong sometimes. Objectively wrong. All the time, in fact.

You're right that neither "ajross" nor "bjross" should be the moral authority who dictates the moral values. That's because they're almost certainly wrong about some things. You're almost certainly wrong about some things. I'm definitely wrong about some things, and I really hope I find out as much as I can about what I'm wrong about as soon as I can.

Therefore it would be a bad system to set up any one person as the moral authority. Instead, we want a system such that over time, the objectively better views dominate and the objectively worse views shrink in influence.

A total free-for-all where anyone can say anything and any kind of engagement will help promote those views, like 8chan or Gab, is clearly not such a system. You don't think a careful implementation of "tolerating anything but intolerance" could possibly be such a system, and is in fact a "far worse evil"? What rules do you think there should be, or do you think a free-for-all with no rules is the only way to not lead down the "slippery slope"?

laughinghan··on 8chan goes dark after hardware provider discontinues service
> We should be reaching out to these people and at least trying to wrestle them back to sanity.

If you believe that's what we should be doing, why aren't you doing that? There are people right here in this thread you could be reaching out to: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20617883

← PreviousPage 10 of 27Next →