HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

legutierr

3,060 karma · joined July 21, 2011

submissionscomments
legutierr··on SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered securities exchange
> And given that we've seen exchange after exchange fail to perform basic tasks like "don't commingle customer funds," I have a hard time feeling any sympathy for cryptocurrency companies here.

There is nothing per se nefarious about co-mingling customer funds, provided that you are otherwise compliant with the law.

Banks, for instance, don't just co-mingle customer funds, they invest those funds on their own behalf and reap the profits for themselves. Sometimes a bank will share a portion of its profit with its customers, in the form of intest; more often, the bank pays little or no interest, and actually charges the customer fees. A bank will risk its customers' money, and its customers will pay for that privilege.

Kraken has been operating under the money transmitter licensing scheme for a decade, and like banks, money transmitters don't have any legal requirement to segregate customer funds—although they do have the responsibility to maintain sufficient cash balances or liquid investments to cover all of what they owe to customers.

Whether Kraken is breaking the law is something that will likely be decided by a court. The SEC asserts that Kraken has broken the law, but it is not up to the SEC to decide—it is up to the courts.

It is not illegal to operate a spot commodities exchange without approval from the SEC, unless those commodities are also the kinds of securities the trading of which require SEC approval. It is also not illegal to operate as an unlicensed broker-dealer of non-security commodities, or as an unlicensed custodian of non-security commodities. The SEC only has jurisdiction over securities.

It is not in the slightest bit clear yet that the crypto tokens for sale on Kraken are in fact securities of any kind. The SEC asserts that they are, but at this point it is just an assertion. The SEC will have to win in court.

legutierr··on BitVM: Compute Anything on Bitcoin [pdf]
> All NP problems have transcripts that are validatable in polynomial time

Sure, but are they provable in polynomial time?

Proof generation is much more expensive than just running through the original computation through standard means.

> However with some cool zero-knowledge crypto magic, you don't even have to reveal the Merkle inclusion proof, nor even the key itself.

I hate that the exact way that ZK systems work is always omitted from any discussion of the subject. It is very complicated, which explains why no one like to (or is even able to) get into the specifics, but somehow this also leads to handwavy assertion that all we need to do to avoid all that expensive and duplicative computation is to sprinkle in some zero-knowledge proofs.

Due to performance limitations, for all intents and purposes ZK tech is impractical to the point of being infeasible for truly decentralized blockchains with turing-complete smart contract capabilities. It works for more specialized purposes, but it is not a currently solution to the "duplicative computation" problem.

legutierr··on BitVM: Compute Anything on Bitcoin [pdf]
On-chain computation is required if state is also stored on-chain. Local state is transformed by every node on the network in exactly the same way. It's not wasteful—it's the reason that every node knows definitively that the state advertised by the rest of the network is actually correct.
legutierr··on LLMs confabulate not hallucinate
This seems like circular reasoning to me.

"Human's don't just parrot what other people say, therefore we must be doing something more than what LLMs do, because an LLM only parrots the words that it is trained on. But an LLM is not truly intelligent because it is not doing what humans are doing—and because the LLM is not intelligent, all it is doing is parroting the training data."

Where in this line of reasoning is it proved that the mechanisms are different?

What if, instead, the conscious intelligence that differentiates humans from other animals is an emergent quality of language learning, specifically? Isn't there evidence that children that don't have access to language—deaf children who are not taught sign language, or feral children, or seriously neglected children—often cannot reason before they are taught language, and suffer from long-term cognitive impairment for having lacked language during their early development? Wouldn't this point to a fundamental linkage between language and human intelligence?

legutierr··on LLMs confabulate not hallucinate
> The answer to "What are LLMs but humans with extreme amnesia and no central coherence?" is that they are not like humans at all, and only resemble them superficially.

Is there any chance at all that we humans are are also just predicting the next word in the sentence? That the "voice in your head" that so many people report having is itself some kind of LLM that is, to some extent, driving their reasoning?

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehumanization
legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
Everything humans create depends on humanity existing, and humanity ceases to be without children.

Human life is a prerequisite for everything humans create.

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
Congratulations, you really do make a lot of money. Going by the averages, based on the information you shared, and assuming you live in the US, I’d say you make north of $300k per year.

Thanks for sharing that with us. Now we know that you are a member of the group that we are talking about here (the middle class and rich). Maybe you can shed some light on how members your demographic actually think about having children.

So, am I wrong? Are you avoiding having children primarily because you pay too much in taxes to afford them, and not for some other reason?

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
I think you might be misreading some of these comments. I also wonder if you are aware of the history of eugenicist ideas in the west, and how enmeshed those concepts are in many every-day attitudes about who should be having children—often without people understanding the history (and original intention) of policies they espouse. I am not advancing any kind of conspiracy theory here.

And I think you misrepresent the potential harm. Anti-natalists don't just want to forgo having children. Many anti-natalists also want to discourage or prevent other people from having children. In fact, I'm sure many people making anti-natalist comments here do intend to have children themselves—they just want to discourage or prevent other people they find undesirable from having kids.

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
It's such a strange thing to argue that a child who is poor would be better off never to have been born at all—and then to characterize that argument as somehow being in favor of that child's interest.

My point is that a hard-working, upright and moral couple that wants a child should have one even if they are dirt poor, and shouldn't stop themselves because they don't have money. If the child ends up being unhappy in that environment purely as a result of the lack of money, then that is society's failing—our failing—not a failing of the parents'. We haven't done our duty to help this couple raise a happy family.

> In which family did you grow up? Pops and moms were happy campers with middle class income?

This is a strangely personal comment. Is this argument very personal for you? Is there something about your own life that makes you want to deny life to others?

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
> Poverty is a variable to properly taking care of a child, that does not mean that the parent means that being poor automatically makes one unfit to have a child, which is what you're conflating, if I understand correctly.

In fact, the other commenters were conflating these two things, which I wanted to point out. I agree that they should not be conflated.

> If one is poor but can provide the proper nutrition and housing to a child, then great, have them, but if not, then no, I don't believe it is controversial or offensive to say that it would be better for them to not have a child. Child abuse is a big problem for a reason.

The right decision for an individual couple to make is not the same as the right policies and practices for society to implement.

There are people who are unsuitable for having children, but that number is vanishingly small (or at least it should be). Everybody else just needs support, resources, and instruction.

It might be better for a couple that does not have support, resources or knowledge to forgo having children. Whenever that happens, though, it is a tragedy for humanity. The rest of us should find ways to support families that are otherwise lacking, so that having children is the best option for them.

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
> We should work towards counteracting those systemic incentives, by making it easier for middle class, educated people to have kids (an example would be % tax breaks for each child, which would be more money for middle class people).

Yes, and we should also reduce poverty as well, no? So that we can make it easier for currently-poor to have kids as well?

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
I think you might be missing the point.

The apparent concern that these comments show for the well being of children is misdirection and rationalization, hiding the true intent behind anti-natalist perspectives, which are fundamentally eugenicist in nature.

At their foundation, these comments presume that there are people who deserve to have children, and that there are people that do not—in other words, that there are children that deserve to be born, and that there are children that do not deserve to be born.

Poverty is just a proxy for other qualities that would be much too controversial to articulate explicitly.

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
In what world is this NOT a controversial point?!? Genuinely, I ask: what is the cultural environment in which you exist, such that you can make this argument without at least knowing that other people would find it deeply offensive?

> If you cannot properly take care your children, don't have one.

OK, so poverty prevents a person from "properly" taking care of children? Would you say that poor people able to take care of their children, but only "improperly"?

What, might I ask, is the minimum acceptable level of income that a couple should have before having children? What do they do, those hard-working, upright and moral couples who don't make enough money to meet your standard? Should they live their whole lives childless, and die alone?

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
> People who are irresponsible probably aren't calculating the costs..or they don't care.

Are you saying that poor people who have children are implicitly irresponsible for having had children? That seems to be what you are saying.

As a general rule, don't we want everyone to have kids—including poor people? What do poor people have to do to have kids "responsibly", in your view?

legutierr··on Most demographers now predict that human population will plateau
Don't we want people in general to have more kids, not just middle-class people and rich people? And don't we want those kids to have healthcare and lunch at school?

Are you saying that middle class people are less able to afford children because they pay too much in taxes? Really? Taxes are a primary consideration, not the cost of housing and education?

legutierr··on One robber baron’s gamble on railroads
> Cash already does that and so does my chip n pin card.

Does the merchant who accepts your chip n pin payment receive the funds in their account immediately after they accept your payment? In the US, merchants have to pay fees and/or interest to get same-day access to that money—because such access effectively functions as an advance on receivables. In most countries, same-day settlement is completely unavailable.

Cash isn't much better. Can a store owner pay for inventory with cash? Maybe some inventory, but most things need to be paid for electronically. Can a retailer process payroll using cash? Turning cash into electronic money is a hassle and a security nightmare. Armored cars exist for a reason, and they aren't free.

Crypto payments can be spent immediately upon receipt. No settlement delay, no need for armored cars.

> There's an advertisement showing in the UK that lampoons crypto. A bloke buys some onions from a stall (ie direct sale from field to consumer) and he is asked which crypto he will use to pay with. The putative buyer says he has a fiver (cash).

Funny. What is the advertisement selling?

> Blockchain transactions require time to work. The ledger has to be updated correctly by agreement with the rest of the network to work and that takes time. I can do a tap to pay and my phone beeps within a very few seconds to note a transaction.

This comment reminds me of the Kodak executives who thought there would never be a market for the digital camera the company had invented, because its resolution was so much lower than that of film.

Your information is out-of-date. Bitcoin is slow. Next-gen crypto is fast. Personally, I'm partial to the lightning network, which finalizes payments in seconds.

legutierr··on One robber baron’s gamble on railroads
> What exact counter party risk is eliminated by blockchain technology?

Some specific examples currently available:

• Atomic swaps, where traded assets are immediately moved between accounts upon execution of the trade, eliminate the possibility that settlement will not complete.

• Real-time commerce, where merchants accept payments in a format that can immediately be turned around and spent, without waiting for reimbursement from third-party networks.

• Loans backed by on-chain collateral, such that default triggers immediate transfer of collateral, eliminates the risk that collateral may not be obtainable upon default, or that the value of collateral may fall too far before the loan is liquidated.

> It’s not like I audit the entire trail of any arbitrary transactions, which is usually where things like that come into play.

Open databases can be digested and analyzed by open-source tools, and by trusted independent third-parties. Closed databases cannot be analyzed by anyone except for the database owner and government authorities. Some government authorities are trustworthy, others are under-resourced, incompetent or corrupt. Even if you personally won't read the full history, you benefit from other people being able to do so.

> Also, how’s blockchain better than existing and ongoing open banking projects? They’re enfranchising people today.

Problems can have multiple good solutions! Still, open API access is different from open access to underlying data and algorithms. Open APIs and blockchains can co-exist and benefit from each other.

> What about fraud?

Fraud is a complex topic. The traditional financial system has seen lots of fraud over the years (think about what we witnessed in 2008). Credit card fraud is also a rampant problem that is only managed by large financial firms heavily surveilling payment networks.

There are fraud vectors that blockchain networks are more susceptible to—just like there are other fraud vectors that blockchain networks are less susceptible to than traditional financial systems.

In my view, the greatest fraud risk in crypto comes from the issuance of tokens that are questionable in some way—a risk that I think can be eliminated if strong controls are implemented regarding the issuance of tokens on-chain.

legutierr··on One robber baron’s gamble on railroads
Is there a better solution for the performance of atomic swaps between antagonistic traders each operating in a different legal jurisdiction?
legutierr··on One robber baron’s gamble on railroads
It's relevant that the first railroad bubbles took place several decades before the events described in the article. Sometimes it takes a long time for capital-intensive technologies to be fully deployed, and for economic benefits to be fully realized.

In twenty years the use of public blockchains in everyday finance and trade will be mundane. Former crypto skeptics will explain that their earlier complaints pertained only to the crazy things happening in 2020, not the boring & ordinary things that crypto is used for in 2040. And meanwhile, nearly everything "financial" involving counter-parties will happen on-chain.

Why? Because public blockchains eliminate counter-party risk for a large number of transactions, provide unparalleled transparency, and give anyone with an internet connection access to global financial markets, enfranchising billions of people who are otherwise locked out due to unsatisfactory local conditions. Blockchain tech will make developed economies more efficient, and will accelerate development world-wide.

If you don't agree that public blockchains actually do anything useful, then you'll probably object to the railroad analogy. But if you see value in blockchains, then there are clear parallels:

• Initial cost of the build-out being funded by early investors who might not be around to realize the long-term benefits of the technology.

• Speculative energy attracting scammers alongside legitimate operators.

• Long-term benefits not being obvious after the first wave of investment dies down.

• The true value of the technology only being realized when network effects are fully realized, years after the technology's introduction.

legutierr··on ‘Sea is constantly dumping bodies’: fears Libya flood death toll may hit 20k
Misrata is in Libya, no? Were the people who captured and killed Gaddafi not Libyans?

Are you saying that these people were working under orders from NATO? What was their motivation, if they were not fundamentally angry about how Gaddafi had treated their fellow countrymen?

legutierr··on ‘Sea is constantly dumping bodies’: fears Libya flood death toll may hit 20k
Right, of course. The thousands of people gathered in protest in Kiev were all there at the direction of the U.S. State Department.
legutierr··on ‘Sea is constantly dumping bodies’: fears Libya flood death toll may hit 20k
A Russian puppet was overthrown by a revolution of the people, and replaced by a democratically-elected president, followed by multiple successful elections, and the peaceful transfer of power from one party to another, over nearly a decade, and Russian apologists call it a "coup".
legutierr··on ‘Sea is constantly dumping bodies’: fears Libya flood death toll may hit 20k
If Lybian forces were on the verge of committing war crimes and killing thousands, then "intervention" would be an appropriate word to describe what the Western powers did. They "intervened" to prevent an imminent atrocity, if you believe them.

And I am inclined to believe them, not because of what Western governments have said, but because the whole Arab Spring played out in real time on social media.

I agree that what happened to Gaddafi himself was horrific. It would have been a much better thing if he had been arrested and brought before a tribunal. But he was killed by Libyans, who were angry about the Libyans that Gaddafi himself had killed. The contribution that Western Governments made to those events was to stop the killing of thousands of people who opposed the regime. Arguing against intervention is arguing in favor of what would have happened without intervention—which is, effectively, what we have seen in Syria.

Now, was Volodymyr Zelenskyy on the verge of murdering tens of thousands? Were Ukranian forces gathered, ready to rain artillery shells down on a major Ukrainian city? If not, I don't think it would be appropriate to describe the Russian invasion as an "intervention". What would Putin have been "intervening" in? Ukranian self-determination?

legutierr··on There are now two types of PayPal dollars, and one is better than the other
Are you asserting somehow that blockchain tech violates the fundamental physical laws of the universe?
legutierr··on CNET is deleting old articles to try to improve its Google Search ranking
Do the engineers at Google even know how the Google algorithm actually works? Better than SEO experts who spend there time meticulously tracking the way that the algorithm behaves under different circumstances?

My bet is that they don't. My bet is that there is so much old code, weird data edge cases and opaque machine-learning models driving the search results, Google's engineers have lost the ability to predict what the search results would be or should be in the majority of cases.

SEO experts might not have insider knowledge, but they observe in detail how the algorithm behaves, in a wide variety of circumstances, over extended periods of time. And if they say that deleting old content improves search ranking, I'm inclined to believe them over Google.

Maybe the people at Google can tell us what they want their system to do. But does it do what they want it to do anymore? My sense is that they've lost control.

I invite someone from Google to put me in my place and tell me how wrong I am about this.

legutierr··on I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
> Come for a couple of weeks, or get an immigrant visa.

You mean, come for a couple weeks, but don't fall in love or start a family with an American girl or boy.

> Getting married is fine. Getting married and then changing your mind is acceptable.

I would imagine that getting married and changing your mind is what this policy is meant to encourage! What about getting married and not changing your mind? What about having and raising children?

Is it United States policy that the children of such marriages must be raised only by single parents?

legutierr··on Automakers try to scuttle Massachusetts ‘right to repair’ law
I’m not sure how this logic applies when having insurance is mandatory. If you don’t have insurance, you’re not driving legally.

Are there really people out there who wouldn’t otherwise buy insurance, but they choose to do so only because the cost of repairs is too high?

legutierr··on Supreme Court strikes down affirmative action in college admissions
> primarily coming from decreases of nonwhite students

Given the actual numbers, its more likely that the largest number of applicants negatively affected by this will be white, in absolute terms.

legutierr··on SEC Sues Binance and CEO Zhao for Breaking US Securities Rules
Former Comptroller of the Currency (and former Chief Legal Officer at Coinbase) Brian Brooks served as CEO of Binance.US for only 3 months in 2021. He makes a very credible witness!

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_P._Brooks#Binance.US

← PreviousPage 2 of 26Next →