Because every use case I heard so far can already be solved more efficiently without blockchains.
1,002 karma · joined May 15, 2008
[ Kismet Code: 0b8f2d ]
meet.hn/city/us-San Diego
Socials: - github.com/leifg
Interests: Remote Work
---
Because every use case I heard so far can already be solved more efficiently without blockchains.
I've been following this space for a while and honestly I don't see how a counterpart would actually look like. We had blockchains/crypto for almost 13 years and the only thing that came out of it is a speculative semi-unregulated asset market. Still Forbes, NYT etc... always write articles like "Cryptocurrencies are volatile asset that is doomed to crash, but the underlying blockchain technology is here to say". Without offering any kind of proof for the second part of the statement.
Show me one blockchain application that has nothing to do with virtual assets that not only turns a profit but is provably more efficient than a database based solution.
Whenever I bring this up, the response is usually: "We're just at the beginning, this will take a while". For a space that is claiming the disruption of everything it's moving pretty slow.
And the second question: what happens if you use your private key? Every website that uses password has a mechanism to reset your password. Take that feature away you'll lock out millions of users.
Here is an English translation: https://cleanenergyrevolution.org/publications
There are multiple providers that sell you various areas of space. But in the end it’s just a piece of paper that grants you nothing. Yes you can brag to your friends that you own a giant piece of land on the moon with earth view but not only is that pretty useless it also doesn’t matter ever. Because if the moon is ever colonized you won’t be able to claim the said land just because some private company said you own it.
When talking about NFTs I often hear that somehow ownership rights are attached to it. Which is only true if the rightful owner of the art explicitly states that ownership is defined by “whoever has access to the private key”.
1. You are responding to a comment that didn't talk about mandates under an article that says nothing about mandates. You are the one who brought it up.
2 and 3: In isolation you are right, we should probably take more measurements towards healthy living. But if you only bring that up as a counter point to COVID measures, you are at very best making a flawed analogy.
My point is: if there is anything feasible measures we can take for healthier living, great we should do that. But we should ALSO do something about COVID.
1. No one is talking about mandates 2. Yes living unhealthy is a burden on the health care system. But I am fine with that as long as your actions only have consequences in your own life. With an infectious disease that's different because you suddenly have a multiplier. I didn't hear about any ICU capacity issues because of obese people. 3. We (at least most countries) already have measures to increase the overall health of our society (smoking bans in certain places, age limits on alcohol consumptions, programs in schools to provide healthier food in cafeterias, you name it).
However by catching COVID you are also a burden to the health care system and possibly take away a hospital bed for someone who actually needs it (already happening). I do have a problem with that.
The only argument I can think of against it is: Certain vaccine skeptic people might be incentivized to catch the virus on purpose.
A big reason why influencers or any kind of celebrity are successful is because enough people aspire to be like them. That's pretty hard to achieve for an AI.
It limits you to certain jobs and there is a lot of competition (from anecdotes I see there is a lot of interest for developers to learn but not a ton of interest in companies to use it). I started with Elixir in 2015 and even though there are more companies now using it than back then, I don't see a strong upwards trend line.
Furthermore what happened twice: Elixir will be one or two projects within the companies. In one case it was a micro service architectures with plans to replace Elixir with a different language.
So worst case scenario is you will end up in a company that technically uses Elixir but for various reason you will not end up working in an Elixir based project and you only have a limited set of other languages to choose from. So at the very least pick a second favorite and apply to companies that use that technology.
All of that being said: I use Elixir for 100% of my side projects and love the language. I love the ecosystem and the community.
On a technological level I think that is pretty sound.
I think however that introduces a bunch of potential social issues in the aftermath:
- If people would get a piece of paper after the vote that shows their random ID and their vote they would have to immediately notify a person working at the voting booth to correct it - If for whatever reason they find out that the official record afterwards shows they vote for someone else, is there gonna be a process to correct it? - If there is, that could open the door for people forging random voting slips in order to swing votes retroactively - If there is a somewhat airtight system that prevents forging it could create a real market for buying votes. If someone wanted to buy a vote nowadays it is pretty hard to verify that the people actually voted for their candidate. Now all the bought voters would need to do is send in or send a picture of their random ID.
You can probably address all of these problems but I'm not sure it will be more economical than paper ballots in the end.
When does non-reversal ever benefit the average Joe?
The only scenarios I can think of is when you transact with non-trustable sources. E.g. buying “stuff” off the darknet (and even here you usually have an escrow).
And that’s just not a use case in most people’s everyday life.
So by just port scanning on the SMB port you’ll find a lot of computers and would have access to all their files.
Not a lawyer here but I’m guessing.
Not all legal loopholes automatically deprive you of all your savings. Intentional loop holes only go so far before consumer protection or other entities overwrite it. And if both parties are in agreement and in good standing you can figure out a way to find a reasonable compromise.
Yet we have an almost endless list of people being cheated out of their money (countless stories of people/exchanges losing their private keys, pump and dump schemes left and right, not to mention the lawsuits against Tether)
- read this $blockchain_book - just wait, these things take time
I have never once heard specifics that are even close to convincing
Reminds a little bit of Java labels where you can do this:
public class Labels {
public static void main(String args[]){
https://hn.ycombinator.com
for(int i=0; i<10; i++){
System.out.println("......."+i );
}
}
}
the https: is a label named https and everything after the colon is a comment so this is valid code.Unfortunately for libraries you will also have to have a system in place for all the library hosting providers (npm, rubygems …) to transfer ownership as well.
Just went to the homepage of McDonalds and guess what their title says:
Burgers Fries & More. Quality Ingredients.
…
In reality you have an insane amount of fraud and shadiness going in order to increase some arbitrary token value.
Undoubtedly git's implementation is very similar to current blockchains but it's missing a reward function (PoS, PoW).
So I would argue it's not a blockchain because of that.
Yes and: Whenever you add new features you will create new edge cases for existing code.
So even if you could evaluate all edge cases of existing code you would have to do that on your existing code base for all changes going forward.
Last time I checked there are already tons of apps for banking use cases. I use a third party budgeting app across multiple accounts. For my European bank account I use a third party tool to wire money. During my time as a freelancer I used tools that fetched my transactions, automatically categorized it and gave my accountant access to it to prepare my taxes.
What use case do you want to build that can’t be build on top of an API?
Great you solved a very specific problem and replaced it with a myriad of other problems. Who is gonna take care of your private key? Are you really that confident in your tech skills that you can keep the private key to your money safe? I am not. If someone else issues and protects your private key, what’s stopping them from charging you fees for nothing (or spending all your money).
> There would be a public record of all charges the smart contract billed you for
I as a bank customer have exactly zero interest in my transactions being “public” (I know they would be pseudonym, still pretty risky). The risks I imagine coming with this outweigh the supposed advantages by a lot.
> tracking the history of it would be way easier than piecing together your Wells Fargo statements
I don’t know in which century you live but I have a history of all my transactions of all my bank accounts in the interface of my budgeting tool. I can immediately see if there is a suspicious charge. But maybe you have a recommendation for a blockchain based budgeting tool that lets me see details of every transaction, rather than public keys.
> This also would be much easier for auditors and financial crime investigators to notice.
If it was so easy to investigate shady things on the blockchain why aren’t all these pump and dump scammers and ransomware groups in prison?
And yes they have been given assurances to entrepreneurs. I have been on this planet for 30+ years and my bank accounts have never gone to 0 because of a “database problem”
I really don’t understand what your point is.
Even assuming your timeline is correct. And even ignoring that the top comment on this HN addresses this exact point pretty well: Are you telling me the goal post is now 32 years?
And while we’re picking arbitrary points in computer history. The iPhone was released in late 2007 and is around 2 years older than the Bitcoin blockchain. I hope I don’t have to make the argument that smartphones have had a bigger impact on society than any kind of crypto/blockchain solution.