This rant has hardly anything to do with the linked announcement, except that it starts with (paraphrasing) 'I once tried using REBL in an unsupported way and gave up after some hours'
The criticisms have been adressed or discussed in many other contexts already, which is also why I won't engage in such discussions here.
The 2012 section seems not correct. In the time between 2012 and 2020 I deployed Datomic in various non AWS environments. Datomic was never particularly tied to AWS. I think your timeline also misses Datomic Cloud, which was an AWS exclusive product that launched much later than 2012.
As someone who is using Datomic Pro in production for many years now I must agree with you. One time I began a project with Datomic Cloud and it was a disaster similar to what you described. I learned a lot about AWS, but after about half a year we switched to Datomic Pro.
There were some cool ideas in Datomic Cloud, like IONs and its integrated deployment CLI. But the dev workflow with Datomic Pro in the REPL, potentially connected to your live or staging database is much more interactive and fun than waiting for CodeDeploy.
I guess there is a reason Datomic Pro is the featured product on datomic.com again. It appears that Cognitect took a big bet with Datomic Cloud and it didn't take off. Soon after the NuBank acquisition happened. That being said, Datomic Cloud was not a bad idea, it just turned out that Datomic Pro/onPrem is much easier to use. Also of all their APIs, the "Peer API" of Pro is just the best IME, especially with `d/entity` vs. "pull" etc.
If LLM would write code faster or better than me, I would use LLM. But LLM comes up with perverse algorithms that I need to understand, debug and fix.
Sorry, not there yet. By far not.
This day I asked it not too fundamental questions about Clojure and it was able to provide impressive, accurate answers and provide correct code examples. However if you continue the dialogue and ask it to do more advanced stuff, it will just make up stuff out of thin air. For instance it will use functions that don't exist and claim that they can be imported from packages that don't exist or don't have them. Once you point out these mistakes, it will admit them and come up with different changes which can be even worse, but sometimes also be better and save the whole thing. Overall I'm not sure how useful this will turn out, given that its not reliable. It may be useful to get some initial intuitions and informations (non specific stuff it usually gets right), but it can also mislead you badly.
I asked it, how it makes these mistakes only to understand them and admit them once I point them out. It has no answer beyond the usual "I'm a language model". It also told me that it is capable of logical inference, but denied that the next day. Then it told me that its answers would always be consistent, which is a lie.
The whole thing is really weird, because its somewhat very smart and capable and incredibly stupid and dishonest at the same time.
The answer is more like "your problem is a feature, you just don't see it yet". Many things are very different in Clojure and can quickly lead to misjudgement like " leaky abstraction" instead of "seamlessly integrated host interop"
1) There are enough templates and starter packs with documentation. Frameworks have been tried, but they quickly turn out to limit your Clojure given powers.
2) Thats true, but its not leaky abstraction. Clojure never claims to abstract the host away, it embraces it so you can do all low level Java/JS stuff and seemlessly use their libraries without FFIs.
3) You have all Java/JS libs. Most Clojure libs are simply "done", so they get no commits. I don't know of any unmaintend ones.
4) Java is improving? Clojure is mostly done with that already. It was designed long after Java and makes many improvements obsolete.
Wrong. It flooded the network with vacationers who normally could not afford travelling at all, while workers had to resort to their cars again to reach their jobs in time.
Counting everyone who "would not have travelled by train", meaning "likely not at all" as saved emission is not very convincing.
Cryptocurrencies do generate rent. You can lend them and collect interest on it.
Houses don't grow in value because they generate rent - they are deteriorated by residents and need permanent investment in repairs to hold their value. Instead, they grow in value if their environment and surrounding infrastructur improves because more people will want to live there and offer a higher price.
Likewise, if more merchants accept a coin, the coin is more valuable because its more flexible.
Since June, the German government allows even police to secretly spy on Germans "preventively", i. e. without suspicion or proof of crime or future crime and without decision by court of law, by installing trojans on their phones and PCs, i. e. through the app store.
"Your right to privacy is being respected in Germany!" - This is not true.
While tools can save us from stupid mistakes, some mistakes are so stupid that relying on tools to prevent them seems much more dangerous even. Log4j should not have been used by anyone, and certainly it should not have been extended and "improved" in an endless cascade of irresponsible additions, likely violating every principle of good practice, ever. I hope that this is what industry people take away from it, not that some magic language feature should have prevented it.
Its just incredible how bloated Log4J is. You'd think a logging library would be rather lightweight, straightforward to configure, no?
No, it is one of those efforts that suffer from their underlying problem being so well understood that, apparently, everybody working on it feels compelled to "enrich" it with more options, config layers, adapters, extensions.
And like with files, you are also free to read chapters of a book in any order. But files have little to do with lines, no? Of course a function definition in every sane language is continuous text, even though you "are free" to read it backwards or starting in the middle.
Is it just me or is $50k USD a terrible offer for an exploit like this one.
Usually, if you successfully exploit a smart contract or DAO, you make multiple 100k sometimes even millions for disclosing.
The positive test has to be made in Germany and in most counties of Germany you need a doctor that confirms by signature that you went into quarantine, also in Germany.