HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

light_hue_1

2,728 karma · joined December 13, 2015

submissionscomments
light_hue_1··on Judge orders government to begin refunding more than $130B in tariffs
No. The people are to blame.

Both the people who voted for the criminal to be president. And the people who supported such a horrible Democratic candidate that she couldn't even win against Trump.

light_hue_1··on Government grant-funded research should not be published in for-profit journals
This defeatist attitude is why we can't have nice things anymore.

Fun fact, all of those things happened and this is already government policy for any NSF grant: https://www.nsf.gov/policies/document/faq-public-access

So maybe consider that when you give up on obvious things that are good based on some conspiracy theory that the "man" is trying to keep you down, what you're actually doing is being part of the system and endorsing it. Changes like this do happen, they just happen despite you.

light_hue_1··on Florida public universities to pause hiring new H-1B workers
You're leaving out what happened in Florida.

First, Florida killed tenure. You get reviews every 5 years and can be fired if they don't like what they see.

Second, Stop WOKE, means that Florida gets a say in what I teach.

So Florida took away the most important (and for many maybe only) attractive part of the job: academic freedom.

Almost half of Florida faculty are trying to leave. So yeah. Of course they get the bottom of the barrel. That's all that's left for them. With the ability to get a job almost anywhere else in the world you'd have to have extreme circumstances to consider Florida.

light_hue_1··on How did Joann Fabrics die while Best Buy survived? It wasn't Amazon
That's so alien to me I can't even imagine it.

I'd much rather drive somewhere fun with the kids, work on a hobby, read a book, or just frankly sit and do nothing than go to a store.

light_hue_1··on Writing code is cheap now
Writing code was always cheap! You could outsource for inconsequential amounts of money and get massive amounts of code in return. Yet, the vast majority of companies do not do so. Because coding is not the hard part of being a software engineer / programmer.

That's like saying that photography killed painting because it saved you from having to draw things. Drawing is basically free now, I just take the photo. But the number of painters (and by that I mean, artists who paint) is dramatically higher today than in 1800. Artists didn't die because of mechanical reproduction, they flourished, because that wasn't the problem they were solving.

light_hue_1··on Silicon Valley can't import talent like before. So it's exporting jobs
Yup. All the H1B haters are going to get what they want: silicon valley will lose its engine and the next major tech companies will be overseas.

I see it personally. People who are awesome. Their FAANG desperately wants to get them to come to the US. They can't for years. Then they give up and open an office in India or Eastern Europe and the US loses hundreds of jobs and great talent.

This teaches such companies to go overseas. And once they have taken on the burden of doing so expanding is much easier there than here.

It's amazing to see a country that has everything and every advantage throw it all away. But I guess Europe did the same thing a century ago.

light_hue_1··on The Age Verification Trap: Verifying age undermines everyone's data protection
As a parent, I'm happy that social bans are finally a thing.

But, I don't get the approach. It's not like social media starts being a positive in our life at 20. The way these companies do social media is harmful to mental health at every age. This is solving the wrong problem.

The solution is to take away their levers to make the system so addictive. A nice space to keep in touch with your friends. Nothing wrong with that.

light_hue_1··on How did Joann Fabrics die while Best Buy survived? It wasn't Amazon
If by roughly the same you mean 10% to 100% more (think cables for high markup) and I have to go to the store instead of having it come to me. With much worse selection. Then yes. That's an amazing experience!
light_hue_1··on Agentic Software Engineering Book
Yes!

Fun fact, this isn't new. There's an entire discipline that has been doing this for 50 years: machine learning.

Literally the hard part that people deal with in ML is how do you specify the goal of a machine that's just going to blindly make it happen (the other half is how do you optimize that function but that tends to be considerably easier). Like, if I want a good image recognition algorithm what function should I use to compute how good my current approach is. Particularly when I don't have annotations for every output.

We're going to need to extend the methods that we developed in ML for many other fields over to software engineering.

light_hue_1··on Agentic Software Engineering Book
If you're going to write with AI give me the prompts. Don't produce this strange tone-shifting full-of-fluff mess where most of it is machine filler content. The density of ideas to text is absurdly low.

Let's just be open an honest with one another. If I really want to read something like this my AI can generate it from your prompts just as well as your can.

light_hue_1··on We're no longer attracting top talent: the brain drain killing American science
> The US has a global reputational advantage that will take decades to fall behind China, regardless of what any US administration does.

As a former academic at a top US university, no, the US no longer has that strong reputation. 10 years ago, if you were someone, you wanted to come to the US. The best students in the world came and stayed.

Things are radically different now. Much of the best talent no longer comes and when they do come they leave. It's night and day.

It's not a binary choice. It's not the US or China. It's the US or Canada/EU/etc. And if you're from China, you used to stay, now you leave.

This isn't reddit. I saw this first hand.

light_hue_1··on Magnus Carlsen Wins the Freestyle (Chess960) World Championship
Chess is in such a sad situation again.

The world champion (which is determined for classical chess) isn't even remotely the best player. He's barely even in the top 10 and may soon fall out of that too. In terms of strength he's the weakest player to win in half a century even in absolute terms. And I can't think of any time in modern history of chess when such a low ranked player won.

We really need to do something to reinvigorate the game. Chess world championships used to be front page events. The winners would be stars and everyone knew their name. Now, even I don't bother to follow anymore.

light_hue_1··on OpenAI should build Slack
By market cap? Is the money using slack?

Company size when you're talking about tools for humans makes no sense in terms of market cap.

Plenty of companies with many more employees than Google use slack.

light_hue_1··on 11.8M EU citizens pay taxes to governments they cannot vote for
I don't understand if you're intentionally obstinate or just oddly brainwashed? I'll try one last time, in a simple sentence.

Cannot vote for means even if the entire result is tied and it hinges on one vote, my vote does not count under any circumstances; it can't change the outcome at all.

Is that better? 85% of Americans are literally in this situation.

light_hue_1··on OpenAI should build Slack
> and I also doubt a large co like Google could operate out of Slack

Plenty of corporations much larger than Google operate out of Slack.

light_hue_1··on 11.8M EU citizens pay taxes to governments they cannot vote for
It's not misleading. I have no idea why people are voting this down. It's just a simple fact.

We have 3 parts of the federal government we can vote for: executive, senate, and house. Yet, the vast majority of people reading this have never cast a vote that mattered in any of those. I certainly have not.

Most states are not competitive when it comes to electoral votes. It doesn't matter if 100% of MA or CA comes out. Whoever is blue-colored will win those EVs. Beyond that, any other vote is worthless and won't change the outcome.

Most states are not competitive when it comes to the senate. Who wins in most races is predetermined by their color affiliation.

Most house races are the same. Many house races don't even have any meaningful opposition because everyone knows who will win.

It's even worse at the local level. Depending on the type of position 60-90% of races are uncontested.

Of course people don't turn out. For 85+% of people it doesn't matter.

> about 1/2 of citizens who are eligible to vote do not

I'm part that majority. No matter how many of me show up even if it was an unlimited number of people, there is literally nothing my vote can do to change the outcome. So yeah. Why waste the time pretending we're in a democracy?

We're in a rule by a tiny minority.

light_hue_1··on 11.8M EU citizens pay taxes to governments they cannot vote for
85% of Americans pay taxes to a federal government that they cannot vote for.

My vote is totally irrelevant. I've moved 3 states in my life. Never once has it mattered because of how we vote. My state will be blue. My congressional district will be blue. I might as well do nothing.

Thankfully I'm a dual citizen with Canada so my vote has mattered there at least part of the time.

So this isn't anything special.

I'd say the EU is in a far more democratic spot by this metric than the US.

light_hue_1··on Is particle physics dead, dying, or just hard?
Sparsity != symmetry.

It's simple to say "Ah well, it's sparse" that doesn't mean anything and doesn't explain anything.

Symmetries are equivalent to a conserved quantity. They exist because something else is invariant with respect to some transformation and vice versa. We didn't discover arbitrary constraints we found a conserved quantity & the implied symmetry.

"There are integers", "the numbers should be small" all of these are nothing like what works normally. They aren't symmetries. At most they're from some anthropic argument about collections of universes being more or less likely, which is its own rabbit hole that most people stay away from.

light_hue_1··on Billing can be bypassed using a combo of subagents with an agent definition
Why would you report this?!

A second time. When they already closed your first issue. Just enjoy the free ride.

light_hue_1··on We mourn our craft
Assembling code doesn't require typing. Linking doesn't require typing.

Even though once upon a time both did.

Claiming that this isn't coding is as absurd as saying that coding is only what you do when you hook up the wires between some vacuum tubes.

The LLM is a very smart compiler. That's all.

Some people want to sit and write assembly. Good for them. But asserting that unless I assemble my own code I'm not a coder is just silly.

light_hue_1··on We mourn our craft
That's just gatekeeping.

It was and is my craft. I've been doing it since grade 5. Like 30 years now.

Writing tight assembly for robot controllers all the way to AI on MRI machines to security for the DoD and now the biggest AI on the planet.

But my craft was not typing. It's coding.

If you're typist you're going to mourn the printer. But if you're a writer you're going to see how the improves your life.

light_hue_1··on We mourn our craft
I'm that 40 year old now. Been writing code since grade 5. Loved it so much I got a PhD, was an academic, then moved into industry.

I don't mourn or miss anything. No more then the previous generation mourned going from assembly to high level languages.

The reason why programming is so amazing is getting things done. Seeing my ideas have impact.

What's happening is that I'm getting much much faster and better at writing code. And my hands feel better because I don't type the code in anymore.

Things that were a huge pain before are nothing now.

I didn't need to stay up at night writing code. I can think. Plan. Execute at a scale that was impossible before. Alone I'm already delivering things that were on the roadmap for engineering months worth of effort.

I can think about abstractions, architecture, math, organizational constraints, product. Not about what some lame compiler thinks about my code.

And if someone that's far junior to me can do my job. Good. Then we've empowered them and I've fallen behind. But that's not at all the case. The principals and faculty who are on the ball are astronomically more productive than juniors.

light_hue_1··on We tasked Opus 4.6 using agent teams to build a C Compiler
> This was a clean-room implementation (Claude did not have internet access at any point during its development);

This is absolutely false and I wish the people doing these demonstrations were more honest.

It had access to GCC! Not only that, using GCC as an oracle was critical and had to be built in by hand.

Like the web browser project this shows how far you can get when you have a reference implementation, good benchmarks, and clear metrics. But that's not the real world for 99% of people, this is the easiest scenario for any ML setting.

light_hue_1··on How AI assistance impacts the formation of coding skills
This is the argument that people used to fight against rich customized IDEs like emacs for decades. What if you need to ssh into a machine that only has baseline vi in an emergency?

I'll happily optimize my life for 99.999% of the time.

If the Internet is down for a long time, I've got bigger problems anyway. Like finding food.

light_hue_1··on Canada
Yup. That's the brainwashing for you.

That having a bit more money matters when your employer can fire you for any reason. When college costs are astronomical. When you can lose your healthcare for any reason. When getting cancer might mean losing your house. When housing costs mean that anyone who rents could well be thrown out into the street.

But your tv is bigger than three average tv in Germany. For sure!

That's not quality of life. That's trinkets to hide the horrors. All good as long as you don't think about it and get lucky.

Wealthy America is great though.

light_hue_1··on Canada
I grew up in Canada and live in the US now with kids.

The US is not one country. It's two that are radically different.

There's wealthy America. The top 5% to 10% that have healthcare, have their own safety nets, don't need to worry about money, their kids go to select schools that they can buy into (mostly by buying into the right neighborhoods), an amazing pension plan, etc. My kids go to a fancy library with reading time, puppets and classical music. All the things I love about Canada and more.

That country is amazing and the quality of life is unparalleled unless you're obscenely wealthy.

The bottom 80 to 90% percent of Americans live a life that is far inferior to any western and even many developing countries. They have no safety nets, no job security, no retirement, housing insecurity, they're even the smallest accident away from ruin, etc.

In other countries people know roughly how badly or how well they're treated by the system. Only in the US have I experienced the level of brainwashing where people are thankful for the horrors of this system, and somehow wash away anything they see or hear about anywhere else in the world.

Because your family mostly decides if which America you live in, most people don't understand the other side at all and can't comprehend how they live.

light_hue_1··on Anthropic's original take home assignment open sourced
Keep in mind that the boat on competing with machines to generate assembly sailed for 99% of programmers half a century ago. It is not surprising that this is an area where AI is strong.
light_hue_1··on Scaling long-running autonomous coding
Browsers are pretty much the best case scenario for autonomous coding agents. A totally unique situation that mostly doesn't occur in the real world.

At a minimum:

1. You've got an incredibly clearly defined problem at the high level.

2. Extremely thorough tests for every part that build up in complexity.

3. Libraries, APIs, and tooling that are all compatible with one another because all of these technologies are built to work together already.

4. It's inherently a soft problem, you can make partial progress on it.

5. There's a reference implementation you can compare against.

6. You've got extremely detailed documentation and design docs.

7. It's a problem that inherently decomposes into separate components in a clear way.

8. The models are already trained not just on examples for every module, but on example browsers as a whole.

9. The done condition for this isn't a working browser, it's displaying something.

This isn't a realistic setup for anything that 99.99% of people work on. It's not even a realistic setup for what actual developers of browsers do who must implement new or fuzzy things that aren't in the specs.

Note 9. That's critical. Getting to the point where you can show simple pages is one thing. Getting to the point where you have a working production browser engine, that's not just 80% more work, it's probably considerably more than 100x more work.

light_hue_1··on Porsche sold more electrified cars in Europe in 2025 than pure gas-powered cars
Nothing to do with quality. It's all image.

When Americans discover again how crappy their cars are compared to what's available elsewhere, like we did with Japan, there will be a reckoning once more. And again American cars will become the laughing stock they really are.

In the meantime, this incredibly short sighted protectionism will end just like the last round did. Further hollowing out our industrial base and permanently giving away large parts of a massive market.

And I'm sure all of the people involved in this insanity will want a bailout too.

light_hue_1··on Porsche sold more electrified cars in Europe in 2025 than pure gas-powered cars
No one cared to begin with. Just look up the horrors involved with Apple phones. People want their fancy devices. Doesn't matter if slave labor is involved. Doesn't matter if we need to add nets to prevent laborers from killing themselves instead of putting up with the horrible conditions we force them into.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →