No wonder the Internet has such a low SNR.
282 karma · joined July 29, 2008
No wonder the Internet has such a low SNR.
The data doesn't show a significant decrease outside the West.
Why is Kerberos insufficient to solve the sign-in problem that we had to invent new protocols?
If you read the paper carefully, there are many other arguments one can make against it. However, it is an interesting paper and its message is worth considering.
Peer-review is not a perfect process. I think the research community is better off with publishing such a paper.
What's next? Symphony No. 9 by Paul Graham? Theory of Relativity by Paul Graham? The Bible? :-)
Securing the data center is the least of your worries for such an attacker. I'd detail additional attacks that all subvert the encryption process:
1. Compromise the site's private SSL certificate. This allows the possibility of MITM attacks. There is some evidence that NSA is already mounting such attacks on the Internet.
2. Malware on the client-side. A compromised browser, or a compromised OS.
3. The US government mandating that NSA installs hidden firmware on all data center servers.
I argue that strong semantics are extremely important when building secure services. I thought their service offers one such semantic: client-side form data encryption. They do not offer JS code integrity or any guarantees about the client-side encryption not being subverted.
By telling people about datacenter security and then calling it a "a detail that some people who are security-conscious might care about" or "data center security probably does matter", you continue to raise the fog of confusion in people's minds. Instead, the FAQ could educate the users and separate client-side encryption (which is what the service offers) from client-side code integrity (which the service does not offer).
If you start telling me that I'm paying for security measures that have no effect on your service security guarantees, I think you're selling snake-oil.
At this point, I'm very reluctant to trust my data to your service.
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/08/03/underworld-mont...
Such a behavior would raise an eyebrow in the US, but it was completely normal in that corner of the world at the time.
Eurosys 2012: http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2168851
When the top news on HN is how to make $5 selling used computer cables on Amazon, you know coding is dead.
http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/ssaroiu/public...
However, I have to disagree with your conclusion (based on Camus) that questions remain unanswered. I think that's a failure -- Camus's failure as well as yours. It's easy to throw up your hands and say "I don't know. It is what it is." This is precisely the reason why I think "The Stranger" is a book with a lot of potential but ends up a failure. I suspect leaving things in limbo at the end is often masking the writer's (or director's) shortcomings.
You're probably happy with your life as a result, but you're taking the easy road and that road leads to nowhere.
In the meantime, I'll continue to stay unhappy and flabbergasted by the discrepancy between logic and fairness on one side and society on the other.
For me, I was with you until I read your suggestion to "read your comments" to learn about your experience.
I think the article has a list of nice suggestions, but if you're asked to give a keynote and you haven't given more than 100+ talks/lectures/presentations before, you should do one thing only: Stop. Decline the invite.
Your startup failure was good. It hit quick. You learned. You moved on.
If I had more time I'd tell you about all those failed startups that suffer a really slow death. Like the YC startups. Pretty much all of them are failed. They haven't seen the light yet. You have. Be grateful.
These are money-losing businesses. As we speak.
Real life is much more complicated.
However, I've never encountered a person who pays attention to details and can switch this on or off, depending at which stage the project is in. You either care about details (and you can't help yourself), or you don't.
When you are good but don't pay attention to details you end up with things like ... the Facebook website. You make a million bucks by some random chance and then you start writing crap articles like this one. And then all the cool under-30 kids start worshipping you.
Anyone who pays attention would notice that things that work well are always built by people who pay attention to details.