HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lstroud

130 karma · joined April 22, 2011

submissionscomments
lstroud··on Shame on Y Combinator
Irony...advocating discrimination against Trump supporters because you believe they advocate discrimination.
lstroud··on A Message to the Apple Community in Europe
Seems like it boils down to determining who gets to make tax law in the EU. Is the EU able to levy taxes on citizens of their member nations directly? Or, are the nations themselves responsible? I'm not sure the legal structure of the EU gives Brussels tax authority. This will be an interesting question to see resolved. It will tell us a lot about the future of the EU.
lstroud··on A New Map for America
The smaller the project/team, the easier it is to recognize mistakes and change direction. At the federal level, competing interests make that nearly impossible.
lstroud··on A New Map for America
You do know that roads crossed state borders before the interstate, right? In truth, for the traffic volume, they were pretty good.

That said the states would have evolved them to meet the needs, while the federal government took a more revolutionary approach. I tend to prefer the agility of incremental approaches. That said, when you are on the right side, revolutionary change is nice too. Despite how it seems today, I'm sure there are those that would argue the money could have been better spent. Ultimately, the question is where you put your faith; we the people or we the government?

lstroud··on FBI May Demand iOS Source Code, Signing Key
Why is the Democratic Party and President Obama taking heat for this? It is his call. He could stop it if so desired. After all, it is an election year.
lstroud··on Obama Signs CISA Bill into Law
Your point is well taken, but if memory serves, the specific technologies listed were developed by private corporations and industry consortiums. Would be interested to see a fact checked history on this, however.
lstroud··on Drug Goes from $13.50 a Tablet to $750, Overnight
What's the last thing you bought that was manufactured by government. If you think prices are high now, then go look at prices of non subsidized government manufactured products. I think you will change your mind.
lstroud··on Bernie Sanders' 404 page
On the first, these are cultural problems that are not solvable by politicians without creating worse problems (as evidenced by current events).

The second is a misunderstanding of the concept of a republic. Each state has a say. That's not unfair. It certainly wouldn't promote stability for heavily populated cities to have complete control and entire states neglected.

Not sure I completely disagree on military spending. Like most things, it's a balance. We probably needed a rebalance (was done in the gov shutdown deal). However, I'm not sure it needs further cuts. Maybe just better focus.

Healthcare is a joke. What was passed, and the way it was passed, was deceitful. Turns out it was snake oil. Made some things better, made more things worse, and didn't fix the problem (cost of healthcare).

From a politics perspective, it sure would be nice to have a leader that brings people together. This administration is far to willing to leverage our political differences as a tool for political gain. That has made us culturally worse by creating an environment of distrust, disregard, and division Among our citizens just for having different ideas.

lstroud··on Germanwings plane crash: Co-pilot 'wanted to destroy plane'
The flight attendant also wedges the door open (and blocks entry/exit with a cart during this time. Yes, they could incapacitate, but it would take time to do this, get the door closed, and dead bolted. One would hope that the commotion would bring help before all of that could be accomplished.
lstroud··on Apple Confirms Its $3 Billion Deal for Beats Electronics
Will Beats be a wholly owned subsidiary or integrated into Apple?

I would imagine corporate structure will provide the answers on why Apple made this decision.

lstroud··on Toward a better programming
This seems reminiscent of the "wolfram language" stuff a couple of weeks ago. Perhaps it's a trend, but I can't shake the feeling like I am seeing a rehash of the 4GL fiasco of the 90s.

I have a lot of respect for Chris. So, I hope I am wrong.

lstroud··on Wolfram Programming Cloud
Out of curiosity, would you classify this in the 4GL camp?

Not to denigrate the technology and functionality that the Wolfram language is exposing, but it sure sounds a lot like the 4GL pitches from the 90s. Is that a fair comparison?

lstroud··on Average water use per person*day by country
Water usage should also imply that the water used is not reclaimable. For example, steam from a hydroelectric plant falls back as precipitation. Irrigation water re-enters the water table or streams. For water to be used in a way that is negatively impacting it must be converted to a chemical that won't naturally degrade to water. For example, urine, ozone, etc.
lstroud··on Now That It’s in the Broadband Game, Google Flip-Flops on Network Neutrality
It boils down to what they are selling?

Does the product ad say, 1 Gb bandwidth for $XX when use of bandwidth doesn't exceed 20%?

Generally, these sort of exceptions are not made clear at the time of purchase.

Frankly, if they are selling bits or bandwidth it shouldn't matter the type of account. The type of account should only impact customer service. The water company analogy should apply.

lstroud··on HTTP 2.0
Wow. I don't see that at all. You must not use any of the platforms you mentioned.

If you look under the hood on OSX, iOS, or Android, they are all composed of smaller single purpose components. If you are arguing that they do not use interprocess communication to join these component together, then you are correct. However, that is not the Unix philosophy. A great example is Outlook vs OSX/iOS Mail/Calendar/Contacts/Notes. On OSX and iOS, those applications try to do one thing well. On Windows, Outlook tries to do everything.

Beyond that, just about every embedded device and the vast majority of servers now run linux (or a unix variant). Just look at a list packages on those linux devices and you will understand that it clearly is built around combining small single purpose components.

Given that, it is hard to argue that the Windows philosophy has won. In fact, Windows seems to be struggling (as evidenced by slowing interest and reorg/rearch/rebrand thrashing in Redmond. Looking at the market, I'd argue that the Unix approach won quite some time ago.

Am I missing something?

lstroud··on Why employees shouldn't have hours
When it comes to IT, I can buy it. However, ask yourself how you would run a manufacturing plant when you didn't know when people would be there? Or, how would customer service work if there was no one to answer the phones?
lstroud··on TypeScript: a language for application-scale JavaScript development
How does it compare to Dart & Harmony (even coffeescript)?

I know that is a long answer, but I'd love a bullet point list of how if compares to the other javascript++ languages that have been coming out over the last couple of years.

lstroud··on Obama Admin Pursuing Executive Order to Enact CISPA-Like Cybersecurity Language
Between this and his sponsorship of DOJ domain seizures ,without due process of any kind, it's hard to see how any technologist could support Obama.
lstroud··on Obama Admin Pursuing Executive Order to Enact CISPA-Like Cybersecurity Language
While you may be able to find attribution of that to some fringe elements of the Republican party, I have not heard Romney or Ryan say anything even close. In fact, they seem to be far more process oriented than the current administration that continues to try to find ways around government process (avoiding votes, expansion of executive orders, use of conference, recess appointments, etc).
lstroud··on G4S is just the latest in a long line of outsourcing disasters
The problem is not outsourcing, it's thinking that you can outsource (or delegate) and important task and not pay attention to it's execution.

Good management breaks outsourced projects down into replaceable, manageable chunks. This is important for oversight and for competition. If you size an outsourced chunk of work correctly, then you should be able to increase competition for that contract. If you structure the contract correctly, your oversight should be able to identify and replace problemed contractors.

These guys are all smart enough to know that. It's just that they are also all smart to know that it is easier to avoid political responsibility for failures when it can be blamed on an outside contractor.

lstroud··on G4S is just the latest in a long line of outsourcing disasters
I think people often confuse the axiom...

Stated more correctly, smaller, more focused, organizations outperform larger, more bureaucratic(more management) organizations for particular tasks.

It's not that governments are outperformed by the private sector every time for everything (some things require size and longevity). Conceptually, it has nothing to do with whether an organization is private vs public. It's about incentive, regulation, and consequence horizons.

Incentives Generally, private organization's incentives (if tied appropriately to the desired outcome) are more aligned and offer higher rewards. Government organizations, if completely transparent, have a hard time justifying high rewards to their constituents. All other things being equals, people prefer higher rewards. So, the talent tends to accumulate in the private organizations. There are some exceptions to this (political influence), but I'm generalizing. :)

Regulation The smaller the organization, the fewer rules. Not only do laws tend to work this way, but internal organizational rules work this way as well.

As organizations grow, managers try to scale their ability to influence direction by legislating organizational rules. As more and more of these rules come into play, the overhead and unintended consequences of these rules grow. Since these managers are unable to directly participate in the execution of the tasks (the reason they created the rules at the start), they are slow in detecting changes that should require rule changes.

The overhead and lack of agility created by both size and expanded regulation(rules), makes large organizations far less efficient than smaller organizations. Unfortunately, governments have disproportionally larger sets of rules. Not only is their ruleset larger, and their employment not aligned to performance, but they also have unionization that has a differing set of goals. This creates even more operational friction making it very difficult to allow people to do what they do best. Tragically, this makes efficiency and productivity in large government organizations nearly impossible.

Consequence Horizons Smaller organizations tend to have better alignment between their existence and their ability to execute. This is because they are paid for execution and are typically unable to structure longer term contracts. As a result, if the people paying the bills are not happy, they cease to exist quite quickly.

As organizations grow in size, they start to manage for risk avoidance and not for execution. The larger they get, the more they are able to influence the market to avoid direct competition, to change the criteria by which they are judged, and to structure contracts such that they are far more stable over longer periods. This 'cushion' allows these organization to ignore or tolerate consequences to a higher degree. As a result, they are less sensitive to market judgements about their efficiency, productivity, or ability to execute. They loose sight of that as a goal and start to engage in higher order goals (happiness, employee well being, brand, reputation, influence, etc). These are not bad necessarily, it just makes them less efficient at particular tasks.

In particular, large government organizations are disproportionally disassociated from consequence. This is directly related to election cycles, politics (spinning the message to create success out of failures), and constantly getting inexperienced leadership. The first two are points are obvious, but let me explain the last. New politicians are elected and they appoint the people that they feel are best to run these large organizations. Typically, neither the politician or the person appointed has never spent a day working in that organization or executing the tasks for which they are responsible. With large organizations, it takes truly special managers to make an organization efficient at something you have never done yourself. This is even more difficult when you are not answering to your boss for your ability to execute, but instead are answering based on the ebb and flow of the political landscape.

In general, my point is, that you are right. Large private organizations do not have a significant advantage over large public organizations. That advantage can be widened based on political systems. However, the real advantage that people reference when making this argument is the enormous advantage small to medium private organizations "enjoy".

Understand that I am only talking about efficiency and execution and not societal value (differing goals). I also recognize that there are many tasks/goals that require larger organizations and more longevity.

lstroud··on A 12pt Font Should Be The Same Size Everywhere
Shouldn't we just switch to dimensional measurements like millimeters, inches, etc and expect the operating system to use whatever metric it chooses to make it display size appropriate (pt, px, em, etc)?

I think the problem with this is that developers (me included) have enjoyed using resolution to to change the physical size components in order to gain screen real estate. Perhaps, shifting to a zoom/scale setting would be a better approach than tying ourselves to resolution.

Humorously, it would be kinda like a print guy measuring font size in fibers and the size of the type changing based on fiber density. :-P Then again, they probably do that.

lstroud··on Google Announces Global Campaign To Legalize Gay Marriage
So, what does a political campaign / stance mean for a search company? Would they skew search results to support a position? If I am their competitor, it seems like an opportunity for FUD, even if they are doing the right thing.
lstroud··on Newegg Still Telling Customers That Installing New OS Violates Return Policy
While I understand the economics of your argument, are you suggesting that NewEgg would resale a returned machine without wiping it and re-setting it up?

That would be a horrid security practice and open them up to liability lawsuits. I'm assuming they are smarter than that, in which case, wiping it is wiping it.

lstroud··on US and Israel created Stuxnet, lost control of it
The truth is, if you love the Internet you had better start fighting to stop these escalations. Otherwise, it will cease to exist. The first time a massive attack causes real fear in western civilization, people will start questioning how much they really need it in their lives.

The lack of plausible deniability will lead to escalation. Once it does, national security (from the perspective of each country) will govern it's growth, not freedom.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4