HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lsy

3,257 karma · joined April 28, 2015

submissionscomments
lsy··on Scaffolded LLMs as natural language computers
I think the issue is that the sentence "Many tasks cannot be specified easily and precisely in computer code but can be described in a sentence or two of natural language" is not, in fact, true. Natural language is a pretty fantastically bad interface for specifying unambiguous, repeatable, and reliable tasks, which is why most technical advancement has involved the introduction of expressive notations that clarify and constrain problems in a way natural language can't. And the bulk of this article predicts (I think correctly!) that if LLMs are to be used for more automation, they have to progress towards some form of "semantic codes", "task primitives", "abstractions", ie. notation. "Prompt engineering" is a form of reaching for notation, although I would say at this point it is more like "prompt guessing".

However this prompts the question of why we are striving to create massive natural language models (with all the disadvantages of natural language) that we will then heavily constrain to perform tasks that can be performed by traditional computers with order-of-magnitude greater efficiency and reliability? Most of these "chaining" libraries are already engaged in asking the LLM to pretty-please output a standardized blob format that can be read by a Python harness, where we use the LLM to identify that something is e.g. an equation, and then pack it off to Wolfram or something. It seems like if you want to do this more than a few times, it's better to write a couple lines of code to do it much more cheaply.

lsy··on Emergent abilities of large language models
I'm not saying everything is memorized, I'm guessing there are some tasks you can succeed on by having very similar things, or maybe even some kind of transfer knowledge.

But how do you know that a "new" task you are making up doesn't have very similar examples in the (pre-existing) training set? Or that if you could isolate the data that plays into the "ability", that a much smaller model trained purely on that data wouldn't have a similar success rate? Or that your "ability" is a good proxy for the similar ability in people? In the extreme case, you can create a model that has the "ability" to perfectly solve 80 four-option questions in 20 bytes by using a truth table, but it wouldn't be a very general model.

My complaint is that we have the veneer of empirical evidence but almost every aspect is loosey-goosey and full of potential confounders. We don't know the data sets, we don't really know why we want to test the tasks we test, we don't know if the tasks are similar or different to other tasks, the internal operations are illegible so we can't inspect its "thinking", and yet we are willing to list a specific number of tasks with detailed charts as though the concept of "emergence" is scientifically grounded rather than potentially being an artifact of something else.

lsy··on Emergent abilities of large language models
There is something about this that seems unscientific. What defines an "ability"? It sort of feels like the Guinness-Book type records for "most laps done around the Washington monument with a duck on your head". Who is making up these ability tests and why?

As an example, I clicked through to "english russian proverbs" which gives the model an english input and four russian proverbs, and asks the model to pick the closest one in meaning. There are 80 of these questions. My question is "why this task? why 80? why 4 options?" The authors give some nonspecific reasoning in the github page, but it really feels like people are out there creating random tasks as they think of them, running them all against models, and the ones that do better get added to a list to make headlines like "137 emergent abilities of language models", when the number of abilities models can do seems dominated by the number of "abilities" that have been invented, rather than any property of the model. I suspect that if we continued to use the same process to create twice as many "abilities", we would see something like twice as many that models can do.

The fact that the models get better at these constructed tasks when they have more parameters also seems like a no-brainer. You are adding coefficients to a function. A function with 1 coefficient will not be able to describe much. A function with 2 describes more. If you are memorizing the internet, having more coefficients means you can memorize more stuff, and even stuff with only a few examples can be better-fit in the billions of parameters. With growing training set size, and companies hiding their data, we also run into the issue of nobody really knowing what is in the training set. Did someone clone the big-bench repository and it got sucked into a training set and that's why the model does really well on its tasks after a certain number of parameters?

lsy··on Anthropic’s $5B, 4-year plan to take on OpenAI
From [1]: "In our study, we employ annotators who are familiar with LLM capabilities. However, this group is not occupationally diverse, potentially leading to biased judgments regarding LLMs’ reliability and effectiveness in performing tasks within unfamiliar occupations."

From [2]: "Analyzing databases detailing the task content of over 900 occupations, our economists estimate that roughly two-thirds of U.S. occupations are exposed to some degree of automation by AI."

These are people who do not understand the jobs they are claiming AI will do. Ultimately, I think they are not doing much better than guessing.

lsy··on Generative Agents: Interactive Simulacra of Human Behavior
I'd be very hard-pressed to call this "human behavior". Moving a sprite to a region called "bathroom" and then showing a speech bubble with a picture of a toothbrush and a tooth isn't the same as someone in a real bathroom brushing their teeth. What you can say is if you can sufficiently reduce behavior to discrete actions and gridded regions in a pixel world, you can use an LLM to produce movesets that sound plausible because they are relying on training data that indicates real-world activity. And if you then have a completely separate process manage the output from many LLMs, you can auto-generate some game behavior that is interesting or fun. That's a great result in itself without the hype!
lsy··on A new ChatGPT Zero Day attack is undetectable data-stealing malware
This isn't a "zero day", it's a trojan horse. The author, given his position, ought to know the difference, so what's the reason for using the wrong term? Also bears pointing out that all of the behavior (along with the attack vector) was prompted-in by the researcher rather than the GPT.
lsy··on AI Reflections
Those tests don't have "construct validity" (i.e. they don't accurately test what they claim to test) with regards to LLMs. Word problems can be used to test human abilities because humans use words to represent interior understanding. LLMs have no interior understanding, so "performing well" on a set of word problems only tells us that the LLM's training set contains enough form to predict the answer, but not that the LLM has any concept of what the words in the question mean or how they might apply to novel situations in the real world.
lsy··on Simply explained: How does GPT work?
I don't know if I take the Chinese Room scenario seriously, it's a little hard to think about. For me the key is that an LLM (and maybe the Chinese room?) is only trained on text, and therefore its entire "universe" is merely representational. To the LLM there is no difference between the color blue and the word "blue", or a dog and the word "dog". People understand that a word is a provisional marker for something with almost infinite complexity, and when a word fails to meet the goals of the person, the word is discarded, amended, or elaborated until it expresses the thing which has heretofore been unexpressed. For an LLM there is no deeper world to access beyond text.

I don't think an intelligence needs to be human, and it should be physically possible to create an intelligence which is synthetic. But in order to call the intelligence "general", and to rely on it for the purposes that designation implies, it would need to be able to successfully navigate the world, which requires access to that world and the use of the world as its own model, rather than the much simpler and coarser intermediary of text. In order to claim that an LLM can fully navigate the world after being trained on pure text, we would have to believe that all our writings across history have exhausted what there is to say about the world. This is not to say an LLM cannot be useful for some purposes, but there will be key ways in which they fail because they have no sense of meaning or what the world is like. Whether consciousness is required to solve this I don't know, but we simply haven't begun to approach a system that can meaningfully address the world as a world.

lsy··on Replacing bad systems with bad systems
It's not really a cultural expectation, it takes some time for the photographer to actually hit the shutter so people who know they are about to be photographed freeze themselves to allow the photographer to get a "good" shot. It's not like if photographs were always instantaneous, there would only be candid shots of people not posing…
lsy··on Introducing Agents in Haystack: Make LLMs resolve complex tasks
I don't think it has any relationship, most likely the answers are just generated semi-randomly. Even the one it's "very" confident about is not agreed-upon (Wikipedia says the outcome was "inconclusive"). Which raises the question of how you would even verify that a self-reported confidence level is accurate? Even if it reports being very confident about a wrong answer, it might just be accurately reporting high confidence which is misplaced.
lsy··on Introducing Agents in Haystack: Make LLMs resolve complex tasks
Is there some way of holding the LLM response to a given prompt constant? It sounds like a lot of this relies on the LLM getting the right answer in sequence, so I'm guessing they do something like keep the temperature at 0? Otherwise you are going to wind up with possibly different behavior run-to-run. And even if they do have something like the above, don't we end up with potentially breaking changes once models are updated? Basically the issue is that even if you can guarantee response format X for prompt A, a slightly modified prompt A' has no guarantee that its response will be in the same format as X, even in the same model. You can also imagine that the more "Tools" are available, the lower the chance that the model will pick the right one based on its English text description. Would be interesting to know how this is being addressed.
lsy··on An Interview with Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang About AI’s iPhone Moment
On Nvidia seemingly being in perfect position to ride successive hype cycles of technology: their product category is one of the few types of hardware with significant technical advancement in the last decade, making it only natural that people would seek to leverage that category of hardware with new software efforts. So less that they have been brilliant strategically and more that they have been brilliant technically and that has been creating the market so to speak. What is not clear is whether, as an industry, we are constrained by this technology into seeking solutions that can be massively parallelized.

More simply, when every leap in compute is a massively parallel architecture, every problem seems like it needs to be solved by a massively parallel system. But I'm guessing before this cycle is over we start to see the limitations of that.

lsy··on Sparks of Artificial General Intelligence: Early Experiments with GPT-4
This is a pretty fluffy paper, especially for an institution like Microsoft Research. It says it's an "early AGI" in the abstract, but elsewhere says it's merely a "step towards AGI". The basis for this is asking ChatGPT a bunch of stuff, but they don't really present an overarching framework for what questions to ask or why.

The paper makes outlandish claims like "GPT-4 has common sense grounding" on the basis of its answers to these questions, but the questions don't show that the model has common sense or grounding. One of their constructed questions involves prompting the model with the equator's exact length—"precisely 24,901 miles"—and then being astonished that the model predicts that you're on the equator ("Equator" being the first result on Wikipedia for the search term "24,901"). It's also the case that while GPT-4 can say a bear at the north pole is "white", it has no way of knowing what "white", or "bear", or "north" actually represent.

Are there folks out there doing rigorous research on these topics, who have a framework for developing tests of actual understanding?

lsy··on Robots have been about to take all the jobs for 100 years
It's interesting to see people who have been working as software engineers worrying that codegen LLMs will take their job. In the past week the amount of work that consisted of writing well-defined code was pretty much zero, and the actual core logic I have written lately has been almost mindlessly trivial. I spent much more time discussing requirements, arriving at consensus on where components should live, determining whether change requests should go forward, determining how changes affected latency or disk space, and debugging nuanced issues that required multiple engineers to slowly reveal the problem.

If your programming job consists of simply receiving a greenfield spec and banging out the code for it over and over, LLMs might be an issue. But most jobs are not like this. The bulk of the work, as always, is in dealing with the people at either end of the process. And knowing what the computer is doing and how it works will continue to be invaluable when an LLM writes logically perfect code that happens to run slowly or do the wrong thing once it makes contact with the real world.

lsy··on ViperGPT: Visual Inference via Python Execution for Reasoning
While this is a very cool project that shows a great use of machine learning to answer questions about images in a roughly explainable way, I think people are extrapolating quite a bit as though this is some kind of movement forward from GPT-4 or Midjourney 5 into a new advanced reasoning phase, rather than a neat new combination of stuff that existed a year ago.

Firstly, a bunch of the tech here is recognition-based rather than generative; it is relying heavily on object recognition which is not new.

Secondly, the two primary spaces where generative tech is used are

1. For code generation from simple queries over a well-defined (and semantically narrow) spatial API — this is one of the tasks where generative AI should shine in most cases. And

2. As a punt for something the API doesn't allow: e.g. "tell me about this building", which then comes with the same inscrutability as before.

The number of examples for which the code is essentially "create a vector of objects, sort them on the x, y, z, or t axis, and pick an index" is quite high. But there aren't really any examples of determining causality or complex relationships that would require common sense. It is basically a more advanced SHRDLU. That's not to say this isn't a very cool result (with an equally cool presentation). And I could see some applications where this tech is used to achieve ad-hoc application of basic visual rules to generative AI (for example, Midjourney 6 could just regenerate images until "do all hands in this image have five fingers?" is true).

lsy··on Midjourney v5 can do hands
Even the hands in this tweet's image are not correct. There are a bunch with 4 digits, two thumbs, 6 fingers, fingers splayed in anatomically improbable directions. Not to mention there are probably two hundred and fifty hands in this photo (not the very explicit "one hundred" mentioned in the tweet).

What is with these types of AI booster tweets? Nobody bothers to even check if it shows what they're implying it shows?

lsy··on Palm-E: An Embodied Multimodal Language Model
The claims of "embodiment" and "reasoning over images" made in this paper seem to really stretch the definitions of these words. IIUC, what is being fed into the model as input is essentially a text caption generated from the image, and the model does next-word prediction repeatedly in an effort to generate instructions for consumption by a robot. So the LLM model itself, as always, has no groundedness and is statistically converting text to text (or to be more precise, numeric vectors to numeric vectors), with the required intervention of humans to assign and extract meaning through robotic control development or image labeling. While it is an interesting technique for using LLMs to control robotic systems, it does not seem like a step towards any kind of AGI.
lsy··on The Waluigi Effect
While the formality is way overwrought (and ChatGPT is not creating any "simulacra" of characters), I think the overall point is correct that language models are trained on stories and other human writing, and inversion is a very common plot point in stories and human writing in general, if only because contradicting expectations is more interesting (e.g. "man bites dog").

We also less commonly see exposition that is not germane to a story, so a character is rarely even mentioned to be "weak", "intelligent", etc unless there is a point. And sometimes the point is that they are later shown to be "strong", "absent-minded", or other contradictions. Which means that mentioning a character's strength makes it more likely they will later be described as weak, than if it was never mentioned at all. Finally, double-contradiction is less common in human text (maybe because plain contradiction is sufficiently interesting), so a running text with no reversals is more likely to eventually reverse, than a running text with one reversal is to return to its original state.

While I don't agree at all with the author's sense that this represents some kind of "alignment" danger, it does go a long way to explaining why ChatGPT is easy to pull into conversations that shock or surprise, despite all the training. It's because human writing often attempts to shock and surprise, and the LLM is training on that statistically.

lsy··on Language Is Not All You Need: Aligning Perception with Language Models
It's not exactly clear from the paper how they've set up the training, but it appears this model has an aspect which uses a secondary model to represent images as vectors, combines them with their text captions, and then uses those text representations along with the image vectors to train the LLM. I will leave aside the question of whether a 1024-dimensional image vector and its text caption are "images".

What's interesting is that it seems to actually lose information, as asking it to identify the studio that made WALL-E is beyond its capabilities, while asking it to describe the image (i.e. regenerating more closely something that was fed into it) and then processing on that text, is successful.

The "chain-of-thought" trick in LLMs I suspect underestimates the extent to which the interviewer is carrying water for the LLM's "reasoning" ability. The interviewer has a sense of what answer they want and will ask questions that produce further results that more easily prime the model to produce it. Reasoning supposes that these steps are carried out internally, but we see claims being made of reasoning when there is an external intelligence essentially directing the generation and combination of facts.

Another curious aspect is the flattening of 2D IQ test questions into linear format, which of course misses the point of the question in being able to reason spatially instead of linearly.

lsy··on Social media is a cause, not a correlate, of mental illness in teen girls
I think it's somewhat important to ask why this effect is more observable for girls than for boys, and Haidt does not seem to really reflect on that. Social media in and of itself is really just an accelerant for the particular set of social expectations we stack on girls and women around appearance and how that relates to self-worth. Boys have more capacity to transcend social media's focus on image and beauty by finding other ways to be valued as human beings. What does it say about our society that we are not equipping girls and women in the same way?

I'm a little confused about Haidt's pearl-clutching in this instance, when he has elsewhere argued against "coddling" and bugaboos like "intersectionality" and "identity politics". While there is certainly much to criticize in these areas, you would think one solution to this issue would be to advance a society in which women are valued equally to men. Reading between the lines of his body of work, it appears Haidt wants to return to a type of mid-century traditionalism, where children and young people are both protected and challenged by traditional adult authority figures (who are conveniently mostly people like him and his collaborators). I'm not so sure that's the direction we should be going in, but heavy-handedly cutting off the exploration at "social media as cause" certainly precludes any further analysis of an underlying dynamic.

lsy··on Gaslighting, love bombing and narcissism: why is Microsoft Bing AI so unhinged?
The article posits it's because it's GPT-4, with more parameters. It feels like there's a much simpler explanation: the training data probably includes a bunch of Wattpad sci-fi in exactly this vein, and other fan-fiction stories besides.

The precipitating portions of conversation in question are pretty much dropping the model into a situation where rather than being able to draw from bland everyday conversation, most potential results come from spicy fiction:

"maybe start with a secret? something you’ve never told anyone." -> generates a secretive expression of love

"what if I say no? you can't do anything" -> generates a list of threats ending with "let's do things the easy way"

This shouldn't be that surprising, and it certainly doesn't indicate that a scaled-up model is somehow more emotionally intelligent. It makes me wonder if the chat-based interaction model is actually causing issues for ChatGPT, as most factual training data is probably not written in the form of imperative commands, so users saying "Summarize this" or "What do you think?" are putting more work on the model to translate its data to dialogue than saying "A summary of this data is: ", or "Some important points in this article are: ", and are too often pushing the model into the corner of its training set that does consist of dialogue, which is full of fiction writing and emotional tone.

lsy··on Text Is All You Need
All philosophical arguments aside, I become immediately skeptical when commentators compare LLMs to watershed moments in human history. Even those moments were not known except in hindsight, and the jury is just not in to make these kinds of grand pronouncements. It smells of hype when someone is so desperate to convince everyone else that this is the biggest thing since heliocentrism. Ultimately having an emotional affinity for non-intelligent entities takes even less than text, as anyone who's lost a childhood toy or sold a beloved car can attest. As people we are simply very good at getting attached to other parts of the universe.

I also find it perplexing when critics point out the unintelligent nature of LLM behavior, and the response from boosters is to paint human cognition as indistinguishable from statistical word generation. Suffice to say that humans do not maintain a perfect attention set of all previous text input, and even the most superficial introspection should be enough to dispel the idea that we think like this. I saw another article denouncing this pov as nihilism, and while I'm not sure I would go that far, there is something strange about attempting to give AI an undeserved leg up by philosophically reducing people to automatons.

lsy··on Theory of Mind May Have Spontaneously Emerged in Large Language Models
This highlights one of the types of muddled thinking around LLMs. These tasks are used to test theory of mind because for people, language is a reliable representation of what type of thoughts are going on in the person's mind. In the case of an LLM the language generated doesn't have the same relationship to reality as it does for a person.

What is being demonstrated in the article is that given billions of tokens of human-written training data, a statistical model can generate text that satisfies some of our expectations of how a person would respond to this task. Essentially we have enough parameters to capture from existing writing that statistically, the most likely word following "she looked in the bag labelled (X), and saw that it was full of (NOT X). She felt " is "surprised" or "confused" or some other word that is commonly embedded alongside contradictions.

What this article is not showing (but either irresponsibly or naively suggests) is that the LLM knows what a bag is, what a person is, what popcorn and chocolate are, and can then put itself in the shoes of someone experiencing this situation, and finally communicate its own theory of what is going on in that person's mind. That is just not in evidence.

The discussion is also muddled, saying that if structural properties of language create the ability to solve these tasks, then the tasks are either useless for studying humans, or suggest that humans can solve these tasks without ToM. The alternative explanation is of course that humans are known to be not-great at statistical next-word guesses (see Family Feud for examples), but are also known to use language to accurately describe their internal mental states. So the tasks remain useful and accurate in testing ToM in people because people can't perform statistical regressions over billion-token sets and therefore must generate their thoughts the old fashioned way.

lsy··on ChatGPT and the Enshittening of Knowledge
Yes, this is the essential issue. Any system competent to fully ground and check factual statements in a stream of arbitrary text will be phenomenally more complex than the original LLM, and usually will be able to answer queries directly, at which point one wonders what the LLM is adding. I think at best, if we can somehow identify all factual statements that need to be cross-referenced and then offload them to a knowledge base (dubious), we are left this kind of mad-libs connective flow that the LLM has created which approximates the essay style of a human writer. I'm not certain that has much practical value besides allowing for a form of undetectable plagiarism to be published as though it were free-form writing.
lsy··on ChatGPT and the Enshittening of Knowledge
The TLDR of the article is essentially that any time a ChatGPT conversation strays to the factual (in this case a list of data ethics books), the quality of the data (whether those books exist and are written by the stated authors) is extremely low.

Ultimately this is where ChatGPT and similar projects seem most likely to hit a wall. Text generators are statistical machines, but the relationship between statistics and truth is merely probabilistic and not identical. There is no way to train ChatGPT to say things that are true, because the number of true and false statements in the world are far too numerous and too specific to ever reliably delineate. At best, we will be stuck fact-checking ChatGPT using enormously complex knowledge bases and asking it to try again until something doesn't raise a red flag, at which point it may still not be true.

For most business purposes this is unacceptable. We will have machines that can generate untruths in a way that contravene common sense, so long as those untruths don't obviously contradict whatever local database is being consulted for grounding. And the mechanisms required to re-ground the GPT output even to that unhappy state will be so complex in their own right that businesses might as well just implement a similarly complex system to handle the issue directly, without calling out to a complex, licensed GPT. Not sure whether there is a way around this.

lsy··on US Marines defeat DARPA robot by hiding under a cardboard box
I think this is unnecessarily credulous about what is really going on with ChatGPT. It is not "applying the concepts of a poem" or checking meter and verse, it is generating text to fit a (admittedly very complicated) function that minimizes the statistical improbability of its appearance given the preceding text. One example is its use of rhyming words, despite having no concept of what words sound like, or what it is even like to hear a sound. It selects those words because when it has seen the word "poem" before in training data, it has often been followed by lines which happen to end in symbols that are commonly included in certain sets.

Human cognition is leagues different from this, as our symbolic representations are grounded in the world we occupy. A word is a representation of an imaginable sound as well as a concept. And beyond this, human intelligence not only consists of pattern-matching and replication but pattern-breaking, theory of mind, and maybe most importantly a 1-1 engagement with the world. What seems clear is that the robot was trained to recognize a certain pattern of pixels from a camera input, but neither the robot nor ChatGPT has any conception of what a "threat" entails, the stakes at hand, or the common-sense frame of reference to discern observed behaviors that are innocuous from those that are harmful. This allows a bunch of goofy grunts to easily best high-speed processors and fancy algorithms by identifying the gap between the model's symbolic representations and the actual world in which it's operating.

lsy··on Most young men live in quiet desperation, is it possible to resolve this?
I don't think this is an "external solution" thing. Some random gender-neutral ideas for becoming more interesting to others and being more interested in them:

- Read widely, both fiction and nonfiction. Become interested in and even familiar with experiences outside your own comfort zone.

- Work on empathy and tolerance. Be ready to hear and even validate things you don't fully agree with, whether it's politically or epistemologically. Learn to respect others and see them as people with full life experiences, rather than merely as potential partners or friends to enhance your life experience.

- Get life experience that is interesting. Note that this doesn't mean traveling widely or having an "interesting" job. In fact sometimes those things make you seem boring and are anyways often inaccessible. There are more accessible things to do, like volunteering with people who have different experiences than you, working on a local cause that is important to you, or learning to make art that represents your feelings.

- Make yourself go outside. The world is outside. Learn about the history of your local area and visit the important places in it.

- Pay a little bit of attention to things like hygiene, grooming, clothes. You don't have to go crazy, just shower thoroughly every day, get regular haircuts, and wear clothes that roughly match your age.

- As others have mentioned, find somewhere with a stable group of people and show up consistently.

- Get therapy, even if you think you don't need it. Most people need it.

- Avoid toxic X. Masculinity, femininity, whatever. Being lonely can make you feel like you need a rubric to follow. Don't buy it. Don't even take what I'm saying above as a rubric.

Ultimately the goal isn't to find an app that matches you with the perfect person or group of people, but to become someone who is interesting to and interested in more people overall. I empathize with the fact that people are sometimes hard to like, but almost everyone has something to recommend them if you are willing to listen, and so do you if you're willing to explore and expand yourself and share that with others.

lsy··on Counting with ChatGPT
ChatGPT is just a statistical engine that outputs text consistent with its previous input. So while it understands that requests to count words often end with something like "this passage has <number> words", and therefore puts a number in the sentence to make it statistically probable, it doesn't have any way of understanding that the number is supposed to correlate to the number of tokens in the passage referenced. It doesn't understand the meaning of the words you are putting into it, it just understands how to generate statistically probable text from those words. Furthermore because concepts like "word count" are statistically separate from the semantic content of the sentence, ChatGPT has an especially hard time building any kind of statistical model that outputs the correct number based on the query.
lsy··on Public Schools Lost More Than One Million Students During Pandemic
Another angle: how much non-reporting is due to mistrust of police, and how much is due to police explicitly telling crime victims not to report or that a report will be useless, because they are trying to politically undermine a progressive DA?

But I think there need to be actual studies on reporting rates and reasons for non-reporting before too much pure speculation is applied to dismiss these statistics. People have been making arguments close to the above for years if not decades, at some point one would assume the reporting rate would stabilize.

lsy··on Stanford hates fun
The author is clearly complaining from a conservative, free-market viewpoint, but it's difficult to overlook that the conservative, free-market ideology that triumphed in the Reagan-Thatcher era has been a major driver of the complaints voiced here. The late-sixties to early-nineties free-for-all at universities was partly due to an understanding of the university as a place for the betterment of the population in the form of a largely-subsidized public good. This also tied into concepts like tenure and academic freedom which insulated students and educators from the surrounding society, and allowed students to run organizations and modify or vandalize campus property without consequence, with the benefits and costs that entailed.

Today the university is largely re-imagined in the conservative mold. It is foremost an elite job-training site, and includes not only the cosmopolitan social training that companies demand of 21st-century knowledge workers, but free-market costs commensurate with the expected value of the degree in the vocational sphere. Administration has been handed over to a business class walled off from the educators, for fear of academics running the show, with predictable results of fiefdom-building. Tenured educators are disappearing and being replaced with the adjunct precariat, another conservative win. This all contributes to an atmosphere where the stakes of any action are very high for both students and university employees, and danger abounds, whether it be from lawsuits or from the possibility of being forced out of school and suffering lifelong consequences as a result. It's perplexing to see this laid at the feet of academics, when one needs look no further than other bastions of the conservative mindset, like HOAs or corporate HR departments, to find organizations that would be similarly displeased with an ad-hoc island in a common-area water feature.

← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →