HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lvoudour

814 karma · joined February 5, 2017

submissionscomments
lvoudour··on A view to the possible habitability of ancient Venus over three billion years [pdf]
It's itching me the wrong way as well. I prefer academic publications "dry" and austere, keeping distractions at a minimum. Stylish, cutesy graphs are better suited for other forms of dissemination
lvoudour··on As Scotland's 'Trainspotting' Generation Ages, the Dead Pile Up
Apparently high numbers of fentanyl users (article from 2012 which more or less coincides with the big spike in the graph)

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-17524945

lvoudour··on We Need a New Science of Progress
The major difference between what they're saying and existing fields (history, sociology, STS, economics, urbanism) is that the authors are only talking about looking at successes, not failures. That is juvenile at best, catastrophic at worst. Studying progress without studying failure is incredibly ill-defined, because you have to start by defining progress, and you can't actually guarantee progress without studying failure and studying how to avoid failure.

You perfectly articulated what I wanted to write but couldn't find the right words. Reinventing the wheel is one thing, but reinventing it and adding corners to it is just embarrassing.

lvoudour··on FPGAs Have the Wrong Abstraction for Computing
Regarding the end of the article:

A new category of hardware that beats FPGAs at their own game could bring with it a fresh abstraction hierarchy. The new software stack should dispense with FPGAs’ circuit emulation legacy and, with it, their RTL abstraction

Are you or the author working on something along these lines and if so can you give an example? I'll tell you the truth I was expecting a proposition and I felt kind of "robbed" when I reached the end and no alternative was given

lvoudour··on FPGAs Have the Wrong Abstraction for Computing
Seems like the author is arguing that when FPGAs are used for "computation" and not for prototyping or replacing ASICs for low volume production, there should be an ISA to abstract the gory details like in GPUs/CPUs, and Verilog is not an adequate abstraction in that regard because it's more like a programming language.

Now, I may misinterpret the author's argument, but I don't understand the obsession over ISAs. It's a bit short sighted IMHO and, I agree with you, HDLs may not be elegant or pretty but they do their job just fine, ie. low level modeling at the primitive level. They are not programming languages.

I also don't see how vendor locking fits with the rest of the narrative. Whatever intermediate abstraction the vendors offer (the author gives no examples which makes the post read more like a rant) it still won't expose the inner workings which (unlike CPUs/GPUs) are crucial for truly open FPGA development.

Now should we strive for a better alternative, an evolution to FPGAs that benefit from an "ISA" type of abstraction? I'm not smart enough to visualize it, but sure why not. An example would be nice though

lvoudour··on The Future of Food Delivery [slides]
It's seen as part of the standard business expenses like utilities and rent. Of course it squeezes their profit margin but what can they do? Competition is fierce. What most joints do though is to require a minimum price per order to allow delivery.
lvoudour··on The Future of Food Delivery [slides]
I used to live in Dublin until recently and coming from a country (Greece) where food/coffee delivery is free (apart from any tip), fast and ubiquitous, I was taken aback by the fact I had to pay a substantial delivery fee.

The upside was that driver safety seemed to be taken more seriously (it's a cutthroat business in Greece and drivers are pushed to their limit, accidents being rather frequent in their line of work).

lvoudour··on Ask HN: Turning Windows into a high-quality development environment
I personally haven't seen anyone in past ten years or perhaps more using Windows, let alone for programming at any businesses I worked at. Whereever I went, everybody's using Macs with macOS to do development. Is Windows even still a thing, or are you looking to explore Windows programming as a curious hobby past-time?

I'm sorry, but this is the archetypal "living in a bubble" comment (that is becoming very common on HN lately).

First of all the OP didn't ask "which is the best OS for development", there's probably a good reason he/she needs to work on windows.

And second, wondering if windows is still a thing for development and assuming macs are the standard, is absurd and detached from reality. I'll refrain from guessing your line of work (although I have my suspicion) but I'm pretty sure you never worked e.g. in electronics, sensing, finance, etc.

lvoudour··on OpenAI LP
Isn't consciousness a manifestation of intelligence? I don't see how the two can be treated separately. Talking about AGI is talking about something that can achieve a level of intellect which can ask questions about "being", "self", "meaning" and all the rest that separate intelligence from mere calculation. Otherwise, what's the point of this whole endeavor?
lvoudour··on OpenAI LP
How is it a distraction if that's the one and only goal of OpenAI? What are the investors investing in?
lvoudour··on OpenAI LP
Sorry for being a buzzkill, but if you create something with an intellect on par with human beings and then force it to "create value" for shareholders, you just created a slave.
lvoudour··on Slow Software
Maybe the USA Today site when accessed by EU IPs? https://eu.usatoday.com/
lvoudour··on Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China censorship
> Likewise, morality beyond legality is much more likely if it doesn’t yield any ground to competitors

Then, why do it at all?

You want to tell the world what is right and wrong, fine, do it as an individual, write a book, found a religion or something. Enforcing your moral values inside the company and even worse, using the company's power to force them to the world - only to abandon them when it hurts profits - is perverse IMO.

lvoudour··on Ex-Google engineer describing the company's role in China censorship
9/ For many people there is little difference between what is legal and what is moral. This mindset is especially dangerous when it is held by people in power, such as Google's executives. The mindset is: if it's a legal requirement to censor, then we should do it.

Except when standing on a moral pedestal does not hurt your bottom line. Then apparently it's ok to dictate what is moral and what is not, what is good and what is evil and use your power to force your agenda. It's not google's (or any company's) version of morality that gets me, it's always the hypocrisy

lvoudour··on The future’s so bright, I gotta wear blinders
> It's an oversimplification to say that Moore's law is over. Some important metrics have stopped improving. Others are still going, for now.

It's not over, but we're seeing trade-offs that we didn't see in the past decades, like clock rate stagnation and exotic cooling but most importantly, architectural changes.

Architectural changes present the biggest difficulty IMO because they require a change of mindset from the user's perspective. Multi-core was supposed to be an easy transition but it's still underutilized, GPUs for general purpose computing is doing well, but it's based on a popular 20 year old technology (and it's still not as accessible as CPU programming).

However the move to heterogeneous platforms will require substantial effort from a developer's perspective (however good the tooling might be to abstract things). Programming a CPU is one thing but programming a CPU with embedded GPUs,FPGAs,AI dies, etc. will certainly move a lot of people out of their comfort zone

lvoudour··on Bloated
Curious as to why you think AMP is a step to the right direction.
lvoudour··on Machine Learning Confronts the Elephant in the Room
Look over the man's head ;)
lvoudour··on End of Greek Aid Package as Country Faces Demographic Crisis
That's Greece in a nutshell right there. Skills were never relevant, and still aren't. It's all about who you know, and what political leverage you have. The results are there for all to see. I left Greece 6 years ago, and unfortunately whenever I visit, nothing seems to change.

Same as you, I left about 6 years ago, but I think things are gradually changing (albeit slowly). The state's "tit" has dried out and clientelism is not as rampant anymore, businesses that used to rely on state funded projects (and took advantage of connections) are much fewer, run of the mill shops that offer no quality of service are quickly phased-out by competition.

There's still lots of tax-evasion, undeclared employment, etc. and lots of dodgy businesses staying afloat (especially in tourism) but I still see a glimpse of change in the horizon.

The three big problems I see that make actual change hard are (a) too many young educated people have fled the country (b) the political environment is still fluid and (c) there are still many obstacles that make starting a business there unattractive. If (b) and (c) are solved, (a) will solve itself and people will come back to start again

lvoudour··on Why Use an FPGA Instead of a CPU or GPU?
All vendors have linux toolchains. But they are still proprietary and bloated (at least after a point)
lvoudour··on How Europe Learnt to Swim
I'm sorry but this is an absurd comment.

How do you define Europeans? North/western only? The continent's name is ancient Greek and, while the eastern borders may have changed, there is no point in time where the greek mainland was not considered part of it even in ancient times.

And what the hell do genetics have to do with a geographic designation?

lvoudour··on Fred Turner: Silicon Valley Thinks Politics Doesn’t Exist
Google and co aren't the smiths, they are the ones that hire them
lvoudour··on Why is Juul worth $16B? It’s more like a cigarette than you think
I don't know why you're getting downvoted, I think your comment is spot on

> People do move from Juul to more advanced setups, and yes, they step all the way down to 12 or 6 mil (nicotine) off the bat and likely go down to 3 mil after a few months.

That's certainly true for me, started vaping few months ago at 12 mil, switched to 6 within two weeks, trying 3 now.

50 mil is insane, there is absolutely no way you'll ever get hooked off nicotine and if it's true that they don't offer lower nic alternatives that's just insidious (and no different to what the tobacco industry has done for decades)

lvoudour··on Rome vs Greece: a clash of empires
Anyway, if I have a point, it's this: never underestimate the inadequacy of the US primary education system.

That happens everywhere it's not an American thing ( btw, the article is from an Irish newspaper), there's too much to cover in so little time. But learning shouldn't stop when we graduate, I can't blame school for my adult-life shortcomings, I got the basics and that should be enough IMHO

On the subject of the article, it's definitely not as popular as the punic wars or Caesar's conquest of Gaul, but then again what is?

lvoudour··on Macedonia Agrees to Change Its Name to End Bitter Dispute with Greece
It's the Balkans: disputes may seem inane to an external observer but they last generations and usually end up in (or perpetuated by) wars. It's the first time since I can remember where a dispute is resolved peacefully, without huge external pressure.

I don't know how long it's going to last but to be honest it was a prime example of ostrichism on our part (I'm Greek btw). Not that the other side didn't partake in kitsch demonstrations of nationalism, but at some point we should have taken cue from the rest of the world that called the country Macedonia and moved on, rather than pretend the matter is not de facto over and behave like a stubborn child

lvoudour··on Ask HN: Is there a new habit you cultivated recently that is really paying off?
Started working out, started vaping (and stopped smoking). Noticeable quality of life increase in just a few weeks
lvoudour··on What makes a country good at football?
the men's team is a joke.

Not American, but I think you're too harsh. It's certainly not top tier but lately it has fared much better than teams with bigger history and love for the sport

lvoudour··on What makes a country good at football?
Didn't downvote you, but I fail to see how your comments are related to the original post (why some countries are better at soccer).

Anyway,

Blind allegiance. Stop and think about the context.

P.S. I know European football has a lot of violence -- those stories about fan violence and absurdity. But I don't feel qualified to speak to it, really. I also don't perceive the players as being quite so chewed up by the game, although I vaguely recall some stories of arthritis and significantly limited mobility. And headers are becoming increasingly suspect in brain trauma.

I'm European but I watch a lot of NBA. Trust me there's no comparison when it comes to allegiance and supporting your club/team. In Europe and Latin America it's close to a religion. You stick to your team no matter what,changing allegiance is frowned upon and shows lack of character (what's called bandwagoning in the US). But is this unhealthy? Not to the degree your post argues

There's definitely sports related violence (especially in eastern Europe, balkans, latin America) but sports is just an excuse, there are deeper rooted problems that generate it. There's little to no sports related violence in northern Europe these days, even in Britain which was notorious for it in the 80's, but people are still loyal and mad about their teams.

As for injuries it's an occupational hazard with a great reward to risk ratio, unlike eg. working in a mine, or being in law enforcement - you're paid WAY better and you're WAY more popular even without being top tier. Risking your life for a few mil in the bank is much better than risking your life for a measly pension and a state sponsored funeral.

lvoudour··on FPGAs becoming more SoC-like
That's true, but that doesn't explain why the HDL IDEs lack modern productivity features or why the simulator GUIs have the same interface as 20 years ago. Inertia and vendor lock-in are better explanations IMHO.

I hope with FPGAs becoming more mainstream the open source/hobbyist community will step in and refine some things, but if the big EDA shops don't take hints from the software industry things are not going to change very fast.

lvoudour··on FPGAs becoming more SoC-like
Vivado is absolutely terrible, especially the GUI. Our toolchain at work is set up so that it can be entirely avoided, with developers only writing Verilog in their editor of choice, and calling make or pushing to Jenkins when they want results. And then they go home, as it takes a full day to build a product on our server farm. Sim/others is done with third-party products.

That's how most companies do it in my experience (and I prefer it as well). That said, Vivado is leaps and bounds better than its predecessor (ISE). It may be horrible for HDL coding, but when you need to do timing analysis and floorplanning the GUI is really helpful and the integrated TCL command line makes it very flexible.

Tooling in FPGA-land is a sad story, unfortunately. It's stuck in the 90's. I've ranted enough times to feel I'm beating a dead horse, but it's frustrating to see how behind the times it is compared to software development. Just look at HDL IDEs as an example:

The vendor ones are worse than simple text editors, 3rd party IDEs cost an arm and a leg, while feature wise they are nowhere near their software counterparts. Take the most popular HDL IDEs (or should I say eclipse plugins?) and compare them with visual studio pro or jetbrains. The feature discrepancy is staggering (as is the price difference). We use Sigasi at work and while it's definitely better than a text editor, the basic version costs ~800$/yr and apart from error-checking, goto-definition and renaming there's not much else going on. For the same price you can get the whole jetbrains suite with a couple hundred dollars to spare.

lvoudour··on Intel's 10nm Is Broken, Delayed Until 2019
I agree. And barring some groundbreaking invention that completely alters the hardware landscape, I think the trend will be heterogeneous/domain specific ICs. Which means new software development paradigms as well.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →