1,808 karma · joined August 9, 2022
And I kind of agree. Yes, the mistake was not hedging MBS and treasuries interest rates.
But are they really the only bank in the world doing that mistake?
What truly made it fatal is the VCs. That's also why nobody is coming to buy them. The speed at which the bank run happened, showed exactly how much they valued the bank.
If you're swimming with sharks, it's a big mistake to bleed. But let's not pretend the sharks are innocents. Bleeding isn't usually so fatal.
Which is why I don't think the sharks deserve a bailout.
Today it is VCs tantrum. It's actually ridiculous. We've reached the point where the riskiest sector in the financial system gets to cry and get rewarded for bad behavior and self destruction.
This isn't a problem of a strong Fed in control choosing what to do. It's a problem of a spineless Fed that gives in to manipulation. It isn't a problem of central banks manipulating, but being manipulated.
Once the financial system realized it's in their own interests to be fragile, it was game over. They will keep on holding everyone hostage.
Unless we figure out how to rescue the hostages without paying the kidnappers, this will continue happening.
It only takes one of them to do this calculation and take the gambit, and the rest of them just follow because they have to.
The shitty bank choices were independent mistakes, and were the major mistake. But the reason it blew up so strongly is because key players had an interest in a blow up.
They are such bad actors, their words were all pretending this is something bad, but their actions weren't to recapitalize the bank but to let it blow up intentionally, while spreading FUD. They made a very successful gambit here that they could blow the system up to get what they want (rate hikes stopped). And they won with that gambit.
If they get away with this, this gambit to them was totally worth the risk that the Fed won't chicken out.
It's a case of murdering and keeping the inheritance.
If I were the Fed, I would see this as a jackpot that finally the rate hikes are creating deflation in the best possible location and continue straight ahead. This is even better deflation than you can get by rising rate hikes for everyone.
And as a cherry on top, no depositors lost anything. I guess the losers are everyone else who get to eat inflation with nowhere to escape it.
The bottom line is that letting banks invest their clients deposits, while clients - even startups that even know in advance they will need this money in short duration - will keep on blowing in our faces. It might be mortgage backed securities, or treasuries, or anything else.
It's always the same story: banks are leeching money getting rich from taking risks with everyone's money, and the risk is bailed out again and again and again by the government.
They are given government mandate to be the only way to hold money. And then a government privilege to gamble that money on whatever financial instrument that we currently pretend has no risk. And then when we discover it had risk after all, the government pays for the risk.
All the while, banks were leveraged 10x or 20x on the fake "no risk", paid 0 interest rates on deposits, and got to take all the profits from that risk.
The fact that even startups couldn't co opt away from this madness speaks volumes. They were getting leveraged with 10yr duration instruments with depositors base that they knew is burning cash.
If those startups wanted to buy 10yr bonds with their VC money, they would've done it. But the bank just got permission to gamble their clients money.
It's even worse because more than getting bailed out, the thing these VCs want the most is for the rate hikes to stop. They got to both break the system with their actions and get what they wanted.
The Fed releases a digital dollar that you can bank without needing to be a part of this oligopoly. Banks are forced to give better terms to be attractive again, terms that will make up for the risk of the bank using your money. Deposits are no longer guaranteed because being in a bank is now a deliberate choice instead of something you're forced to do despite having money.
Banking is not competitive in any way. The small players are very risky to bank at. The big players get to be riskier because they are protected by the government.
Minewhile these people out of their privilege as bankers got to play with much bigger leverage, while paying zero interest rates to their counterparty which turned out to be fully paid for by the government in the end.
100% investment loss in this case is hardly enough, with the leverage levels banks can access they can literally collect pennies in front of a train and have positive expectation values for shareholders, while investing in negative expectation value investments.
And they did collect pennies in front of a train. Bought 10yr treasuries at historical lows. They paid their customers nothing for it.
VC investment strategy for VC bank. They took the zero or hero attitude until the end. Again, we're taking about people with already VC mentality of "worst case 100% loss, best case 1000%".
No wonder that once VCs recognized their own shadow they fled so fast.
And now they are pretending as if it's the fate of the banking system on the line.
VC bank, managed like VC venture for VC firms. They deserve to lose VC money.
Their loans are probably also worthless than they claim, but they managed to successfully swindle the Fed in the most VC way ever with the shortest deadline. I'm betting FDIC is going to pay twice as much as expected in the end.
At 10x leverage, when you're correctly assuming your customers will be bailed by the government instead of you getting criminally prosecuted, the worst you can lose is 100% of your money. With the kind of leverage you get in a bank, you don't even need to have positive expectation value investment to have positive expectation value for the bank shareholders.
even with completely trash odds of 50% chance of losing it all and 50% chance of earning only 20% with 10x free client deposit leverage, your expectation value is still 100%!
This is the moral hazard you're dealing with. At 10x leverage ratios of banks, they can take the worst possible bets and still win so long as their maximal loss is just losing all the investment.
You're just encouraging this behavior. This latest decision gives a huge incentives to all banks out there to blow out. Just the incentive structure alone is enough to collapse the entire financial system at this point. It was already eating itself and it's only going to get worse.
It's just a matter of time before they blow it beyond repair.
There's absolutely no excuse left for why banks get to invest any of their clients money. They get free leverage from their clients for free. They can send it to zero and the entire risk will be held by the government. That's absurd.
Revoke banks ability to invest deposits. They can't get to have the cake and eat it too. They could offer higher interest rates for non guaranteed accounts which bear risk, or zero risk for the already zero interest rates.
It's sad you're actually satisfied with a fictitious corporate entity "dying" when these people have perfected the art of making hostage situations with other people's money. It's all continuing because they get to successfully trade the hostages for a bailout each time. This guy is a professional Madoff, the only difference between them is that this guy is abusing bank's priviledge to get the government to backstop his ponzies.
With CBDC I get to put in my bank what I don't want with the government and vice versa.
They are using you as leverage because you have zero leverage on them. There are bank runs and the JP morgan stock is going up, because people have literally nowhere to flee to.
How can small banks compete against big banks that can allow themselves to act this way? They can't. If you're big you get to risk it all. If you're small nobody will come to you as they know they won't be insured by a spooked Fed stopping "contagion".
There's no legitimate reason to keep banks priviledge as a government supported oligopoly of investment institutions allowed to play with other people's money. If you admit the government is actually backstopping those deposits, there is absolutely zero reasons why banks get to gamble it in the first place. They are getting to eat the cake and have it too. This has to stop.
If I gambled away all your money you'd never give me more again. If the bank gambled away all your money and the government came and made you whole, you'd look to become a banker too so you get to gamble away money that isn't yours.
There is absolutely no reason banks should be given the priviledge of being the only way to deposit money, while playing with those customers money and simultaneously having zero risk on that money.
These banks are getting 10 to 1 leverage, from me, captive customer. Break their monopoly. I want an account at the Fed, and I want zero banks to be able to take leverage with my money, unless and until these banks give me a worthwhile interest rates on deposits. Let them actually compete. Right now it's not a competition, there are too big to fail banks which actually hold deposits, and there are small banks which can fail arbitrarily and cannot possibly compete because they actually assume the risk themselves.
I want zero risk CBDC. At the Fed. With the Fed's current interest rates as they give to real banks.
All their privileges should be gone. They can stay as investment institutions and if you trust them as that you're free to put your money there.
They get all the priviledge with no responsibility. If they cover for them, this should be the end of banking. Nothing less. Digital coin with zero risk and connection to all standard paying systems. Same interest as banks. Demote banks to investment institutions and make their special priviledges obsolete. No bank except the Fed will be too big to fail then, when no one's forcing you to bank anywhere.
The transformation back into feudalism is nearly complete. Hope you're happy with the freedom to develop your slave career. Don't forget career is the most important part of your life, don't forget to pay your 50% taxes so that we can give them as social support to people who compete with you on pricing, as we artificially choke supply with regulations so that god forbid your work will lose its leverage over your life.
It is unfortunate, but it seems like if you allow bad people to take innocent people hostage and reward them for that, you only get more hostage situations.
This is coming from a bank who had lobbied for the regulation to be repealed. That had the CFO of Lehman brothers from 2007. These are professional hostage takers. I would say persecute them, but we all know this isn't going to happen, and they aren't the only people acting this way. They are getting away with scamming people because we let the government make up the losses to the people they scam.
It's no wonder the VCs fled the ship so fast, many of them knew what was brewing. This is VCs money that is lost. That's where startups get their money. These startups slept with dogs, they shouldn't be surprised they wake up with fleas. It's VC bank using VC playbook of zero or hero. Let them get the zero. Do you honestly think all those VCs had no choice in where their startups deposit their money?
It's not "dumb regulators". The regulators didn't "screw up".
The government isn't coming to save you and you shouldn't expect it to, because it's literally controlled by the same griefters who have learned to perfect the art of milking money from everyone by taking innocent people hostage.
Let them blow the hostages. Or get more hostage situations. I'm all in favor of letting them blow the hostages this time. The good startups will be forced to dilute the corrupt VCs who pointed them towards SVB, and raise money elsewhere. The bad startups should just fall.
The VCs whose money those startups are built upon, have connections to this bank. This entire back acted like some VC venture, with explicit design of taking the risk of zero return.
0 dollars should be given to depositors. Absolutely zero. These griefters learned how to use the common people as meat shields. It's the CFO of Lehman brothers. Let the VCs who supported this lose their investments and be forced to raise money now. If those businesses are worth something, investors will buy them. Let the VCs who gave bad advice be wiped clean from the investment. Their choices led to this.
If you banked directly at the Fed, or with crypto, then moving some of your money to a bank would actually be a choice. And the entire incentive structure would shift accordingly.
They have no incentive to change. They are given a government backed mandate to be your only choice. Given those privileges, it's their incentives to abuse them. They have been continuously abusing them for years. It's not only risk, it's the interest rates they give customers. They get to arbitrarily pick and choose their friends to get good interest rate while you get trash.
They get to do all of this because they are protected with innocent people as meat shields. Meat shields that have no other choice but to protect these people from consequences.
But when you're up against corporations, the only thing they can lose is money. And the incentive structure is such that losing 100% with some probability is still profitable. That's why this happens. No regulation can bring the loss further down. Therefore you can't regulate it away.
Regulation is only a possible solution to a problem when it has a high enough probably for a penalty, and high enough penalty (100% is always the maximum!), to tilt back the expectation value from different choices.
You can't solve this with regulation. Regulation can't, by definition, solve misaligned behavior which already happens under when the risk is 100% loss on getting discovered.
We're only in this mess because banks have excessive privileges. These privileges lead to misaligned incentives. No amount of regulation can realign the incentives back. Only revoking their privileges.
Their privileges include being the only entities able to deal with the Fed and hold deposits .
Let people bank directly at the Fed. Or with crypto. But banks don't deserve a special privilege of being the only way people can hold money.
Furthermore, loans should not be transferable.
Now banks will actually have to price loans correctly. And putting your money in a bank would be a choice they will have to tempt you with, by actually giving real interest rates. And you won't have misaligned incentives, because there is no captive audience.
Giving your money to the bank would be a risk you're doing willingly. A risk they will pay you for taking instead of robbing from you by their regulatory privileges.
Only thing that can stop this misalignment of incentives is to revoke the regulatory privileges of banks. Let everyone bank directly at the Fed. There's no reason these banks should get the privilege of holding other people's money. They dont hold the risk so they shouldn't hold the privilege.
It's not regulations that are the problem. They were obviously using this bank as a free margin account using customers money to leverage their debts. They did it because they have a lot of money to win when betting with other people's money and only 100% to lose.
10x margin and the government making your counterparty whole if you fail?
Of course this degenerate bank used it in the most VC way.
Don't make a single client of them whole. Those banking there probably had connections to the people making tons of money when the bets went their way. Those who recommended banking there need to lose their credibility.
The risk they took was not a mistake. It was a feature. It was intended.
That's absolutely ridiculous. Where do I sign up. I want to gamble other people money at 10 to one leverage and nobody suing me if I fall.
My cushion if I make a margin account at the bank is what, 2 to 1? Do you know the interest rates you pay for these margins? Compare that to interest rates the banks give their customers.
They are absolutely privileged, by law. You as an individual or even as a corporation don't get this privilege.
Why is it in their interest not to risk it in a ridiculous way? If I had several margin accounts of 10 to 1 that can only go down to zero, the highest return isn't by spending it wisely. It's by spending it in the most risky way, getting that sweet 10x on that risk and the rest can go to zero for all I care. I don't even need a positive expectation value investment to have a positive expectation value from this shenanigan.
Even investing in an unfair coin toss of 40% to double, getting free 10 to one margins my expectation value is an absurd 400% return starting from what should be negative expectation value investment.
The banks have privileges that are absolutely rigging the game in the most distorted ways possible. The shareholders equity doesn't justify their privileges.
Now we're saying, actually, banks effectively don't impose counterparty risk on their clients. So the government is actually who's taking the counterparty risk.
If that's the government and not the customers, why did they get that privilege? Why is the government only there when the risk is fulfilled?
Limited liability is fine. It's not fine when who's really liable is the government, while the original deal was between the bank and its customer. Student loans are also not fine either, since you don't get to set them to zero.
Revoke Banks privilege of handling money. Let them play the game like the rest. Even the government itself needs to raise money using Treasury bonds. I want a fair game. This game is rigged. One player has the privilege of effectively using the government as an insurer for it's counterparty risk. It has repeatedly blown and abused that privilege. Revoke it.
Let me hold my account at the Fed if I have positive balance, just like the rest of the banks. Call it CDBC or whatever. Let me get the Fed interest rates just like banks do. The banks are free to do business as they have always done, to loan money. They are free to deal with the trench of people who need loans. Not with my money. My money is only there because they forced me to. That's not a fair system. I don't approve their usage of it for their margins but I literally don't have a choice. Which is why they also get to give me zero interest rates while the Fed gives them much higher rates.
Where even getting margin called on extremely big margins compared to my initial investment, the government would sweep in because that margin wasn't even mine to play with?
Where I get absolutely ridiculous interest rates from the Fed which I don't need to pass on to my meat shield clients, I just get literally free money from the central bank?
All these privileges for no responsibility. This has to end. If we all admit it's other people's money, and we all admit that in failure, the government will also cover for them, and they get to play these completely absurd investments with leverage of 20 to 1, their privilege is just unjustified.
When the broker fucks up and let you blow your margins, the broker pays the bills. But banks get to blow the margins with everyone's money and somehow the government only comes in when they blew it, but wasn't responsible to keep tabs on their margin in the first place? And there's barely any margins, the leverage ratios are insane.
Of course debt holders would require much higher interests. The whole thing is just a sad scheme where the government is letting privileged entities a monopoly of using leverage on other people money, while the government holds the tail risk.
I would love to get 20 to 1 margin with the government taking all the tail risk to zero and allowing me to dip below zero by design. If I blew it I could start again just like Lehman CFO which moved over to SVB.
If you take their responsibility, you have to take their privileges too.
If banks are rescued from this, the only logical conclusion is that all banks should just cease to exist. Why should they get to play with what is effectively taxpayer's money, since that is where the risk will be paid from if they lose?
Let it all fail. If you don't let it fail, might as well go full on CDBC and revoke banks privilege and role in managing money. What's even the point of having banks when the banks don't really hold the risk themselves? Why have them as gatekeepers? They don't deserve a single dollar earned from risk that they don't hold.