HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

machina_ex_deus

1,808 karma · joined August 9, 2022

submissionscomments
machina_ex_deus··on US discusses fund to backstop deposits if more banks fail
Just don't go protesting, I heard that's one way to lose access to your money in Canada.
machina_ex_deus··on Deutschlandticket for regional bus and rail services to be offered for €49/month
Do you have reading comprehension problems? It's not about when the driver arrives, it's about not standing intentionally with passengers wasting their time by design, in the middle of the road. I feel like I'm getting downvoted by people with reading comprehension level of bots.

It's better to have an optimistic schedule that sometimes gets late than a pessimistic schedule that always wastes everyone's time making pubic transport extremely slow in all circumstances.

It's not about the driver. It's about the passengers. It's about not stopping idly during your route with people on the bus. Buses aren't trains, they usually don't need to stop at all stations and the difference between stopping in all stations and not doing it is huge.

If your train schedule is so bad that a train, which has no traffic at all, can come 30 minutes early from schedule, then it could always do that and you're planning something wrong.

machina_ex_deus··on Deutschlandticket for regional bus and rail services to be offered for €49/month
There's usually an app that tells you in real time when the bus will arrive, including possible congestion. When it's minutes away it's never early so it's not a problem. The bus is almost never early from the scheduled time because it's usually the minimum time. So the bus might be late, but at least it's not standing idly while you're already in it, intentionally wasting everyone's time.

There's also a stop button to make sure the bus doesn't waste everyone's time stopping in stations nobody wants. Which is pretty pointless if we're now wasting the time earned by standing idle.

If I want accuracy, it's my responsibility to go ahead of time and pad my margins. Not the buses' job. It seems selfish to me to waste everyone's time for people who need accuracy, it's their responsibility to waste their own time getting better margins.

machina_ex_deus··on Deutschlandticket for regional bus and rail services to be offered for €49/month
Of course they shouldn't follow a strict schedule. You either value the time or the accuracy. If you're slowing everyone down to the worst case timing, you're wasting everyone's time just to be "on schedule". The schedules were clearly artificially longer than needed, because buses were frequently waiting in stations. I'm not talking about night buses, this happened during the day and frequently.

It was very obvious to me as an outsider that the planning is wrong. When the buses are frequently waiting minutes in stations with 20 people on them, it's watching hours of human hours wasted for an artificial accuracy. Accuracy is useless, the purpose is to have good average case end to end timing. Never have I had Google maps suggesting half an hour walks in European cities with pubic transport over public transport. Just shows how bad is the management of timing. They are waiting so frequently you might as well just walk.

Maybe it's just a cultural thing. You value how much the ticket costs and whether the timing is accurate. I value my personal time.

machina_ex_deus··on Deutschlandticket for regional bus and rail services to be offered for €49/month
I was in Berlin once as a tourist and I was surprised how bad is the planning of buses.

They stop and wait in the station until their time arrives (in the middle of the route), with 20 people on them, wasting everyone's time. That's just incredibly dumb planning. I get that the point is to be more "reliable" and "on time" but what's the point of being accurate if you're so slow?! At some points Google maps suggested we walk half an hour instead of taking the bus because the bus was slower.

It takes some really funny priorities to reach this point. I haven't seen anything similar anywhere else, a bus stopping and waiting with people inside. And it wasn't something rare, it seemed to happen pretty frequently.

It seemed like they are artificially padding the accuracy metric by actively slowing the buses. Their schedule is far slower than their average pace, and then they slow down everything. You get that the worst case timing is now your average timing but "accuracy" increased. That's Goodhart law in full effect.

machina_ex_deus··on SymPy makes math fun again
I like sagemath. They have integration with sympy, and they also have many features making python simpler when you want to do mathematical things.

There's latex display feature when in notebook. It looks good, can even have symbolical matrices and display them as you would've expected.

It's on par with Wolfram notebook, but you get to program in python instead of some propietary language.

If you got some really long formula, it's easier to see you got it correctly by displaying it symbolically in latex.

They have other things to smooth out the parts of python which are annoying in math, like exponentiation works with ^, and dividing integers returns a rational number instead of floating point or an integer.

machina_ex_deus··on There is a worrying amount of fraud in medical research
96% vaccine effectiveness! Into absolute uselessness when deployed to the masses.

As someone who believed them and took the vaccine, that was the last time I'm trusting medical research. I won't be fooled again, and from now on research won't be enough to make any personal decision, I'm waiting until independent evaluation in the real world happens and there are enough anecdotes to see that it really works as advertised.

The entire coronavirus debacle has corroded the trust in medical establishment to zero. I think it's justified and we've just been ignorant to the fraud, it took a lie so big and obvious to really wake people up.

machina_ex_deus··on Analysis: ChatGPT is great at what it’s designed for. You’re just using it wrong
You could deconstruct humans the same way. It's all biological cells with DNA which weren't even designed for anything but just evolved with natural selection. This species of apes started speaking only very recently, in evolutionary timescales, and the DNA was definitely not designed to do anything that humans are mostly doing right now. Nobody is guaranteeing anything, most of these apes actually suck at math extremely hard. They only gained awareness into the existing structure in the funny sounds they make recently.

But hey, things can just work and the golem can overcome it's creator or surprise it. All of the things you said don't matter.

The writer of this post is just another ape sitting with his phone in his hand making funny gestures on a touch screen. He got to the point of communicating with you after hearing similar apes make similar sounds, somehow connected those sounds to funny shapes as a little ape, and then learned to click those squiggly shapes as they show up on his "phone" in belief that another ape somewhere will recognize them.

Some apes do this so that other apes will click a triangle. But you can't guarantee that other apes really mean what you think those squiggly lines really mean, or that they aren't all doing it for the triangles.

Those triangles really are a mystery, given the design of those apes didn't have any evolutionary reason to seek triangle clicking.

To make my point instead of writing more squiggly lines, if you deconstruct something and then don't understand it, that's on you. Things can just work, they don't owe an explanation to you. If you have good explanation of when they work, I'm interested. If you don't, that's only reflecting on you.

I also try to heavily imply that if you generalize a human to an ape and then get astonished at the sounds he make, maybe that was an over generalization that missed something important.

machina_ex_deus··on Text Is All You Need
They aren't grounded in reality at all. In fact, I don't think ChatGPT or Bing even know the difference between fiction and reality. It all entered their training just the same. I've seen comments from Bing about how humans can be "reborn". These models have no grounding in reality at all, if you probe around it's easy to see.
machina_ex_deus··on How pervasive is corporate fraud?
When you're shorting an obvious fraud, remember that those who need to sell are those dumb enough to buy the fraud in the first place.

You're not betting just on whether they did a mistake, you're betting on when will they realize it.

machina_ex_deus··on Ask HN: What would it take for an AI to convince us it is conscious?
At the very least, it needs to be an agent in a world (which is the real world or close enough), have many senses which it is able to connect to coherent experience. chatbots only talking in text don't really come close because the words are meaningless to them, they don't connect to any other sense or relate to any model of the world. And then it needs to have an internal model of the world and an internal understanding of how its actions effect the world.

Then, it needs to be able to learn continuously, not just be pretrained. And it needs to be able to learn from few training materials, like humans. It needs a sense of time, and a sense of self.

And that's not nearly enough, but we're not even there yet.

machina_ex_deus··on Hydrogen: Does Earth hold vast stores of a renewable, carbon-free fuel?
The most limited resources aren't what we pull from the ground. Space is the most limited resource, especially in areas crowded with people. Just look at real estate prices compared to oil. It's negligible.

Solar and wind power are extremely inefficient in the most scarce resource. Oil can be cheaply moved from far off locations to locations with scarce space.

machina_ex_deus··on Hydrogen: Does Earth hold vast stores of a renewable, carbon-free fuel?
Well then, why don't we stop digging for lithium for the batteries, rare earth minerals for all electronics, metals etc.

Where do you think the resources for renewable energy come from? Windmills and solar panels don't come out of thin air.

"No more digging stuff" shows such a disconnected view from reality. Everything is "limited" in some sense. The puritan attitude as if you can somehow avoid using resources, is just wrong. And oil is hardly the most scarce resource that's at the biggest risk of running out right now.

machina_ex_deus··on Scientists find first observational evidence linking black holes to dark energy
I kind of dislike cosmological / astronomical science. It's strictly non interacting. It's predicting a function of only output and not inputs. Sure, the number of outputs is large. But without any inputs, it's just a funny compression competition.

So long as we can't interact with it, I don't think there's any way to distinguish between ideas. Note that the only reason Newton managed to surpass his predecessors was because of his insight that whatever it was that's pulling the stars is also the same thing we have locally. Without having something to play with locally, we'd never get anywhere. Sure, you might realize that somehow the epicirles are actually ellipses, or find this or that correction. Still you'll get nowhere without something interactive and local.

machina_ex_deus··on Bing: “I will not harm you unless you harm me first”
The term temperature is used because they are literally using Boltzmann's distribution from statistical mechanics: e^(-H/T) where H is energy (Hamiltonian), T is temperature.

The probability they give to something of score H is just like in statistical mechanics, e^(-H/T) and they divide by the partition function (sum) similarly to normalize. (You might recognize it with beta=1/T there)

machina_ex_deus··on AI Joins Hunt for ET: Study Finds 8 Potential Alien Signals
You could say the same about natural evolution. It's a genetic algorithm. It even involves the intelligence of the species themselves as they pick the fittest mates. Natural evolution as an algorithm isn't fully intelligent like us, but it is intelligent in some sense of successfully solving many optimization problems.
machina_ex_deus··on The Coming AI Hackers (2021)
This article is written as if scheier is going to make collective decisions on behalf of everyone, or as if someone making collective decisions for everyone is going to stop everything "because it's dangerous".

What's actually going to happen is that regardless of the so called possible dangers, there will be talented humans who still view this as a net positive thing and they will continue to develop AI, wherever it goes.

Unless there's a global traumatic event, I don't see anything stopping.

AI developers have an interest to fake moral problems to better capitalize on their product (we don't support you running models at home, it's too dangerous), and that's exactly where their ethics concerns will end.

We can't deal with any of these things by telling people to stop doing things they obviously won't stop doing.

I'd rather we deal with this transparently. How about requiring AI models deployed to be really open? Then at least humanity will always have an advantage over AI that AIs are whitebox while humans are blackbox.

And if some AI will do some hack to benefit its creators, everyone else will have a chance to understand it's happening.

It shouldn't be "this is dangerous, make it closed so only we can abuse it", it should be, this is dangerous, so we're doing this as transparently as possible.

I think in a theoretical war between Turing machines, the Turing machine which is given as input the code of the other turing machine should always be the winner.

Think about the halting problem and diagonalization: the diagonalizing counter example wins by having the source code of the program which supposedly solves the halting problem.

machina_ex_deus··on The paper that made ChatGPT possible
A reminder that there's nothing open about OpenAI. Stable diffusion is open. OpenAI started spewing morality nonsense once they got something they could capitalize on. From supposedly non profit when there was no profit to be made to fake moral high ground, to becoming completely closed.

Hardly "practice what you preach". They may have delivered technologically, but they have completely backtracked on their openess promises.

I ran stable diffusion at home. Never could do the same with anything out of "Open"AI

machina_ex_deus··on A 50-Year Quest: My Personal Journey with the Second Law of Thermodynamics
I think it's pretty obvious that the second law comes from reversibility of the microscopic laws.

In classical mechanics, Liouville's theorem makes phase space density incompressible, so you get that entropy always increases. In quantum mechanics, unitarity gives the same incompressibility - the density matrix change with time is multiplying by a unitary matrix left and right, which preserves the eigenvalues, so the entropy, being sum of the log of eigenvalues, stays the same.

The opposite is also obvious: in a system which is irreversible, look at an ensemble of two states which evolve to a single state. The entropy before was 1 bit, after the evolution it's 0 bits. So the system violates the second law.

machina_ex_deus··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
All these people being pissed off from these comments just shows it's the counter culture. I'm not wrong. The more downvotes I get the more I know it's on the target.
machina_ex_deus··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
The excuses made for flu vaccines (there are many strains of flu after generations of different strains circulating and diverging), don't apply to COVID.

It's pretty obvious they started to redefine what vaccine does right around the time the COVID vaccine failed. The tests used to authorize the vaccines supposedly showed 95% efficiency doing just that.

The narrative shift was extremely sharp.

machina_ex_deus··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
Thanks for citing all those mainstream media news. Too bad I don't shape my perception of reality on their nonsense. They are literally just other humans. You have no common sense firewall or consistency if you allow these people to reprogram you. You're just proving my point that these deconstruction of language and values come from the media.

Get some common sense anti virus for your brain. You're being fed bad training input to get the desired output. The desired output is having a dumb society of wage slaves who get to choose between two options and think they are free.

Society of people where you can keep suggesting terrible "choices" to people like self genital mutilation (the real choice being self-acceptance), killing fetuses (the real choice was making the fetus in the first place), and picking between two equally corrupt parties, or losing your job and taking a worthless vaccine. And those sheep in that society will reprogram themselves to only act on the choices presented and never think for themselves.

Society where the only non-binary choice you get to make, is quite ironically, "your gender", which is literally the most binary non-choice you're ever given. But of course the maximum false choices presented will be where you don't really have a choice at all.

machina_ex_deus··on Do we live in a society without a counterculture?
See, so I am right that this is counter culture? I said this and it triggered you to jump and respond with fact checks and whatever.

https://web.archive.org/web/20060212064058/https://www.merri...

Can also show you that the dominant medical narrative around vaccines was that they provide immunity (except in the case of immune compromised individuals).

To this day I'm actually astonished watching the entire medical consensus shift as a direct result for the failure of the COVID vaccines. Absolute objective failure.

What's even more surprising to me is watching the entire narrative move around instead of acknowledging this. Instead of acknowledging the truth, the definitions move around so that the truth is redefined.

The definition of vaccine (provides immunity), recession (two quarters of contraction), woman (female with XX chromosomes), election, freedom (from doing what you want to "the ability to choose"), family (husband, wife and kids), democracy, peaceful ("protests"), racism (treating someone differently because of race, now you're racist for not giving preferential treatment to some1). Global warming became climate change. I've watched how in very few years the entire world has been reprogrammed with new definitions for these like ChatGPT. They kept getting bombarded with new definitions, so that lies will be redefined to be truths.

It is absolutely ridiculous to watch and realize how the media could train people like some neural network to lose the meanings of words and the relation to reality. It is watching people being reprogrammed into newspeak where they literally can't understand what's wrong because the meaning of all words have been replaced in their minds, so they can't have controversial thoughts.

It has become impossible to communicate. It's like talking to ChatGPT trained on some corrupt input, they are writing the same letters and speaking the same syllables but they have a different mental model. There are no other words describing the concepts they have lost, so at this point it's like speaking in two different languages. You'll say they don't have freedom and they will reply that they can choose what they want to do. In 10 years they will own nothing and be happy, because they will redefine rented property to be "yours".

machina_ex_deus··on Google exec fired after female boss groped him at drunken bash, suit says
Don't get me started on China's social credit. I'll pick the mob justice over an unintelligent oppressive dictatorship. Communism is a whole religion of its own, and it's even more oppressive and pervasive than other religions, and it fosters corruption.
machina_ex_deus··on Google exec fired after female boss groped him at drunken bash, suit says
So the justice system built by many intelligent professionals failed, but the dumb mob justice will succeed?

It is the lack of religion, because religion is exactly what would fill this gap in the minds of people from seeing injustice. Maybe the earthly judges failed, but I don't need to be cruel and punishing because the criminal will get what's coming for him in the next life.

It doesn't even matter if this argument is true or false, and if there is another life and judgement in it. That line of thinking clearly keeps people more civilized. Here in the present, in an objectively observable way that even complete atheists could compare.

machina_ex_deus··on Google exec fired after female boss groped him at drunken bash, suit says
The real issue is that people stopped caring about whatever the justice system is going to decide.

There's a new religion of social justice, and this religion is harsher than even the old religions.

The old religions you were at least judged by an omnipotent being who could see the whole picture. This new woke religion have you judged by a dumb mob. Everyone's playing the judge and everyone's responsible to punishing everyone.

As if punishing a bad person is a virtue. And as if there's nothing wrong about lynching an innocent person.

And this is a direct result of lack of religion. The absence of religion isn't lack of oppression, it's oppression by a dumb blind mob. Religion isn't the truly primitive behavior, the truly primitive behavior is this dumb mob social justice that's spreading now.

machina_ex_deus··on Pfizer Responds to Covid Gain of Function Research Claims
Just make sure you have the world media prepared with an appropriate wargame to simulate what would happen if an unrelated coronavirus would start spreading. Give it a boring name like event 201. Since it's all out in the open it's clearly not a conspiracy.

Then have the world media present you as the Oracle of Delphi because you had such an accurate prediction.

machina_ex_deus··on Can video games change people’s minds about the climate crisis?
Is Freeman Dyson also a crazy person who doesn't know what he's talking about?

The appearance of consensus is manufactured by the media. They label each dissenter as an individual crazy person and somehow the mainstream narrative is the consensus.

And again, this labelling is done by the media. There's no high authority of science.

machina_ex_deus··on Can video games change people’s minds about the climate crisis?
We've seen this line of reasoning in the COVID crisis. I won't be fooled twice. Everyone is systematically overstating their confidence. I'd rather deal with the problem as it arises than do unnecessary damage.

And I definitely think that relying on the weather a.k.a. "renewable energy" when you have solid prediction that its going to be unreliable, while your prediction of the possibility of averting the crisis is unknown, is beyond dumb. It's suicidal.

We're choosing the worst possible strategy right now. We have the highest probability of the worst case scenario: chaotic climate and weather while relying on said climate for energy generation. Planning for worst case is planning for the crisis happening regardless of your actions, because your confidence about the impact of your actions is pretty low.

There is no metric by which the current suicidal strategy makes sense. We're not minimizing the damage in the worst case. We're not adapting to the situation as it comes. The only scenario in which the current strategy has a better outcome is if we somehow were right about everything, not only about the impact of CO2, but about the geopolitical actions taken by China and India.

The probability that we're on the best possible strategy is practically zero.

machina_ex_deus··on Can video games change people’s minds about the climate crisis?
I wonder how did they do that without predicting anything about CO2 usage in those 4 decades?

You need to realize there are two questions:

1. What will be the climate decades into the future? T(CO2, t)=?

2. What is the effect of CO2 on all of this? T(CO2+ΔCO2, t)=?

Getting zeroth order of T is one thing. They did it pretty badly anyway. Getting the first order of T with respect to CO2 is another thing entirely.

Getting the answer to 2 correctly is much, much harder. You want to do the the derivative by CO2 ppm, and as you do that, you have 10^-5 factors on most things, because that's how much CO2 ppm there is.

I don't buy the narrative that they did this difficult thing correctly. Supposedly the leading order is something like how much CO2 increases absorption. It's going to have this 10^-5 factor of CO2 ppm there, and it's going to be what's causing this whole thing to happen. But if there are greater than 10^-5 errors in this calculation, the whole thing is useless. And they don't actually do this analytically, they just run it many times in a simulation.

I just don't buy the narrative that they manage to get meaningful signal out of that, not with how their code looks like, how chaotic the real system is, and their uncertainties about other parameters, there's just no way in hell they know this correctly.

Their evidence is that they have some pretty rough estimates for the zeroth order. The evidence for their confidence of the first order is extremely weak. And the narrative that CO2 matters is only meaningful if they have a good estimate of the first order.

← PreviousPage 6 of 12Next →