HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

machina_ex_deus

1,808 karma · joined August 9, 2022

submissionscomments
machina_ex_deus··on Can video games change people’s minds about the climate crisis?
There are two arguments, and they like to confuse people that they must be related.

There is all the data of what is actually going on in the world. Temperature readings, satellite images, etc. This can be called science and it is evidence, but it doesn't come with anything saying what is causing it. The equivalent of a primitive man meticulously measuring the rain.

Then there is the conjecture that this is all because of CO2 and its all our fault. This is purely religious argument, not at all different than the good old "Gods are punishing us" argument from a primitive man. The only evidence for this argument are some trash computer models which are running far beyond their predictive capability.

It's also inevitable that if we have "global warming god" and "global cooling god", one would emerge victorious.

It isn't science, it's just masquerading as science. The data analysis of real world data is science. The trash computer models attributing all of this to CO2 aren't science.

These are similar to the computer models in the COVID crisis which have overshoot reality by orders of magnitude.

machina_ex_deus··on Can video games change people’s minds about the climate crisis?
The entire narrative is that a gas which is just 400 parts per million - 4 10^4, or 0.04% - causes heating of 1 degree Celsius around ~300 degrees over absolute zero (so 0.3% increase in temperature) over a time frame of decades - so 0.03% increase per year - and the only evidence we have tying the conjectured cause of warming (CO2) to the actual climate are computer models, whose accuracy is extremely bad in the span of few months.

We're talking about predicting an effect which is 10^-5 orders of magnitude different from current configuration, with tools that were tested and failed within much shorter timeframes (~ months instead of years) and all of this is the only "evidence". The prediction abilities of these tools are only around the general trend, they failed predicting the magnitude correctly. So around 10^1 orders of magnitudes of accuracy.

All of this by computer models which have horrible code, all copying from each other, and are extended way beyond their empirical testing - while being fixed with fudge factors called "flux adjustments".

All of this in an extremely chaotic system. The kind of chaos which has no hope for even short duration prediction.

It's not science. It's a religion. There are no confidence intervals on this because if they had done a systematic analysis of the entire thing, they would have to admit that the chaotic behavior dominates their analysis by several orders of magnitude.

They do have plenty of data for what is actually going on - but the conjecture that it is CO2 causing it (as opposed to being just chaotic behavior, other factors, anything else really) has very little evidence. They abuse conjunction fallacy to convince everyone.

machina_ex_deus··on Justin Roiland dropped from Rick and Morty after domestic abuse charges
sex offender?! Did I miss something? It says he's accused of domestic abuse, not sexual attacks. I've also saw messages suggesting he's very tactless and creepy, but I've seen nothing suggesting he's a threat to anyone around him.
machina_ex_deus··on Justin Roiland dropped from Rick and Morty after domestic abuse charges
Then let him get what he deserves, as fits the crime. I'm not even talking about forgiveness. Justice isn't stopping bad people from doing good, it's stopping them from doing bad. Again I'm all in favor of him getting justice. Pay his victims. Go to jail or whatever it is that's the punishment for this. But this cancel culture isn't justice.

And of course he's not supposed to seek forgiveness from us, that's my point. He needs to be judged by a judge. Not me, neither adult swim. Definitely not this mob justice.

One of the major points of religions is to prevent mob justice. To be judged fairly in an intelligent process, with a fitting punishment.

How is firing him from his job a fitting punishment? There's no law for that because there shouldn't be. The justice system has as a principle the concept of minimizing the consequences of uninvolved parties.

There wouldn't be so much hunger for vengeance if people believed others will get what they deserve.

machina_ex_deus··on Justin Roiland dropped from Rick and Morty after domestic abuse charges
It's likely to make people around his position lose their job. If there were safety issues at work, like I said, I'm 100% in favor of kicking people out for the first transgression in work. If there wasn't, your argument is pointless. You're just ignoring reality for the convenience of your vengeful rightousness.

Stop acting like you get some sick virtue points by enacting vengeance on bad people. Two wrongs don't make it right.

How about a message that even sinful people can still do good? Or that they should channel their flaws to something good?

As if I care for roiland being fine. Your message is that it's fine because the only ones being hurt are everyone around him.

And this has everything to do with cancel culture. It's happening to Harry Potter over nothing right now. It's all over the place. People cancelling the constitution because "slave owners", owning slaves is definitely worse than domestic abuse.

It's all nonsense. Either an action is good or bad. Bad action on bad people doesn't make it good. It makes you bad as well. Everyone sins. You don't judge an action by whether it's helping a sinner because then no action will be good. You judge it only by itself.

This is a new form of religious atheism where the mob is responsible for justice instead of God. And in my opinion, society is better when justice is served by an intelligent entity rather than blind mob.

It shouldn't be the mob's job to stone him.

machina_ex_deus··on Justin Roiland dropped from Rick and Morty after domestic abuse charges
I think the moral and message and consequences are stronger in Rick and Morty than your usual sitcom.

Your usual sitcom the heroes are infallible and get at most a slip on the wrist. Here the narrator is saying, this anti hero is so bad he could literally destroy the whole world. He can't undo his mistakes because some mistakes are beyond even his abilities to undo.

We're resetting the situation because that's what sitcoms have to do, but it's the opposite of a happy ending. That's the message I got at least. Similar to the vat of acid episode. That actions have consequences and not all mistakes can be corrected.

It's actually the normal sitcom heroes that get away with everything by virtue of plot armor or plot ingenuity, while Rick and Morty cynically reset it because the show must go on, while hinting strongly that this is the only reason it's allowed and consequences were as real as they could be.

machina_ex_deus··on Justin Roiland dropped from Rick and Morty after domestic abuse charges
It was already getting worse, at this point it's not really going to be Rick and Morty anymore. Ship of Thaddeus except different ship entirely.
machina_ex_deus··on Justin Roiland dropped from Rick and Morty after domestic abuse charges
I don't think he's replaceable. It's like house of cards without Kevin Spacey. Actually even worse, one of the best episodes was an episode completely voiced by Justin, of an entire society, and he managed to play so many different personalities of the same character. Never seen this level of voice acting.

It was pretty obvious that he's got issues. Had a scene where a writer literally confesses that he has bad tendencies and channels it all into his work (the gazorpazorp episode).

It's kind of sad that society and cancel culture don't allow bad people to do good things. If those were workplace allegations you really can't let someone like that work, but that's not the case.

I'm all in favor of him both losing most of his money to compensate his victims and continuing to work on Rick and Morty. But society can't handle nuance, and the mob judges people instead of actions. Literally nothing good happened as a result of this cancellation. Just blind mob justice.

People aren't black and white, bad people can do some good things and everyone sins. He deserves a punishment fitting his crime, and the purpose of the punishment isn't vengeance. If an action is good there's nothing morally wrong with letting a bad person do it.

machina_ex_deus··on Signal app's president-“layoffs in tech are to keep salaries in check”
There's no reason to have any narrative other than the Fed raising rates.

If you've watched with absolute astonishment how despite the COVID crisis the stock market kept on climbing because of the Fed printing press, then you'll learn the lesson never to fight the Fed.

Now the directions are reversed. If the Fed could pump the stock market despite the worst economic doom and gloom, when the Fed raises rates this high into a powder keg, I expect to be surprised even more.

I wasn't surprised yet. We're not even at the same peak level of interest rates of the 2008 recession, and we're still in high inflation.

I think companies are starting to dread the depth of the incoming recession.

machina_ex_deus··on Microsoft Hosted Sting Performance in Davos on Night Before Announcing Layoffs
I heard the new matrix doesn't try to hide, it's in your face gaslighting you and demoralizing you every time you observe it.

Who needs to conspire secretly when you can do it publicly, and then turn around and say it's not a conspiracy since it's out in the open?

machina_ex_deus··on How You Respond to Security Researchers Says Everything About You
I'll translate your messages so you'll understand how you sound to customer support:

"I reported a security valley to LastPass’s bug boopy bopy.

Please ask your security team to look at the linked bug boopy bopy ticket. The teetee team shat the bed."

"Allow me to explain carefully.

I followed the steps in your security page, yes. I reported the issues I found to bowy.

However, bowy employees take it upon themselves to teetee issues on behalf of their customers.

In this case, the bowy employees shat the proverbial bed and incorrectly dismissed an issue I reported. Because the issue was closed as Not Applicable (erroneously), it’s unlikely that your security team will notice it without escalating some awareness of this teetee error to them.

So please pass that onto your security team so they’re aware to look in the Rejected tab."

"This is the order of operations so far:

I identified a coopy seesee-channny in the LastPass software. I reported the issue to bowy with a detailed analysis and a patch for making the funky conta tammy like it was intended to be. Several days after I reported it, a bowy employee stupidly went “no FOL expee? not applicable” and closed it erroneously. I’ve contacted toto support with one goal in mind: To ensure your security team actually sees the report in spite of bowy closing it. I don’t care about whether or not your team overrides their decision. I just have an ethical obligation to disclose security issues.

If this isn’t resolved by 5:00 PM Eastern today, I’m going to say “Fuck it” and go Full Disclosure.

Escalate. Tell me when you’ve escalated.

I don’t need your help beyond that."

"Thank you for escalating.

I don’t understand your question. I reevee egengi your software to study how it works, found a valley, and then reported it."

That's how you sound. All he could notice is that you have something with shitting in beds twice, and that you "Fuck it". I bet from confusion he asked his manager what to do and the manager replied that you are a phishing email, and he didn't even understand that.

If you do end up needing to talk to people who wouldn't understand you, explain nicely what are your credentials, don't shit in beds, and ask nicely to get direct contact with someone responsible who can understand you. Not broken telephone. Don't speak to people in gibberish to them.

And honestly, shitting in beds is an uncommon saying and universally gross. Keep that shit to yourself.

You're trying to communicate professionally, not be that barking dog shitting in beds. It's not the world's fault they can't take that seriously. It is your choice. Your words. Your image and communication isn't there to serve your internal identity, it's there so that people will respect you and take you seriously.

I couldn't care less how you present yourself, but I assumed you're at least not oblivious to how you sound and look to everyone. I don't mean to insult, just to put a mirror. And to remind you this is your choice.

machina_ex_deus··on How You Respond to Security Researchers Says Everything About You
It's interesting that after all my points, you decide to nitpick that one sentence where I didn't assume you weren't a customer, I stated the fact that you didn't contact them as a customer.

It's interesting because it's similar to how you decided to base your entire judgement of this company on encounter with customer support.

You can't just throw everything into bad or good bucket because of how it triggers you emotionally. I bet I quite annoyed you. Doesn't mean the best thing to do is just find that one sentence where I'm slightly wrong and judge me on that.

Try to emotionally detach. When a bug is pissing you off, do you throw the whole program with it? Or do you understand what's going on and what is there to learn, despite the annoying bug?

Do I have something to learn from this incredibly annoying person that embarrassed me on HN?

Or should I just find something to nitpick?

I'm not your enemy. Customer support isn't your enemy. And the security researcher coming to your company with some anoying bug bounty isn't an enemy either. There's that saying, Homo homini lupus. Don't be like that.

machina_ex_deus··on How You Respond to Security Researchers Says Everything About You
You would probably have a better chance of escalating any issue with a mail to anyone that isn't customer support. If you're a security researcher, imagine customer support as this big human firewall to communicating with this corporation, meant to be extremely strict so the communication with the rest of the cooperation won't be flooded with all the things customers want.

If you're not understanding this properly and wasting time trying to contact someone through customer support, that's on you. Which company doesn't even matter.

machina_ex_deus··on How You Respond to Security Researchers Says Everything About You
At most they would refer you elsewhere, but most probably they would kindly ask you contact someone else so they can serve people looking to order pizzas. They get prank calls and all sorts of nonsense. They get customers asking all kinds of weird questions constantly, and they can't distinguish them from Mr important security researcher here that's not even a customer. They will just get confused, return an automated reply and move on to next request because they are paying them to handle bulk requests. They are not meant to escalate to manager, it's literally their job not to do it. And their manager is just another customer support person.
machina_ex_deus··on How You Respond to Security Researchers Says Everything About You
Did this guy seriously try to reach the security team through the normal customer support channel that's probably automated with bots, and then judged the company according to that?

And that's after they do have a bug bounty program, and instead of speaking with bugcrowd who denied him, he decided to go through a channel that's clearly not meant to handle these kinds of issues.

This is just such a poor understanding of how companies work. If he just emailed a real person in the company he'd have a real chance of getting a real response.

Imagine judging a pizza company by how the pizza ordering hotline didn't take your vulnerability disclose. This sounds ridiculous. Now customer support is just like pizza ordering line.

If you want to contact a company on something they usually don't have a normal channel, you need to speak to the right people. Need to write a nice email, even if they don't have "security.txt", to some manager or someone else you could contact, and ask nicely who to contact further about it. And try more than one person.

If you're not a customer, do not go through customer support. It's the worst channel in every company because they need to serve bulk communication. And they see an incredible amount of shit from confused customers, so don't expect them to realize that there's something important going on.

And be nice. If you're acting like an asshole, you could have a million dollar issue and you won't get past customer support. They are asshole filter. They are meant to filter out all the assholes trying to reach the corporation. Their number 1 instinct is to block assholes. If you sound like trouble, it's literally their job to filter you.

machina_ex_deus··on Twitter has fewer than 550 full time engineers
The media definitely knew they are exaggerating nonsense, but they wanted to convince people and advertisers to leave Twitter, and all this scaremongering helped.
machina_ex_deus··on Study: Exxon mobil accurately predicted warming since 1970s
It's like mortgage, the existence of mortgages hurts the home buyers and increases the price of homes. You have to compete with other people willing to enslave themselves with long mortgages to buy the house.

But approach a simple minded person and he'll say, "how can you get a house without mortgages"?

People are so quite bad at understanding the interests behind actions and instead buy the misleading narrative that pushes them to do the complete opposite.

Everyone's predicting the weather is going to become more chaotic yet the conclusion is that somehow we should rely on it to produce energy. Want to guess what would happen when that backfires? Oil makes a comeback and these people take a huge unearned profit.

I think any solution to climate change that involves relying on the climate is absolutely bonkers. It's ridiculous. You have leaders flying jets and having coast line houses lecturing you about climate. Watch what they do not what they say. Words lie but actions betray thoughts.

machina_ex_deus··on Study: Exxon mobil accurately predicted warming since 1970s
Did it really hurt their business tho? It seems that pushing climate change only improved their profit margins with artificial scarcity.

I'm not sure people are correctly analyzing their interests here. Renewables are still unreliable in winter, most of the oil is used in transportation and the power grid is just decades away from supporting electric cars.

Minewhile they get to enact cartel style output limiting and competition suppression in the name of climate change. I'll also note that the narrative only truly took off when they started getting pressure from shale oil competition, not the literally 40 years beforehand that they had good margins.

All in all I believe that the timing and actions are in their advantage.

machina_ex_deus··on Exxon made ‘breathtakingly’ accurate climate predictions in 1970s and 80s
At least in my country, the poor usually vote for conservative policy, and it's usually rich leftists trying to push communism and welfare while those receiving said welfare vote against them.

The poor know best there are no free meals. It's the rich elitist that can afford to virtue signal with ideas of dumb policies, because they aren't close to the edge of economical ruin if those policies go sideways. And they mostly go sideways.

When policies take money from the poor to give to the poorer, it just reduces social mobility further and creates dependence on the government.

By the way, all this climate religion hurts the weakest in society the most. They can't buy a Tesla or afford heating when "carbon taxed" or when renewable energies who rely on the weather (which we all knew is going to be unreliable) freeze and result in them freezing to death in winter.

Oh and by the way, it's also a scientific consensus that global warming is going to result in net lives saved because people die from cold much more than from warming. It's just a narrative you'll never hear. And because those dying from cold are usually the weaker parts of society. And those owning real estate close to the coast usually have much more money.

And there has never been a scientific consensus. Freeman Dyson, for example, which died in 2021, was the last remaining physicist from developing QED, a physicist I respect much more than the pop science scientists, thought the climate change religion is misguided and even called them religion.

machina_ex_deus··on Liquid democracy: two experiments on delegation in voting
Yes, the threat model is that the government is the malicious entity and the people are the verifier.

If the government creates the code and the protocols they are hard to secure against the government itself.

Elections are the only time you do not trust your government because in elections you establish your trust. If you trust the government with elections that's a circular trust problem and it only needs to win once.

So the boundaries are what the people can verify, what many Bobs and Alices can do physically together in the real world to see that real Bob and Alice exists and support the government. And the government is Eve. If you're giving Eve the power to determine who's real without needing to present a real human, you already lost.

Audits means that Eve only needs to compromise a few more auditors. Real elections Eve needs to compromise impossible number of people.

machina_ex_deus··on Liquid democracy: two experiments on delegation in voting
Hands raised is even better, fair point. So long as you're physically verifying humans, it's good. The problem is that usually direct and liquid democracy aren't scalable, and you're not going to do country wide elections on everything. So these methods tend to converge to some electronic hack instead.
machina_ex_deus··on Liquid democracy: two experiments on delegation in voting
You still didn't prove the non existence of cryptographic backdoor, hardware backdoor or anything else in the chain.

There's also a decent chance the audit fail, then now what do you do? A person can be unreachable. Do you now cancel the entire system because a person was unreachable? If the answer is no, the audit is useless. It was already proved many times that audits which don't have any penalty or contingency when they fail are meaningless.

Moreover, You can't trust anyone's random other than your own. In this case, the so called auditors are also a small point of failure, and if you allow any1 to audit, people will eventually find someone who's missing.

Audits are like stack cookies, they are terrible security practice. You need to have security boundaries and defend them to have a good security system. Attempting to check if the horses left the stable is not a reliable boundary, it's good only as supplemental security measure. Just like having a blue team and a red team isn't enough, you need to have firewalls, you need to have defensible network architecture. You need endpoint protection, and you need to keep everything updated.

machina_ex_deus··on Liquid democracy: two experiments on delegation in voting
Liquid democracy, direct democracies and all these shenanigans sound good on paper but they are incredibly easy to manipulate by the government.

Only paper ballots, with humans counting them, and humans observing them, can properly be "Proof of human": proof that there's an actual human being behind the vote. The fundamental problem in "Proof of human" is that fake identities are easily fabricated, dead humans can keep on voting if the government "forgets" about them, and finally, backdoors can be inserted into software systems creating a single point of failure, and the incentives of the government funding these systems is to get re-elected. Mail ballots, voting machines, and early voting where there are months of voting and volunteers don't have time to oversee months of voting, it's all problematic.

The fundamental measure in "Proof of human" is how many humans you need to trust to have confidence in the results. Do you need million election workers to go rogue? 100,000? 100? or maybe only 20 election workers in the right position can completely change the result? That's what makes the difference between fraud being a conspiracy and plausible: the number of people who need to be part of the conspiracy.

Getting a cryptographic backdoor in electronic voting systems is not even in conspiracy land, it requires only handful of people to be a part of it, and it can even happen remotely by an adversary country (such as Russia).

machina_ex_deus··on Wolfram Alpha and ChatGPT
I'll take it to the extreme and say I don't care if it even produces anti semitic content, and I'm saying that as a Jew.

Propaganda is spread by the media, by journalists, by people with viewers with genuine trust, not by random trolls in the internet. It's spread by professors in the academia, by teachers. If it is a random anonymous person on the internet you don't trust what he says.

machina_ex_deus··on Why Fortran is a scientific powerhouse
There are two individual claims, that should be inspected individually:

1. Data from the field showing warming up / other real world observations. I'm not disputing this. This has been corroborated by many different methods without any clear single point of failure.

2. Given 1, what is the probability that the reason for the observed effects are CO2.

This is the crucial policy question, and the problem is that the evidence for 2 is actually purely from these models.

It's easy to take the conjunction fallacy here and immediately jump to 1&2 being more probable than 1 alone, but it's wrong thinking.

The problem is only magnified, in my opinion, by the fact that only few parameters have even had the same kind of detailed analysis that CO2 had. And then the code has clear bias towards the narrative, and the forcing of CO2 in the model is extremely detailed in the parts where the narrative says it's important (radiation forcing) while neglecting many other effects, and taking various things that actually depend on CO2 to be constant.

And finally the problem is that the policy decisions are the complete opposite if 2 is wrong: if we're heading towards more chaotic weather and CO2 isn't the culprit, you would want to rely on fossil fuels instead of the weather (a.k.a solar and wind) for energy.

machina_ex_deus··on Why Fortran is a scientific powerhouse
The way I see it is analogically to writing secure and memory safe code before people knew these things matter.

You needed someone with an incentive to go over code, find the bugs, break into computers and for the entire industry to mature from using strcat to having bug bounties and fuzzing and protect zero. It didn't happen over night and there had to be incredible incentives on the attacker / bug finder to exist, to probe and test the parts that aren't tested, and to serve as the devil's advocate.

The analogy is that it is hard to find bugs which happen silently. Computation inaccuracies are a huge class of bugs that also happen silently. There are no incentives to look at old code.

There's just nothing like it for climate models, and the default behavior of code development is that whatever isn't tested or validated by something will always stagnate with bugs.

The code copy just makes everything worse because implementing the same thing in two different ways by different people is actually good at catching bugs.

So even if I wouldn't have trusted a single climate model, I might trust several climate models developed independently.

The way it works now is that they always prefer to rely on code of others, because academia is driven by citations, and creating new models from scratch means you're missing out mutual citations.

It's a systematic problem, the same way security had been a systemic problem: current methodology just doesn't produce code that fits the requirements. Nobody had neither the incentive nor even the idea that these things should work differently.

Admitting that this is a systemic problem is just a politicized subject.

There are plenty of people saying these models are problematic but getting those working on the models to admit that enough such that the entire system can change its methodology, that won't happen because of human reasons.

machina_ex_deus··on Why Fortran is a scientific powerhouse
Here's the real reason: they are all copying code from each other. Tons of tons of code. Literally all climate global circulation models share a lot of code.

If the author had actually seen how crap the climate models look, maybe he'll realize the argument is actually backwards and climate models are bad.

I've tried code reviewing some of these models just to get an idea of how reliable they are. My mind was blown by the extremely poor quality of the code combined with literally no redundancy between different models in some parts. If some code written in 1990 just made a slight mistake, nearly all climate models would have the same bias.

And I did find some distributing surface level inaccuracies, such as constants being taken from very old inaccurate measurements in the 1980s physics books (at least according to the comment), some constants being very low precision compared to the accuracy required (some constants with only 2 decimals of precision), and some things that aren't constant at all and should depend on temperature/pressure/CO2 levels/height.

And these are important in a system that actually spends huge efforts to model factors with much weaker impact.

machina_ex_deus··on Wolfram Alpha and ChatGPT
How about looking at political conversation as less of a fight and more of a dialogue? In which case I wouldn't mind any intelligent input from chatGPT even if it's against my viewpoint, and nobody really needs artificial stupidity as there's already plenty of human stupidity to go around.

Get your out of your tribalistic mindset. And get your tribalistic mindset out of the way of real progress (as opposed to so called "social justice" ""progress"")

machina_ex_deus··on Universe 25, 1968–1973 (2022)
Any modern replication? With all the replication crisis everywhere, and this research being extremely narrativistic, are there any modern experiments affirming these conclusions?

It literally ran once and in the same environment, and only the last findings were taken? How do we know it's not just some specific genetic defect that propagated? Did they reintroduce new genes into the gene pool? Some other failure of the experiment? There wasn't even a control group in this entire thing, it's closer to a bedtime story than science.

I'm extremely cautious about making broad assumptions with so little data.

machina_ex_deus··on Automatic1111's GitHub account suspended for "ToS violations" [restored]
They can ban the offending repo. They are either extremely incompetent or malicious, either way I'm totally avoiding GitHub from now on. Absolutely disgusting behavior.
← PreviousPage 7 of 12Next →