HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

maj0rhn

95 karma · joined June 6, 2013

submissionscomments
maj0rhn··on Fifth Circuit holds that First Amendment protects the right to record the police [pdf]
I don't think this case was at all about the legality of recording the police, as the headline proclaims. The defendant was never charged with illegally recording the police, or with anything at all.

The conclusion, in fact, gives the police officers qualified immunity from the plaintiff's claim of First and Fourth Amendment violations. The "further proceedings" on the Fourth Amendment claim is what was found for the plaintiff, but I didn't read the whole opinion to know what that means.

It's scary that some of the comments in this thread are from people who would read an opinion like this -- or read the HN headline -- and take it to heart in terms of their own actions. That's just dumb. Look at all the precedents that are cited in the opinion -- it's not a simple case, and, indeed, there were dissents from the majority opinion.

Be careful out there.

maj0rhn··on Ask HN: What is the biggest untapped opportunity for startups?
It is untrue that >90% of cardiovascular deaths are attributable to overweight. In fact, if you look at the Framingham model for predicting heart attacks, obesity is not a feature (other than its indirect effects on blood pressure and diabetes).

The main cause of cardiovascular disease is hypertension, which is 100% treatable at very low cost and with very high safety. I haven't checked the numbers lately, but it's not too far off to note that only 50% of hypertension is diagnosed and only 50% of patients take their medications.

So, the lapse is not in medical science -- we know what to do -- but in healthcare delivery.

maj0rhn··on Misophonia: Scientists crack why eating sounds can make people angry
Does the definition of the disorder exclude a mere conditioned response? I would have liked to see a control group that included people who were conditioned to have an aversive reaction to a particular sound.

Seeing as how "misophonia" is a named condition, I suspect that it is somehow different from conditioned responses. Can misophonia be deprogrammed?

maj0rhn··on Influenza A (H1N1) – How many bits does it take to kill a human? (2009)
Or I can wait for the end of your lifespan. You're going to die no matter what. Zero bits.
maj0rhn··on Influenza A (H1N1) – How many bits does it take to kill a human? (2009)
Deriving a "lethal bit count" from virus genomes is not quite fair, since the virus requires considerable metabolic support from the host genome.

I think I can kill you with 21 bits: hydrogen cyanide is a three-atom molecule. Assume 128 chemical elements --> 7 bits per atom. And the molecule will assemble itself from the constituent atoms, so no extra information is needed for that.

Hydrogen fluoride might work, too: 14 bits.

And, of course, a slug of plutonium would kill you both chemically (poison) and radioactively: 7 bits. Can't do better than that.

Oh wait, if I shot a stream of electrons at you, that could kill you, too. There are six types of leptons (ignoring anti-matter), so that's three bits.

maj0rhn··on Paralyzed man regains use of arms and hands after experimental stem cell therapy
They are not humans because they are not fertilized eggs. Unfertilized eggs are haploid, not diploid, meaning they are unpaired chromosomes (am ignoring X and Y). It also means they could not produce a living human... too many problems owing to the missing second chromosome in each pair. Is like having 25,000 gene deletions!

Some animals have a phenomenon called parthenogenesis which allows an unfertilized egg to develop into a living organism. This does not naturally happen in humans. (And I doubt it happens unnaturally.)

maj0rhn··on Ask HN: What is your favorite equation?
You're right -- thank you.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%E2%80%93Einstein_relati...

maj0rhn··on Ask HN: What is your favorite equation?
de Broglie: E = h * nu

It comes up so often! Whenever someone asks what's new, the answer, of course, is "E over h." :-)

maj0rhn··on Hospital on Airship May Sweep Patients Above Clouds in Quest of Sunlight (1930)
It appears that the hospital area is pressurized, given that an "open air promenade" is separately called out as such.

Also, the main threats from chronic tuberculosis were lung hemorrhage and inanition (wasting) -- not hypoxemia.

For whatever reason, the term "antibiotic" is customarily not applied to anti-tuberculous medications, even though, technically, it applies. "Antibiotic" usually refers to anti-bacterial drugs that are given for a short period of time (a couple weeks), but the definition is hard to pind down. Anti-tuberculous treatments go on for months.

maj0rhn··on Can Good Doctors Be Bad for Your Health?
I'd offer case-mix as a simple explanation of the findings. In other words, when lots of cardiologists in a hospital leave for a conference, elective procedures are deferred until their return... which means that emergency cases constitute a larger proportion of the reduced number of cases that do come into the hospital during the conference. It is completely reasonable to believe that emergency cases have a higher mortality rate than elective cases. This would raise the mortality rate, but not the mortality count. The same effect would probably be seen over long holidays, when people tend not to schedule elective cases.
maj0rhn··on Ask HN: How to Find the Best Info on Cancer Treatments?
It looks to me like France has two main GBM groups: (1) Hospital Pitie-Salpetriere in Paris, and (2) La Timone Hospital in Marseilles.

This page from Expertscape will help you find the individuals in those institutions who know the most about GBM.

http://expertscape.com/ex/glioblastoma/c/fr

The page is not perfect (e.g. the top person is at Harvard, not in France, and the second person ranks high because of a clinical trial), but it's probably the most efficient place to begin your research.

maj0rhn··on Ask HN: How to Find the Best Info on Cancer Treatments?
I'd submit it's really not possible to digest the ton of information you've found with any confidence that you can pick the "right" path for your relative. After all, such large masses of information is why doctors specialize -- even they can't digest such quantities unless they spend large parts of their professional life living the information.

A better bet is to find an expert who has digested all that information, and use him or her as your guide. If you are not confident in the knowledge base carried in the brain of your relative's current doctor, you can find out the people in the world who know the most about GBM by looking here:

http://expertscape.com/ex/glioblastoma

Disclosure: my cousin developed Expertscape.

maj0rhn··on If hospitals were run like startups
If hospitals were run like startups, they would ship a 1.0 product as soon as possible, tolerating the embarrassment it causes and not worrying about the people they killed.

A better model is aviation, i.e. an industry where failure is often catastrophic. Look at the success of jet engine manufacturers in producing product that does not fail. Trans-oceanic flights on just two engines is something that would have been considered folly 30 years ago. It's all well and good for Southwest Airlines to have super-perky flight attendants that innovate by singing songs during post-landing announcements, but the real core of their business is safety, just like the real core of medicine is treatment outcomes.

maj0rhn··on Men in committed, romantic relationships have lower testosterone
The paper's flaw is that it doesn't look at other potential confounders. Here is a simple, but important one: Is there a difference between the amount of sleep that partnered and unpartnered people get? (My experience is lots less sleep when partnered.) It's important because testosterone production depends on pulsatile secretions of other hormones from the pituitary gland that occur during sleep. So, getting less sleep means lower testosterone levels. Take heed, start-up slaves! :-)
maj0rhn··on Association Between Sauna Bathing and All-Cause Mortality Events
The cost of access to saunas is not zero in money, and not zero in time. This in itself creates differences between groups, which is why randomized trials are far superior to case-control or observational studies. This is so well established in medicine that there is no cause to rethink the reasoning.
maj0rhn··on Association Between Sauna Bathing and All-Cause Mortality Events
Another uncontrolled-for possibly contaminating factor. There are a host of diseases that make people heat intolerant. Multiple sclerosis (big in Finland) and heart failure are two of them.

People who are relatively intolerant of heat will tend to avoid saunas, thus biasing the outcome in favor of positive health outcomes for people who are able to tolerate the heat.

So they would have had to do a very careful assessment of these people at the time of enrollment in the study.

maj0rhn··on Association Between Sauna Bathing and All-Cause Mortality Events
$80 per month is a lot of money for most people. It's like buying a new pair of running shoes every month. Quite a luxury. This in itself separates groups of people. Reasoning stands.
maj0rhn··on Association Between Sauna Bathing and All-Cause Mortality Events
As always, correlation does not equal causation.

According to the abstract, the effect was significant only at a "dose" of 4 to 7 sauna visits per week in the 20 years of follow-up.

Now, I don't know much about the availability of saunas in Finland, but one must ask: what kind of person can financially afford, or make time for, 4 to 7 sauna visits per week? Even with the statistical adjustment for traditional cardiovascular risk factors, I seriously doubt that the people who use saunas frequently have the same income levels, attention to health, and all sorts of other habits as the people who never use saunas.

So I would put this study on the heap of interesting correlations that ultimately mean nothing.

BTW, they should look at the development of Alzheimer disease. There is suspicion that high body temperatures (e.g. with fever) can incite the changes in protein conformation that are thought to be essential in the establishment and progression of the disease. So, if sauna users stay a little too long, and get a little bit hyperthermic, they may be setting themselves up for Alzheimer disease. That would be a bummer.

maj0rhn··on Cancer Is More Bad Luck Than Bad Behavior, Study Says
The Bloomberg article mis-interprets the scientific article.

In effect, the scientific article shows how we could predict which tissues are most likely to become cancerous if we had no population statistics on cancer. That is, we could look at the rate of cell divisions in a tissue and say "Oh yeah, divisions occur frequently here, so there are going to be more cancers in this particular type of tissue."

The scientific article does NOT say that the cancer which has arisen in random person X is mostly due to "bad luck" in person X. If person X smokes 4 packs of cigarettes per day, the person's risk of lung cancer is certainly affected. Of course, there is still some element of luck (not every heavy smoker gets lung cancer), but you can think of it like using loaded dice at the time of each DNA replication... loaded dice don't turn up snake eyes every time, but they certainly change the odds, and if you were playing craps there is no way you would want to use loaded dice.

My reaction to the scientific article is... yawn. The result could have been predicted. Cancer is a disease of DNA replication. It makes sense that clinical problems arising from DNA replication would occur most often in places having the most DNA replication events. But it's nice to have experimental verification.

maj0rhn··on HTTPS as a ranking signal
I don't get it. I have a website that is purely content and available to everyone. It has no user accounts, no sign-ups, no nothing but static pages. Why should I use HTTPS for that? To prevent man-in-the-middle attacks?
maj0rhn··on Domain name search with regular expressions and curated sets
Looks very useful, but would it be possible to choose different colors for the available/not available tiles? It's very difficult for those with subnormal color vision to distinguish the red and the green. Thanks.
maj0rhn··on I got tired of packing my own capsules so I made Nootrobox
The reductio ad absurdum does not work here. You are advocating (or at least facilitating) that people put things into the their bodies, in the manner of pharmaceuticals, that would not otherwise go there. The responsibility is on you to prove it's ok. "First do no harm" -- this has been the credo of western medicine since 400 BC.

You want people to ingest these substances without knowing the cost. Unethical.

maj0rhn··on I got tired of packing my own capsules so I made Nootrobox
Moreover, prove there is no harm from these chemicals. Good luck with that!
maj0rhn··on I got tired of packing my own capsules so I made Nootrobox
Prove it.
maj0rhn··on I got tired of packing my own capsules so I made Nootrobox
Consistently sleeping 8 hours a night will do more for your brain than these chemicals. What a waste.
maj0rhn··on How to get business ideas – remove steps
I do not understand this. It seems to be an argument that a measuring cup is more valuable than a nurse. All the words in the world won't convince. Ever been sick?
maj0rhn··on How to get business ideas – remove steps
> physchological studies have more than adequately shown > the large deviation of mental stability in truly gifted > individuals

This is a common misconception. If, for example, one looks at physicians as a group (the occupational class with the highest so-called IQ), they are in general more stable and mentally healthier than the rest of the population.

If one ventures into the realm of savants, then those people are, by definition, not normal, so anything goes. But they are small in number.

maj0rhn··on How to get business ideas – remove steps
I'd disagree. If someone figures out the principles underlying an effective anti-Alzheimer vaccine, or anti-sarcopenia vaccine, that will be a "difference" no matter what definition is applied.
maj0rhn··on How to get business ideas – remove steps
The penicillin story is not what most people think.

Fleming discovered the mold and its anti-bacterial effect in 1928 by happenstance, but this knowledge languished until the outbreak of WW2 in Europe in 1939. At that point, the Oxford group realized the war was going to cause enormous numbers of gas gangrene cases (truly a terrible affliction), and they very deliberately set out to find a treatment. Their research was, therefore, incredibly directed, and, indeed, most of their work centered on culture and chemical preparation.

Fire, wheels, writing, and industrial production of penicillin -- greatest inventions ever.

maj0rhn··on How to get business ideas – remove steps
The reasonable upper bound of benefit when designing a new OS or a new information-sharing medium is, a priori, much higher than the upper bound of a new measuring cup or a new dessert. So, this means someone entering those quests can reasonably state that they are tackling something big, i.e. worthwhile.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →