HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

malvosenior

4,408 karma · joined March 18, 2009

submissionscomments
malvosenior··on College-educated workers are taking over the American factory floor
The cumulative effect of wasting (more or less) 8 hours a day 5 times a week is also dramatic. You can work to improve the social life of a homeschooled child, improving the education of a publicly schooled child is a much bigger challenge if for no other reason than the amount of time they're "stuck" receiving a rote and mediocre (at best) education.
malvosenior··on College-educated workers are taking over the American factory floor
The need to be a "jackass", "party"... in college and high school seems uniquely American (probably a couple other 1st world countries as well). Not only have we extended adolescence nearly indefinitely, we've invented a desperate need for people to embrace self-destructive behavior to better match pre-adult societal expectations. The 20th Century did a real number on people's personal and social philosophy. It's going to take generations to shake off "sex, drugs and rock 'n roll" as the primary motivator.

All of this is to say, that just because school better aligns an individual's behavior with that of their expected peer group, it doesn't mean that's a good thing.

malvosenior··on College-educated workers are taking over the American factory floor
$120K (for a BS) is still a lot of money to owe straight out of university. I think it would be hard to justify getting that in debt for most degrees.
malvosenior··on The Old Boys' Club: Schmoozing and the Gender Gap
> Even so, you can still point to the discrimination being traditional gender roles, where women are the ones who typically stay at home. Or even to the economy itself; we don't value raising kids as much as we value rising through the ranks of management at some cooperation.

Aren't these statements at odd with one another? When you value raising kids at or above office work, then it doesn't look like "discrimination" that women chose to stay at home to raise a family, it looks like a personal choice that's highly valued by many. I think being a CEO or being a grandparent can both be viewed as successful in our society, they shouldn't really be compared directly though.

malvosenior··on The Old Boys' Club: Schmoozing and the Gender Gap
If it's voluntary, it's not discrimination. Men have kids, but they don't quit their jobs to become stay at home dads at nearly the rate women do.
malvosenior··on The Old Boys' Club: Schmoozing and the Gender Gap
> We collaborated with a large commercial bank in Asia that has millions of customers, billions of dollars in assets and in revenues, and thousands of employees.

I don't know that using an Asian bank for the study is going to give you results that translate at all to the western world. Very different business and interpersonal cultures.

The study seems pretty biased from the get go. They claim that lack of female participation at the higher levels of the corporate food chain is due to discrimination without even talking about women dropping out of the workplace at a higher rate to have children (or any other conflicting points of view). Seems like junk "science".

malvosenior··on Emotionally focused couple therapy can help love last
I don't think the post you're replying to is demeaning life choices. The grandparent is advocating for cheating and calling it ethical. The comment you're replying to is correctly stating that it's unethical to have an open relationship when your partner doesn't know it's open. Key quote from the grandparent:

> partner upon discovering they are a practicing non-monogamist

You don't "discover you're a practicing non-monogamist", that's just a euphemism for finding out you're being cheated on. You either agree to non-monogamy or you don't but the only ethical time to give someone that choice is before you've started practicing it behind their back.

> I find demeaning others life choices publicly online to be anti-ethical, but what do I know. Please be nice.

It's actually the grandparent that keeps demeaning people's life choices by calling monogamy "boring", "vanilla" and "on the wrong side of history".

malvosenior··on Emotionally focused couple therapy can help love last
I don't think most poly people advocate for cheating (which is what you're doing here). You also make it sound like people are being "tricked" by society into not liking it when they find their partner is cheating on them, when that's the most natural and human response you can expect when you find out you've been deceived at the highest levels.

The only way having multiple partners is ethical is if they are all aware of each other and it was agreed upon before hand that the relationship is open. What you're advocating for is extremely unethical.

malvosenior··on Jack Dorsey Needs to Step Down
> And figuring out what is a "conspiracy" or "junk science" should ultimately be left to the reader, with algorithms otherwise ranking content as neutrally/objectively as possible.

I think the vast majority of the users would prefer this as well. Just give me a chronological timeline and gtfo.

There's a small extremely vocal minority of users that want to censor any and all thoughts they don't approve of. This group has tons of journalists in it and for one reason or another, Twitter has paid outsized attention to it and let it shape the product and company policy, to nearly everyone's loss, including Twitter.

In fact one of the very best things about Twitter is it gives regular people a way to refute journalists, bad journalism and media agenda. It gave the audience a voice and they use it. "Protect journalists" seems like code for "protect the narrative".

malvosenior··on Jack Dorsey Needs to Step Down
I think it makes total sense to question if a CEO can be part-time and be effective (I agree with the author of this post, they can't). That being said, this post is all over the place.

> Greatness is in the agency of others, and many talented executives have left the firm.

Uh huh. Twitter has always succeeded in spite of itself. There's never been any innovation and execution has been middling at best. I don't think there were ever "great" executives on board, and if there was, they didn't accomplish anything.

The rest of the post is just a stereotypical political rant about Russian bots and Trump. If there's a problem with the culture of Twitter's user base, much of the blame must lie on those with blue checkmarks. It's a toxic community.

malvosenior··on An open letter to GitHub from the maintainers of open source projects
I'm having a hard time understanding your reply. I don't think anyone is talking about Github being abusive to employees.
malvosenior··on An open letter to GitHub from the maintainers of open source projects
As stated I choose the liberty of everyone to use free software regardless of intent.

> By not choosing one, you're choosing the existing system

It's become quite popular to say that being ok with the status quo is a political position. And while I couldn't disagree more, I've always believed in free software and I'll proudly stand by that status quo as my political position if that's how others want to view it.

malvosenior··on An open letter to GitHub from the maintainers of open source projects
Go for it! I didn't say it was an inappropriate channel (that was a GP post). I do think it's misguided and against the spirit of open source software though.
malvosenior··on An open letter to GitHub from the maintainers of open source projects
If the CEO of GitHub gets fired it should be because he mismanaged communicating that GitHub shouldn't be the moral arbiter its customers. I think GitHub leadership's morals align with Microsoft's here. I also share this moral framework, I don't want private companies creating an extra-judicial layer of subjective morals. You shouldn't pick and choose who your customers are for many reasons.
malvosenior··on An open letter to GitHub from the maintainers of open source projects
> At the core of the open source ethos is the idea of liberty. Open source is about inverting power structures and creating access and opportunities for everyone.

I think the core idea of open source is that code should be shared for free. Not shared for free (with people I politically agree with). By policing who can use software, the author's of this letter are very much going against the spirit of open source.

It should not be the position of the tool maker to dictate who can use the tool they create. Once you put it out in the world, people you don't agree with will use your software (if you're lucky enough to have users that is).

I see no difference in slamming Github for having a customer certain activists don't like vs the MPAA cracking down on DeCSS.

malvosenior··on Why Climate Alarmism Hurts Us All
Pro nuclear is a good thing though no? It seems like the solution to climate change and energy production. I know I'm very skeptical of people who claim to be pro-environment then rally against nuclear power.
malvosenior··on Why Climate Alarmism Hurts Us All
It's interesting to compare and contrast climate change and nuclear war. When I grew up it was common knowledge that the world could end at any point in time via nuclear holocaust. It was more or less the most direct existential threat to humanity the world had ever seen. It did spawn some nihilistic artistic movements and general detachment, but I'd say that the anxiety people felt was much lower than what you hear from the younger generations re: climate change.

Even on this site, you'll see many people say that they don't want to have kids because of climate change. I don't recall people in the 80s saying they wouldn't reproduce due to the future threat of nuclear war.

I'm not sure what the exact cause is but I suspect it has something to do with the how the different generations process authority and media messaging. Earlier generations being much more skeptical of what they are told.

malvosenior··on Fake News Is Still Fooling Facebook’s Fact-Checking Systems
I don't think you should do it yourself. The community will do it and the original source material will be there to reference.
malvosenior··on Fake News Is Still Fooling Facebook’s Fact-Checking Systems
I'm not sure it is 100X better. The tabloids have always published clear fictions. I think the danger is that people take ABC and the New York Times way more seriously than houston-star-ledger-journal.com.

They're both problems but I think the mainstream media version is much more dangerous and powerful.

malvosenior··on Fake News Is Still Fooling Facebook’s Fact-Checking Systems
Well when the press works in coordination to hide a pedophile ring involving two presidents, a prince, Bill Gates and tons of media and business leaders, then yes I don't think "almost entirely corrupt" is an inaccurate statement.

> Can you point to something that actually functions better?

I think Wikileaks is a good model. Get raw information out there. We don't need filters and narrative in the way of figuring out what's going on. Social media helps too, especially when the long form of highly edited videos becomes available. The whole thing with the Covington teens is a great example.

malvosenior··on Fake News Is Still Fooling Facebook’s Fact-Checking Systems
The MSM in the US is almost entirely corrupt. It's proven time and time again that it will push agendas, hide facts, kill stories, make things up...

If you doubt what I say I suggest you spend some time looking into MSM coverage of Epstein and Weinstein. Just recently it was leaked that ABC news killed an Epstein story for political reasons then tracked the whistleblower down at their new job at CBS and got CBS to fire them.

I suggest reading Ronan Farrow's Catch and Kill to get an accurate take on the current state of journalism:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catch_and_Kill

malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
Maybe so, but the Google statement does say that the employees in question did all of this in a systematic way that was outside the scope of their job responsibilities. I'd actually like to know a lot more about step 1, I suspect it holds the key to figuring out what's going on.
malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
I am a native English speaker, I just find the original statement to be more natural and less forced.

Out of curiosity if you think that the statement is true, but constructed in a way that hides information, what do you think actually happened? If I understand your position it looks something like this:

1. The four people mentioned setup watches on people's calendars, went looking for information on people... the targets of their searches weren't part of their every day work life.

2. They shared that information with someone (no one knows who) but not the press or externally.

3. The people who had the information shared with them then leaked it externally.

4. Google found out and fired the original four people from step 1 and wrote a memo deliberately masking step 2.

It's possible the above is accurate (please let me know if I got your position incorrect), but I don't think the wording of Google's announcement alone is enough to prove that. I'm apt to take it at its face value, especially because step 1 is by far the worst part in my mind and that doesn't seem to be in doubt.

That's why I'm curious if you have some inside knowledge or something (your bio says you work at Google).

malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
> Otherwise, who cares if somebody wants an alert that I have a meeting?

I would care if the person doing this then leaked my meeting information and tried to use my meetings for political gain.

malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
It doesn't matter if it's family appointments or work appointments. Keeping tabs on someone like that is a violation of personal privacy.
malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
Setting up alerts around a co-worker's calendar that you're not actually meeting with is definitely stalking. Would you want someone doing that to you?
malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
I'm not asking you to prove a negative though, I'm asking if you have any proof that what Google says is untrue since you say that it is. Using a passive voice doesn't mean that it's untrue, I actually find the Google wording to be more natural than your version.

Is there anything beyond the semantics of the Google statement that makes you feel that it's false?

malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
I think it's extremely difficult to read Google's statement and come to this conclusion. Again, do you have any evidence to suggest that what your saying is true? Do you know that the people who did the information gathering didn't do the leaking? If there's a source that states that, I'd love to read it.
malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
Yes it is, from the Google statement:

> We want to be clear that none of these individuals were fired for simply looking at documents or calendars during the ordinary course of their work.

> To the contrary, our thorough investigation found the individuals were involved in systematic searches for other employees’ materials and work [...] This information, along with details of internal emails and inaccurate descriptions about Googlers’ work, was subsequently shared externally.

malvosenior··on Four fired workers file charges against Google
I think it's all about intent (that's how I'd judge it as a manager anyway). Were people accessing their co-worker's calendars to help schedule a meeting or were they doing it to harass and coerce them? The former is obviously fine and the later is obviously a serious issue that someone should be fired for.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →