HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martin

220 karma · joined March 11, 2007

submissionscomments
martin··on Oracle kills Virtual Iron. Is MySQL next?
Agreed that it's not the same sort of situation. MySQL is obviously well known and has significant market share, and although Oracle is a competitor to some extent, Postgres is probably much more similar in terms of who the typical customer is.

And anyway, how many people here have heard of Virtual Iron, much less used it? There's good reason for that -- it's really, really bad, or at least it was 6 months ago. We had it for a while because our MIS group was too cheap to buy VMware. Its Java-based frontend was clunky and unstable. VMs would frequently hang when powered down or rebooted through the console, stuck in a "shutting down" state that could be resolved only by rebooting the physical box. On a number of occasions, the server inexplicably got in a state where none of the VMs would power on until the box was rebooted. Snapshotting was based on LVM, totally different (in a bad way) from how every other virtualization product I've ever seen works. The "console" feature was based on VNC, and as you might guess, extremely slow.

After some time, we finally shelled out for VMware ESX/VirtualCenter, which isn't perfect, but still a much better product. I don't know why Oracle bought VI to begin with, but I'm not exactly sad to see it go.

martin··on The New Résumé: Dumb and Dumber
Here in New York we're having a miserable time hiring new grads for IT, worse than last year. We recently signed on with a headhunter, just for the sake of trying something else.
martin··on Recovery.Gov -- tracking “how and where we spend taxpayer dollars”.
Right. It has nothing to do with a company not bothering to go to some discount code site -- the point is that a large enterprise has different needs from some guy buying a computer to put in his den.

There's a reason Dell has different product lines for consumers and businesses, and that businesses buy the latter despite the higher price. To sell consumer PCs so cheaply, Dell has to use the cheapest hardware available at the time of manufacture. (Also, they have to agree to install various crapware from EarthLink and AOL and Real Networks, but that's another story.) This means that the hardware used in the consumer products changes frequently, and that it's not necessarily the highest quality or of the best-known brand. The business lines, like OptiPlex, have longer lifecycles and use more reputable, name-brand components.

For a consumer, price is the most important factor, so the home product is fine. But in an enterprise, those savings would be quickly wiped out by administrative overhead and perhaps worse reliability. A decent IT department tests new software on every hardware/OS configuration on which it will be used prior to deployment, and they'll have a standardized desktop build process based on a cloning product (e.g. Ghost), Remote Installation Service, or something similar. Good luck doing those things if you have 287 different hardware configurations in your environment, or if your computers have some off-brand NIC that doesn't support PXE booting, etc.

martin··on Noteflight: start-up that lets you compose music within your browser
Totally agree on the ease of use thing. I used to do some MIDI composition with an old version of Cakewalk Home Studio years ago. It was light on notational features (that's not really what it was intended for) but I've never come upon another app that I found to be as straightforward to sit down with and just bang out some musical ideas. This web app could easily become a perfect solution for that sort of informal usage. But the UI needs to be stupid easy, and currently it's not. It seems like you should be able to import a MIDI to get started, too.

I think score sharing done right (i.e. better than this) would be pretty awesome, too. Open it up to non-members and add search, tagging, ratings, commenting, etc., and you'd have the YouTube of musical compositions and arrangements. There's a BIG community of musicians out there for whom that could prove very valuable.

martin··on Ask HN: What can't you do in Excel?
#1 is possible using COM automation. You can write an app that interfaces with Excel via COM, or integrate your own functionality into Excel by developing a COM add-in.

#5 can be done in Excel by implementing an RTD server (http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/excel/HP030662371033.aspx). An interesting example is here: http://fransking.blogspot.com/2007/03/yfquotertd-real-time-d...

martin··on I just launched a $2,500 scholarship for entrepreneurial ideas...please apply!
Ramit's blog is well respected in the personal finance community -- I've been reading it for a long time. I'm not totally sure I understand his aim with this project, but I'm inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt that it's not as nefarious as you suggest.
martin··on Apple tells Mac users: Get anti-virus
I'd question just how much of a problem this is, even on Windows XP. I've worked with lots of firms where end users don't have admin rights and still use dozens of apps without any issue. It's really inexcusable for a Windows app to require admin rights in 2008 (unless it's actually doing system-level stuff), but even if you've got one that does, there are still options for a reasonably savvy user to work around it.
martin··on Xobni launches 4 partnerships that will change Outlook forever
OK, only people in IT departments want integrated solutions. Except they're the ones buying the software. So what's the problem?

Integration is not a bad thing. If you don't like the way Microsoft does it -- whether it be the quality of their implementation, or their disregard for standards compliance, or whatever -- that's cool, and I don't even disagree. But business decisions are made based on the bottom line, not on ideology. If Exchange meets the business requirements, and is cheaper to administer than a hodgepodge of other technologies, pragmatically it just doesn't matter if it doesn't implement IMAP exactly to spec.

I'm not a big fan of MS, but they're just giving the market what it wants here. If you can do better, please do.

martin··on Xobni launches 4 partnerships that will change Outlook forever
Integrated groupware services, including email, calendaring/scheduling, global address list, distribution lists, folder/calendar sharing, distribution lists. Built-in webmail, mobile services, out-of-office. Integration support for Blackberry for push messaging, enterprise IM (LCS), anti-spam and anti-virus services, voice messaging, fax messaging... the list goes on.

Obviously, practically none of this is stuff you can't find elsewhere. But if you know of a single other offering as complete as Exchange, I'd love to hear about it. And perhaps the biggest point of all: extensive integration with Active Directory, which is the directory service of choice in a huge percentage of enterprises.

martin··on Xobni launches 4 partnerships that will change Outlook forever
If you'd quit a job because of the mail client on your desktop, that's your right. A colleague of mine recently gave notice because she didn't like the coffee in the cafeteria, and that was her right too.

Like it or not, Outlook and Exchange are still the best-in-class solution for enterprise messaging, which is why they're used. If you can't understand why that is, then I hope you've never worked in an enterprise. Perhaps you'd prefer Lotus Notes?

I'm not a Microsoft fanboy by any means; I have a Mac and use Gmail every day. But being able to put aside one's biases and pick the right tool for the job is the difference between an IT professional and a zealot.

martin··on It is now completely impossible to sell a laptop on eBay
I sold my laptop on eBay about a year and a half ago. The winning bidder had a 100+ feedback rating, so I thought everything was fine, but then I get the email that he wants me to ship it to Nigeria. I contacted eBay via their chat support, and they were actually not that lame -- they agreed that obviously one of these scumbags had pwned a legitimate account, and refunded my money. When I relisted it, it sold without incident.
martin··on Xobni Walks Away From A Microsoft Deal
Well, it's kind of a blurry line that separates the two. The financial industry existed before all of those products did. Building a financial model doesn't require these products -- one could do it by spending hours pouring over government filings, etc. to compile all the information needed -- so they're all "time saving." And since time is money -- faster modeling means more work can be done in the same time, and/or fewer analysts are required to do the same work -- they're all "money making."

I suppose you could distinguish between the "market data/financials products" and "products that save time and thus money in other ways." Mekko, for example, might fall into the latter group -- it's basically just an advanced charting tool. It retails for about $500. DealMaven, which is basically a workflow improvement tool, would probably fall into that category as well, although I'm not sure what it costs.

martin··on Xobni Walks Away From A Microsoft Deal
Well, I work in the financial industry, so that's the type of product I'm familiar with... but Bloomberg, FactSet, SNL, Capital IQ, Datastream, Mekko, DealMaven... all of those offer Excel, Outlook and/or PowerPoint plug-ins that carry price tags well above those of the Office apps they depend upon.
martin··on Xobni Walks Away From A Microsoft Deal
"Since the price of MS Office Home Edition is $150..."

I don't think that really has anything to do with it. There are plenty of Office plugins that cost hundreds or even thousands of dollars. It's all about how much value the product offers and how much that value is worth to the users. I don't disagree that $100 a seat seems a bit pricey for Xobni's existing functionality, but I don't doubt it could someday be worth that or even more to a large organization.

martin··on How to market your website on the cheap, by co-founder of reddit.com
It's common in places like banks where they need to present at least the illusion that they're doing whatever they can to prevent the flow of confidential information out of the company.
martin··on If You Wanna Be A Phone Company, You Can’t Go Dead
I use GrandCentral as the phone equivalent of a throwaway email address -- it's great as a number to give out to people who you don't want to give your actual phone number. But I wouldn't trust it for anything more -- today isn't the first time I've had issues with it.
martin··on Gartner Says Vista Will Collapse. And That’s Why The Yahoo Deal Must Happen
"I think Microsoft's business model is eventually doomed, but not in any time frame short enough to make the Yahoo deal matter in that regard"

I'm not so sure about "doomed" -- "threatened," I might allow, for a sufficiently liberal definition of "eventually."

Vista isn't doomed because the desktop is dead -- it's doomed because it sucks. Web software may represent a legitimate threat to Microsoft someday, but it seems the more immediate concern ought to be that they can barely develop software anymore. It took 6 years to get from Windows 95/NT to Windows XP -- a huge step forward in so many ways. Then 6 years later, Vista brought us what, exactly? Worse performance on the same hardware? A pretty new interface that practically requires a 3D graphics card to open the start menu? DRM? A completely reorganized interface offering negligible improvements over the old one? A privilege escalation implementation that causes as many problems as it solves? An eye-popping $319.95 price tag for the "full" version? Sign me up...

martin··on You weren't meant to have a boss
$55/mo? Here in NY, you'd be lucky to get a Band-Aid for that. The cheapest plan I've seen here is the state-subsidized Healthy NY, which is ~$200/mo for crap coverage.

My girlfriend is going back to school in the fall, and she's facing the decision of what to do about insurance. Seemingly, no reasonable option exists.

martin··on Ask YC: what is your favorite startup related quote?
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16031
martin··on How Fog Creek Saved me half a grand OR Great Customer Service
Right, and then they'd give you your money back, and they'd still not have made any money -- if anything, you'd be a net loss if they spent any time trying to help you.
martin··on How Fog Creek Saved me half a grand OR Great Customer Service
Not that I disagree that this is an example of good customer service. But even if they had sold you a 2-user license for $400, it could've wound up a wash for them if you called support for help setting it up. And given that they clearly considered both of your hosting options suboptimal, they probably saw that as a good possibility.
martin··on Ask YC: Monitor setup recommendations?
At home, I have a 15" MacBook Pro with Dell's 30" panel, and I like that setup a lot. The 30" has enough room for all the apps I'm actively using, while things like iChat and iTunes sit on the laptop display off to the side.

I'm also pretty sure there's no way to drive two external monitors from a MacBook Pro. But my previous setup was a Power Mac with dual 20-inchers, and I like the single-large-display setup better, at least on OS X -- there's just more flexibility in sizing and arranging your apps onscreen.

If you're going to go the 30" route, the Dell's worth considering -- it works well and will probably save you 25%+ over the Apple, especially if you can find a coupon code for it.

martin··on 37signals Releases Backpack Financial Numbers
Isn't Google the Google of the SaaS model?
martin··on New create your own subreddit site -- seeking feedback
That can be easily fudged, can it not?
martin··on Xobni: The super plugin for Outlook
Yeah, it didn't work for me yesterday, but it worked for me earlier this morning.
martin··on Xobni: The super plugin for Outlook
Good to hear -- I've re-added myself to the mailing list, so hopefully I get a new invite soon.
martin··on Xobni: The super plugin for Outlook
I was using Xobni for a few months and really liked it, but wound up having to uninstall it a while back. With it installed, Outlook would hang upon launch about half the time. Once in a while, the whole plug-in (menu and side bar) would just disappear, and I'd have no idea how to get it back, and sometimes the search functionality would stop working. Hopefully it is (or is getting) more stable, because I really miss the functionality, and the plug-in I'm now using instead (X1) is horrendous.
martin··on ScratchBack: Hahaha What The F*ck?
"PHP will probably do OK here, all it needs to do is spit out some JavaScript, but anyone who has coded in it knows the vast potential for fail[sic] it presents."

Now that's a compelling argument.

martin··on Video Interview: The Xobni team give an inside look at the newly launched startup
Is it just me, or does a genuinely useful product directed toward an under-served market with lots of money to spend provide no evidence of a bubble whatsoever? Xobni saves me time and makes my work life easier almost every day. No matter what the market's doing, there's always room in the market for products like that.
martin··on Ask YC: What was your first computer?
Tandy 1000TX. 80286 @ 8MHz, 640K "should be enough for anybody" RAM, 20MB hard drive, both 360K 5.25" and 720K 3.5" floppy drives, MS-DOS 3.2. 1987.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →