HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

martythemaniak

11,234 karma · joined February 26, 2007

submissionscomments
martythemaniak··on Google says the AI-focused Pixel 8 can't run its latest smartphone AI models
It's probably the RAM - 8GB on Pixel 8, 12GB on the Pro. But also, companies do software locks all the time, eg various software features not available on the cheaper ones.
martythemaniak··on Why Google's 'woke' AI problem won't be an easy fix
> But it has backfired precisely because human history and culture are not that simple: there are nuances which we know instinctively and machines do not.

The reason it's hard to fix is not because machines don't know things we know, it's that people don't know things either. I would bet close to 100% of people complaining about 'woke' AI would not be able to produce historically accurate pictures either and not because of drawing ability but because of lack of historical understanding (again, not because of lack of access to facts/google/etc).

Here's an example: If you asked an image model to show you a picture of WW2 solders firing artillery in drag, you'd mock it as being 'woke', absurd, pushing "gender ideology" yadda yadda. But that did actually happen: https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/12cmtam/...

Any AI that does not return pictures of soldiers in drag firing artillery is biased and not historically accurate. Will DALL-E, SD, MJ, etc do that today without specific prompting? How many people here would draw such a picture if asked for pictures of ww2 soldiers? Most complaints about 'woke' AI are people complaining that AI doesn't re-affirm their pre-existing ideas. I'm highly skeptical that the people complaining about black popes have the same complaints about white depictions of jesus.

martythemaniak··on SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears an FAA hurdle
This is good. Flight 1 had 63 corrective actions and it took 5 months to complete the report. This one took 3 months and had 17 corrective actions. They'll get to orbit this year for sure
martythemaniak··on Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer population, DNA suggests
Generally right, but also we don't know what war actually looked like. Here is footage of two traditional tribes at war in Papua New Guinea in 1963: https://youtu.be/JI4uirwxx1Y?si=ej9v6bdYX7y8i7Yv

War could have been anything ranging from killing everyone to two groups tussling like soccer hooligans until someone gets hurt and one group backs off.

martythemaniak··on Mark Zuckerberg says Quest 3 'is the better product, period'
Future iterations of the Vision will be far more like the Quest than the other way around. Apple built a great VR headset but they go to ridiculous lengths to not call it that, so much so that they've engineered a bunch of impressive, but useless and expensive tech to support their marketing. Specifically, future versions will drop the expensive outside screen and drop the heavy and expensive glass and aluminum in favour of simple light plastic.

There's tons of ink being spilled today about "VR" vs "Spacial Computing", about how "lonely" and "alienating" the tech is, etc. But as these headsets become common everybody will forget this. Talking to someone wearing a VR headset will not require an external screen with weird eyes, it will be just like talking to someone wearing sunglasses, ie completely unremarkable.

martythemaniak··on Nine US states are teaming up to accelerate the adoption of heat pumps
What are some examples of these new drilling rigs?
martythemaniak··on Pooled number of deaths by age group in EU
Interesting, didn't realize that the winter of 2023 was about as bad or worse than the winter of 2022. It seems this is the first normal winter since 2019.
martythemaniak··on The rise of batteries in six charts
I think Amprius are further along than you might think, ready to scale commercial production, not research prototype. Super neat factory tour: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_Hd4HfH1ss
martythemaniak··on The rise of batteries in six charts
It'll probably be a while before you see them widely available, much less in small consumer devices. eVTOL and other battery aircraft can't really work without this level of density so I imagine they'll consume all available supply (at premium prices) for a while.
martythemaniak··on College Is All About Curiosity. And That Requires Free Speech.
I'm pretty amused by the vast disparity between the soaring rhetoric of free speech types and the actual things they say / Want to say. Very very rarely do I see anyone say anything novel or challenging - mostly they just want to say something people used to say freely in the past (jews control the world, women should be making babies at home, non-whites are stupid, etc etc). Maybe we can disagree on whether it's repugnant or not, but surely we can agree that it's very very boring? For example, did anyone find James Damore's writings to be novel and challenging, or were they just glad that someone was telling women to GTFO like people used to in the 70s?

I think a lot of the anger over free speech is not that people can't freely spout their silly old views, but that people won't respect their silly old views.

martythemaniak··on Apple dials back car's self-driving features and delays launch to 2028
"Your anecdote is irrelevant, look at my vast dataset of unrepresentative samples"
martythemaniak··on Boeing whistleblower: MAX 9 production line has "enormous volume of defects"
The best thing they could possibly do is just keep their heads down and crank out planes and they'll crush Boeing in all categories smaller than the 787. The 220, the 321 neo, etc are great, just keep on making them.
martythemaniak··on Have the Boomers Pinched Their Children's Futures? [video]
Depends on local market, but housing material doesn't contribute much to house prices. Land, permits, development charges, fees, make up an enormous percentage. You don't have much on labor.

In other words, no one will buy a shack for $500k when a proper house would cost $600k

martythemaniak··on Why is everything so ugly?
Cybertruck fan here, I wouldn't describe it as either ugly or beautiful. It is bold and different, and utterly unlike anything else out there, much the same way modern architecture was 70 years ago and modern art 100+ years ago. I find this very appealing.
martythemaniak··on ALOHA robot learns from humans to cook, clean, do laundry
Do middle-aged (ie <45 years old) people realize that these robots will be their primary caregivers when they are old? People are having fewer children and populations are shrinking in most places. For increasingly large numbers of people, there really won't be anyone around to take care of you or help you out when you're old (ie, >70). You're either gonna have a humanoid to help you live independently, or you're gonna have a bad time.
martythemaniak··on A vision for the alleviation of water scarcity in the US Southwest
It is probably cheaper to do Solar PV due to unit economics rather than overall system efficiency. There's been a lot written on learning curves and wright's law, but rate of improvement is driven by design complexity and need for customization. Concentrating solar is both more complicated and needs more site customization, whereas solar pv modules are simpler and fly out of factories by the millions.

This is a wonderful table: https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_...

From this post: https://www.volts.wtf/p/which-technologies-get-cheaper-over

martythemaniak··on Does DNA have the equivalent of IF-statements, WHILE loops, or function calls?
I got into synthetic bio for a little while and ended up reading this intro textbook: https://www.amazon.ca/Introduction-Systems-Biology-Principle...

If you've taken "Systems Engineering" or "Control Systems" type classes where you learn about oscillators and other high-level control systems work across a variety of engineering disciplines, this is a great into to how these systems are "implemented" and work inside of cells. It's not "IF" and "WHILE" loops, but more like "How are logical circuits such as e.coli path finding algorithms implemented in RNA"

martythemaniak··on Figure 01 has learned to make coffee
I get that, but this thing in particular does not have a neck. It has a metal stand that's shaped to look like a neck, but it is a static, fixed piece of metal, it doesn't rotate, tilt, nod or anything of the sort. It's a stylistic element that's not relevant to its functionality.

Atlas is a wildly overbuilt thing that's simply not relevant to majority of human tasks. Doing parkour is very impressive, but nobody needs to do backflips to clean the kitchen. The average human has far far fewer capabilities than an idealized 99.99th percentile human. The real world is accommodating of people with various disabilities and limitations, you do not need to be an olympic athlete to live a productive life.

martythemaniak··on Figure 01 has learned to make coffee
I've been very squeezed for time the last couple of years and have tried to buy my way out of this situation, which is one of the reasons I'm so bullish on humanoid house robots.

I hired landscapers one year for over $3K, they did well but they came once a month. It was way too expensive for what they did. I tried hiring a guy on an ad-hoc basis, he did a bunch of half-assed work for $30/hr, then disappeared leaving a bunch of garbage in my yard. Cleaners are available for an $25+/hr on freelance sites. I have someone coming in right now for $30/hr, and they're ok, but they only do 4-5hr chunks and so the house has to get noticeably dirty for them to be worth it. No one will come for 1hr/day and do laundry, they have transit overheard, scheduling, etc. Snow clearing is $300+ per season, but they don't show up for anything less than 3", which happens only ~5 times per season, and they'll only do it within 24hrs (ie, you're not going to get your snow cleared when you need it, because everyone needs their snow cleared after a huge snowfall, you might actually be stuck in your house). I spent a bunch of time finding a student do clear snow and he came once and then ghosted me.

I could keep ranting, but the point is simple: the reality is people are hard to find, more expensive and less reliable than your post implies. There is a lot of overhead and the end result is that a bunch of work that should get done, simply does not get done.

A $30,000 10 year mortgage at 6% is $11/day, $4000/year. Charging costs are negligible, like a couple of cents per day. My EV moves 2000kg 100km for $1.50, moving clothes and brushes around the house is nowhere near that. Any competitive company will also provide regular OTA updates that makes your robot more capable over time.

The bar for these humanoids to succeed is very low.

martythemaniak··on Figure 01 has learned to make coffee
To me, there's only one metric that matters for humanoid robots: Can it earn its keep?

A $30K robot with 10 years useful lifetime, and a 10 year 5% mortgage is $10.40 per day. Minimum wages range from $7 to $15, so the US national average would be around that. If your robot can do 1 hour of minimum wage labour per day, people will buy it.

This is a pretty low bar. Light cleaning (dusting, wiping down surfaces, vacuum), loading the dishwasher, doing laundry, tidying up after kids, etc. These tasks don't demand AGI, agility, adeptness, speed, accuracy, etc.

martythemaniak··on Figure 01 has learned to make coffee
My opinion is towards the end of this decade. Hardware is mostly there - the collection of actuators, metal bits, batteries, cameras and inference chips means you can probably build this today at scale for the price of mid-range car, but of course it wouldn't do anything useful. But given the rate of progress in AI over the last few years and the increasing rate of investment in the field, I'd be shocked if another 6 years of progress would amount to nothing.
martythemaniak··on Figure 01 has learned to make coffee
> I probably answered my own question by calling it “hype-based”.

No, I think you answered your question here:

> I get that our built environment is designed for humans

I don't want a purpose built robot that does one task extremely well, I want a general purpose robot that does a huge variety of tasks well-enough. Make me a coffee, then do laundry, then rake some leaves. Coffee served in the wrong mug? Clothes laid flat and not folded because it can't actually fold? Random leaves still on the ground? It's fine, it's good enough! It still saved me a bunch of time.

Remember, these are aimed at car-level prices. $30k for a machine that lasts 10 years means you're paying $10/day, you do not have to be very good to earn your keep at that price.

martythemaniak··on Give Us Something to Look At: Why ornament matters in architecture
People are looking for objectivity in vain. Beyond basic structure, there is no objectivity in art, music, architecture, fashion, etc. That is, you can make the argument that a discordant piano piece is objectively worse than one that follows well-worn progressions, and that would be pretty believable, but saying that a piece with more tremolos than one with no tremolos is objectively better just doesn't work.

Ornamentation is taste, and taste is very cyclical. If you grew up in an over-the-top ornamented place, it's very understandable that you'd view the simple clean lines of modernist architecture as a revelation. OTOH, if you grew up in bland generic International Style places, it's perfectly understandable why you'd yearn for something beyond basic shapes. You can't separate taste from the environment you grew up in, your predisposition for novelty-seeking etc.

FWIW, I think we're near the end of the modernist cycle. A lot of us grew up in very bland environments and now we want something more. But 100 years ago, the same thing we're now decrying was a breath of fresh, calming air in a suffocating environment.

martythemaniak··on Hyperloop One to shut down
High Speed rail attempts have failed everywhere in North America, it has nothing to do with Musk or Hyperloop and everything to do with how incredibly poorly HSR fits into the existing urban fabric of North America. There have been many studies of building a HSR line between Windsor and Quebec City and you just can't make it work.
martythemaniak··on Volkswagen, Porsche, and Audi say they will use Tesla's EV charging plug
I don't understand your comment. Tesla sells a charger for $230 that comes with 120V/15A and 240V/50A connectors (https://shop.tesla.com/product/mobile-connector). You can also buy a connectors for every type of socket there is (https://shop.tesla.com/product/gen-2-nema-adapters).

I had a 240V outlet installed in my garage and plug that in there to charge. I also bring it with me if I go to cottages, etc. I've used that with questionable sockets and extension cables and the charging speed automatically switches to lower amps if it can't draw the full 12A. You install a dedicated charger if you want 80A or to mount it outside (it's weatherproof)

What am I missing?

martythemaniak··on September 11th That You Have Never Seen
It'll never cease to amaze me that people look at photographs like this and think "Uhhmm ackshually, the planes had nothing to do with this, it was <insert nth truther variation here>"

Here's an annotated high-res one that made the rounds on reddit a few days ago: https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fh...

martythemaniak··on Google Gemini Pro API Available Through AI Studio
This is very good:

- 60 queries per minute free - about 1/5th the price of GPT3.5 Turbo - priced per char, not per token - same image pricing as GPT4 150x150

martythemaniak··on NASA says SpaceX’s next Starship flight could test refueling tech
I read a good analysis of Artemis a while back that essentially calculated the cost per hour of time-on-moon and in that sense it was easy to see that the program was a significant upgrade over Apollo and the costs weren't that bad when calculated per hour. Achieving a 10x improvement over the previous generation usually can't be done without doing something new and different that hasn't been done before, and in-orbit refuelling fits right in. Gemini and Apollo had to work out and develop far more tech to do what they needed to do.
martythemaniak··on Warning from OpenAI leaders helped trigger Sam Altman's ouster
Hi died relatively young and before the general tech backlash, which is why people look back at him fondly. Had he lived, he would've been taken down many notches. I mean, rich asshole who verbally abuses and berates his staff, upgrades his Benz every six months so he doesn't need a license plate like the plebs AND parks exclusively in the disabled spot? That was never gonna fly.
martythemaniak··on Tesla shares 48V architecture with other automakers
The savings in terms of weight and efficiency are actually significant. This was covered in Tesla's investor day presentation earlier in the year:

The section on electronic architecture (~10min): https://www.youtube.com/live/Hl1zEzVUV7w?si=-Vz0gKT5YDbtrG9V...

The sub section (~4min) on 48V in particular: https://www.youtube.com/live/Hl1zEzVUV7w?si=shfI2vEz9taTLSm7...

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →