HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

massysett

5,789 karma · joined October 22, 2013

submissionscomments
massysett··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
Take some existing code and bundle it into a zip or tar file. Upload it to Gemini and ask it for critique. It's surprisingly insightful and may give you some ideas for improvement. Use one of the Gemini in-depth models like Thinking or Pro; just looking at the thinking process is interesting. Best of all, they're free for limited use.
massysett··on Sergey Brin's Unretirement
I made the choice at Costco to not build a relationship with anyone. There's a guy standing at the entrance checking memberships. I've seen him for years. I don't know him. I don't use the automated kiosk if I have several items. I see some of the cashiers for years. I'm cordial but I don't chat them up. One woman who has been there for years chats with me a bit; I'm cordial but don't reciprocate a ton.

There's a corporate supermarket owned by a Dutch multinational not far from me. I see some of the same employees there every week. One of them loves people and recognizes me. I could stand around and chat with him if I wanted. But I don't want to.

I made this choice. Someone who wants to build relationships chats with people. Folks like that chat with people at the grocery store, on the airplane, waiting in line, etc. Often it leads to nothing, occasionally it leads to something. But the point is, they practice it. I don't. The built environment is not stopping it. Not being in a "local store that one of your neighbors owns" has nothing to do with it either. Plenty of relationships are built in corporate chains.

massysett··on Sergey Brin's Unretirement
I don’t think the built environment is that determinative. I live in a car-dependent suburb. Walk Score 2.

My neighbor knows the whole street. She knows the garbage men. It’s because she wants to. When I run into her outside, she chats. She walks her dog and chats with dog owners and anyone else she sees.

Easy relationships are available at the grocery store, post office, etc. I’ve been seeing some of the same people working at Costco for years. I don’t know them. It’s not the built environment. I’d need to take effort to build a relationship with them. My neighbor would. I’m simply not so inclined.

massysett··on It's hard to justify Tahoe icons
> doesn't have a button to navigate to the parent folder.

Command + Up Arrow, which is also visible if you click on the "Go" menu. There is also a toolbar button that shows the entire set of enclosing directories; offhand I can't remember whether this is visible by default. There is also "View -> Show Path Bar" which shows all this information at the bottom of the window.

> I have literally no idea how to get to my home directory

Go -> Home, which shows a shortcut key for this, Command-Shift-H.

massysett··on Package managers keep using Git as a database, it never works out
> Externalities lead to users downloading extra gigabytes of data (wasted time) and waiting for software, all of which is waste that the developer isn't responsible for and doesn't care about.

This is perfectly sensible behavior when the developers are working for free, or when the developers are working on a project that earns their employer no revenue. This is the case for several of the projects at issue here: Nix, Homebrew, Cargo. It makes perfect sense to waste the user's time, as the user pays with nothing else, or to waste Github's bandwidth, since it's willing to give bandwidth away for free.

Where users pay for software with money, they may be more picky and not purchase software that indiscriminately wastes their time.

massysett··on Unifi Travel Router
If I'm traveling for work, I'm working all day. At the end of the day I often just want to rest in the hotel room, especially if I take my dinner in a restaurant.

Typically I don't watch the hotel TV though, as I don't want to figure out what channels are on it and I probably wouldn't want to watch them anyway. If I watch anything it will be on my iPad.

massysett··on What is the nicest thing a stranger has ever done for you?
Physically it is very taxing. Snow is heavy, and the movements aren’t typical of daily activity. Even for a modestly sized property it can take awhile.
massysett··on Emacs is my new window manager (2015)
Emacs says it is “self-documenting.”

Years ago it was remarkable for software to have docs built-in as Emacs does.

Then for many years it was standard for software to have help files, and it seemed anachronistic for Emacs to loudly proclaim it is self-documenting.

Now in the Web and LLM age, much software doesn’t even try to have built-in help or even much documentation, and it’s again remarkable that Emacs is self-documenting, especially the part of Emacs that users can program.

massysett··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
Consolidation frees up real estate, allowing new businesses to open. Where I live, old supermarkets are now farmers’ markets, trampoline parks, and health clubs, and an old car dealership is a church.
massysett··on Roblox is a problem but it's a symptom of something worse
I let my kid play Roblox for a couple of weeks and I was absolutely horrified by all the inducements to seek Robux. So I removed it from her iPad, which is locked down.

She gets along just fine without Roblox.

massysett··on A monopoly ISP refuses to fix upstream infrastructure
Why should optical fiber be standard? I want reliable, speedy network connectivity. It’s up to my network provider to determine the best means to do that. I don’t care if it’s tin can and string if it provides the service I need.
massysett··on What happens when even college students can't do math anymore?
Thank you, this answers the question I was going to pose in a comment: why did this supposedly selective university admit students who can’t do basic math? Maybe their grade wouldn’t reflect it, but surely a standardized test like SAT or ACT would have flagged this? Maybe instead of remedial courses, they should stop admitting unqualified students?
massysett··on Magit manuals are available online again
Did you check NearlyFreeSpeech.net? If you are getting little traffic it costs practically nothing for a static site.
massysett··on Why an abundance of choice is not the same as freedom
Sort of. I took the argument in “The Paradox of Choice” to be that too many superficial choices can reduce happines: for instance, choosing between ten different varieties of toothpaste in the supermarket can overwhelm the consumer. I think a practical lesson from that book is that a company can boost sales by reducing the number of trivial choices it offers, making it easier for the customers to pick the “right one.”

This article on the other hand seems to say that people have equated choice with political or economic or philosophical freedom and, furthermore, that this equivalence is a false one. It’s a deeper and more difficult argument to make. I think “The Paradox of Choice” makes a lot of sense but this article leaves me unconvinced. For example I’m not understanding the argument this piece makes about the abortion debate. Abortion rights proponents are not arguing that the right to choose abortion is an empty promise. They’re arguing that women need to have real choices so they can in fact choose abortion if they wish. The arguments this piece makes to suggest choice does not promote freedom seem to me to support the opposite conclusion: that choice is an essential component of liberty and freedom.

massysett··on You Want Technology with Warts
Another possibility is that the designers carefully examined predecessors to learn from their mistakes, and went through a long refinement period before stabilizing the design. This is Common Lisp.
massysett··on Testing the Raspberry Pi 500+'s new mechanical keyboard
More powerful PC from whom? Some no-name outfit? Good luck sorting through the flea market dreck.

Raspberry Pi has built the best brand in this space.

massysett··on macOS Tahoe
> The best part is, though, nothing ever changes.

Wasn’t true when they switched to systemd, or when KDE 4 came out, or when the new Gnome came out, or when the kernel renamed Ethernet interfaces to enps-whatever.

massysett··on Betty Crocker broke recipes by shrinking boxes
Cake flour, any full-line supermarket will have it.
massysett··on American Airlines flying empty Airbus A321neo across the Atlantic 20 times
Can the headline be changed on this so it’s not ridiculous clickbait? “American Airlines trains its pilots by having them fly airplanes” is more informative.
massysett··on Quirks of Common Lisp Types
Since the title includes the word "quirks," the observation I'll make here is entirely appropriate: the post oversimplifies this.

It says: "So as we can see, at both run-time and compile-time, Common Lisp does typechecking to prevent silly errors."

This is not entirely accurate, as the Common Lisp standard does not require such typechecking.

The Common Lisp standard specifies the types of the arguments that a function expects. It generally does not specify what happens if the function receives arguments of unexpected types. It explicitly does not specify this: the standard says that if you give a function unexpected types, the consequences are undefined:

https://www.lispworks.com/documentation/HyperSpec/Body/01_dd...

where "undefined" means that any behavior, from an error message to a harmless failure to a catastrophic failure, can occur:

https://www.lispworks.com/documentation/HyperSpec/Body/01_db...

Let's take + (the addition function) as an example. It "might signal" a type error if some argument is not a number:

https://www.lispworks.com/documentation/HyperSpec/Body/f_pl....

where "might signal" means that the result is unpredictable but if the function does signal an error, it will be of the given type:

https://www.lispworks.com/documentation/HyperSpec/Body/01_db...

I can understand why the standard is written this way. Checking the types of arguments takes time. Sometimes you might not want to check the types for performance reasons.

It seems the author is using SBCL. As a practical matter, SBCL on the default settings will check the types of arguments. SBCL's manual (along with the manual of its predecessor, CMUCL) discusses how to manipulate these settings - the author discusses this, with the DECLARE form. But Common Lisp does not require this checking, so if you need your types checked, consult your implementation's manual. Indeed, SBCL allows you to change the settings for SPEED and SAFETY to specify how much type-checking you want.

All these caveats are also true for structures. The author says structure types are checked - again, as a practical matter, SBCL will check these unless you tell it not to. But that's not what the standard requires. Indeed, the standard explicitly states that "It is implementation-dependent whether the type is checked when initializing a slot or when assigning to it."

https://www.lispworks.com/documentation/HyperSpec/Body/m_def...

[edit] Relevant part of SBCL manual is here:

https://www.sbcl.org/manual/#Declarations-as-Assertions

massysett··on Websites and web developers mostly don't care about client-side problems
The chat bot operator slurps all websites and gives answers to all questions free of charge.

No other website can compete with that.

The whole story with streaming media is not just that pay streaming became more convenient. It’s also that content creators used legal and business mechanisms to make piracy inconvenient. They shut down Napster. They send DMCA notices. They got the DMCA enacted. They got YouTube working for them by serving ads with their content and thus monetizing it.

Chat bots are just like Napster. They’re free-riding off the content others worked to create. Just like with Napster, making websites more convenient will be only part of the answer.

massysett··on Apple has not destroyed Steve Jobs' vision for iPad
Even though you can now make the keyboard a small floating one and use swipe typing?
massysett··on Electricity prices are climbing more than twice as fast as inflation
I think that's the idea with deregulated electricity. Where I live (Maryland USA) I can pick who generates my electricity. I have no choice in who delivers it and that is still regulated.

I found that in practice the non-default options do not wind up being any cheaper so after trying it for a few years I switched back to the default option, where the price is not regulated but is set through a prescribed auction process.

I suppose the deregulation might still put downward pressure on prices in theory.

massysett··on Is air travel getting worse?
Using a rear door (in addition to the front) for entry and exit is unusual but not unheard of.

https://thepointsguy.com/news/why-the-american-airlines-shut...

massysett··on Streaming services are driving viewers back to piracy
What a surprise, it’s easier to steal than to pay content creators. (I know, someone will now chime in and say it isn’t really stealing, etc etc.)

Actually I disagree though. Software and UX for torrenting is a pain. It’s easier to buy a $10 DVD.

massysett··on Streaming services are driving viewers back to piracy
No. Go buy a Moana DVD. USD 9.99.

https://www.amazon.com/Moana-Ron-Clements/dp/B01MAZGH7Z/ref=...

massysett··on I tried every todo app and ended up with a .txt file
Don’t switch text editors, and don’t use a plugin.

For a few years I used Orgmode. I didn’t use Emacs. That is, when I needed to edit text files, I used Vim or macOS TextEdit. I used Orgmode to track my tasks and keep notes. That Emacs was underneath it was purely incidental, and I didn’t use Emacs for anything else. For me, Orgmode was not a plugin. It was the primary software I used, and there was this Emacs thing under it.

Ironically, these days I do actually use Emacs, and I use OmniFocus for tasks, mostly because OmniFocus gets multi-device sync right so it’s worth the price. But don’t hesitate to use Orgmode even if you don’t want Emacs otherwise.

massysett··on Claude Code IDE integration for Emacs
> When you treat it as 'just an editor' you're working against its design rather than with it.

No. This is exactly the sort of talk that turns people off from Emacs. You can use it as "just an editor." Indeed, read the GNU Emacs Manual. It almost entirely describes "just an editor." An excellent editor. The user needs to consult the Emacs Lisp Reference Manual only if extending Emacs is desirable.

Comments like this one suggest that Emacs is designed only to be programmed and that if the user does not program it, the user is "working against its design." This is just as false as saying that a Vim user who writes no VimScript is working against Vim's design. No, the user who doesn't program the editor is...using the editor. As designed.

massysett··on Claude Code IDE integration for Emacs
I think this sort of comment turns people off from Emacs.

Most people don’t want to become experts in the editor. The editor is a means to an end: writing code, writing text, etc. This comment suggests to the new user: if I don’t program Emacs and publish packages in it, I’m not really using it, I’m just dabbling in it. But I don’t want to program the editor, so I shouldn’t use it at all.

I also don’t think the comments you criticize discourage users who would have discovered something transformative. Someone interested in programming their editor isn’t discouraged by someone who complains that Emacs is missing some modern prettiness, or that it’s not popular. There is plenty of Emacs evangelism that will hook those receptive to it.

I would like to balance out your comment by saying: it is just fine to, as you would say, dabble in Emacs. Don’t write advice. Don’t publish packages. Use customize. Don’t write a .emacs. Use the pull-down menus. It is still a delightfully powerful and well-documented editor even if you do none of the “expert” things. The developers have added so many of these features precisely so Emacs is easier to learn and use, and don’t let commenters who call you a dilettante convince you that if you’re not an Emacs Lisp maestro, you shouldn’t bother with Emacs.

massysett··on The anti-abundance critique on housing is wrong
Just like the old days, when people would subscribe to the daily newspaper for the crossword, the comics, the TV listings, the want ads, or the ads and coupons with the Sunday paper.

NYT is really just making the old newspaper model work in the new age, albeit with higher reliance on subscription revenue and less an ad revenue.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →