HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

matai_kolila

500 karma · joined September 14, 2022

matai_kolila AT proton DOT me
submissionscomments
matai_kolila··on Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?
It's not a general "we can't do this" argument, it's got specific criteria, one being company size for certain regs to apply.

But honestly YC probably doesn't even think about any of this, for good or bad. Most companies are super duper behind the ball on privacy regulations, despite the negative consequences.

matai_kolila··on Ask HN: Does GDPR and CCPA Apply to Hacker News?
I'd guess HN isn't big enough for basically any privacy law to apply.

Some parts of GDPR at least call out company size explicitly, other parts allow for "cost of implementation" to be considered, which for HN would probably be "prohibitively high" regardless of triviality, considering the team size.

matai_kolila··on Laying myself off from Amazon
"Performant" is not the same as "well designed". What you feel is a pleasant UX, which is art, or closer to it at least, and would fit your analogy drawn against a chair or a car.

However what we're discussing here is how the code and otherwise hidden implementation is designed and built. OP is not a UX designer, OP is a software engineer, and should not waste time building things that are "beautiful" in that capacity.

UX and systems design are almost entirely unrelated, and should not spend time in one another's domain.

matai_kolila··on Laying myself off from Amazon
Don’t mistake “beautiful” code for “clean” code. Clean code has value in its ease of maintenance, it’s easy to work with. “Beautiful” code falls into the completely arbitrary land of “what is beautiful?”

Wars have been fought over defining beauty, but the important thing to note is that beauty is orthogonal to function. Clean code has clear criteria and value, beautiful code does not.

matai_kolila··on Laying myself off from Amazon
I’m sorry but this is complete nonsense; there is no pleasure derived from viewing “beautiful” code from the perspective of the consumer such as in your other examples.

A program is not like a car, a chair, or a house, and if any of this were brought up in a design meeting for code, you’d rightfully be laughed out of the meeting.

But it’s fine to disagree about these things up to the moment where you attempt to slow progress towards delivery for these values. At that point, the point at which functionality is hindered in any way by your artistry, are you now a problem on a development team.

There are plenty of productive ways to deal with problems, but make no mistake, on any competent software team you will be disabused of this “art” notion, not the other way around.

matai_kolila··on Laying myself off from Amazon
Beauty doesn't put food on the table, is my point, and I'm beyond sick of working with people who put "code beauty" before "code usefulness".

Ugly code that works pays bills. Beautiful code that doesn't work is, in a very literal sense, worthless.

I'm not against writing clean code (there's utility in that), but I feel like some folks lose the plot and quit their jobs when they can't make "beautiful" things anymore, and I think that's more often a sign of burnout than it is a desire to "return" to creating art.

matai_kolila··on Laying myself off from Amazon
Sigh... another loss at the hands of, "Code is Art!"

It's not art. Art requires no function, it exists as a representation. (Professional) code, and software engineering generally, must produce valuable things, and sometimes the process of making those valuable things isn't "fun", but that's never been part of the equation. Aligning "fun" with "valuable" is nearly impossible, and when you try you're dooming yourself to almost certain failure.

This is really burnout, and the mental health effects that cause burnout. I'm sorry the author has gotten to this place, but wrapping it up in "passion" is a disguise.

matai_kolila··on Ask HN: Twitter Competitors?
No, it doesn't matter. Twitter is unimportant to this world.
matai_kolila··on Mom handcuffed, jailed for 8-year-old son walking half a mile
Yes, I am.

Nothing is gained without risk, and this woman likely now regrets accepting that plea deal. Her attorney should have explained to her what the outcome would have been for taking this deal, and clearly had she known she would not have, since she is now attempting to have the verdict expunged from her record.

matai_kolila··on Amazon confirms corporate staff cuts that could hit 10k employees
Can you show me where I said "building microservices is obvious"? Or if you don't believe I said that, can you describe what you think it is I'm suggesting here? Because my intent was to say, "It is obvious that microservices can be designed well and designed poorly." In fact, if you'll observe, I removed the word "microservices" from my final statement, to demonstrate that such a statement is trivially true for any given thing.

Nowhere did I say, "It is obvious how to design a good microservice." but it seems like you're arguing against that statement, not the one I made.

And for what it's worth, I don't give a hoot who you are, who Bryan Cantrill is, or what your supposed competencies are; make your argument, don't rely on your pedigree to speak for you. That should be obvious.

matai_kolila··on Mom handcuffed, jailed for 8-year-old son walking half a mile
I'm baffled as to why her attorney advised she take the plea deal.
matai_kolila··on Mom handcuffed, jailed for 8-year-old son walking half a mile
> Heather Wallace plead guilty to child endangerment and can no longer work with kids.

The real mistake was pleading guilty. She should have gotten better representation...

matai_kolila··on Ask HN: Twitter Competitors?
I bet if you never thought about Twitter again, you'd be just fine.

There is no 9-9-6 culture shift, there is no value shift in software engineers across the country, there is no need to build a Twitter competitor, none of this actually matters.

matai_kolila··on Amazon confirms corporate staff cuts that could hit 10k employees
There absolutely are bad microservice architectures, that's a weird claim to make. Good microservice architectures minimize or entirely eliminate the friction around the coordination and debugging. I'm working on splitting out a monorepo as we speak and I'm determining tradeoffs we'll need to make. If I do this wrong, there will be a lot of pain around navigating between the services, but there are choices I can make now that minimize (or eliminate in some cases) that pain.

I recommend you find a way to spend time with someone who knows how to design a quality microservices architecture. It will completely change your opinion about how microservices interact and the supposed "pain" therein.

matai_kolila··on Amazon confirms corporate staff cuts that could hit 10k employees
So it's "bad micro-service architecture imposes a heavy penalty on team co-ordination", then.

...which is a fairly obvious observation. "Bad <x> imposes a heavy penalty on team co-ordination" is generalizable.

matai_kolila··on Notion AI – waiting list signup
FWIW my small company has zero issues using Notion, what you're describing sounds like a situation specific to your use case, not a generic Notion issue.

But more fundamentally, it sounds like you just don't believe the product works, which is fair, just not a very helpful comment. "How would the AI even know what that feature even is?" by learning about how its documented in the rest of Notion.

Fundamentally though, your comment has serious "Uber? No way that's going to work! Why would I get into a stranger's car?" vibes.

matai_kolila··on Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative
Without specifying that, they’re at best doing a poor job of explaining what their technology does, but more likely they are trying to mainstream it.
matai_kolila··on Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative
That's a very "snapshotted" view of Reddit, one that doesn't hold up to scrutiny once you consider what Reddit is today.
matai_kolila··on Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative
If you're billing yourself as a "Reddit Alternative", you definitely care about mainstream appeal.
matai_kolila··on Lemmy: A Federated Reddit Alternative
Not that I think these folks want mainstream appeal, but if you want mainstream appeal, stop federating stuff! Nobody cares about privacy and control over their own information nearly as much as privacy advocates think they do, and if even one thing is slightly harder as a result, people will simply never adopt your tool or technology.
matai_kolila··on Crypto exchange AAX suspends withdrawals
Of course he can have $100,000 in his wallet, that $80k will be usable to exchange in return for $50k of goods, for sure!
matai_kolila··on Box breathing techniques and benefits
A lot of this is complete hokum, and it’s frustrating because the people who should know better end up being the most caught up in the pseudoscience…

Edit (don't want to give folks a second comment do downvote into oblivion): I need y'all to understand, "Just try it." is not the counterargument you think it is. I'd expect that from Scientologists and homeopathy advocates. I don't need to "just try" NSAIDs to believe they work, and plenty of people feel "good" after visiting a chiropractor despite that being much more obvious and clear hokum.

And no, one or a dozen studies do not validate a damn thing on their own. There is not the level of consensus you think there is when it comes to any of this, the article even points this out at the top.

matai_kolila··on FTX faces potential hack, sees mysterious outflows totaling more than $600M
Not well!
matai_kolila··on What if regular exercise is the best cognitive exercise?
One thing I've learned over the years is to completely ignore anything you read on HN related to health and wellness...
matai_kolila··on Bubbles
I feel like I'd StumbleUpon this...
matai_kolila··on An unconfirmed tweet about Freeport LNG is upending gas markets
What does verification have to do with this?
matai_kolila··on An unconfirmed tweet about Freeport LNG is upending gas markets
Why is anyone still believing this stuff? How is anything on Twitter taken seriously anymore??
matai_kolila··on Musk’s first email to Twitter staff ends remote work
FWIW they teach 1 in MBA schools, if MBAs are doing 2 it's despite their education, not because of it.

Also most top tier MBA programs are an excuse to get wildly drunk basically daily and make a bunch of powerful friends, so it's very possible most people who go don't learn a damn thing.

matai_kolila··on Why Is Tipping Everywhere You Checkout?
Ah come on now, nobody actually does that.
matai_kolila··on Why Is Tipping Everywhere You Checkout?
My worry is that this "asking for tips" trick is allowing employers to reclassify non-tipped positions as tipped positions that they can then substantially underpay, and not a lot of people know the laws that would force the company to match back to minimum wage if tips don't cover it.

From a #teamchaos point of view I'm a little hopeful this new push is a bridge too far, and it gets us to rethink tipping culture.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →