HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mattgreenrocks

9,224 karma · joined January 20, 2011

submissionscomments
mattgreenrocks··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
Ideological purity is a crutch for those that can't hack it. :)

I love it when the .NET threads show up here, people twist themselves in knots when they read about how the runtime is fantastic and ASP.NET is world class, and you can read between the lines of comments and see that it is very hard for people to believe these things while also knowing that "Micro$oft" made them.

Inevitably when public opinion swells and changes on something (such as VSCode), all the dissonance just melts away, and they were _always_ a fan. Funny how that works.

mattgreenrocks··on I don't care how well your "AI" works
> This is the culture that replaced hacker culture.

Somewhere along the lines of "everybody can code," we threw out the values and aesthetics that attracted people in the first place. What began as a rejection of externally imposed values devolved into a mouthpiece of the current powers and principalities.

This is evidenced by the new set of hacker values being almost purely performative when compared against the old set. The tension between money and what you make has been boiled away completely. We lean much more heavily on where someone has worked ("ex-Google") vs their tech chops, which (like management), have given up on trying to actually evaluate. We routinely devalue craftsmanship because it doesn't bow down to almighty Business Impact.

We sold out the culture, which paved the way for it to be hollowed out by LLMs.

There is a way out: we need to create a culture that values craftmanship and dignifies work done by developers. We need to talk seriously and plainly about the spiritual and existential damage done by LLMs. We need to stop being complicit in propagating that noxious cloud of inevitability and nihilism that is choking our culture. We need to call out the bullshit and extended psyops ("all software jobs are going away!") that have gone on for the past 2-3 years, and mock it ruthlessly: despite hundreds of billions of dollars, it hasn't fully delivered on its promises, and investors are starting to be a bit skeptical.

In short, it's time to wake up.

mattgreenrocks··on A time-travelling door bug in Half Life 2
Beautiful, and by that, I mean completely and utterly horrific.
mattgreenrocks··on 210 IQ Is Not Enough
I always love the articles that end up holding mirrors to some of the commenters. :)
mattgreenrocks··on 210 IQ Is Not Enough
What you worship owns you, and everyone worships something.

The modern world makes a lot of money off psychological vulnerabilities. Better to know yours than be unaware and played.

mattgreenrocks··on Aldous Huxley predicts Adderall and champions alternative therapies
So kind of like our social media feeds then?
mattgreenrocks··on Messing with scraper bots
It would be such a terrible thing if some LLM scrapers were using those responses to learn more about PHP, especially because of that recent paper pointing out it doesn't take that many data points to poison LLMs.
mattgreenrocks··on iPhone Pocket
IMO the e series is/could be used as an anchor to ratchet other phones higher in price.
mattgreenrocks··on iPhone Pocket
What “the market wants” is a maximally addictive device. It’s a really low bar even if highly profitable. Bigger screens make it more exciting and addictive.

Just profoundly weird to me that small manufacturers can’t make small phones because they’re small and can’t pay for it, and large manufacturers can’t make it because…(checks notes)…they’re large and don’t want to pay for it even if there’s demand.

mattgreenrocks··on Becoming a compiler engineer
Good synopsis! I enjoyed my time doing some compiler-type work in the past, but there are so few job openings that it can feel quite cramped after awhile, especially without great experience/credentials.

Definitely worth some self-study, however, if only for the healing effect of being exposed to a domain where the culture is largely one of quality instead of...everything except that. :)

mattgreenrocks··on We chose OCaml to write Stategraph
Industry is just starting to come around to it, but I've never been more happy programming than when using a strongly-typed language with sum types. What most people fail to understand is that fighting the type checker is almost always a feature, not a bug. It is training you to write code in a way that it understands, which forces your thinking to be less sloppy, even on non-happy paths.

Sum types enable much higher levels of expressivity of what valid states are while still being statically analyzable. Any new PL lacking them, IMO, is making a huge unforced error. They don't apply for every situation, but they do handle a large amount of day-to-day programming concerns.

Side note: OO is oft-maligned in OCaml, but I really appreciate that they included it anyway. I much prefer languages that give you a set of tools to use in whatever situation you find yourself in.

mattgreenrocks··on Why aren't smart people happier?
There is a HealthygamerGG video where he talks about gifted kids as special needs kids bc of this factor. I found it really enlightening. I definitely had to confront it in my own life.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QUjYy4Ksy1E

mattgreenrocks··on You can't refuse to be scanned by ICE's facial recognition app, DHS document say
> Kristi Noem says no US citizens have been arrested so it's all OK, right?

They've certainly been held in custody, though.

Unfortunately, lots of people are going to arrive at a first-hand understanding of the oft-repeated systems adage: "the purpose of a system is what it does."

mattgreenrocks··on Addiction Markets
Yep. Generational memory is short. Eventually our kids or our kids kids will try whatever smoking’s been rebranded to just to spite the adults. And the cycle begins anew.
mattgreenrocks··on I'm drowning in AI features I never asked for and I hate it
Having an OS that doesn’t feel trashy by default should be an incredibly low bar to clear, but alas.
mattgreenrocks··on Advice for new principal tech ICs (i.e., notes to myself)
There’s a reason burnout rates go up at staff+ levels. Expectations go up w/o a commensurate amount of managerial control.
mattgreenrocks··on The Great SaaS Gaslight
Thanks for the insight. Actually a great approach for a rather commodity product.
mattgreenrocks··on Advice for new principal tech ICs (i.e., notes to myself)
Agree. I wouldn't say it's broken; the somewhat-overlapping Venn Diagram metaphor is apt. But like many other domains of power, there's a persistent belief that those who are recognized (promoted) are indeed the best candidates and that false negatives eventually correct themselves.

Believing otherwise is psychologically dangerous: if the system is somewhat arbitrary, then that opens up the possibility that their promotion was also somewhat arbitrary and not under their control.

mattgreenrocks··on The Great SaaS Gaslight
Fair. I doubt people want rent-seeking companies inserted into their transactions, but they want what's on the other side, so they just accept it.
mattgreenrocks··on The Great SaaS Gaslight
Agreed, it's rather insane to me. Basically seems like distribution trumps pretty much everything, sometimes even whether it's a viable business model.

I was grocery shopping the other day and saw Liquid Death, which is a brand of...water, but with edgy marketing? I'm told to "make things people need," and then regularly see rent-seeking companies held in great esteem, ultra-undifferentiated offerings such as Liquid Death, an API client with a monthly fee, and other things that seem to contradict the maxim of making things that people need.

mattgreenrocks··on Advice for new principal tech ICs (i.e., notes to myself)
Thank you for writing this. I worry it may be lost on a lot of people on this forum: the need to accrue and gain status is a very first-half-of-life concern for many, and leveling systems are designed to leverage this instinct for the org's behalf. For those who grew up 'gifted,' or accomplished, then it can be hard to not see themselves that way, and the title is tightly coupled to identity at a subconscious level. (Note the disproportionately negative reply to the parent's post.)

I went through a period where I cared a bit too much about an org's leveling system. Not surprisingly, I wasn't promoted, even after giving up some technical work. Eventually, I became really unhappy: I had cut myself off of any work that was fulfilling. It really did feel like I was letting some important part of myself wither away in pursuit of a bullshit hierarchy. I eventually left and joined a startup. I'm slowly remembering how much I like to write programs. Needing to work towards survival is a very tangible goal that has the benefit of making politicking and made-up titles less of a focus...for now.

It's honestly a bit scary how you can lose parts of yourself in these systems. Tread carefully if you aren't 100% into them. Also semi-convinced that some tech middle managers project their own anger/grief over leaving the IC work behind onto those rising through the ranks instead of processing it and finding a sustainable equilibrium.

mattgreenrocks··on Advice for new principal tech ICs (i.e., notes to myself)
I'd argue not every engineer is necessarily cut out for staff-level positions and responsibilities.

I've always felt staff+ was a bit of a trojan horse on the IC ladder. I understand the role and its importance to be closer to the work. But some companies really seem to love separating you from the work to be done in pursuit of the almighty iMpAcT.

I have seen extremely talented engineers not get their promo to this role because they were "too into coding." And I have advocated for one of them (w/o their knowledge), arguing the project wouldn't exist in it's current form without their technical contributions, and then witness the org retcon their judgment into a staff-level promotion without any significant change in duties.

Makes it hard to take too seriously, honestly. If the purpose of a system is what it does, then it's meant to be a miserly, inertial source of institutional status. One that can get you a lot more money, of course, so play the game as best you can without losing yourself in the process.

mattgreenrocks··on Advice for new principal tech ICs (i.e., notes to myself)
Ha, this is true. I thought the post was quite useful beyond getting the author’s name out there.

It can get much more navel-gazing than this, such as the posts by 24yos who insist they finally figured out what life is about after working at a startup for 3 years. :)

mattgreenrocks··on Americans can't afford their cars any more and Wall Street is worried
> It's the last bit of personal expression they have in life.

No it isn't, they chose to make their consumer choices into an identity that needs "expressing." It's just a car. I don't begrudge their choice to want the car they want, I dislike the implication that they're somehow forced into buying it.

mattgreenrocks··on How to stop Linux threads cleanly
It’s free on x86 for relaxed ordering, which is sufficient for this use case.
mattgreenrocks··on When a stadium adds AI to everything, it's worse experience for everyone
Nothing against sports fans, but your comment made me wonder if all the grocery stores hopping on the “game day” wave for advertising campaigns are doing so bc their data shows that sports fans are easier to sell to.
mattgreenrocks··on Replacement.ai
Correct. If we don’t do anything, it effectively is about as immutable as a law of nature. But if enough people respond, the system will change in some way.

Note that the stench of inevitability likes to sneak into these discussions of systemic problems. Nothing is set in stone. Anyone telling you otherwise has given up themselves. The comment section attracts all kinds of life outlooks, after all. The utility of belief in some sort of agency (however small) shouldn’t be surrendered to someone else’s nihilistic disengagement.

mattgreenrocks··on Hacker News – The Good Parts
Agree. What I think the parent is observing is more the userbase collectively becoming an avatar for Silicon Valley talking points sometimes. It isn't always overt; it's more of a sense of disproportionately rewarding discussion points that mesh with the current zeitgeist (e.g. pro-AI posts doing better overall).
mattgreenrocks··on "Vibe code hell" has replaced "tutorial hell" in coding education
I see. You are correct. Wrong is merely feedback on something outside of us, not a value judgment of us as people. But education and other systems need us to believe the latter at some low level so they can retain authority.
mattgreenrocks··on In 1776, Thomas Paine made the best case for fighting kings −and being skeptical
It’s not just “kings,” its concentration of power in all spheres of life.

The fact that this point is largely lost on the audience of this site just shows how bad things have gotten.

People who want to amass power for its own sake need self-reinforcing systems that restrain them.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →