40 karma · joined April 12, 2012
So I avoid any features that would make repeated calls to their API to make changes on the user's behalf.
Billions of people around the world will soon be forced into Facebook's newly redesigned layout, and based on the outcry already, many will hate it (typical).
For over a decade, I've been empowering internet users through software, allowing them to take control and use sites as they wish, rather than how the site creators wish.
"Old Layout" is my new extension that reverts Facebook to the old layout, even if you've been forcibly switched to the new one.
It does this by pretending to be an older browser - one which Facebook has determined it can't support in the new layout. So, it serves you the old one instead! It's not perfect, but most users will not experience any problems or differences from the experience they are used to.
At some point, Facebook may remove this fallback option. But until/unless that happens, users can once again use the site in the way that they wish.
I would buy into this model. Not everyone would, no. But I imagine enough would that it could change their focus. Maybe.
They have many people who have invested their lives creating this company. They want their payout. If they have to create a bubble to get it, that's what they are going to do. They'll get their cash, you can bet on that.
And if they have a problem with that, surely they would have sued AdBlock Plus by now. Right?
If they apply this rule to individuals who alter the way the site appears to them, they are opening a can of worms. There is no way they consistently enforce this.
My microwave has been broken for 4 weeks and I haven't had time to even replace it. There are only 24 hours in a day.
This is a very short-sighted view, common to many companies. The BEST way to satisfy the stockholders is to create a fantastic product that users love, long-term. Example: Amazon.
Unless your primary interest is creating a short-term bubble and profiting before it pops, which seems to be the mentality of many investors and companies these days.
I don't like that attitude. I'm not looking to get rich quick. I'm looking to do cool and interesting things. And if I get richer in the long term, all the better.
Which is fine - they have a right to do that. But everyone should be aware of this, because at some point when Facebook decides they don't like your politics, or hobby, or sexual choices, they'll arbitrarily shut you down, too. So, don't give them any more than you can afford to lose. But I see many companies investing a ton of time and money into their Facebook strategy. My point is to beware, because it may not be a good choice.
As the developer of one of the most popular Facebook customizers (Social Fixer / http://SocialFixer.com ), I call your bluff.
Facebook is the wild west. Their code is bloated and overly-complex, their approaches to UI designs are truly insane, and writing any kind of Facebook-customizing app is incredibly difficult. I think Google has been way more supportive of developers than Facebook.
The bottom line is, they offer a site and for many reasons (support, consistent brand image, etc), they want the same UI for all users. So they aren't going to explicitly support extensions that let users change how their sites work, fragmenting their users into lots of different UI's that might conflict and cause problems that are impossible for them to debug. And both Facebook and Google are huge operations, with much bigger goals than you know of. Tweaks to the UI are probably not even on their radar.
If this is your first UI redesign to endure, I say welcome to the club! I've had my stuff break on a regular basis as Facebook randomly tosses out new UI changes (and not even to everyone at the same time!). And they do it ALL THE TIME. That's the game we play. Frustrating, certainly, but also very challenging. It forces you to write better, more robust, more DOM-agnostic code, and pushes you to solve problems in better, more efficient ways.
If you don't like it, opt out and stop doing it. IMO, whining about it is kind of lame.