HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mbostleman

897 karma · joined August 14, 2013

submissionscomments
mbostleman··on Research finds no gender bias in academic science
What is your prediction of the efficiency of helping the poor that giving the poor money achieves? I assume from your comment you think it's a positive number?

We know that there is a set of people that can't manage money in a sustainable way for themselves. Surely, giving this set of people money produces zero to negative help. But I don't know the make up of all of the "poor" or why they're poor in the first place.

mbostleman··on Steven Spielberg: ‘No film should be revised’ based on modern sensitivity
I think what we have going on today is more than simply "weird" or scandalous on the level of nudity, but instead is remembered as the cultural cleansing mechanism that killed tens of millions of people in the 20th century.
mbostleman··on Studies Link Marijuana Legalization to Positive Public Health Outcomes
Except that what's fatal is high relative, not absolute, speed.
mbostleman··on Hundreds of changes made to latest editions of Roald Dahl's books
This makes me happy to know that I still have all the original editions, accumulated in my childhood, on my shelf.
mbostleman··on Health concerns grow in East Palestine, Ohio, after train derailment
I'm finding it extremely hard to separate signal from noise in the social and legacy media spheres right now. I'm waiting for things to settle.
mbostleman··on GitHub to lay off 10% and close all offices
I'm really behind. I thought Github had no offices, no org chart, and full comp transparency. Was that a very early version during a bubble? There's probably a book I could read by now.
mbostleman··on Chinese surveillance balloon spotted over U.S., Pentagon says
And the Tetons in western Wyoming / eastern Idaho.
mbostleman··on Ask HN: How do you balance support and sprint tickets?
Like many others here, rather than answering how to make it work, I would say the premise is not valid - scrum isn't the right tool for devops. Probably something more akin to Kanban should be looked at.
mbostleman··on Make your DOM look like an eye that can focus on anything
It shares the same behavior with a completely different implementation.
mbostleman··on Laws barring noncompete clauses spreading
My personal experience with non-compete is something that was being purchased from me by my employer as part of a severance package. Does this mean that that ability for me and my employer to make those deals is removed?
mbostleman··on As last module docks, China completes its space station
But, all moral posturing notwithstanding, is it not also true that if the OP just gets a browser or a browser version or a browser configuration that supports geolocation that they will be back in business?
mbostleman··on Why Meta is tanking and how Zuckerberg can fix it
I don't understand how Meta could be a compelling game changer like the iPhone because I don't understand what practical value it offers. The iPhone and mobile in general has had an incredible impact on economic efficiency alone, much less the cultural changes it has driven. People can't live without their phones. Whether or not that's a good thing is TBD, but it's hard to imagine a product that is similarly indispensable - Automobiles maybe? Electricity? Indoor plumbing?

Ok, so then compare Meta's big idea. Standing in a room with a screen strapped to your head, blocking out the rest of the world and rendering your body useless? What exactly is that going to provide other than an enhanced gaming or entertainment experience? I fully suspect that I'm missing something because it seems ridiculous. Not the idea of an immersive experience to enhance entertainment, but the idea of taking the largest social media portfolio of companies and pivoting towards this.

For context, I get metaverses. I was a pretty big participant in SL from 2006-2010ish. I wrote tons of lsl and collaborated with builders to sell 10s of thousands of dollars of silly things that made people's experience more fun. So as a fun side thing, I get. But how exactly could that translate in to THE thing? Especially if it means sitting like a zombie on my couch?

mbostleman··on Texas solar and wind resources saved consumers nearly $28B over 12 years
>>renewables in the US have been dominating the construction of new power plants>> That may be the case but I think the question here is whether that success is based on the technology's own free market merits.

The statement I was responding to was this: >>You're >10 years out of date solar and wind have been cost competitive for a long time>>

Here, for instance, just two months ago is the CEO of First Solar saying that "solar is going to be investible again [because of the Inflation Reduction Act]". This doesn't strike me as a technology that is exactly flying on its own. And again, to be clear, there is no judgement intended as to whether or not government market manipulation is justified - that's a different question.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/first-solar-to-invest-1-2-billi...

mbostleman··on Texas solar and wind resources saved consumers nearly $28B over 12 years
I would be surprised if what you’re saying is the case. For one, I would expect solar and wind to take off on their own and people falling over each other to replace fossil fuels with them. Especially if what you say has been the case for 10 years. Otherwise, the argument for why that hasn’t happened would have to be some kind of conspiracy theory I would think (like the oil companies have colluded to rig the market).

One thing I do know is that I worked at First Solar from 2008 to 2016 and a couple of things things happened while I was there that don’t fit what you’re saying. First, when the cost of fossil fuels went up, we made bank because that got us closer to “grid parity”. I don’t remember anyone saying that we were in a commanding lead well over grid parity. Just that we were close enough for people to start buying. A year later when the fossil fuel prices would drop, we were back on the ropes. Second, we had a project in west Texas in the mid teens that everyone talked about as being the first, fully financially sustainable implementation of solar. The reason was because it was located in an area of highly dispersed population and very high temp extremes. So the economies of scale that made conventional plants so valuable were not there.

Anyway, I’m not armed with enough details to make a good argument, but I am suspicious of your claim.

mbostleman··on Texas solar and wind resources saved consumers nearly $28B over 12 years
Because the government regulates, subsidizes, and mandates these forms of energy. It does all these things because renewable energy is more expensive and so they have not been sustainable, financially, on their own in the free market. Therefore the government, and by extension those who lobby the government for this, are compelling people to spend more for energy. Whether or not this is justified is a different question - but regardless of justification, this is why it's political.
mbostleman··on Retired U.S. generals, admirals take top jobs with Saudi crown prince
Crumbling for sure. But incredible turn arounds have happened before. Consider the US posture at the end of the 1970s vs only a decade later.
mbostleman··on Ask HN: How did you stop drinking?
I wish the Athletic stout were more available in my area. It’s amazing.
mbostleman··on Ask HN: How did you stop drinking?
I starting dating someone who was sober. For the first two years, I never drank around her - only if we were traveling apart. Then I just decided to quit altogether so that she wasn’t cast as the party pooper. It’s been three years since then and the first two were really hard. But in the last year, my addictive attraction has transitioned in to revulsion. I now feel pity for people who drink. I never saw this coming. I drank an unhealthy amount but never considered quitting for “recovery” purposes. I just met this girl and it worked. I quit smoking in 2004 and it took me roughly the same 3 year period for that addiction to subside and turn around to revulsion.
mbostleman··on 'Serious errors' in research linking deaths to red meat
Where there is a large industry, there is a large anti-industry. To me, the point is that there is a large potential for bias in either direction so incentives to reproduce, validate, and otherwise test results need to be found and somehow added to the process. I would say that despite the size of this industry, this particular issue is the tip of the iceberg when you consider all the industries that have a significant impact on humans.
mbostleman··on Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers
Good for her!
mbostleman··on What would a “good” WebMD look like?
I'm wondering why my question got downvoted. I've had this happen before when asking questions. Could it be a matter of a couple of readers not assuming benign intent? As in, someone thinks I'm not actually asking a question but making a statement and they don't agree with the statement. Either way it's interesting.

Perhaps the more likely to be read as benign version would be this: We all agree site A is bad because it's misaligned (which I think all agree is due to being driven by ads). Then we propose that site B is good - but there's no indication about WHY site B is good. We know why site A is bad, but why is site B good. And more specifically since we're describing the value in terms of alignment, what alignment is there in site B that drives the goodness?

mbostleman··on What would a “good” WebMD look like?
>>Why is the private sector responsible for providing accurate health information? As this article shows, the incentives for people running medical websites <in the private sector> and the people reading them are not aligned.>>

I don't know that the cause of this particular misalignment is "private sector". But no doubt the current implementations by the private sector exhibit this misalignment.

>>I'd say the UK NHS website <which is public sector> and symptoms/medications pages hit the nail on the head>>

I assume this implies that the NHS website does not exhibit the previously noted misalignment. Why is that? Obviously this site's sole funding is not from advertising. I assume it's from taxes collected by the government. So what is incentivizing those that build this site and maintain its content to make it so good?

mbostleman··on Observations from our Joe Rogan Experience experience
Exactly. It seems like a common pattern - I often wonder how much a rise in popularity is because of those that like it vs. those that are somehow angered by it.
mbostleman··on Google cracks down on VPN based adblockers
Same argument for simplifying the tax code or even completely abolishing the IRS in favor of collection infrastructures already in place (like sales tax) - but what will happen to the multi-billion dollar tax prep industry?
mbostleman··on The end of the manual transmission is near?
I got my CDL in 1990 on a Silver Eagle tour bus. I was already comfortable with manual transmissions, but the double clutching blew my mind. It was a whole other level of understanding what all had to happen to transfer power.
mbostleman··on Workplace surveillance is coming for you
Yea, I suffer from serious oppression and inequity narrative fatigue. I couldn't really get past the first few paragraphs. Sure there is inequity between workers and their management. But first off, it's not always tilted towards management. There are many indexes on which we can measure how one party fares over another. But anyone who is moved to write about inequity only assumes a single index and that management is always oppressive and employees are always helpless and oppressed.

Secondly, the longer I have been a participant of society and markets, I've come to realize that power imbalances are as affected by how much the participants stand up for themselves in the face of power grabs as it is how much other participants grab. But again, when inequity is described, those that grab are universally criticized for grabbing and those that allow it are never offered advice or encouragement on how to either resist or walk away. I believe the latter would be much healthier for society and markets.

mbostleman··on Who’s your favorite public thinker?
Coleman Hughes, Thomas Sowell, Ayn Rand, Milton Friedman, Friedrich Hayek
mbostleman··on Sorry, your wife is Indian, landlord won’t rent to you
This study, by it's own admission in the summary, does not have a cause for the 23% net difference in house values (55% gross, 23% remaining after adjusting for home quality, maintenance, and other market characteristics). Specifically:

"The question is: What explains this? We don’t know with any precision. In our paper, we reviewed literature on racial bias and pointed to its potential as an explanation, writing: “Our findings are generally consistent with the widespread presence of anti-Black bias.” We left it for future work to explore some of the relevant mechanisms that link bias to valuations and quantify their importance."

So the thought is that it MIGHT be bias (a bit presumptuous then to title the study "Biased appraisals..."). And we are waiting on future studies to actually provide the causal link.

But even if every bit of the 23% delta is caused by racial bias, we need to consider the trend. As far as I can tell every important sociological data point on this matter (employment, wealth, marriage, laws, etc.) has been improving decade after decade. I don't know what numbers this same study, or one equivalent to it, would reveal from say 5 or 7 decades ago, but I assume it would have been substantially worse.

All of which is to say that proposing a narrative that racism is rampant and getting worse does not seem to be supported by the data. To the contrary, it would seem that it is less than it's ever been and continues to decline.

EDIT: To be clear, I am not suggesting you or anyone here is proposing a narrative that racism is rampant and getting worse. But I think it's safe to say that proposal is prevalent in pop culture.

mbostleman··on Sorry, your wife is Indian, landlord won’t rent to you
<<And... unless you're in a marginalized minority group, you really aren't in a position to know how racist people are.>>

Does this mean that it is not empirically measurable then? That would explain a lot because actual data is what I find missing from the claims of how prevalent racism is.

mbostleman··on New evidence suggests giant asteroid impacts created Earth’s continents
Orthogonal and bickering, but I find it interesting. I can keep two thoughts going at once. Sort of.
← PreviousPage 3 of 17Next →