HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

meany

619 karma · joined September 3, 2021

submissionscomments
meany··on Judge decides against Internet Archive
The slowness and lethargy of the system is by design. For instance, The constitution is really hard to change to prevent tyranny. Checks and balances against power protect all our rights. There is no garauntee that the people in power will choose your path forward. There is also no garauntee that the majority view is yours. Hitler for example was elected. The system was setup to ensure for hundreds of years at the price of short term inefficiency. Read the history of an imploding republic - France, Rome, Weimar - and you will see similar pushes to speed reform for the masses that ended in tyranny. Reading the federalist papers will give good perspective on the rationale for these things. One may disagree with the conclusions, but the concerns and rationales are reasonable
meany··on Judge decides against Internet Archive
But the judges should only overrule legislators when their laws violated higher level legislative authority or constitutions, right? Do you think a judge should be able to legislate what the law is independent of elected officials? Why would you trust them, especially since they are appointed by politicians or elected themselves?
meany··on Associations between infant screen use, EEG markers, and cognitive outcomes
They could have the causality reversed here. In that children with cognitive impairment are put in front of screens more often. As a parent, I can say that there a few things that can give you a break better than letting the kid play on a screen.
meany··on The Holocaust shouldn't be a catch-all metaphor for hate
What do you think countries did differently in the 1930s-1940s to help Nazi victims that they’re not doing for these other cases of genocide? I doubt the Allied countries would have done anymore to stop it then we do today, if they hadn’t been forced into war by the Axis. Race has much less to do about the lack of action then the enormous cost of action. I think where race does play in is not just the ethnicity of the victims but also the ethnicity and perceived civility of the perpetrators, prior to the war. Germany was a liberal democracy that turned to unimaginable darkness. You don’t see the same reaction to the Soviet Gulags, which killed more people, because the Soviets were already viewed as brutal.
meany··on More students are turning away from college and toward apprenticeships
I can’t speak to what the original poster experienced in college, but your heated response implies a resistance to at least some forms on inquiry as unacceptable or inappropriate or at a minimum worthy of disparagement, which I think undermines your argument a bit.
meany··on Anyone else witnessing a panic inside NLP orgs of big tech companies?
It's evidence of resentment, but not of well reasoned discourse against something the tech industry is doing. Characterizations like this anthropomorphize a group into a single entity that is easier to hate and assign intentions, too. It's not constructive to any conversation that moves a discussion forward. A person who is mad at "tech bros" is likely more upset about systemic forces that they want to blame on a target. It's logically equivalent to making sweeping statements blaming immigrants for suppressed wages.
meany··on Ok, it’s time to freak out about AI
There are counter points to this - DDT, Gatling Gun (Inventor thought it would reduce deaths, because you'd need less soldiers), Thalidomide.
meany··on Court of Versailles vs. the Wild West
I agree with your review. I enjoyed the Wild West vs Versailles take, but then the 100% focus on diversity took it sideways. The politics at these large companies is still driven by getting senior leadership to like you and see that you are moving their agenda forward. But even in that case, it’s not 100% politics, for the most part you need to be able to both deliver and play the game to advance. His whole focus on diversity was not well reasoned or an accurate portrayal of what goes on at these companies.

Source: I have worked in big tech

meany··on First Republic drops 60% despite government’s backstop of SVB
It could be interpreted as loss of faith in the bank and the risk of a bank run, which impacts the ability to get investment to support current depositors needs. That’s essentially what happened at SVB.
meany··on Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Last Act
I think it’s worth reflecting on how you incorporate and use anecdotal stories to broadly characterize 320M inhabitants from one of the most ethnically diverse and multicultural nations on earth.
meany··on The False Promise of ChatGPT
I think the thing that this misses is that majority of work and activities doesn't require much intelligence, but they the foundation of careers, hobbies, and activities that provide people meaning and value. I have a friend that used ChatGPT to write a letter to his wife on their 15th anniversary. My son's using it to write emails to friends (hopefully not school work). It doesn't need to take over the world to replace the vast majority of average people's intellectual contributions.
meany··on Why Poverty Persists in America
How much of this spending is really about creating defense jobs in the various representatives districts? Here is an article that argues defense spending is a form of indirect welfare.

Abstract: this article, we present a new theory that, given the economic consequences of military spending, some governments may use military spending as a means of advancing their domestic non-military objectives. Based on evidence that governments can use military spending as welfare policy in disguise, we argue that the role of ideology in shaping military spending is more complicated than simple left-right politics. We also present a theory that strategic elites take advantage of opportunities presented by international events, leading us to expect govermments that favor more hawkish foreign policy policies to use low-level international conflicts as opportunities for increasing military spending. Using pooled time-series data from 19 advanced democracies in the post-World War I period, we find that government ideology, measured as welfore and

https://www.jstor.org/stable/25766258

meany··on Banning words won’t make the world more just
In general, creating division between classes, races, religious groups presents opportunities for individuals to gather power by taking up the cause for one group. By establishing an “other” you have an enemy to rally support for your leadership. This is the basis of power for every demagogue from the Cleon in Athens to Joe McCarthy and the American Red Scare. This is also a core theme in Orwell’s 1984.

In the context of the OPs topic, there are those who honestly are trying to improve the world, but many people have new found careers and political power created by the division on both the Right and Left.

meany··on Ask HN: Are you anxious about AI existential risk?
My main worry is that a small set of capital owners will vastly benefit in a runaway AI scenario at the cost of human laborers (including service workers). If a few companies control essentially infinite intelligence, they could capture all the income currently paid to workers, while the vast majority of workers are left obsolete.
meany··on Uncle Sam to block Adobe absorption of Figma over monopoly fears
I think the bar for criminal prosecution is much higher than than "everyone suspects." It needs to be beyond a reasonable doubt, which I think is a harder case to make. You'd need documented evidence that that was the goal. Otherwise, I think it would be pretty easy for lawyers to create some level of doubt. I doubt the justice department could win that in a court of law.
meany··on Open letter regarding research on reflecting sunlight to reduce climate change
Is that the purpose of the proposed research to understand the risks and potential benefits?
meany··on Uncle Sam to block Adobe absorption of Figma over monopoly fears
Are you suggesting that Adobe and Figma executives should be criminally charged with an attempt to monopolize the market?

Edit: I looked up the justice department’s stance. From: https://www.justice.gov/atr/antitrust-laws-and-you

The Sherman Antitrust Act

This Act outlaws all contracts, combinations, and conspiracies that unreasonably restrain interstate and foreign trade. This includes agreements among competitors to fix prices, rig bids, and allocate customers, which are punishable as criminal felonies.

The Sherman Act also makes it a crime to monopolize any part of interstate commerce. An unlawful monopoly exists when one firm controls the market for a product or service, and it has obtained that market power, not because its product or service is superior to others, but by suppressing competition with anticompetitive conduct.

The Act, however, is not violated simply when one firm's vigorous competition and lower prices take sales from its less efficient competitors; in that case, competition is working properly.

meany··on B2B startups stop innovating the day you give power to product managers
Interesting, I’ve always thought of this quote justifying deeper user research than just asking users what they want, not less. I’ve seen people who don’t really understand user needs over index on what they say they want versus deeply understanding their workflow and needs.
meany··on The Political Bias of ChatGPT – Extended Analysis
It's not so much a bias of rural over urban, but lower population states versus larger states. You could be urban and just be smaller in size. This part of the "great compromise" was actually for smaller, non-slave states like Delaware. Virgina, the largest state in the nation at the time and a slave state, proposed the Virgina Plan, which proposed the creation of a bicameral national legislature, or a legislature consisting of two houses, in which the “rights of suffrage” in both houses would be proportional to the size of the state. Small states objected, because they'd had equal representation under the articles of confederation.

https://www.senate.gov/about/origins-foundations/senate-and-...

The overall final compromise did include compromises to slave owning states, but this vestigial is not due to those compromises. In fact, they were against it.

meany··on Bay Area homeowner is the face of California’s latest housing drama
Are you sure that its the majority in the districts they have the zoning? If it was the majority, wouldn't the rules change?
meany··on Tech CEOs Should Be Held Accountable, or Even Fired, Amid Layoffs
Shareholders can sell there stock and I'm sure many did - that's how they send a message that they don't like the path leaders are on. Shareholders buy/hold/sell stock knowing the contractual obligations. As a shareholder, albeit a tiny one, I don't see how I'm harmed.

When you say CEO compensation isn't tied to supply and demand, what data do have to support that? We pay football/basketball/baseball players well more than 1M dollars. Do you think the impact between a good and mediocre CEO for a large company is less than 1M? Even tiny drops in performance due to decisions at the CEO level would cost millions at the biggest companies. As companies scale larger, bad decisions will cost more and more. I think a rationale case can be made that many of these CEOs are generating more value than they cost in compensation.

meany··on Ask HN: What's the best lecture series you've seen?
Not sure best ever, but I really enjoyed “The Other Side of History” (available from Great Courses Plus now Wonderium). I found the deep dive into daily life through history helped me better understand the common threads that all humans experience.

Course Description:

Imagine you're a Greek soldier marching into battle in the front row of a phalanx. Or an Egyptian woman putting on makeup before attending an evening party with your husband. Or a Celtic monk scurrying away with the Book of Kells during a Viking invasion. Welcome to the other side of history, the 99% of ordinary people whose names don't make it into the history books—but whose lives are no less fascinating than the great leaders whose names we all know. Here you'll encounter such diverse individuals as:

a Mesopotamian hunter-gatherer making a living in one of the world's earliest permanent settlements;

an Egyptian craftsman decorating the pharaoh's tomb in the Valley of the Kings; a Minoan fleeing the island of Santorini during a volcanic eruption;

a Greek citizen relaxing at a drinking party with the likes of Socrates;

a Roman slave captured in war and sent to work in the mines; and

a medieval pilgrim on the road to Canterbury.

https://www.thegreatcourses.com/courses/the-other-side-of-hi...

meany··on Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for reading ‘Mein Kampf’
Stanford Review link supporting OP

https://stanforddaily.com/2023/01/22/protected-identity-harm...

meany··on Stanford student may need to ‘acknowledge harm’ for reading ‘Mein Kampf’
Stanford review story link. That confirms OP.

https://stanforddaily.com/2023/01/22/protected-identity-harm...

meany··on Remote workers face a lonely wave of layoffs
Why are you saying these are the wrong incentives? If these corporations are failing and making bad decisions that result in more competition, which eventually brings them down, isn’t that “creative destruction” at work. Or are you saying that “creative destruction” itself is a bad mechanism that should be managed? Something else?
meany··on Globalization is dead and no one is listening
At the time, the belief among most policy people was that China’s economic growth would lead to democracy. Obviously, that didn’t happen, but I don’t think it’s accurate to suggest they traded against the worlds interest for profit. In the early 90s after the fall of the communist bloc, it seemed to many that global liberal democracy was inevitable.
meany··on A once respected biology journal indicts evolutionary biology for ableism
Don’t you think making an ageist statement to refute this is a bit hypocritical?
meany··on Retirees Are One Reason the Fed Has Given Up on a Big Worker Rebound
When you say the US isn’t immigrant friendly, I think your focusing on concerns about the impact of very high immigration that has surfaced in recent years among certain groups and media, rather practical resistance to immigration.

“The United States is home to the highest number of immigrants in the world. An estimated 50.6 million people in the United States—a bit more than 15% of the total population of 331.4 million—were born in a foreign country. The number of immigrants in the U.S. has increased by at least 400% since 1965. The population of immigrants in the United States is incredibly diverse, with nearly every country in the world represented among U.S.”

Source: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/immigrati...

meany··on Cognitive ability is a powerful predictor of political tolerance
I agree that direct debate is a waste of time in these situations, and I as understand, research shows only makes the flat-earther more adamant. In situations like this, I focus on trying to understand what the emotional underlying driver is that moves people to support these kinds of views and see if I can engage with that. Humans are not primarily logical. Our views are heavily driven by need for acceptance by our community or to rationalize our uniqueness/importance, both which relate back to our survival
meany··on Why pronouncing names correctly matters
I have a really hard time pronouncing words that are not within the standard set I use in most day to day. In some cases, someone can say the word or name to me and i cannot reproduce it. I also can’t hear differences or reproduce many music tones. If you play a few notes, I can’t hum them back. I suspect the part of my brain used in sound identification and reproduction has a very low “iq” relative to the average.

I find it pretty stressful when I’m meet someone with an uncommon sounding name, as I worry they will take offense and I really don’t know what to do. I practice the names offline in the hopes of learning them.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →