HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mech1234

428 karma · joined January 9, 2020

submissionscomments
mech1234··on Bernie Sanders Aims New Tax Hike at Executive Retirement Plans
We live in a time where small community organizations are on the decline. These organizations exist in the form of clubs, athletic leagues, religious organizations such as churches, and others.

Churches provide an emotional support network to many people, perform acts of charity, and generally do much more good than harm. If you intend to use the Westboro Baptist Church as an example of the harm done by churches please be aware that you risk throwing the baby out with the bathwater. If you castigate churches for being close-minded, please consider reading up on the Unitarians for a decent depiction of how varied the moral philosophies of churches can be.

If you want to make accelerate the trend of declining community involvement, tax churches. I don't think it is wise.

mech1234··on YouTube can restrict PragerU because it is a private forum, appeals court rules
What is the main thesis of the particular video?

It is that the spread of the British Empire spread Western democratic norms.

This particular facet is well-supported by the facts. I agree that it fails to be sufficiently critical of the British. However, it falls well within the Overton Window and any claim that this particular video is incendiary, or that it is sufficiently wrong that it should be discouraged for people to watch it, is absurd.

To the degree that History departments want to tell a moral narrative, they need to be a lot more careful than a youtube channel, I agree. I remember my British History professor in college implied that any Republicans taking courses at a state-supported university are hypocrites, so I'm well-aware of the ideological leanings of the ivory tower. If it came down to it, I'd prefer a left-leaning history department to a right-leaning one, just for the fact that you can (typically) squeeze more nuanced narratives out of the (typically) increased moral relativism of the left. It's a pretty slight preference though, subject to the tradeoff that a bleeding-heart professor still has enough assertiveness to admit to moral failings across all sorts of different cultures.

Regarding objective facts of a video- they remain true on the ground. Regarding the moral narrative- I see no reason to hold the rest of the world's commentariat to the same standard of preference as a history department. I would also remark that PragerU has the merit of making it's moral leanings obvious enough that you don't have to guess at their direction of bias, in contrast to other presenters who may be willfully disguising their revisionism.

Perhaps it's easier to discern the truth when you give competitors on all sides of the moral landscape a fair fight.

mech1234··on Reddit purges 1/2 of The Donald’s moderators – replaces them with approved mods
The larger you grow the set of rules the more precisely you can apply selective enforcement.
mech1234··on The war on food waste is a waste of time
Your solutions can exist. Whether they should or not is an economic tradeoff problem. Production is not free, storage is not free either. Neither one of us have been arguing with hard data yet regarding total $ costs, or evaluation of long-term risks, but the tradeoffs do exist.

The U.S. grows 13 billion bushels of corn per year (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_production_in_the_United_...). Of this, it looks like about 1 billion bushels go to feeding U.S. residents directly. I tried to lookup the volume of corn silos in the U.S. to get a good figure for how many years' worth of consumption we keep lying around, I haven't found anything yet.

And this is all looking at a pretty low-level survival grain- canned foods are a bit more expensive to store, then fresh produce, then frozen foods, then fresh meat, etc. (approximately). These foods are also more expensive to produce.

mech1234··on YouTube can restrict PragerU because it is a private forum, appeals court rules
I agree that the video "Evolution: Bacteria to Beethoven" is misleading and serves a religious agenda.

The video accepts natural selection, and references real research data, which is nice, but it asks too much of science. The implicit claim is "until all biological mechanisms underlying evolution are fully explained, you should remain skeptical of the theory of evolution."

An obvious likely audience interpretation of the video could be, "this calm, smart, and reasonable-sounding man is telling me that it is fine to be skeptical of evolution. I'll keep on believing in creationism."

However, this amount of misdirection is reasonable, is fairly typical among political organizations, and does not reflect an incendiary or particularly damaging viewpoint. If the corpus of PragerU videos can pass this bar, then there is no reason to de-rank them in YouTube.

mech1234··on YouTube can restrict PragerU because it is a private forum, appeals court rules
If you are referring to to the video "If you Live in Freedom, Thank the British Empire", it is factual regarding its objective claims but heavily spun in its subjective claims and in which material it chooses to cover and omit. It would be wrong to call it wrong- no history professor would claim that the historical events it discussed did not happen. Disagreement would only occur regarding how beneficial they were and whether important details were omitted.

In the context of that particular video, the degree to which the value judgements disagree with academic consensus is mostly reflective of the ideological leanings of current history departments in comparison to PragerU. And to address the main thesis of the video- Western democratic freedom is almost certainly more widespread nowadays than it would have been without the presence of the British Empire (also assuming that France or similar colonial competitors didn't swoop in to fill the power vacuum).

The way that the video seems tone-deaf is that it isn't sufficiently critical of Britain's moral failings. However, its central thesis is not incorrect.

mech1234··on YouTube can restrict PragerU because it is a private forum, appeals court rules
Yes, it is sad that Fox doesn't have enough left-leaning commentators.

Media producers have realized that consumers self-select into viewing distribution channels that appeal to their existing beliefs. It creates a feedback loop where media market segmentation by political affiliation drives people further apart.

PragerU is a conservative entity that tried to penetrate a liberal bastion; I like it for that. I also like it when liberal entities try to penetrate conservative bastions.

From my subjective survey of the media landscape, it seems that the left-leaning bastions currently dominate. To the extent that they push reasonable conservatives off of their channels, they encourage conservatives to bifurcate: either join them, or retreat to far-right positions.

mech1234··on The war on food waste is a waste of time
There is some margin in food inventory, but food lead times are long (several months) and stocks (grain silos, grocery store inventory) are small relative to the rate at which they are consumed. Increasing production capacity also takes time in addition to the existing lead time.

These reasons dictate that it's more useful to think of food distribution as a flow than as a stock. In this sense thinking of calories produced divided by calories consumed straightens out thinking in the long term.

mech1234··on The war on food waste is a waste of time
Your statement seems confused.

The food production system as a whole produces more food than humanity as a whole consumes. If you can and freeze your leftovers as an individual it does not change this.

At a system level- farms, silos, and grocery stores have no interest in storing any more stock than reasonable, and continually stuffing a growing stock into a larger warehouse/silo is wasteful.

If wide swathes of citizens changed their behavior to habitually can and freeze more leftovers, and waste less, it would be a good thing, and farms would decrease production, I agree. But it misses the point I made.

mech1234··on The war on food waste is a waste of time
Grits are made of dent corn.
mech1234··on The war on food waste is a waste of time
If we lived in a world where 0% of food was wasted, we would be living in a world with 0% safety margin for a supply shock (aka famine).

For this reason alone, I don't mind food waste too much.

It's also a reason (although I think corn ethanol is more wasteful than useful on the whole) for the government to support corn ethanol. If famine arrives, divert the dent corn from the refineries and have everyone eat more grits.

mech1234··on YouTube can restrict PragerU because it is a private forum, appeals court rules
The world is a better world when reasonable opinions are well-considered on all sides.

Prager U's videos are not hate speech. They are reasonable opinions voiced in a calm manner.

It is sad that YouTube chooses to de-promote Prager's content. But it is not illegal.

mech1234··on YouTube can restrict PragerU because it is a private forum, appeals court rules
I wasn't aware that this claim was central to the suit, thanks for that. Many people here are not focusing on that claim. EDIT: Per other replies, it seems like that claim has a large amount of direct evidence against it.

I think it is interesting that in some long-term sense there is pressure for the government's regulatory reach to move farther up the network layer stack.

~50+ years ago it was clear that telephone lines were a natural monopoly and required regulation. Over time this transferred to ISP's, over time this may transfer to "platform websites", which currently to me seems like a pretty dang vague category.

It would be very strange for an Elizabeth-Warren-esque tech regulatory crackdown to occur without guaranteeing certain freedoms of speech for users.

mech1234··on Heathrow third runway plans ruled illegal: not consistent with Paris agreement
Do you accept that increasing the size of a local factory creates local jobs?

Why would an airport be any different? >50% of the employees are going to be ground crew, security agents, etc.

mech1234··on Heathrow third runway plans ruled illegal: not consistent with Paris agreement
On the margin, compared to the alternative, this will: 1. Make flights to and from, and connecting flights through, Heathrow more expensive. 2. Move more flights to other neighboring airports. 3. Reduce the volume of people flying to/from/through the Heathrow and the UK in general.

I am not sure how much of each effect is needed to absorb the change.

mech1234··on Tokyo Olympics “looking at a cancellation” if coronavirus not contained
Yep, and they come up higher on the search results in bing and google. Not sure if I really recommend them, but their dang domain name sure is a hell of a lot easier to remember. Maybe I would recommend them on that fact alone- in a public health crisis, easy access to critical information is important.
mech1234··on Tokyo Olympics “looking at a cancellation” if coronavirus not contained
Referencing the http://coronavirus-realtime.com/ website, the graph of the number of infections over time is suspiciously non-exponential right now. I think China and the rest of the world are both struggling to collect data on confirmed cases.
mech1234··on AB2712 – California Universal Basic Income
Why is it already the government's money?
mech1234··on AB2712 – California Universal Basic Income
The precautionary principle seems to be thrown to the wind here.

The unintended consequences of such a policy are far-reaching and poorly understood. UBI has seen a lot of coverage in the media recently and gets a lot of people excited on social media. Most coverage of it is shallow, but even the most in-depth studies of it that have been performed have been too small scale to have any bearing on the reality of transforming an entire state's economy.

It would be nice if we lived in a post-scarcity (or sufficiently close) economy where we could afford these things. I doubt we do.

mech1234··on AB2712 – California Universal Basic Income
This bill will not pass. Its introduction is primarily a signalling exercise and a populist rallying cry.
mech1234··on Inside the Philip Morris campaign to 'normalize' a tobacco device
You do not actually disagree with dcolkitt.
mech1234··on Suspicious Discontinuities
You are being needlessly contrarian.

Fiscal policy comprises both borrowing and taxing; the two are fungible as far as spending is concerned.

mech1234··on Suspicious Discontinuities
I'm getting strange vibes for how people must be reacting to this.

Your idea of a possible better world is so bad that you should feel bad! /s

mech1234··on We can’t leave it to billionaires to solve the world’s problems
I think that billionaires' wealth is justified, with the exception of criminal billionaires. Assuming that they pay all taxes that they are legally required to pay, why do you think that they do not have a right to their own personal property? They earned their property through voluntary agreements with other individuals.

A Warren-style wealth tax comes up surprisingly short in terms of funds collected for the government relative to the risks it faces ($2.75 trillion over 10 years, https://www.factcheck.org/2019/06/facts-on-warrens-wealth-ta...) The risks it drives include capital flight, worsened corporate governance, and decreased economic dynamism. These are all long term risks that are difficult to quantify. Most countries that have ever instituted a wealth tax have later repealed it. In every economic sense, taxing income is a better idea than taxing wealth.

Much of our understanding of wealth distribution is biased toward our home country. There's a pretty good chance that if you are an HN reader you are in the top 1% of income or wealth in the world (http://www.globalrichlist.com/). When I consider how little of the government's efforts try to solve global humanitarian problems compared to the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation, I tend to think that the Gates' charitable contributions do more to address income inequality than a wealth tax on Gates would have.

In many ways the charitable contributions by billionaires solve problems that the government is poorly equipped to solve due to collective action problems. Forcing any large-scale charitable effort to be redirected through the government risks stultification, political misappropriation of funds, endless bickering about policy goals, projects cancelled due to changes at each election cycle. Having a two-pronged approach of private and public charity is more robust.

mech1234··on Dell Sells RSA to Private Equity Firm for $2B
This language misunderstanding took longer to clear up than I thought it would.
mech1234··on What happens to a mail-order mattress after you return it
Get a firm or very firm innerspring mattress from IKEA. You can do this for less than $300 and it will fit in the back of a sedan in it's roll-up-package.

Sleep on it for a bit. If you don't like the feel, which you probably won't, add a memory foam mattress topper for ~$50. Use a thicker or thinner topper to suit your needs.

Congrats! Because your mattress is firm, its foam will not break down for a long, long time. Sleep easy knowing you didn't waste stupid amounts of money and that your mattress will last essentially forever.

mech1234··on Dell Sells RSA to Private Equity Firm for $2B
Are you implying that public equity is some sort of government-owned entity?

My best guess is that you are confused as to what the term "private equity firm" means. Your post is so entwined with implications that I have no idea what you really mean.

mech1234··on Facebook tax court trial begins over Ireland offshore deal
I doubt facebook committed a crime here. The right way to address tax avoidance is to change the law, not to punish companies that comply with the law through arbitrary levels of complexity.

Even if everyone in the room is aware that facebook is practicing avoidance, avoidance is still legal and categorically different than evasion.

Now- The right way to figure out whether this was a crime seems to be by examining the fair value of the intellectual property sold to Facebook's Irish subsidiary. I hope the discussion here can center around this.

mech1234··on How to Collaborate with People You Don’t Like (2018)
Did you eventually get paid?

Sounds like the old phrase "you can't understand something if your salary depends on not understanding it" applies. If the boss of the company spreads misinformation that impugned you, his reports will believe it.

mech1234··on Kickstarter employees vote to unionize
Kickstarter prints money, so I don't think they'll be hurt too much by this.

I think that Kickstarter as a company could exist in its current form with little change for a long time. I wonder how the culture works around there.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →