HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mech1234

428 karma · joined January 9, 2020

submissionscomments
mech1234··on Stop Lying About Our Sons
One thing I've been thinking a lot about lately is the increasing lack of productive physical activity available to men in a lot of settings. Idleness and sedentary lifestyles are increasing in prevalence. Manual labor and sports are both on the decline. Physical activities are good for the body and soul, and it's sad to see them disappearing.

I think catharsis is important for men in particular, and idleness is particularly destructive for men. If there aren't engaging activities available for men, they will make something up to stay busy, often in destructive patterns.

mech1234··on Kroger (chain grocery store) is running paramilitary spy gear in parking lots
I've seen similar towers at walmart. I usually park next to them to make it easy to find my car.

Not really that different in application than the security cameras we've had for decades though, unless I'm misunderstanding something.

mech1234··on Why Aren't More Highly Intelligent People Rich?
This article is extremely brief and contradicts the more nuanced reality of a lot of published research.

For people with higher intelligence, their income is generally higher. The correlation is strong, the effect size is large, and the research has replicated very well. Conscientiousness also correlates strongly positively with income in a similar way.

This article seems to start with a baseline assumption of what "rich" means, but doesn't state what that assumption is. I imagine it is a pretty high bar and the article is essentially saying "successful moonshots come from all walks of life/ all IQ levels."

Taleb has written on this topic and when he did it prompted a lot of discussion. He notes that above a certain IQ threshold, the correlation becomes lower, and uses this observation to dismiss the whole correlation. However, if you look at the scatterplots he uses in his own article, you start to realize how strong the relationship really is. I can't find his article yet, might be able to find it soon...

https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2008/02/06/correlation...

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01602...

https://danielmiessler.com/blog/how-nassim-taleb-is-both-rig...

>How important is intelligence to financial success? Using the NLSY79, which tracks a large group of young U.S. baby boomers, this research shows that each point increase in IQ test scores raises income by between $234 and $616 per year after holding a variety of factors constant. Regression results suggest no statistically distinguishable relationship between IQ scores and wealth. Financial distress, such as problems paying bills, going bankrupt or reaching credit card limits, is related to IQ scores not linearly but instead in a quadratic relationship. This means higher IQ scores sometimes increase the probability of being in financial difficulty.

mech1234··on Colorado voters are set to decide if wolves should be reintroduced to the state
I'd rather have a wolf surtax added to the bear patrol tax.
mech1234··on US says it can prove Huawei has backdoor access to mobile-phone networks
A question to Europeans reading this-

If you had to assume that U.S. 5G equipment manufacturers would provide backdoors to U.S. officials, and Chinese 5G equipment manufacturers would provide backdoors to Chinese officials, and Europeans had to use one or the other, which would you choose?

mech1234··on Appeals to Consequences
I think you're wrong in ways that are difficult to untangle.

To give an example of an obviously flawed deontology, "Never swim within 30 minutes after eating" is a deontological rule. Many experienced swimmers (or eaters) know that this is a rule that can be broken safely, and choose not to follow it.

Not to say that better or more complicated rules don't exist. The 10 Commandments are a deontological system, and are not identical to consequentialism.

The contrast is- following pre-established rules, which were (hopefully) written with good outcomes in mind, vs. judging the likelihood of good outcomes on-the-fly.

mech1234··on Appeals to Consequences
The reasonably expected ends justify the well-considered means, if and only if they are net good.
mech1234··on Appeals to Consequences
Deontological ethics or deontology is the normative ethical theory that the morality of an action should be based on whether that action itself is right or wrong under a series of rules, rather than based on the consequences of the action. (from wikipedia).

You may be confused because you've circled the drain a bit considering a few particular philosophers and their stances. The categorical imperative is a particular deontological rule that closely resembles consequentialism.

mech1234··on Appeals to Consequences
I've had a theory that:

In the long run, consequentialism and virtue ethics converge.

Calibrate your chosen virtues to produce good outcomes. The more experience you have, the more closely you can understand which virtues result in which ends.

It's like playing poker, choose your bets.

mech1234··on Ask HN: How do you manage your financials?
I can mention that if you use mint.com and have anything that isn't quite perfectly standard about your financial accounts it won't work well.

for example- My wife and I have a joint brokerage account at Fidelity, and my wife also has a 401k at fidelity. She has a login associated with the brokerage account, and one associated with the 401k. However, via each login, all of her accounts are visible.

mint.com cannot understand that these accounts are duplicated. There are manual overrides to disable certain accounts, but these overrides work on some portions of the site (such as the overview page) and not other portions (such as the net worth tracker over time chart).

I feel that mint has already reached peak revenue per user and is now trying to glide through the rest of its lifecycle with minimal investment in the site, so these problems might not work out ever.

mech1234··on Was the Nuclear Family a Mistake?
>In 1970, the family structures of the rich and poor did not differ that greatly. Now there is a chasm between them. As of 2005, 85 percent of children born to upper-middle-class families were living with both biological parents when the mom was 40. Among working-class families, only 30 percent were. According to a 2012 report from the National Center for Health Statistics, college-educated women ages 22 to 44 have a 78 percent chance of having their first marriage last at least 20 years. Women in the same age range with a high-school degree or less have only about a 40 percent chance. Among Americans ages 18 to 55, only 26 percent of the poor and 39 percent of the working class are currently married. In her book Generation Unbound, Isabel Sawhill, an economist at the Brookings Institution, cited research indicating that differences in family structure have “increased income inequality by 25 percent.” If the U.S. returned to the marriage rates of 1970, child poverty would be 20 percent lower. As Andrew Cherlin, a sociologist at Johns Hopkins University, once put it, “It is the privileged Americans who are marrying, and marrying helps them stay privileged.”

I think this paragraph has a lot to say about how marital cooperation helps wealth creation. I've seen statistics (a long time ago) that a married couple only consumes 1.4 times the living expenses of a single person. The rest can go in the bank or into a higher standard of living. This also has the economic benefit of diversification, where the family can still make ends meet if one income is lost.

"Marriage inequality" does not seem to be a category of inequality that can ever be addressed through government led redistributive efforts.

mech1234··on Wikimedia Cookbook
You should get into baking if you want to see where precision matters and how it can be expressed in cooking.

Generally, things you cook on the stovetop don't need strict quantitative controls. Exercise your own judgement and experience- you can understand how the onion will taste based on how it looks. Mix it, heat it, season it, eat it.

mech1234··on The Seven-Year Auto Loan (2019)
Buy a car cheap enough that if you total it, you aren't upset.

Drop collision coverage. Only carry liability insurance.

Feel liberated.

mech1234··on A proactive approach to e-scooter safety
I was really hoping to see statistics regarding fatal accident per mile in comparison to other forms of transport, guess I'll have to dig deeper for it.

Makes sense that scooters would be roughly similar to bicycles though.

mech1234··on Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth?
No. Household sizes have been getting smaller, not larger, over time. It would be pretty far-fetched for the combinatorial effects of mixed-income households to boost the median in spite of this.
mech1234··on The mysteries of aerodynamic lift
I suspect if you made a wing out of a flat piece of material, tilted at the appropriate angle of attack, it would be sufficient to fly a plane. It just wouldn't be optimized at all.

Really, you need full Navier-Stokes behavior to explain all the forces acting on the wing. Bernoulli doesn't generalize to a full vector field, it's a simplified version of Navier-Stokes. Calling in the big guns doesn't make for an easy discussion.

(mechanical engineer, I figure I had like 1/3 of the fluids classes the real aerospace guys get).

mech1234··on Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth?
Another well-regarded source is the congressional budget office. The data linked below from 2014 is even more optimistic than my previous data because it uses household income instead of individual income. (because the distribution of individual incomes is skewed and growing even more skewed, median household incomes grow faster than individual incomes). The CBO data shows 26.1% growth in the incomes of middle quintile households since 1979. This growth is larger if you look at the lowest quintile, include taxes and transfers, or do both. The data goes up to 2014 and would show larger growth still if it went all the way to 2019.

https://www.cbo.gov/publication/53597

mech1234··on Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth?
I think it is a mischaracterization.

Notably, the graph provided at the second link covers a time period ending in 2008, the depths of the great recession. Things are numerically a bit better than depicted there. The overall story is the same- the bottom and the top of the worldwide income distribution is where things are growing fastest, but the middle is growing slower. It is certainly growing though.

10% real median income growth since the 80's is nothing to sneeze at.

mech1234··on Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth?
It's false that none of the growth is being captured by middle income people. It is being captured to a greater extent by the very top of the income distribution and by the global poor, but income is growing across the board.

Real median wages and household income in the U.S. are higher than they've ever been.

This is all despite the increased international competition typified by globalization trends and detailed by the Elephant Curve.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LES1252881600Q

https://milescorak.com/2016/05/18/the-winners-and-losers-of-...

mech1234··on Flight Simulator 2020 – New Development Footage
I checked the minimum required specs advertised for FS2020 and it made me sad. I have a pretty decent used dell M6800 workstation at home (gen 4 i7, K3100M graphics, 32GB RAM) and I don't know if I'll be able to run it.
mech1234··on Netflix's Junk Bonds Explain How We Are in a Corporate Debt Bubble
Are you including 401k index funds/ general retirement funds in your definition of pensions? That is a typical source of stock ownership for many Americans.

You don't have to actively follow the stock market to be an owner of stocks. Buying and holding index funds or mutual funds in general is a great way to build wealth with little effort. Many households in the middle class are stock owners through this method. Most large employers offer retirement plans that include this.

mech1234··on Netflix's Junk Bonds Explain How We Are in a Corporate Debt Bubble
>A once-every-three-years study by the Federal Reserve Board found that in 2016, 51.9 percent of families owned stocks, either directly or as part of a fund.

https://www.politifact.com/california/statements/2018/sep/18...

I would add that there is so much total stock wealth, even though the top 10% own 84% of said wealth, the remaining amount is very very large.

mech1234··on Can We Have Prosperity Without Growth?
Lots of people underestimate the degree to which economic growth fuels good life outcomes for wide swaths of people.

-Even though many people live paycheck to paycheck at many different income levels, enough income growth can get you out of a paycheck-to-paycheck lifestyle and enable you to have real financial autonomy.

-One thing that has stuck in my mind over the last few years is that one of the worst outcomes of unemployment is when people feel useless as a person- leading to psychological problems and behavioral problems.

-The pace at which we solve real, useful problems grows with economic growth.

mech1234··on Starlink Is a Big Deal
A couple things:

1. Signals travel faster through the air and vacuum of space than they do fiber optic cables or electrical cables. 2. If there is an HFT trader based in the U.S. looking to trade based on events happening in Spain or Japan, they still want to get data across continents in the fastest way possible.

EDIT: Apparently other posters traded on the information arbitrage opportunity of replying to your post several seconds faster than I did. gg.

mech1234··on Poverty hurts children in ways we're beginning to understand
What programs tackle child poverty?
mech1234··on U.S. wants the EU to accept chemical-washed chicken as part of trade deal
Seems to me like the real motivation is defending their own agricultural industry. American chicken is cheaper and likely just as good. The health claims are weak, everyone can understand protectionism, but it is often masked behind other claimed goals.

The data on salmonella is not super solid, but points to higher levels in the U.S. https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-47440562

mech1234··on Why Do American Houses Have So Many Bathrooms?
Can't agree more with this. Spending ~25k every 15 years on a bathroom remodel needs a budget of over $1000 per year. Do you really get that much value out of it?
mech1234··on The Wuhan Virus
From the scattered information I have read, the infection has a very long dormant period (2 weeks), during which it may be contagious, and a high R_0 value of at least about 2.0. The R_0 value states how many people will catch the virus from an existing infected person.

These two factors together are scary. I am extremely interested in seeing better data though.

mech1234··on New York on track to ban cashless stores and restaurants
The vulnerable are often underbanked. They might not have a bank account, debit or credit card, or smartphone with Venmo/Cash app/(whatever app is popular today).

Cash is the easiest way to help vulnerable groups. If a homeless person wants to buy a cheeseburger, its better to accept the cash rather than have him fill out FORM NY-892-F INDIVIDUAL RETAIL ESTABLISHMENT CREDIT ACCOUNT CREATION FORM, proposing to send a monthly bill to his non-existent address, or non-existent email.

mech1234··on The Myth of Self-Reliance: An encounter with Emerson’s essays
Rich people skew right-leaning. We can imagine many reasons for this, but I'll break it into two groups:

1. The same moral leanings that are identified with right-leaning parties are moral leanings, that when applied to your own life, can help make you more wealthy.

2. Having these moral leanings have no impact on your future success.

Considering that in absolute numbers the rich are more charitable and pay more taxes than the poor, and if you believe that the majority of the rich are strong value-creators (implying that they are generative, and are contributing positively to the economy rather than playing a zero-sum game), then for any portion of factor #1 above that is true, there is a moral argument to be made that adopting right-leaning values leads to a better world for both yourself, and for society as a whole.

All of this is speculative and stated in broad generalizations, but it's an argument that I've worked into my mind as a Pascal's wager of sorts and that I've found very convincing.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →