HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mech987

102 karma · joined December 7, 2021

submissionscomments
mech987··on Covid learning loss has been a global disaster
I think the proper argument to be made here is comparing its mortality for this age group to that of the flu and other causes. Car accidents or homicide are other interesting ones.

Liver disease kills more 35-44 year olds according to the amac.us source.

https://freopp.org/comparing-the-risk-of-death-from-covid-19...

https://amac.us/estimating-the-risk-of-death-from-covid-19-v...

mech987··on Where does the wealth go when asset prices go down?
Let's say you own a magic box that produces 15 potatoes a day, automatically. You use these to help feed your family, and sometimes you sell the extra potatoes you don't want to eat, or give them away to friends.

One day the box starts working a little bit less- it only produces 12 potatoes a day.

What happened to your wealth?

mech987··on Unusual stock trading by members of Congress
>Two senators from Oregon turned a combined profit of $122,000 on iShares Russell 2000 Index Fund between January and March.

This particular trade is not worth worrying about. Wow, some senators traded on an index fund. Must've been some real insider stuff, to know enough material non-public information about a collection of 2000 companies to be able to wring all that profit out of it.

mech987··on California targets loud exhaust with sound activated cameras
I don't have empathy for loud pipes on trucks, but for motorcycles I give 'em the benefit of the doubt. Speaking as somebody that rides a quiet motorcycle and has almost been hit by inattentive drivers. The people that complain about the noise are implicitly valuing their own comfort over another person's safety. Even if you say that riding a motorcycle is an unnecessary risk, the tradeoffs are still obvious to me.

When it comes to life and death on a motorcycle, the precautionary principle applies- anything that makes you more conspicuous is generally safer. I'd trust my own intuition over the unreliable state of scientific research on the matter.

mech987··on The U.S.S. Akron and U.S.S. Macon, America's “flying aircraft carriers”
It's a bit tangential, but the role of small disposable drones in warfare will only increase in the coming years. They're one of the more terrifying (non-WMD) weapons in terms of capabilities in my mind.
mech987··on California proposes 4-day work week without pay cut for large companies
Hey it's a 25% raise if you do the math by the hour!

As someone in North Carolina I'm glad I don't have to wake up to headlines of the state government pretending to try to pass strange utopian wishful thinking laws every few weeks. Not that we're perfect either, but the scope of ambition of CA politicians is so very, very, cute.

Has that California law requiring female board members (or else a punitive fine) for CA HQ'ed companies been struck down by the courts yet? I would be flabbergasted if that law survived the courts. Y'all have it strange out there.

mech987··on Lowering sodium intake doesn’t help heart patients
I wonder if the commonly thought of causation relationship for sodium and health problems is inverted.

Speculatively, i.e... your body has a greater need to use the sodium-potassium pump more when you're stressed, which makes you crave salt, and eat more sodium. The high stress is what causes bad health outcomes, the high sodium levels just happen to correlate with it.

mech987··on The tech bubble that never burst
I bet you're not adjusting for dividends though-

I remember vaguely a chart of total inflation-adjusted return, including dividends. Forgetting dividends leads some people to be much more pessimistic than they should.

If I can find the dang chart I'll post it.

mech987··on I no longer grade my students’ work, and I wish I had stopped sooner
If you grade improvement rather than mastery, you incentivize feigning incompetence at the start of the course to game the system.

The closest thing I ever saw to this was my high school weightlifting class. Your bench press single rep max was a high percentage of your overall grade, and was tested several times over the course of the semester. You were graded on improvement. The teacher made sure not to mention this before the first test, to keep people from cheating, but a few kids were in the know and faked a low max.

From a philosophical/values point of view- what is more important for education- incentivize all students to try to achieve the mastery level expected, or incentivize all students that as long as it looks like they're making progress, that is enough? I'd go with mastery. The appearance of progress is too easy to game, too subjective, and not easily applicable to varying courseloads.

mech987··on The rich niche
>Jonah Peretti was right in 2017 when he warned that paywalls are “bad for democracy.”

Haven't we also come to the conclusion that ad-supported clickbait journalism is bad for democracy?

mech987··on The unsustainable growth of the container ship industry
If I remember right the pollutants they're talking about are not CO2. The fuel oil that these big ships use is pretty sulfury and dirty and makes a lot of NOx, and that's the sort of stuff that the statistics refer to. They also don't use catalytic converters or some such similar tech.

Some environmental coverage likes to omit this level of detail and it makes them sound extra extra horrendous.

mech987··on NFTs means the future value of art is zero
>But it only takes one person to decide that they want to sell their copy for free - and the floor becomes zero

That's not quite right. If we plot out all the bids and asks, the price floor only becomes zero if the seller with a $0 ask has enough volume to flood the market. Otherwise

If the Red Hot Chili Peppers decide to release only 300,000 copies of an NFT album, then the limited distribution would keep the price floor above zero. Even without a limited distribution there's a pretty good chance that most people wouldn't part with their copy unless they got enough money for the trouble.

mech987··on I automated my job over a year ago and haven't told anyone
Why is work just a means of transferring wealth upwards?
mech987··on Basic income would not reduce people’s willingness to work
I imagine that the validity of this research is completely dependent on the particular monetary rewards and other incentives built into the experiment design.

Getting paid $5 to do a boring task for an hour is a totally different ballgame than getting paid $100 for the same. Even moreso after you've done it for 100 hours. And in the context of a a person who is visiting a research lab the incentives to keep participating in the potentially "interesting game" are different than real life.

mech987··on In Praise of Corn Ethanol
One reason I'm glad I don't live in California :)

Around here in NC you can find ethanol-free gas at some particular gas stations for a reasonable price, usually maybe 20% markup over normal gas prices.

mech987··on In Praise of Corn Ethanol
I didn't know about the history of MTBE until reading this, that bit was pretty interesting.

The thing that bothers me most about ethanol is that it is hygroscopic and ruins gasoline after sitting for relatively short periods of time in humid conditions (weeks to months).

← PreviousPage 2 of 2