HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

medbrane

20 karma · joined July 31, 2017

submissionscomments
medbrane··on I still prefer MCP over skills
>here's no mechanism for progressive disclosure of parts of the tool's abilities

In fact there is: https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/agents-and-tools/tool-us...

If the special tool search tool is available, then a client would not load the descriptions of the tools in advance, but only for the ones found via the search tool. But it's not widely supported yet.

medbrane··on SSE sucks for transporting LLM tokens
Indeed, the reconnect behavior is described in the protocol and the server will simply resume from the requested sequence id.
medbrane··on Samsung Family Hub for 2025 Update Elevates the Smart Home Ecosystem
But hey, your fridge is now more secure because blockchain (I'm not kidding, it's in the press release)
medbrane··on An LLM does not need to understand MCP
Indeed, the article would have been correct one year ago.

Now, modern LLM APIs do require the tools to be described outside the prompt [1]. This negates the whole article, although one bit where he's right is that it does not matter if those tools are MCP tools or local, the call to LLM looks the same.

[1] https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/function-calling?api...

medbrane··on The current hype around autonomous agents, and what actually works in production
That was in 2022, before LLMs, and they "lost" as in they had to pay back $482 USD.
medbrane··on Old Soviet Venus descent craft nearing Earth reentry
>one of the oldest Western traditions is to demonize Russia and Russian people

Would you blame them? Who cares is something good happens now in Russia while they are brutally murdering their neighbors?

Nobody cares whether Hitler was great at drawing or not.

medbrane··on Old Soviet Venus descent craft nearing Earth reentry
>Broadly speaking, Russian historians are generally of the opinion that the Holodomor did not constitute a genocide. Among Ukrainian historians the general opinion is that it did constitute a genocide.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holodomor_genocide_question

medbrane··on The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A)
No support for long, streaming interactions, like a terminal
medbrane··on The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A)
An endpoint implementing this protocol would describe the agent and its capabilities, including examples. So I guess you could index that and create a discovery service.
medbrane··on The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A)
But MCP doesn't claim to address agent to agent communication, right?
medbrane··on The Agent2Agent Protocol (A2A)
That's dependent on the particular LLM one uses.

But it can be a json with the tool name and the payload for the tool.

medbrane··on Prompt Engineering Is Snake Oil
But not for gpt3.5 family.
medbrane··on Prompt Engineering Is Snake Oil
Indeed, a reduced prompt size is unlikely to compensate for 8x inference cost increase.

Also fine tuning OpenAI's black box with data generated using gpt4 does not really require a lot more skills than prompt engineering.

medbrane··on France fines Microsoft €60M for imposing advertising cookies
But serverside tracking without consent would still be illegal, right? GDPR does not make a difference between cookies and other mechanisms.
medbrane··on Breaking up with JavaScript front ends
What you ask for is now possible using Next.js and the new React Server Side components. Check the link in the sibling comment tree.
medbrane··on AirPods don't “just work”
Note that you have to configure that on each device separately.
medbrane··on Chinese activist Ai Weiwei says Credit Suisse closing foundation's bank account
https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2020/12/11/china-to-renew...
medbrane··on Apple ordered to not block Epic’s Unreal Engine, Fortnite to stay off App Store
They do a lot better than a hypothetical Facebook store, which Epic suit would make possible.
medbrane··on 50% – 75% of cases of Covid-19 are asymptomatic
>but don't assume you will be protected from coronavirus 100%.

Washing hands does not protects you 100% so why bother?

medbrane··on 50% – 75% of cases of Covid-19 are asymptomatic
>because they're concerned about the efficacy of tests other countries are running. That's rich. I understand that the US developed test had a lot more issues that the standard not-invented-here one.

And a lot of countries do the test twice, and only act on double positives or double negatives.

>doing nothing is not doing harm How can this be OK? People will spread it if they think they are not sick.

medbrane··on Tesla races past $100B in market valuation
So you are saying that the opposite (a long position) is advisable? But that would make the current investors behavior a rational one, right?
medbrane··on Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones
After 5 hours you can put then in the case for charging:

> 5 minutes in the case provides around 1 hour of listening.

Together with the case Apple quotes 24h.

medbrane··on Intel's CIP wants to collect the “categories of websites you visit”
They also keep it after you eventually opt out.
medbrane··on Intel's CIP wants to collect the “categories of websites you visit”
They have this question in the page:

> If I participate in the program, is there any personal information in the data collected?

..then they proceed to tell you what they don't collect. You can read between the lines that yes, they do collect PII.