HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

menotyou

204 karma · joined September 22, 2015

submissionscomments
menotyou··on IPv6 Deployment Status
Citation "IPv6 was designed to restore the end-to-end model of communications with all nodes on networks using globally unique addresses. But considering this, IPv6 may imply privacy concerns due to greater visibility on the Internet."
menotyou··on Why software projects take longer than you think: a statistical model (2019)
I think the truth is much more simple:

  - Did you ever see any project finished ahead of time?
  - How many project did you see where scope was shrinking during execution vs. expanding?
menotyou··on Ask HN: Why do functional programmers hate loops (for, while, etc.)?
I would argue

  sum(0) = 0
  when n != 0: sum(n) = n + sum(n-1) 
is kind of clearer. But quite often it is not that easy to give an recursive solution for an iterative problem. When you want to change every even number in an array/list from n to n+1 you can somehow do it recursively, but it is mor obvious to iterate over the elements (which in many functional languages can be expressed by "apply" or some similar function).
menotyou··on Commuters prefer origin to destination transfers
Quite the opposite for me. I would start with the long haul segment, because missing the long haul flight because of a late local flight would mean more trouble than being already near my final destination which gives me more options for the final segment in case problems arising.
menotyou··on Ask HN: Why aren't modern programming languages, like Rust, more legible?
I don't think this is related to your ADHD.

When your read a program it puts cognitive load on your brain. How much is a bit depended on your education and experience on the subject, but what you have to do is to transfer what you are reading to your mental model what the program is actually doing. Your capacity of things you can process in your brain is limited so you can fairly assume that the more load is put on your brain the more of that capacity is used, and the nearer your are to your maximum capacity the more difficult and exhausting is the task to understand the program.

When you need to decode a "{" or a "@" in the program to a actual processing step. you can assume that

  if (a) {
    b;
  } 
  else  {
    c;
  }
is more difficult to decode compared to

  IF    a 
  THEN  b 
  ELSE  c 
  ENDIF.
simply the latter one is nearer to your natural language (I actually think to replace "ELSE" with "OTHERWISE" would be even better) and the "ELSE" implies both the opening and the closing braces.

You can argue if

  a ? b : c; 
is more readable, I would argue it is not.

It's not like special characters are always bad. For example

  a->b
works quite well when a is pointer and the arrow "->" symbolizes graphically where a is actually pointing at. But nowadays we languages which use "->" and "=>" for different things and for their similarity they interfere which each other when doing the decoding and adding to the cognitive load.

When designing a language you have to trade of brevity or number of characters to type and readability. Most, if not all languages, nowadays opt for brevity because it appeals to the developers to type less and makes it more easy have more complex functionality in one statement. The price you pay is readability and finally maintainability of the program.

I think the first programming language which failed by its overuse of badly readable syntax was Perl, which was replaced by the much more easy to read Python.

I personally believe the psychology of programming is an under-researched subject

Disclosure: Alongside to CS I studied cognitive psychology when I attended university.

menotyou··on Why a browser and mail combination is worth it
Looks like they want to upgrade their user experience from "annoying" to "hostile"
menotyou··on Why a browser and mail combination is worth it
I have to use Outlook with my employer and I am sorry to say that its UI went from fairly good to bad to annoying over the last decade or so. Outlook serves in many ways a good example of bad UI design but not as an reasonable mail client.

Likewise I used Thunderbird privately, and still use as my POP3 based mail archive, I find the UI not as bad as outlook, but still not really practical my everyday needs.

So I ended up with using Vivaldi in spite of not being a believer of integrating mail an browsing in one program.

menotyou··on Ask HN: Which substacks do you read as soon as it hits your inbox?
None
menotyou··on Vivaldi on Android bypasses restrictions to let users access Bing Chat
I am a happy Vivaldi user. But what is Bing Chat and why would I want to have this?
menotyou··on Brute.Fail: Watch brute force attacks fail in real time
I put on my firewall a block for incoming traffic for all IPs outside Europe which helped a lot with the quantity of attempts.
menotyou··on Home food delivery’s questionable value, for consumers and investors
I used Hello Fresh for a couple of weeks but in the end let it go for the quality of their recipes.

I felt the meals were too much designed from the marketing department: Looked nice on the photos, but overly complicated to prepare for a daily dinner, and as my wife put it "Every meal taste somewhat similar".

What was missing was simplicity.

menotyou··on Please tell us what features you’d like in news.ycombinator (2007)
How do I do this on Android?
menotyou··on Objects Have Failed (2002)
To get an API I just define a type for double-ended-stacks functions manipulating it. Or if you prefer to define it with immutable variables the functions accept an double-ended-stack and return a new copied and modified stack as result.

The set of functions will be a moduls resembling what you call an API.

I am not argue this can not be done on OOP, but I find it counter-intuitive and overly complex to do so.

menotyou··on Objects Have Failed (2002)
I did not say that it is not possible to do it. I said it is counterintuitive for me to express or model it in that way.

And as you can see in the discussion arising, even this simple example is becoming a complex modelling problem in OOP.

menotyou··on Objects Have Failed (2002)
> Anyone else have a similar experience?

Exactly contrary. I find modelling in objects classes counter-intuitive and thus not good to reason about.

When I paint a wall I apply a function (paint) to the object (wall), not the object is painting itself. I can apply the same function to a different type (aka class) of object e.g. I can paint my chair. Stays the same function.

So in my cognitive model of the world the objects are objects manipulated by me, not subjects executing "methods", but OOP is treating them as subjects.

menotyou··on Jira is awful, welcome to AJIR
Using email addresses as login ids is a bad design because makes it virtually impossible for your users to change their email addresses. Talk to people who used their office email and later changed their employer, people who want to abandon gmail for privacy or other reasons, or whose email provider simply went out of business.

I would be surprised if your app would have a "change your email/login" function implemented.

menotyou··on Jira is awful, welcome to AJIR
> ...we have to tie your user to your email...

No, you don't have to. You want to.

The concept of tying email addresses to user accounts came Google to better track their users. Of course thankfully taken over from everybody in the industry.

Especially when you offer a "free" trial for your software you should not ask your users to pay with their data. Even first before they see what they'll get for in exchange.

You literally ask me to pay the price first before I see the product

menotyou··on Jira is awful, welcome to AJIR
I thought I would get a magic link without need for authentication?
menotyou··on Jira is awful, welcome to AJIR
(1) You already admit that you keep my address for future use.

(2) Whatever you consider annoying is most certainly different from what I would consider annoying

(3) I need to trust you which I don't because of (1)

menotyou··on Jira is awful, welcome to AJIR
Need to leave my email for trying.

Case closed.

menotyou··on What you can’t imagine clearly, you value less
I am an aphant, I can not imagine anything.

While I can appreciate to have a good income and always had good paying jobs, I was never really interested in making a career and becoming filthy rich. Possibly because I can not imagine myself in this situation.

On the other hand I was always better then others on making long term strategic plans.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphantasia

menotyou··on What Is the Essence of Computing? (2017)
With object orientation you can not even fry an egg because you can not prperly decide whether frying is a method of the egg, the pan or even the stove.

Ist's a procedure which takes a piece of food, a pan and an oven and produces a fried egg.

menotyou··on Ad blocking is under attack (2017)
> Vivaldi hasn't made it pass evaluation stage on desktop for me as it often crashes when I try it (linux distros).

I happily use Vivaldi on Linux Mint for more than two years without any issues!?

menotyou··on Ad blocking is under attack (2017)
> no one wants ads, really, they want search engines with relevant results

I actually don't care about ads. I use an ad-blocker because I am concerned about everybody in the industry tries to track and profile me.

menotyou··on How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is
> Russian funds were indeed frozen, but with the exception of banks processing gas payments so that can go ahead.

This is not correct. You have to understand that "money" at commercial banks is not money, but only a debt of that commercial bank with the account holder. Gas and other commodities are always paid in real money, which exists only in to flavors: Paper money and accounts directly at the respective central banks. This means you can have your real USD only on accounts at the FED and real Euros only at ECB etc. The West froze Russian accounts on EZB (the contracts are nominated to be paid in EUR) and at the same time wanted to pay the gas only on these accounts, which for obvious reasons was rejected by Russia. Russia requested to have their accounts unfrozen or paid in Rubels.

There was some face saving detours introduced into the payment process, but in the end the West pays now in Rubels.

Another example of self inflicted pain was when the West made it impossible for Russia to make debt payments. It was not Russia who suffered (they saved their payments), but the western creditors who lost their money.

I know a few investors who held Gazprom and Lukoil stocks over many years. They were factually expropriated because the brokers are refusing to process dividend payments or even selling the stock back to Russia. Again, not Russia was hit but citizens in the West.

menotyou··on How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is
The whole issue is self inflicted by the German government. So far Russia adhered to the supply contracts. The stakes are high for Russia here. If Russia would not adhere to the contract even in these times, other contract partners like India and China would likely reconsider their long term contracts.

It was Europe which decided not to by cheap Russian gas anymore and to ground their own economy. Instead Europa has to buy gas now on the spot market for about ten times the price. So Russia is more than happy by adhering to the contract and watching Europe to inflicting the damage themselves.

If the West would have decided to buy their NLG somewhere else 5 years ago, Russia would have invaded the Ukraine even with less considerations.

menotyou··on Parsing XML at the Speed of Light (2012)
Abandonig XML would help the climate immensly.
menotyou··on The Composition over Inheritance Principle (2020)
Yet another lengthy article about how to solve problems you would not have if you would never have started with OOP.
menotyou··on Ask HN: Do You Use RSS?
Yes.

I use netvibes for reading.

menotyou··on The collapse of complex software
The article refers to this kind of complexity:

[0] <https://twitter.com/internetofshit/status/986006653605687296...>

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →