HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

meowface

12,270 karma · joined May 9, 2013

submissionscomments
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
"Value judgment aside" meaning commenting on how this was done without commenting on the actual considerations of whether one should do such a thing
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
I see your point, but in any case the more data / the less detectable, the better. But, yes, regardless of the exact motivation, I do think it's fairly plausible that they knew this would likely get detected fairly quickly no matter what and made a deliberate decision to not try to make it a super subtle, super clever insertion.
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
I would guess this part - since it's so sensitive, and fairly small - was either written or heavily driven by humans. Though I do also think it's possible their internal Mythos ~5.5 or whatever may also not necessarily be heavily optimized for thinking in the right manner for highly effective underhanded code. (I think it's possible it is capable and they just didn't use it for this, for whatever reason, though.)
meowface··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
Value judgment aside: I am a bit surprised at how sloppily they did this. I think they could've achieved the same effect while decreasing the odds of detection via reverse engineering.

(This field is known as "underhanded code", coined by the Underhanded C contest: https://www.underhanded-c.org. It's a little-known "art"; little-known for probably self-explanatory reasons. There are much cleverer ways of achieving objectives like this. One obviously being you can move more out of the client and into the server, but the other being you can write plausibly deniable client code in a much more benign-seeming way than this. Some of what they added can only be done on the client, but I think some could've been moved, and the client-required parts could've been done more subtly and credibly.)

It's possible they knew the JS bundle gets so heavily scrutinized that it'd eventually get spotted and reported on regardless so they didn't bother doing something more subtle and duplicitous. But still seems slightly lazy.

meowface··on I used Claude Code to get a second opinion on my MRI
I may be missing something, but I think it's unclear that the parent poster here is necessarily actually contradicting anything the AI said. It may depend on the exact information the OP wrote to Claude and GPT. The full transcripts would be needed. (Though there is definitely a separate point that a doctor would generally better know all the right questions to ask, while current LLMs may be making certain assumptions.)

The LLM may have, from its "perspective", implicitly thought the OP was telling it that he had strong reason to believe there was no calcification and was not considering the bigger picture of possibly receiving an incomplete/poor assessment from the medical staff. In fact, the issue here may be the LLM overly trusting doctors vs. trusting its own expertise.

meowface··on The Coming Loop
I detest Elon Musk but I still use Twitter because there just is no alternative to it if you want decent tech discussion.

And I don't think it's smug or dickish. I like AI and I encourage even inexperienced software developers to use it. There's just no denying that the slop cannon phenomenon is still a very real phenomenon.

meowface··on The Coming Loop
This sums up the dynamic: https://x.com/danhockenmaier/status/2021617680525172840
meowface··on The Coming Loop
I and my friends go back and forth, every day, on whether coding with LLMs is a net plus or a net negative.

I'm at the point where I think it's dumb to not do it but also dumb to do it. I have no real answer.

I have settled on using LLMs for everything but to spend more time honing the quality and cleanliness with LLM passes afterwards than I generally would have taken to write it well myself in the first place. This is in some ways the worst of both worlds, but it somehow lets me bypass akrasia while still getting pretty good code out, so I consider it superior to how I worked before. I get more done in three months even if I get less done in a day.

meowface··on The Korean telecom giant at the center of Anthropic's Mythos controversy
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/05/09/opinion/foreign-aid-cuts....

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/05/30/opinion/elon-musk-doge-us...

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/05/opinion/usaid-spending-tr...

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/03/19/opinion/foreign-aid-cuts-...

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/05/08/us/bill-gates-elon-musk-k...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2025/05/28/rubio-aid...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/06/29/sudan-usaid-...

meowface··on The Korean telecom giant at the center of Anthropic's Mythos controversy
If you check my post history, I'm very left-leaning. I'm just establishment-left+woke (i.e., liberal) rather than populist-left+socialist, and Wired is populist-left. I'm the kind of person who actually likes Obama, for example.

It's actually unfortunate, because a not very credible publication writing about the vile behavior of the Trump administration (including Elon Musk personally literally killing hundreds of thousands of children, and possibly millions) only serves to help them. Those particular stories may or may not be fine, but I've seen enough truly abysmal stories to not have any trust in them as an organization.

Like, within one second of opening the article I already saw the headline is deeply misleading and then checked the comments here to see if anyone else had noticed (and they did). It's a joke. The article doesn't even make sense. It's like an AI-generated high school essay forced to hamfist a response to a contrived prompt.

meowface··on The Korean telecom giant at the center of Anthropic's Mythos controversy
Wired has been NY Post-tier (of the inverse polarity) for several years, now.
meowface··on Claude Fable 5
It's very disappointing but I'm assuming it's for rational reasons on their part.
meowface··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
It is more capable of writing code I find tasteful and maintainable. It is debatable to what extent it itself has taste. Its outputs just suit my taste more than Codex's do, even though Codex introduces fewer bugs.
meowface··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
GPT-5.5 is the better programmer but Opus 4.8 remains the better system architect and product designer.

Codex is very "miss the forest for the trees", but is much better at successfully making large changes in large codebases. Claude Code makes more mistakes, but has more taste and a better grasp on idiomatic and elegant software development.

If you can afford to, I recommend juggling both.

meowface··on YouTube to automatically label AI-generated videos
GenAI is good. (LLMs are GenAI, for example.)

This particular subset of GenAI is very very bad.

meowface··on Taking a walk may lead to more creativity than sitting, study finds (2014)
Same. I prefer walking outside (as would anyone) but I find even walking within my own home is pretty good, for people who have enough space. I may look like a maniac pacing in circles while watching some philosophical YouTube video on the big TV, but it's nice.
meowface··on Building Pi with Pi
You'll be dependent on it whether or not you use the main harnesses. You pay for the model. The frontier models will likely always be better than the open source ones.
meowface··on Building Pi with Pi
Codex and Claude Code store all this too. Lately I've started having each agent regularly read each other's chat transcripts as well as their own, including even the very same session I'm in. (With big contexts they increasingly forget a few things that they re-learn by just looking at the verbatim transcript.)

I don't think it's worth writing my own harness or switching to Pi and writing a plugin, but I definitely need to create some skills to automate much of this.

meowface··on Microsoft starts canceling Claude Code licenses
Agreed. 4.7 is a smarter but weirder model. It will get confused in unexpected ways, but when it's not confused it will perform better than 4.6.

It's not a bad idea to skip it and wait until the next model release, but I personally will stick with 4.7.

meowface··on Project Glasswing: An Initial Update
It's just an incremental thing. You're both right. They will slowly become less and less likely to introduce vulns due to higher intelligence and better RL. Offensive capabilities will still probably scale faster than automatic defensive-while-coding ones.
meowface··on Project Glasswing: An Initial Update
I've noticed even people who do offensive security for a living frequently leave gaping holes in their own code. If you're not actively primed to scan the landscape for the gorilla, you will often miss it even if you're a gorilla inquisitor.
meowface··on Python 3.15: features that didn't make the headlines
IMO this is bad, but a formatter that autofixes it would be fine
meowface··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
Paul has addressed this quote many times afterwards. But you've already said you don't care about his opinion, so it's not worth showing his explanation. He still likes Sam.
meowface··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
Really. That guy. I'm afraid you're one side of the coin in https://paulgraham.com/fh.html. Paul himself would agree with me on that if he were to read your post.
meowface··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
I could write a giant response to this with dozens of quotes from him and others and various sources but you would just say it's all lies/posturing, so it would not be a good use of my time. I will say that him becoming one of the most prominent funders and promoters of UBI research/experiments 6 years before GPT-3 is probably not a coincidence, though. OpenAI releasing a paper a month ago strongly suggesting the US move towards a more socialist economic system to handle massive economic upheaval is also probably not a coincidence. He obviously founded OpenAI with the primary intent of making AI so that they could make it go well instead of poorly, and it going well means properly addressing mass unemployment, biosecurity risks, some degree of widely distributed access so that the very poorest get meaningful use of the exact same intelligence as what the very richest get to use, etc.
meowface··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
I'm consistently amused by the fact that there's still this weird faction of populists on even tech-oriented sites like HN and /r/programming and lobste.rs and Mastodon who have this almost antivax-level stance on AI. I'm not precisely sure what explains it, because many of them actually are smart people and good programmers.

AI very likely will cure many cancers and very possibly (assuming combined with good politicians) will bring about global prosperity. A high percentage of AI company employees and executives and open source developers and researchers sincerely believe it will and so they say they believe it will. They have good reason to believe it, and they will likely be proven correct. If 400 (or 40, or 4) years pass and it's still mostly just creating spreadsheets, I will concede, though.

meowface··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
Paul Graham, founder of the website we're on, still says he likes and trusts him. He just was annoyed he was constantly distracted by AI stuff when he was supposed to be running YC as president (which bears no resemblance to any current events...).

He, at worst, finds him to have been (at some point) incompetent, which is very different from finding him immoral. Paul keeps replying to tweets to clarify this when people continue to misportray his stance.

"He was accused by the OpenAI board of lying to them, ousted, and somehow managed to regain control." is the only thing you wrote which is plainly true and valid to state.

I am sure there may exist good, strong criticisms, but your argument is so tendentiously gish-gallopy that it will if anything just make people more likely to disbelieve his critics. (Not that I would do that, since that'd be just as fallacious.)

Why would OpenAI employees all still be happily working for him and publicly supporting him? Why is the company still so successful, and the leader? Why wouldn't most of them have left in droves to Anthropic or elsewhere, by now? Especially given most technical employees at OpenAI (justifiably) share the eschatological views of AI shared' by Anthropic staff and other TESCREALists, in which case they really really try to be careful about who will be responsible for potential future superintelligence. The board and some executives disliked and distrusted him but it's unclear many other people there did or do now. And I'm not just talking about the petition but the people who have continued working there for years afterwards.

meowface··on Sam Altman's Business Dealings Under GOP Scrutiny Ahead of OpenAI's IPO
Is there a more benign explanation for these things? Altman is undeniably famously cagey and political but despite most of the tech and non-tech worlds at this point seeing him as some kind of con artist, I still kind of want to try to believe he's not.

No doubt some of OpenAI's founding principles like "stop + assist if a competitor gets to AGI first" are likely flying out the window, perhaps in part due to him and also as one might anticipate of initial lofty ideals and promises, but even with the recent New Yorker and other articles he seems like someone who maybe regularly placates people to avoid personal problems and lies to get out of trouble rather than a Machiavellian tech baron.

meowface··on Async Rust never left the MVP state
I am a beginner to Rust but I've coded with gevent in Python for many years and later moved to Go. Goroutines and gevent greenlets work seamlessly with synchronous code, with no headache. I know there've been tons of blog posts and such saying they're actually far inferior and riskier but I've really never had any issues with them. I am not sure why more languages don't go with a green thread-like approach.
meowface··on Opus 4.7 knows the real Kelsey
The attribution is likely incorrect. People have been trying to accuse him for many years, and the evidence is not very strong. This article is the strongest yet, but still commits many stylometric fallacies, and other kinds.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →