Actors protesting AI protections remind me of factory workers protesting against automation setting in.
226 karma · joined March 22, 2020
Actors protesting AI protections remind me of factory workers protesting against automation setting in.
For educators looking at evaluating students, essays and the like - we possibly need different ways of evaluation rather than on written asynchronous content for communicating concepts and ideas.
If our cognition is impacted by information, then by the very fact that attention span is a function of the information in our environment. I quite subscribe to the fact noisier environments lead to decline in attention spans.
Personally from over a few products have built, even the best designed product tours get dismissed 90% of the time in SMB & consumer products.
And why they could possibly never realize an AGI with the current stream of models. Being able to display human level intelligence and creative in confined spaces (be it Chess or Go based models) is something we have been progressing on for a bit - now that the same is applied to writing, image or audio / speech generation we suddenly start developing a fear of AGI.
Is there a phrase for the fear of AI now building up?
I don't think anyone in management turns up thinking I want to create the most toxic work environment and work only with folks who are not good at anything or need the whip. Even the best intrinsically motivated people need an environment and challenge to rise to the occasion of doing their best work. Sometimes it's peer competition, at other times it's unreasonable deadlines.
On an individual level our desires and goals are fairly mimetic. Our motivation to do work is a function of our desires, goals and the difficulty level of the problem. A bunch of the observations around theory x/theory y doesn't account for what individual motivation is and how is it derived.
A lot of this literature stems from older generational simpler classification models around how to influence human motivation. In classical Indian literature, a famous Indian philosopher Chanakya talks about Saam, Daam, Dand, Bhed to get things done. Translated it means - persuasion, price, penalty and coercion to get things done.
While philosophically we can lean in on similar models applied to management - the key here is a lot of these theoretical models need evolution to really apply to individuals and situations.
In this case it seems kinda the opposite, the enterprises are the first off the bat - existing products getting easier to use by ingraining LLM's into the workflow.
ChatGPT to a large extent also does seem to be moving search terms away from google. I would love to see trends on google.com vs ChatGPT vs Bing over a period of time - Search definitely seems to be changing, where we want summaries and content rather than a bunch of sponsored ads and websites where the context has to be derived from search.
I am also interested if the same is happening with StackOverflow -> the search on SO -> ChatGPT as a code generator.
For mainstream adoption, the adoption will be driven by the everyday software and applications we use. We are still in the shovels and picks part of the world, yet to see native AI consumer applications emerge (barring ChatGPT).
We do not want to read tweets or content created by AI's or machines, we want to connect with humans who can inform or teach us better. Maybe this would mean the liberation of humans from physical fields to digital fields where we keep plowing.
We were meant to connect, discover, roam, invent and innovate and instead ended up somehow sitting in front of a monitor and calling it work!
Much like writing, teaching and explaining concepts to others also forces us to think through more. I wonder if research around transformation of concepts from our brain into any medium (writing, visual or data) forces more thinking around the concept.
Even as I write this, I draft it, redraft it, eliminate and add to explain the idea. There is also a form of emergence in the concept as I put the thoughts to words.
The passion, the finish line, the eye on the goal, the fleeting moment of accomplishment?
And do you really see work as a product of your life's output. Or the way you live your life as one dedicated to the work. Are your relationships, your friendships, your contribution to your immediate environment around you motivators?
Media - An auto-backup of photos, videos & music is what I like. Use google drive for cloud backup. Have a premium account to accommodate for all the space needed
Notes & Documents & Writings - Public ones - Already part of the internet space. The rest are really things which I can afford to lose. They are like a closet which I don't really mind cleaning out once in a bit and losing it.
Work - Tax filings & income documents are in a digital private locker. The rest of it like work related repositories, code and other stuff. Either open sourced or in private git repos.
Movies & Books - I used to collect things like movies, books and then realized that could just rent and buy them over so no more into hoarding the stuff here.
Best advice, I can give after trying multiple organizational systems is constant pruning and sharing out what you can in public domain.
Most agents need some form of formal instructions tied with designing prompts - which are a mix between formal programming and natural language. This needs a slightly different skill set from the traditional backend engineer or services engineer. This is not a ML or data role either.
Rather than just a prompt engineer, the case for which could be made like a specialist designer - this role maybe more akin to a full-stack developer role who knows how to align LLM's or Diffusion models towards a multi-step goal.
We have long since endeavored to push the boundary on creativity and performance - from pills to sensory deprivation tanks, to extreme adventure to BM like experiences.
You can club a wide range of things under pills. Supplementation is an essential part of health and without concrete stats and evidence this is just sensationalism.
Would be super interested in knowing though - How much of the community here leans in on pills vs supplements vs meditation?
Being asked to defend your work in public and why it's worth being upvoted or talked about is something that folks building should have to go through.
I tend to say the case for being careful doesn't warrant that we do stop experimenting. Will we have some unwarranted effects because of this experimentation - Absolutely yes?
Is there a need for regulation - this is just stifling competition and allowing more closed door experimentation. Once you are in a position of authority spreading doomerism and asking for regulation is a way to stifle competition.
Evolutionary goals are not easy even with autonomous systems as goal definition is largely defined by societal needs, the environments we stay in and the resources we work with.
Will we see a resurgence of a new form of personalized research replacing this void for which folks will be willing to pay for? Is there a need for intermediaries in the space? Does direct publishing and direct to consumer media and publications have a place?
Closed feedback loops to improve the quality of reasoning for LLM's requires human-in-the-loop tools.
Prompting methods are often a hit and miss as the same prompts can lead to variable quality outputs.
PG's work back in the day on writing as a form of think is still pretty relevant. http://www.paulgraham.com/words.html
Both Amplitude / Mixpanel have pretty easy interfaces for building custom reports. If you are a profitable scaled SaaS the integrations available and the customizability + add-on product portfolios like schema management as you grow make it real hard to compete.
I would love to understand if you are building for a different segment of users here or tackling some use-cases and have a different POV which is not captured yet by these tools.
Autonomous agents need guardrails and oversight. An autonomous agent let loose with all the tools in the world will in essence lead to an outcome which is not predicted to be in our favour.
Which is why the Open AI app store and plugins scare me more than anything else - more likely than not they are tool and data feeders into a large scale autonomous system.
Reasoning is just prediction with memory towards an objective.
Once large models have these perpetual operating sensory loops with objective functions, the ability to distinguish model powered intelligence and human like intelligence tends to drop.