HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mexicocitinluez

476 karma · joined January 4, 2024

submissionscomments
mexicocitinluez··on US citizen charged after GrapheneOS phone wipes during airport search
> So if someone was doing insider trading, and the SEC came knocking, then immediately afterwards they start burning every document they have and microwaving their computers, do you think they should get off the hook?

Apples and oranges. They presumably already have some sort of evidence in order to get a warrant and are under criminal investigation.

According to the article the agents said it was just a normal part of screening.

mexicocitinluez··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
The other day I asked it to update a handful of files using a new pattern I built. It was tedious work, and probably would have taken me 10 minutes, but I figure why not just let Claude do it. Well, it spun up multiple agents, each taking a different approach (one writing a Perl script, the other just doing fancy regex, etc) and 30 minutes later had the result. Granted, it wasn't my 30 minutes it was using, but it felt wasteful nonetheless.

Now, if it's something minor, I'll ask Claude about it, and get the gist of what I need to do, and just do it myself.

mexicocitinluez··on Claude Cookbook
> the logic being you don't want to do that every time for every prompt

That's definitely a downside of a minimal MD and I could def be wasting tokens. I've tried to scope the tasks such that it won't feel the need to scan unnecessary files, but it's not bulletproof.

mexicocitinluez··on Claude Cookbook
I shouldn't have been so hyperbolic. I do have some general statements about tone and not to go down follow-up question rabbit holes and when to push back or not to install dotnet while on WSL and just go through Windows. Anything that won't change based on day-to-day dev work.
mexicocitinluez··on Claude Cookbook
This is definitely controversial, but I think the best CLAUDE.MD is no CLAUDE.MD at all. Every time I found myself wanting to put information into that file, I asked myself "Why isn't this already obvious from the code itself?"

I don't need to tell the agent my tech stack, what DB access library I'm using, the way in which I write my tests, etc. Why? Because it's all very clearly spelled out within the code itself. I've gone great lengths to make sure that my fairly complex domain can be understood by a person with little domain knowledge, which means it should certainly be understood by a tool that has a wealth of it.

mexicocitinluez··on Claude Cookbook
Amen on both your and OP's comments.

These tools work pretty well out-of-the-box. I'm sure I could squeeze out better token usage or streamline some tool calls, but it's not something I really want to focus on. Just like I don't want to endlessly configure my IDE, I don't really have patience with spending time on anything besides actually building something.

mexicocitinluez··on I regret migrating to Codeberg
Also, the there are hundreds of ways to use these tools. From semi-intelligent autocomplete to fully agent-driven. Where's the line? What if I had an LLM clean up a fairly long stored procedure? Is that single action now forbidding me from ever uploading that code base to Codeberg? What if no other part of my code was written using LLMs?

> Now this rule will either be never applied or when it's applied it will be an arbitrary decision made with mostly inconclusive "evidence".

Or people just lie. Which is the whole problem with not having a strong way to determine code's origin. And it's also a tad ridiculous because if done correctly, the seams between my thoughts and those of the agent shouldn't be apparent. If it's utilizing existing patterns in my codebase that I've written by hand, then you wouldn't even know.

mexicocitinluez··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
How do you know it wasn't the appropriate technology?

My point is that the idiom has now come to mean "I disagree with your tech choices".

mexicocitinluez··on Terence Tao's ChatGPT conversation about the Jacobian Conjecture counterexample
This has to be one of the more annoying characteristics of the recent models.

Every answer is met with "But did you think about X", or "One more thing to consider" and it almost starts to feel manic as you dig down that hole.

Multiple times I've had to literally say "Stop with the follow-ups and suggestions. Just answer the questions clearly".

mexicocitinluez··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
I'm not saying confusion isn't warranted. I was just commenting about how the "to a man with a hammer" idiom has now come to mean "I don't agree with your tech choices".
mexicocitinluez··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
> Nobody who worked in the 80s or 90s would have selected this solution

How does this support your argument? The tech didn't even exist in the 80s or 90s.

Saying "They wouldn't have made the same choices 40 years" is meaningless in this context. There's a lot of things they wouldn't have done back then that we do today. And this is a field that has been changing by the week recently, which makes even less appropriate.

This idiom now apparently means "I disagree with your tech choices" or in your case, "Someone 40 years ago would disagree with your tech choices".

mexicocitinluez··on Claude Code uses Bun written in Rust now
This saying has been abused 10 ways til Sunday.

"I'm using technology I know that will get us there" is not the same as treating every problem as a nail. It's making a practical choice that probably also had time constraints and other factors we don't know.

mexicocitinluez··on How proprietary formats have become Microsoft’s main tool for lock-in
> To be fair, that’s 50% the shop’s fault. They could have probably provided access via a link like GDrive allows. But of course, some moron on the other end would probably find it incomprehensible why you don’t already have an MS account or why you’re not willing/hesitant to create one, “it’s free!”

Not if you're in enterprise dev. You have 2 types of accounts: Microsoft and Google. Not because you want to, but because that's reality and it's practical.

What I'm saying is if you're an enterprise dev and you don't have a Microsoft account of some type that's a failure on your part. It's part of the job.

mexicocitinluez··on How proprietary formats have become Microsoft’s main tool for lock-in
This is a configuration issue. Onedrive also supports OTPs.

But regardless, what alternative would you propose? Did it contain any sensitive information? Does the alternative integrate with your current system? Do people need to create accounts for it like Dropbox? Do I have to teach all of the employees how do use this new service instead of just right-clicking and sharing the file?

SFTP is a no-go for obvious reasons. I can't even get people to stop clicking birthday initiation links from Australia (we're in the US) let alone teach them how to use FTP.

Dropbox would require a dropbox account. 100% not going to push another piece of softare on them when our current software already does.

mexicocitinluez··on How proprietary formats have become Microsoft’s main tool for lock-in
And if they haven't disabled it, clicking "I can't use authenticator" and relying on SMS is always a backup.
mexicocitinluez··on The LLM Critics Are Right. I Use LLMs Anyway
Same. Granted I have the $100/month Claude sub and barely ever see any of my usage bars go above 50% before they're reset (and that's when I had lined up a bunch of things to test Fable with).
mexicocitinluez··on Grok Build is open source
> Musk bought Twitter looking to build an “everything app,”

Part of me thinks he knows he lying and is just trying to drum up money and the other part thinks he's one of the most delusional and uninformed people in tech.

mexicocitinluez··on EF Core 11 makes your split queries faster
It does as of EF Core 8 or 9.

One of the challenges for their team I'm assuming is making sure the release notes also get copied to the actual documentation. This was one case where I thought the same thing and only until reading the release notes realized it was already a feature.

mexicocitinluez··on Grok 4.5
What was the request?

Also, Claude refuses political stuff in general, not just your specific beliefs.

mexicocitinluez··on What ORMs have taught me: just learn SQL (2014)
> 1. They pretend SQL is standardized, and support a heavily reduced featureset for any given database as a result

EF Core is provider-specific and also exposes provider-specific functionality.

> 4. You end up not wanting to use the objects directly anyways, so you end up with object-object-relation, needing a mapping layer from your database-object to your business-objects, which also defeats most of the benefits from change-tracking

This just isn't true for EF Core. https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/ef/core/performance/effici...

> 5. The generated SQL is periodically utterly nuts, so you have to review every generated query anyways

Not universally true either. You only have to review complex queries. If you're making claims about a specific ORM it would be good to mention it as it's not universal.

> 6. You probably dont want to actually use any of the OOP mapping features like inheritance in your DB

Then don't? Since when is inheritance required for ORM-usage?

I have found a lot of the anti-ORM critiques come from either using a crappy ORM or having not used a good one in the last 5 years.

mexicocitinluez··on What ORMs have taught me: just learn SQL (2014)
With the big exception of Entity Framework which relies on LINQ.
mexicocitinluez··on What ORMs have taught me: just learn SQL (2014)
> I know only a few ORM's but it seems they end up just adding another layer of DTO objects that are entirely separate from the domain classes anyway.

Entity Framework in particular has come a long way in this regard. Particularly owned & complex entities, value converters, etc.

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/ef/core/modeling/

> Worst case it creates a weird database-contaminated domain model that's hellish to maintain.

CQRS is good for this because it forces you into using a different write and read model. My write models are domain objects and my read models are DTOs that feed the UI and via projection I can shape them without issue.

mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
So again, you can train people but not AI? That's literally what you've said and now moving the goal posts in a way that makes no difference to what you said being patently wrong.

It's wild having to argue with people who say demonstrably untrue things and then refuse to admit that what they said was wrong.

mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
> Frankly, I'm sure if people wanted to sneak in an AI generated code by carefully reviewing it and making sure it's targeted and well tested

But this is exactly the point I'm making. If the code is carefully reviewed, targeted, and tested, then why make people have to lie in order to submit PRs?

Why not just say "Irresponsible use or agentic-based PR's will be auto-rejected"?

And that's not even mentioning that tools like Github Copilot can just act like fancy autocomplete. There are dozens (if not hundreds) of different ways to use these tools.

I guess I'm just really not sure how you can unequivocally forbid these insanely powerful tools when they are almost certainly going to be a large part of developer's workflows going forward?

mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
Saying you didn't use AI when you did, regardless of the end product, is lying. What definition of the word lie wouldn't cover that?
mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
A social contract? You invented that out of thin air. They're a means to an end not some discussion on philosophy.
mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
lol Human beings are famously not already trained.
mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
So when you said "AI cant be trained" you didn't mean "AI cant be trained" you meant that you personally can't? lol.
mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
> can be trained to make it good and also improves the community.

AI can be trained. Also, AI can create code that improves the community. It's replies like this that leave me even more confused.

mexicocitinluez··on Godot will no longer accept AI-authored code contributions
> A pull request is a social artifact whose value and meaning is dependent on its author;

Says who? How can you say I'm categorically wrong when your entire point rests upon an opinion?

← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →