Personally I have discussed this with coworkers/managers, but the environment is not going to change. Wherever I go next, I'll be on the lookout for quiet&privacy.
106 karma · joined January 18, 2013
Personally I have discussed this with coworkers/managers, but the environment is not going to change. Wherever I go next, I'll be on the lookout for quiet&privacy.
How do you know? Did you actually ask everyone "Do you have trouble working in this environment because of the distractions?" People are afraid of being seen as "anti-team" and "anti-open plan", and they won't tell you the truth. And others fake it, even if they really hate working in such an environment (I'm one of them) because it seems like a necessary evil these days. So the reality is, maybe that number is higher than you think.
1) I don't want people to be able to see me all the time. It's extremely nerve-racking and I feel like an animal in a zoo. And from my experience, people usually don't care whether I'm deep in some code or doing something less intense - they come over anyway. And people don't care whether their question is important enough to interrupt! As soon as someone taps my shoulder or calls my name, my concentration breaks completely and it takes me another half hour to get it back. Having offices makes people think harder and try to figure out the answer by themselves before going to someone else.
2) See above. The ratio of stupid questions that could have been resolved by Google or just another 2 minutes of thinking, to questions that ignited an interesting discussion is about 9 to 1.
3) How much work is going to get done by 'helping others'? 80-90% of a developer's work can be alone. Team productivity of course is important, but in development teams, this is really just the sum of individual developers' productivity.
In advanced math classes (upper undergraduate or graduate) it is almost impossible to check results or do a complex operation on a simple calculator.
In many cases I have to turn to a tool like Mathematica/Wolfram Alpha. I have a W|A Pro account and it has worked wonders for me. For example, entering "integral from 0 to infinity of (ye^(-y)((-1/y)(e^(-t))+1/y)) with respect to y" into Wolfram Alpha is so much easier than doing the same with a TI-89. I can copy/paste and adjust very easily and the software produces multiple interpretations/representations which is very useful.
It's useful, to some degree, in a musical setting; I find it very easy to hear music and reproduce it immediately (including chord/key analysis, etc). It's fun to take random songs I hear during my day and go about dissecting them.
However it has its pain points. I waste time analyzing useless things like the hum of the refrigerator or the sound of water dripping because everything sounds like a musical note. Also, I can't stand people / instruments that are not in tune. This includes professional pop artists / singers -- a lot of them sound awfully off key to me, even though in reality they probably are within a tolerance level. Ditto going to karaoke with friends who cannot sing. It destroys my ears and gives me headaches.
Most office layout decisions are made by upper management--who usually (conveniently) end up with private offices while the rest of the employees are forced to sit in the open area.
"And if I need to concentrate, I can just put on headphones or go to a quiet room."
The problem is that not all people working in open offices have this option. For example, at my company there is no such thing as a "quiet room."
My opinion is that there should be a mix of both. Let people choose.
This is precisely why I hate open plan. I don't want to be under constant surveillance by others. I don't want to be interrupted every 15 minutes by people asking me questions. I don't want others to be monitoring my screen and checking up on what I'm doing. And when I'm 15 layers into a complicated class hierarchy the last thing I want to do is get into a conversation and completely lose my zone.
Software development does not require 24/7 constant "collaboration". A quick progress meeting a day, maybe more if there is some discussion required, is sufficient in most cases. If there is a particularly technically challenging problem at hand, then sure--get some people into an office and brainstorm together. But in the end, people are going to be working alone 90% of the time. We don't need to be collaborating [i]all the time.[/i]
Also, you are forgetting the obvious: In an open plan, people talk about general bullshit, not just work. They talk about their kids, wives, weekend plans, the weather, sports teams, the latest tech gadgets, last night's game, etc, etc, etc. It gets distracting to the point where I can no longer do any meaningful work without earphones on. Last week, I measured the average noise level in my open office and it was something like 65 dB (this is equivalent to having a pretty loud conversation going next to you all day long). I felt my blood pressure rising and I even complained to management. How people can actually get work done in such an environment is beyond me.
You're probably in the minority when you say you prefer open plan. I'd trade my shitty desk for a real office any day.
Mind you--people in Japan are very smart. Science/math education is way better than in the US. But in the end, emphasis is on conformity and "not standing out too much" or "being different". This kills the spirit of innovation. I grew up in Japan but went to college in the US and work in NYC. Every time I go home, I feel like an outsider even though I spent 18 years of my life there.