This is a better way of saying what I stated in my first paragraph, and, really, a better way of saying my whole comment if you don't care to see the details of my conclusion.
1,719 karma · joined January 26, 2016
american west coast / singapore / 東京
the opinions expressed here are my own and not the opinions of my employer. they might not even be my own professional opinions. they are also subject to a lot of change, as they have through the years.
This is a better way of saying what I stated in my first paragraph, and, really, a better way of saying my whole comment if you don't care to see the details of my conclusion.
Emotionally, I'd like to see a smoking gun, and I'd like to believe that corporate leadership will be held accountable for misrepresentation of their company. I don't believe that it's good for society that you can gain financial wealth or political influence by selling people nothing more than a lot of hot air, and startups/entrepreneurs have enough snake oil as-is. Theranos being able to succeed at this type of behavior gives others the incentive to attempt the same behavior themselves. I believe that companies should have to provide social value for success, not promise everyone a lot of social value with no ability to return. I don't believe that "fake it til you make it" shouldn't be a viable corporate structure for any startup. Take VC with an idea, execute on your idea, profit. Steps 1 and 2 should not be able to be easily inverted for as long and as far as Theranos has taken it.
The problem here is not that Theranos has failed or has misrepresented the product, it's that Holmes personally needs to have been found to directly misrepresent the company in a fraudulent fashion. Her and Theranos can likely be sued (as civil cases require "preponderance of evidence") but I highly doubt you can prove fraud beyond a reasonable doubt unless there is a much greater scandal that is unearthed during an investigation. And that's probably not going to happen.
So let's talk about a federal investigation of Theranos, then: this is someone who has had James Mattis, the current prime candidate for Secretary of Defense, for help and sits on the board of Theranos [1]. She is connected to most of the political elite (Kissinger et al, all of the VC/finance world.) If anyone can put down an FBI investigation on her person, it would be someone this well connected to organizations that the FBI themselves lean upon in some way or another. This is Washington, and let's be real, favors are favors. Helping one of these guys somewhere in some way buys you favors, and you may be able to trade to get the investigation off of your back.
Furthermore, what stands to be gained by all of those on this board in power by prosecuting Holmes? It would tarnish the reputation of potential cabinet members and all others in Washington that "believed in" Holmes and her ideas. The political PR nightmare for these guys isn't worth the trouble of being involved in this. It becomes scandal for them. They would best see the company fade into irrelevance, and begin setting up the message that this is just another failed entrepreneurial case, of people making a moonshot and missing it. Tell Holmes it's OK, give her a powerful position in some healthcare think tank, and be on your way.
Also, what message does it stand to give the American public that have been sold on this visionary? The PR storm told people here is a white, female college dropout who hit the Forbes list and achieved the American dream. Do you really want to start a news cycle where Holmes is now being thrown in prison? Do you want that message, especially when so much of Washington is connected to it? That's emotionally heartbreaking to many.
So there's no bone to pick, if anything negative political blowback, an uncertain ability to prove Holmes herself defrauded people, and enough political power to tell the FBI to look at someone else. This is why I say there's little to no hope of her going to prison for this. Holmes knows what she is doing on that front, even if her visions didn't fully materialize. She has played the PR game pretty well up until this point, shoved her chips all in on the moonshot, and failed to deliver the goods. Frankly, I think she has thought all this through and her bets are on what I've said above. The question is whether or not this line of thinking is incorrect. I am armchairing it, and her life is on the line.
[1] http://www.fiercebiotech.com/medical-devices/theranos-asked-...
The Pre was a fantastic device and did a lot of things right from a UX perspective, IMO. The hardware was terrible and there wasn't any mind paid toward securing anything really, but it was a breath of fresh air in the duopoly.
An elite, highly politically connected, young, blonde, Caucasian woman will not spend time in prison for a dubious charge of white collar crime. There is little to no hope of that in today's society, regardless of how damaging her actions are.
Edit: I'd love to be proven wrong on this comment, but I don't have much faith that this will ever come to happen. It is laughable to think that the American justice system is actually neutral across races or socioeconomic lines. Also, I agree that Theranos is toast. I just think it will try to become toast somewhat quietly.
I think the big problem a new OS will have is compatibility with existing iOS/Android software stacks. You need to be able to run one or the other until you get market share for your own applications, because the majority of the populace wants their bread-and-butter Facebook, Snapchat, et al and these companies will not give your upstart OS any love until you have users.
Yes, but what is the negative externality the market is not currently capturing when these devices are assumed into botnets and used against others? Simple economics states that the $20 device is $20 because somebody else is paying for the security mistakes of the shitty device's developers.
The quantity of journalists are now the surplus, and the real scoops that generate traffic (and revenue) are scarce. Because of this economic inversion, we now have the companies running the media institutions. In a mainstream economic environment, you then have two choices: media that plays into the confirmation biases of its readership (customers) - just as NYT is doing here - or investigative journalism that is digging up heretofore unknown stories people are trying to conceal (eg The Intercept, Muckrock) to get the pageviews and therefore the ad revenue.
So we should ban viral mechanics, those old Facebook games, dark UI/UX patterns, and pay-to-play mobile games as well? They often work in the same manner, and yet you yourself appear to know the risks and appear to be immune to them.
For the record: I like gambling. I like drinking, too. I have neither a gambling addiction nor an alcohol addiction. Should I be disallowed these things I find pleasurable because a subset of the population abuses these things?
> the alt-right seem to really like disrupting conversations that are inconvenient to them
That's aggressive behavior, then. I'm defending the alt-right's ability to use Twitter for expression and talk with themselves, and with people that have shown interest in their ideas. If they're off brigading every source they disagree with all the time with harassment and memes, that's a different issue, and Twitter should be wielding the banhammer in an egalitarian fashion on all groups behaving this way (per the views they hold themselves to.)
In this statement, you are unilaterally making a rule as to what ideals are OK to hold as part of "civilized society", and where the boundary is. Stating your society is more "civilized" than another is an opinion in and of itself, and arguably those who hold views opposite yours likely think your societal views also contain hints of barbarism or offend human nature.
There are multiple ethical views that humanity and even this culture have held throughout the past century alone that the predominant society has now decided are reprehensible, that other nations consider reprehensible, and then there are also views that have been considered reprehensible now widely accepted by this culture.
Personally, my beef is not with whether or not people agree or disagree with these views; the argument in this subthread is external to my original message:
I'm tired of the Valley's progressive ideology consistently espousing acceptance, free organization, and free speech when we as an industry keep taking steps that seem against it when we disagree with the information provided. It is the message of social media: people should be able to communicate and unite worldwide. If we aren't radically upholding this belief, then we need to change the mantra to be aligned to what it actually means: associate with us, our ideas, and our worldview, and we will give you a voice. If you don't, your voice on this platform will be stripped, even if you are not engaged in attacking those that disagree with you.
When leftists think "Right wing" in the US think of the Christian theocracy. However, conservatism is only one sect of the right. The right is also reactionary, and the alt-right is definitely reactionary. I'd argue the alt-right fits nicely into Wikipedia's definition of far-right politics [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Far-right_politics
Edited because my sarcastic use of tone didn't really have a place in the discussion.
If we are truly building a society of tolerance, whether or not one has a visceral reaction to an idea should not stop whether or not one can discuss and debate it. I'm not a neo-Nazi, but I've talked at length with them about their views. I will give anyone a few minutes to explain what they are about, try to listen to it neutrally, and form my own opinion. My personal conclusion of neo-Nazism is that it is a way for white men that feel they have no economic opportunity to blame a convenient target, and they try to rationalize Nazi Germany's domestic infrastructural successes as a reason why the country was doing what was right. I think it is a prime example of scapegoating, and I find it violent and hateful.
If we are paying lip service to tolerance and acceptance of alternative worldviews to make ourselves feel like better progressives, we are doing our views a disservice and acting more hypocritical than those that blatantly wear radical views of censorship and discrimination.
It's unfair and highly inaccurate to say that Twitter is turning a blind eye to terrorists on the platform. However, I'd be interested to know what radical leftist organizers are doing to use the Twitter platform and how many of them have ended up banned as well.
But let's scope this out for a second, neutrally: if the subculture is sharing information that is against the political status quo to its own adherents, and it is organizing for its beliefs, should it be censored because its belief is fundamentally unpopular, especially when it is so far maligned from the political views of Silicon Valley? If Twitter aims to be a neutral platform, dissent takes more forms than just those that we agree with. It's being able to express, share, and debate those views that we can come to agreements on things.
The alt-right movement is in the crosshairs because a lot of people are still reeling from the election, myself included, and people are trying to find any and every excuse as to why Clinton didn't wrap this one up like it seemed to be happening in the exit polls and on the coastal cities. The alt right is popular, full of rage, and more than a little scary to some of us, but I don't think that means they should be instantly suppressed. Only hearing what politics are agreeable to you is how these types of movements rise in the first place.
First, the GRSecurity patchset contains a kernel-level USB whitelist, so you can whitelist only known USB devices. A targeted attacker could attempt to spoof an existing/whitelisted USB device, but it does significantly harden the USB attack surface:
1. https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Allow_only_known_usb_devices
Clearly this only helps Linux people. For those using Linux/BSD/macOS, There's also usbkill, a Python-based antiforensic tool that just kills the computer if a device is inserted/removed that isn't on its whitelist: https://github.com/hephaest0s/usbkill
While this won't stop Samy's box from starting to do its thing, it will at least shut the computer off and mitigate some of the potential damage. usbkill is in the Homebrew repositories for macOS as well. If you have fully encrypted disks and strong passphrases, this is still going to ruin somebody's day trying to use this device.
Yes. In America, this is pretty much how it is. Without a violent criminal record or a restraining order for domestic violence, in a lot of states you can go spend a couple hundred bucks and have yourself a nice handgun.
I am curious just how deep the "firearms business" goes on the dark web. I suspect the majority of sellers are not capable of delivering. Most arms dealers on Tor are pretty well known to be scamming people.
The Watch Edition showed that there's a step too far for them, but it's not the definition you used. Nobody bought the thing. We had to get into the five figures for that to happen, though, and it's because Apple didn't fully understand the luxury watch market isn't entirely driven by how expensive the thing is.
That said, Apple has been pushing the luxo market for quite some time, even before the watch. There has almost always been cheaper items than Apple products that fulfill roughly the same niche. iPhones are often a status symbol, and now having the newest one is, now that they are ubiquitous.
The fact that they are somehow supremely useful sometimes falls out for the sake of design. Remember the little iPod shuffle that had absolutely no buttons that they marketed like jewelry? What about the headphone-less iPhone 7 or the Thunderbolt 3 / USB-C only new MBP? Going older, what about the 20th Anniversary Mac, the G4 Cube, or the iMac which didn't come with a floppy drive and nearly everyone bought that Bondi Blue SuperDrive thing?
Remember, any privacy project could use this help. All of them want to be accessible to the end user, including old-school tools like GnuPG. Often times these security engineers aren't very UX oriented and we like our command lines. Build good interfaces on top of them. Although a shitty name, Felony looked good for this: https://github.com/henryboldi/felony
Someone else asked a similar question in another Ask HN earlier, and I replied with this:
> Welcome to the fray.
> First: decide what your skills are, and where you can contribute.
> Try the Tor Project first:
> https://www.torproject.org/getinvolved/volunteer.html.en
> The community is great there and very accepting of newbies that have the skills.
> Signal / open whisper systems also are open source and accept pull requests:
> https://github.com/whispersystems/
> Read the anonbib:
> http://freehaven.net/anonbib/
> Also, there are other mixnet/darknet projects that could use help, such as i2p:
> https://geti2p.net/en/get-involved
> And if you want decentralized, mesh communications, cjdns and the Hyperboria experiment:
Get involved with any of it. Push for the user, fight for the user. Make it accessible and message the shit out of it. All of them have their merits and any work toward any of them is progress.