HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michael_nielsen

8,027 karma · joined July 24, 2007

https://michaelnotebook.com
submissionscomments
michael_nielsen··on The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume I
Thanks for doing this, Michael, it's awesome that this is now available!

I notice the material is copyright Caltech. Any chance that they'd consider releasing it under an open license? A CC-BY license would enable this material to be repurposed and improved in all kinds of interesting ways.

michael_nielsen··on Poll: Would you vote online if you could?
Online voting has been used on a significant scale in several places, including Estonia, Gujarat, and some cantons in Switzerland. I'm not an expert on how well (or poorly) these experiments have gone, but the following article contains a lot of useful information and pointers:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_voting_examples

Estonia was apparently the first country to allow internet voting in a general election. Participation has grown rapidly, with roughly a quarter of votes in the last parliamentary election being cast online:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_voting_in_Estonia

This suggests that a large fraction of the population are unlikely to care about the theoretical considerations that are dominating the discussion elsewhere in this thread.

Voting by mobile phone is also now legal in Estonia.

The latest Python source code for the servers in the Estonian voting system is available on GitHub:

https://github.com/vvk-ehk/evalimine

Incidentally, I got a smile out of the sampling bias inherent in this poll! It would have been even funnier if the question was "Would you ever take part in an online poll?"

michael_nielsen··on How to Convince Investors
"But while Microsoft did really well and there is thus a temptation to think they would have seemed a great bet a few months in, they probably didn't. Good, but not great. No company, however successful, ever looks more than a pretty good bet a few months in."

As an example, Bessemer Venture Partners passed on investing in Apple, Google, Intel, eBay, FedEx, and many other big companies. Their "anti-portfolio" makes amazing reading, and vividly demonstrates how hard it is to pick winners:

http://www.bvp.com/portfolio/antiportfolio

michael_nielsen··on How to Convince Investors
"Inexperienced founders... try to convince with their pitch. Most would be better off if they let their startup do the work—if they started by understanding why their startup is worth investing in, then simply explained this well to investors."

This advice applies to many things in life -- getting a job, proposing marriage, networking in general.

For instance, I've occasionally met people who obsess about crafting the perfect CV. For many of those people (not all) if they'd brought the same level of intensity to doing good work in the past, they'd be fighting off would-be employers, without any need to sprinkle pixie dust on their CV. Ditto people who try to find some magical method for networking. Do awesome work, and networking becomes mostly a matter of showing up and saying plainly and understandably what you've done.

michael_nielsen··on Alan Turing's Best Productivity Tricks
Turing was very good at finding good problems, and then had the courage to work on them.

The Lifehacker list is amusing, at best. I quickly run out of fingers and toes if I count the mathematicians I know who are runners, have messy desks, and break big problems down into small problems. Few, if any, of them are near to having Turing's influence.

michael_nielsen··on Lessons From a 125 Year Old Business
This list of the world's oldest companies may also be of interest:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_companies

Remarkable to see companies that have lasted more than 1,000 years! And sad to see that Kongo Gumi - a Japanese construction compnay - shut down in 2006, after being founded in 578 CE.

michael_nielsen··on Edit Wars Reveal The Most Controversial Topics on Wikipedia
Or consider this list of the _lamest_ edit wars:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Lamest_edit_wars

Everything from edit wars over fictional waterfowl to the correct size of the Death Star in Star Wars. Read at your own risk.

michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: Has anyone here self-published a book? Any advice?
Do you happen to know if createspace have good distribution through Ingram (who own Barnes and Noble)? Or through independent booksellers? Or are they mainly through Amazon?
michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: Has anyone here self-published a book? Any advice?
A related question about making books freely available:

I'm currently writing a book about neural networks and deep learning. Ideally I'd like to make the book freely available online, with paid ebook and hard copy versions. But I'm uncertain about the impact a free online version will have on sales revenue. Anyone with much hard evidence? Or suggestions for how to make a reasonable amount of money, while keeping the book freely available?

michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: Has anyone here self-published a book? Any advice?
A subquestion, if I may: Anyone know a good way of finding designers for the cover? Preferably designers who've done some work in publishing before, since what makes a good book / ebook cover is not the same as what makes a good website design.
michael_nielsen··on Show HN: How I Wish Scientific Papers Were Displayed
I'm not sure I see why you'd want separate columns for X, Y, etc. Why not have one margin, and use it for theorems, definitions, etc?
michael_nielsen··on Show HN: How I Wish Scientific Papers Were Displayed
I like it!

Clicking on a link and having a figure appear solves a small but real problem.

In mathematical papers it'd be nice to be able to do the same with equation references --- click on the equation number, and the equation would magically appear in the margin. Ditto bibliography entries, theorem statements, definitions, and so on. I guess there are possible solutions other than having them appear in the margin, too.

michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
No, I've published two books previously with traditional companies, and wanted to try something new.
michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
My largest current project is writing a book about neural networks and deep learning.
michael_nielsen··on A Brief History of the Internet (1999)
Without getting into what Al Gore may have said or meant, let me quote the following lovely little tidbit from Paul Ginsparg (who created arxiv.org). It's about physicist Ken Wilson, but Al Gore and Newt Gingrich make a fascinating appearance:

"He [Wilson] was on the NSF taskforce that pushed for the implementation of the early NSFNet, and I was told by George Strawn (one of the people on the NSF side shepherding the process) that Ken was the key person who argued for using the TCP/IP (i.e., internet) protocol, rather than the DECnet protocol favored by many of the other physicists, and we know where that has led… (George also told me that the absolutely essential people who moved the NSFNet through the senate and house, respectively, were … Al Gore, Jr and Newt Gingrich)"

http://quantumfrontiers.com/2013/06/18/we-are-all-wilsonians...

michael_nielsen··on Rare Cancer Seen In 41 Homosexuals (1981)
Nice catch. Additional data point: I saw it when it came out, and it was obvious it was AIDS. I guess that's a piece of history that's gradually fading now.
michael_nielsen··on Booz Allen Hamilton hiring quantum information physicist
BAH was hiring in quantum information as early as the late 1990s, if I recall correctly. Certainly they were doing so by the early 2000s. It's not surprising that BAH is interested: the NSA and DARPA have been funding research on quantum computing since the mid-1990s.

(I worked in the field from 1992 through 2008.)

Edit: See, for example, this 2004 article on "Quantum networks: from quantum cryptography to quantum architecture", with several BAH authors, including the lead author: http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1039117&dl=ACM&coll=DL&CFI... This took a few seconds to find with Google, I wouldn't be surprised to find earlier examples.

michael_nielsen··on An Ill-Advised Personal Note about "Media for Thinking the Unthinkable"
It's been submitted at least three times. All three submissions disappeared off the front page, and two are dead, because it's being flagged. The fact that it's being flagged -- multiple times, I believe -- makes me sad.
michael_nielsen··on D-Wave: Truth finally starts to emerge
Glad you enjoyed the videos (I created them)! Unfortunately, that link has the videos in reverse order. Here they are in the intended order:

http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/quantum-computing-for-the-det...

The main thing that's needed to follow along is familiarity and comfort with basic linear algebra.

michael_nielsen··on Every odd number greater than five is the sum of three primes
Very amusing. Here's a proof by contradiction, for the record. Assume that there are only a finite number, n, of prime numbers. There are at most n^3 distinct odd numbers that can be formed as a sum of three of those primes. But n^3 is finite, and so the number of odd numbers must be finite, which is, of course, false, and so our original assumption must have been false. QED

There are some hilarious variations on this theme (using difficult theorems to prove simple facts) here: http://mathoverflow.net/questions/42512/awfully-sophisticate...

michael_nielsen··on What a stupid idea
The moral of this isn't that stupid ideas are good. It's that unfamiliar insights can be hard to understand and recognize, even for smart people. The right question to ask when confronted with something new isn't "What's wrong with this?" It's "What's the most interesting new insight(s) here?" A lot of smart people like to ask the first question at the expense of the second, and that's a mistake.
michael_nielsen··on The Square Root of Not
If you enjoyed this article, you may enjoy my series of short videos on "Quantum Computing for the Determined", which go deeper into the subject than this article, while remaining accessible to anyone with some basic background in linear algebra. The videos provide an intro to quantum mechanics, and cover the basic quantum computing model, as well as quantum teleportation and superdense coding:

http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/quantum-computing-for-the-det...

(Apologies for the self-plug, but this particular article seems like a good prelude to my course.)

michael_nielsen··on A non-mathematical explanation of one way functions
See the discussion of this point at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5530988 (and child comments)
michael_nielsen··on A non-mathematical explanation of one way functions
Here's a rough draft that would, I think, only reinforce the 'aha' moment. It could be inserted as the third last paragraph:

"There's a potential problem with this procedure. What if Alice had started with some other word - say 'FILES' - and following this procedure also led to the word 'THINGS'. In fact, it might be that many, many English words all lead to the word 'THINGS'. If that were so then Bob would be justified in feeling skeptical that Alice had solved the crossword. She'd be using a "bad" one-way function. Both Alice and Bob need to be confident that this procedure doesn't lead to too many collision between English words. This is a challenge that needs to be addressed if you want to prove that a function is truly a good one-way function."

michael_nielsen··on A non-mathematical explanation of one way functions
You could easily turn a bug into a feature: add a couple of paragraphs to your post pointing out exactly this potential problem, and how you you could test to see whether or not it really is a problem. Your post (which is already terrific) then becomes a great explanation of why not all functions work as one-way functions, and what it means for something to be a good one-way function.
michael_nielsen··on Neural Network Visualisation in Clojure
Andrew Ng has a fantastic example of visualizing deep belief nets:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmNOAtZIgIk

The example starts at about 18:20. You really need to have watched the previous material to understand it, but the basic idea is that he's plotting the hierarchy of features learned by successive layers of a deep neural net (a sparse autoencoder, IIRC, it's been a while since I watched it).

michael_nielsen··on Ask HN: What's the best technical talk you've heard?
Doug Engelbart's mother of all demos (1968):

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY

This is the talk that, according to Wikipedia, included the first public demonstration of the following technologies: the computer mouse, video conferencing, teleconferencing, hypertext, word processing, hypermedia, object addressing and dynamic file linking, bootstrapping, and a collaborative real-time editor. Pretty good for one talk!

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mother_of_All_Demos

michael_nielsen··on The Disposable Academic: Why doing a PhD is often a waste of time (2010)
I wonder when the first article was written claiming that doing a PhD was a waste of time? I'll bet it was in the 19th century. And we'll no doubt keep seeing such articles until such time as the PhD fades from history.

(Nothing against the article in question, which is a better-than-usual discussion of the issue.)

michael_nielsen··on My Interview Questions for Potential Employers
It doesn't matter. What does matter is how strong a commitment is shown to principle. Giving up a million-dollar contract because it supported something shady is impressive. By contrast, someone who ums and ahs and comes out with something lame may well be someone who always puts themself first.
michael_nielsen··on My Interview Questions for Potential Employers
"Describe a time you chose principle over immediate short-term interests."

This question can be asked of a prospective boss, a co-worker, or adapted to the company as a whole.

← PreviousPage 6 of 17Next →