8,027 karma · joined July 24, 2007
The linked blog post provides a reasonable summary.
Metrics to track might include the number of comments made, number of hits on the site, number of upvotes / downvotes, and probably many more.
Some people obviously feel strongly about this issue, and it might be necessary to take steps to prevent gaming of the outcome. Keeping the metrics secret until after the test would help with this. So would publicly announcing that only a small (say 10%) but undisclosed subset of users will be used to determine the outcomes of the testing. So any individual user wouldn't know if their behaviour would affect the results, and so would have little incentive to waste their time trying to affect the outcome.
It'd be nice to take a data-driven approach to resolving this question.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Billiard-ball_computer
The punchline is that (idealized, friction free) billiard balls + billiard ball "mirrors" (for the balls to bounce off) are enough to do universal computation! To reverse the computation, just reverse all the billiard balls.
On average, better than TED, in my opinion, although quality is of course variable.
EDIT: A free pdf of a draft of the paper is at: http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1009/1009.6126v2.pdf. A quick skim suggests that at 14 qubits the state they actually prepare in the lab is, indeed, not very similar to the state they intend to prepare, with a reported fidelity of about 50%. That's the same fidelity they'd get if they just prepared an all |0> state. While the paper reports terrifically interesting work, this and many other details in the paper suggest quite a subtle picture.
"If all you want to do is figure things out, why do you need to write anything... Expressing ideas helps to form them. Indeed, helps is far too weak a word. Most of what ends up in my essays I only thought of when I sat down to write them. That's why I write them... Just as inviting people over forces you to clean up your apartment, writing something that other people will read forces you to think well."
So why not write an essay on how to build large online communities?
It's very broad by comparison with most lists of this nature. Here is a HN discussion of Kay's list: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=664324
E.g., if someone doesn't like techcrunch.com, they can add it to their blacklist, and they will no longer see techcrunch.com stories.
There's maybe a dozen sites (TC isn't one of them) which regularly appear on HN, and which I'd be happy not to see. But I know others don't feel this way about those sites. This seems like a relatively easy way of improving everyone's experience.
We could imagine, then, that what's going on is that the Universe really runs according to the laws of one of these non-linear variants of quantum mechanics, but the power-beyond-the-powers has arranged so that at the length scales that can be probed by the races in Vinge's story things look effectively like standard (linear) QM.
The thing that bothers me a bit about the Zones: how is it that humans think? We are, after all, just machines. So if AI can't be built, then how is human consciousness possible?
I'd be interested to know what (if any) response Vinge has to this. A possible-but-not-very-satisfactory response is that life on Earth is really an artifact from another Zone, and one that goes beyond ordinary Slow Zone capabilities. What prevents us from building AI is that we can't reproduce those capabilities. Seems a bit of a stretch.
The overall picture seems to be this:
* What we think of as the "laws of physics" in any given Zone are actually a kind of VM layer, running on top of some (unknown) physics.
* The implementation is done through extraordinarily tiny machines. What we see as quarks, leptons etc (and the laws they follow) are in reality complex machines made of far smaller constituents.
* The implementation was probably done by some power-beyond-the-powers that lives in the center of the galaxy. It uses the Zones as a protective device - civilizations in the Slow Zone, the Beyond and the Transcend have only relatively limited abilities, unless they can break through the virtualization layer. (That, incidentally, is why the Blight is such a threat in AFUTD, and why the Zones change so much in response.)
If you read both books with this set of ideas in mind, a whole lot of otherwise puzzling scenes and one-off observations in the books make a great deal more sense. There's no reason to call the Zones unscientific.
It's an absolutely extraordinary video (watch closely!), and anyone who can create stuff like this will be able to do whatever they want. More background in this New York Times article: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/18/science/18prof.html?_r=3
http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/lectures-on-the-google-techno...
Skip past the opening, and down to "Basic Description of PageRank". The article eventually gets somewhat technical, but hopefully this at least helps explain the basics. Incidentally, I don't use the term "eigenvector" in the article, but when we're analysing an equation like Mq =q, that's an eigenvector equation!