HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

michaelkeenan

1,213 karma · joined June 9, 2008

michael.keenan@gmail.com

michaelkeenan.net

michaelkeenan.blogspot.com

submissionscomments
michaelkeenan··on How a Medieval Society Withstood Nearly 60 Years of Drought
I haven't read it yet myself, but John Ringo's Black Tide Rising series is on my reading list with this note from a rationalist-fiction-loving friend of mine: "There'll be like twenty pages of epic zombie fighting, and then thirty pages on the logistics of salvaging supplies from abandoned ships. And the characters are complicated and nuanced but nearly everyone is super competent (or dies)."
michaelkeenan··on A Million-Dollar Cancer Treatment: Who Will Pay?
I think you're mixing up different news reports. Cuba reduced their mother-child HIV transmission using five generic antiretrovirals that were invented in the USA and Canada: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2688320/

I'm not sure what would be a perfectly comprehensive metric for health innovations by country. Drug patents might be sort of close[1], but maybe Cuba doesn't apply for patents on principled grounds. For Cuba, it would be helpful to know the ratio of the USA using drugs or other innovations developed in Cuba versus American ones used in Cuba. I hear that drug development can cost billions of dollars[2] so I'd be surprised if Cuba could afford it, but maybe they've done it. Anyone know of any new drugs invented in Cuba?

[1] e.g. https://www.americanactionforum.org/weekly-checkup/new-drug-...

[2] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/cost-to-develop-n...

michaelkeenan··on A Million-Dollar Cancer Treatment: Who Will Pay?
>> we would not have nearly as much innovation in medicine without a profit motive

> Most economists? That feels like a claim in need of a citation

The usual best place for finding out what economists think is the IGM Economics Experts Panel[1]. I mention it because it's a great resource to be aware of, but they haven't addressed this question, though it's covered in textbooks. I checked the Mankiw textbook on Principles of Microeconomics[2], which if I'm not mistaken is the world's most popular one. In the introduction, it says that people tend to supply things when the returns are high:

"Incentives are crucial to analyzing how markets work. For example, when the price of an apple rises, people decide to eat fewer apples. At the same time, apple orchards decide to hire more workers and harvest more apples. In other words, a higher price in a market provides an incentive for buyers to consume less and an incentive for sellers to produce more. As we will see, the influence of prices on the behavior of consumers and producers is crucial for how a market economy allocates scarce resources."

That becomes a background assumption for discussion of incentives in the rest of the book. For example, when talking about externalities, it notes that the patent system increases the incentive to innovate:

"Research into new technologies provides a positive externality because it creates knowledge that other people can use. Because inventors cannot capture the full benefits of their inventions, they tend to devote too few resources to research. The federal government addresses this problem partially through the patent system, which gives inventors exclusive use of their inventions for a limited time."

[1] http://www.igmchicago.org/igm-economic-experts-panel

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greg_Mankiw#Textbooks

michaelkeenan··on Things I Learned from a Job Hunt for a Senior Engineering Role
Downvotes might be from CMV-norm people[1] thinking "that's bullshit" is rude/inflammatory and unfit for HN.

[1] https://changemyview.net/2018/03/28/thats-bullshit-rude-enou...

michaelkeenan··on Review of Steven Pinker’s Enlightenment Now
If we trace an idea (like abolition or gender equality) back to its beginnings, we'd expect to find that the idea was controversial. It must take time for an idea to persuade people, even others of the same movement (who might be primarily focused on other aspects of the movement).

So I think it can make sense to praise Enlightenment-era anti-slavery thinkers and attribute their anti-slavery to their ideals (especially if that's their explicit reasoning), even if not every Enlightenment thinker was anti-slavery. Wikipedia's article on the Age of Enlightenment lists eight major figures[1]. Of those, four are notable for their opposition to slavery[2].

That method shows less support for gender equality being traceable to the Enlightenment. As far as I can tell, none of the eight major figures supported gender equality. A few of Wikipedia's longer list of Enlightenment intellectuals[3] did (e.g. Marquis de Condorcet, John Locke and Mary Wollstonecraft). If they were the first-ever feminists on the path that led to modern feminism, that's evidence that Enlightenment ideals sparked that. But if the base rate of feminist thinkers was similar in the period before the Enlightenment, then it wouldn't appear that the Enlightenment helped. I don't know the answer to that, though for what it's worth, the Wikipedia article on the history of feminism[4] has a whole section called 18th century: the Age of Enlightenment, so it seems that the writers of that article thought the Enlightenment was relevant.

[1] Beccaria, Diderot, Hume, Kant, Montesquieu, Rousseau, Adam Smith, and Voltaire - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_Enlightenment

[2] Montesquieu, Rousseau, Adam Smith, and Voltaire

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_intellectuals_of_the_E...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_feminism#18th_centu...

michaelkeenan··on California should emulate Tokyo, where housing stayed ahead of population growth
Economists call this a transitional gains trap. Here's an economist discussing it (and a theoretical solution):

https://offsettingbehaviour.blogspot.com/2009/09/transitiona...

michaelkeenan··on Effect of longer-term modest salt reduction on blood pressure (2013)
It's more trustworthy than one study because it's a systematic review of many other studies. Reviews of good studies are the best form of evidence[1].

This review was conducted by Cochrane[2]. Cochrane reviews are widely regarded as the best and most rigorous reviews.

[1] http://www.essentialevidenceplus.com/product/ebm_loe.cfm?sho...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cochrane_(organisation)

michaelkeenan··on Walmart will soon have robots roaming the aisles in 50 stores
The 18th century version of this was not using an umbrella to preserve demand for coach drivers:

"Over the years, Hanway and his umbrella fell victim to all sorts of abuse from Brits he passed on the sidewalk. The most pernicious abuse came from an unlikely source: coach drivers. In England at the time, hansom cabs (two-wheeled, horse-drawn carriages) and sedan chairs were the primary modes of transportation. Business boomed especially on rainy days, as both hansom cabs and sedan chairs came equipped with small canopies that kept passengers dry. When it rained, Londoners flocked to these coaches, so Hanway’s umbrella represented a threat to business.

Fearing an interruption in their personal incomes, many hansom cab drivers and sedan chair carriers grew violent toward Hanway. According to the British history magazine Look and Learn, when they saw him walking by, they often “pelted him with rubbish.” On one occasion, a hansom cab driver even tried to run Hanway over with his coach. Hanway reacted by using his umbrella to “give the man a good thrashing.”" - https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/the-public-shaming-of-...

michaelkeenan··on 75% decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas
We're on! Can you email me at michael.keenan [at] gmail so we can be in touch?
michaelkeenan··on 75% decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas
I'd like to bet against civilization collapsing by January 1, 2020. Given how dire that scenario is, I see the problem ceejayoz pointed out where there might not be much value to money at that point. But maybe we can bet on a precursor, like a stock market crash. There are probably scenarios where the stock market crashes first, but there's still time to use money before civilizational collapse.

I think we can solve it like this: if the S&P 500 drops below 50% of today's value (which is 2,562, so the trigger number is 1281), I'll send you $100 immediately, which is hopefully enough time to use that money for buying survival supplies before everything collapses. If that hasn't happened by January 1, 2020, you donate $100 to GiveWell[1].

It's an imperfect measure - I might accidentally lose it due to a nuclear war, but you still might pointlessly win it in a world where the collapse happens extremely quickly, and have a worthless $100 if I'm even still alive and able to use PayPal. But maybe it's good enough?

Want to take that bet, or suggest something else?

[1] https://www.givewell.org/

michaelkeenan··on 75% decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas
Bet on it happening in another continent? Bet on a precursor?
michaelkeenan··on 75% decline over 27 years in total flying insect biomass in protected areas
If you make that a specific prediction, I might like to bet against it, if you're interested.
michaelkeenan··on On Becoming the Enemy
The trend looks good: https://ourworldindata.org/genocides/

According to that source, in 2012, for the first time in at least a hundred years, there were no ongoing genocides.

michaelkeenan··on Trolls are winning the internet, technologists say
The author is a prominent woman journalist, so her experience of the internet probably involves more harassment than most people's.
michaelkeenan··on Startup Serves Up Chicken Produced From Cells in Lab
> this is not going to be replacing real meat from animals anytime soon

Put your prediction on PredictionBook? It's a great way to keep track of your predictions, and learn to be calibrated (e.g. to have about 80% of your predictions-of-80%-likelihood be correct, which doesn't come naturally to people).

http://predictionbook.com/

michaelkeenan··on Healthy California Act: proposal to make findings about single-payer healthcare
I don't think California will negotiate prices down by 50%, and I would bet on that (conditional on this bill passing). Anyone - old-gregg? - want to take that bet at even odds? I suggest using the total cost of one each from the list of medical services in old-gregg's second footnote - angiogram, office visit, angioplasty, etc. I'm also open to other terms.

(Studies show[0] that people answer politically-charged questions more accurately when paid for accuracy, so I think we'd have better debates if people bet on their predictions.)

[0] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/06/17/political-vi...

michaelkeenan··on Uber’s vice president of product and growth Ed Baker has resigned
Put your prediction on PredictionBook? It's a great way to keep track of your predictions, and learn to be calibrated (e.g. to have about 80% of your predictions-of-80%-likelihood be correct, which doesn't come naturally to people).

http://predictionbook.com/

michaelkeenan··on New Zealand Will Give You a Free Trip If You Agree to a Job Interview
There have been a couple of high-profile cases of this. A prestigious mathematician had lived in New Zealand for four years, but his autistic son was declined residency, so he and his family left: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/16/prestigious-ac...

A woman in a wheelchair was declined residency due to her paralysis, despite working and having family in New Zealand: http://m.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=...

michaelkeenan··on A profound apology
Anyone have any evidence about whether that's true?
michaelkeenan··on When You Are Depressed, Make Something
This seems like good advice, but it's based on one example. If you want depression advice from a psychiatrist who's reviewed the academic literature on depression, try Things That Sometimes Help If You Have Depression from Slate Star Codex: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/16/things-that-sometimes-h...
michaelkeenan··on My Unhappy Life as a Climate Heretic
I think you're mistakenly interpreting that quotation as claiming that there is no relationship between temperature increase and catastrophe losses. But it instead makes narrower claims, such as: he was right to question the report; the graph was based on inaccurate information; the later data didn't show a relationship between temperature increase and catastrophe losses.

If he'd written something like "Because there is no relationship between temperature increase and catastrophes, as proven by the insufficient evidence to support that, I was right to question the report", then you'd be right. But he didn't say that. I think he's only saying that he was right to question the report because that graph was inaccurate and invented, and because later data showed there was insufficient evidence for the relationship it was supposed to show. If reports shouldn't contain inaccurate and invented data, especially invented data that isn't similar to empirical data, then he was right to question it.

michaelkeenan··on Homeschooling as a right, and a needed practical alternative
> This is not a view shared by developmental psychologists.

I was curious about this, so I searched for developmental psychology on the difference between mixed-age and same-age socialization. But what I found (from a very brief search) didn't match what you said. An example study is this - Children’s Social Behavior in Relation to Participation in Mixed-Age or Same-Age Classrooms:

"Findings suggested a significant positive effect on children’s prosocial behavior as a result of participation in a mixed-age classroom context. In addition, fewer children appeared to experience social isolation in mixed-age classrooms than in same-age classrooms. Aggressive behaviors were significantly less likely to be noted by teachers in mixed-age than in same-age classrooms." - http://ecrp.uiuc.edu/v1n1/mcclellan.html

But that's just one study. Is it an area of ongoing debate in development psychology? What sources would you recommend for the other side?

michaelkeenan··on Married to someone with anxiety
I get a different impression from the post. Rather than quitting and marriage solving the problem immediately, I think she still has anxiety, because he wrote: "She still has anxiety, and I imagine she always will. But we are able to deal with this in a much more productive way. Sure, there are times where it all gets a bit too much"

I don't think it's correct to say "None of the therapy stuff did them any good" because therapy isn't mentioned in the post. If you meant counseling, he mentioned that positively, in the context of the useful decision to quit the job: "we found a private counsellor who could help get to the route of what was causing some of this anxiety — we then discussed a lot of these sessions and reflected on them and tried to put into practice some of the advice we were receiving. We also made big and brave decisions like my wife quitting her exhausting job up in London"

michaelkeenan··on Professors Make More Than a Thousand Dollars an Hour Peddling Mega-Mergers
I searched for that Krugman quote and found nothing. I think he never wrote it. I think that is exemplary of the problem here - not that economists struggle with facts, but that most people struggle with facts, including facts about other people struggling with facts.

I recommend this article at The Atlantic about what economists agree on. It has citations to surveys of economists: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/04/4-politi...

michaelkeenan··on Finland plans to replace classic school subjects with broader “topics” (2015)
This article gets all its information on from this article from the Independent: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/finland-schoo...

I suggest changing the link to point to the Independent article (and also changing the exaggerated title to the more informative Independent headline).

michaelkeenan··on Verified Voting
The USA is still slightly an epistocracy because there's a civics test before long-term residents gain the right to vote[1]. I think this element of epistocracy is fine; it's not deliberately racist like the other tests were. There are many possible epistocracies.

Some epistocratic measures could decrease oppression of specific demographics, rather than increase it. We currently ban children from voting, presumably because they'd cast bad votes. But if there was a way to measure ability to vote well, then we could let children vote if they have that capability. If there is legal oppression of children (which seems likely, since there's been oppression every other time a non-voting demographic had laws that specifically target them), then the voting children should be able to decrease that. An example of a bad law oppressing children was the Canadian ban against them carrying asthma inhalers in school. Thankfully, this law has changed, but not before it killed someone[2].

Specifically, my proposal is that we adjust the disenfranchisement of citizens that we currently do (of children, felons in some states, and the mentally incapacitated) with a civics test where they can vote if they pass. The civics test for long-term residents might be fine as it is. It seems really easy to me, but maybe that's desirable.

[1] https://my.uscis.gov/prep/test/civics

[2] http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/ontario-mom-urges-schoo...

michaelkeenan··on Seattle: Highest Minimum Wage, Lowest Unemployment Rate
This doesn't affect the overall point, but the "lowest unemployment rate" part of the headline is annoyingly unsupported. Googling "lowest unemployment city in the usa" shows a Google featured snippet listing Sioux Falls as the city with the lowest unemployment rate at 2.1%, which is lower than Seattle's rate.

Edit: turns out the "highest minimum wage" part is also wrong. Seattle's minimum wage is currently $11/hour, and Washington DC's minimum wage is $11.50. (If this is confusing after reading the article, it's because the article didn't mention that the $15/hour rate doesn't start until 2021.)

michaelkeenan··on Municipal ISP forced to shut off fiber-to-the-home Internet after court ruling
> nor is it too much regulation, it's too little

I think the framing of regulation as a spectrum of less to more is unhelpful. We don't need more regulation, we need better regulation. Some better is more; sometimes it's less.

michaelkeenan··on Municipal ISP forced to shut off fiber-to-the-home Internet after court ruling
I think I probably agree with something near your point, but I don't think your examples work. This case - where laws block the sale of internet services - isn't a case of not regulating markets in the hope that a free market magically appears. Rather, it's just bad law.

Healthcare is also not an example of not regulating markets; rather, it's one of the most regulated markets in the USA. Some of the regulations are net-harmful, leading to problems like the gigantic prices of monopolized products.

I think you're mistaken about high prices for monopolized pharmaceuticals being a new phenomenon. Are you referring to the EpiPen, Daraprim, Alcortin A, Novacort, and Aloquin price hikes? But high prices are typical in monopolized pharmaceuticals. For example, Harvoni costs $32,000 in the USA, while its generic version costs $900 in India. This kind of price difference between the monopoly price and non-monopoly price is common.

All that aside, I agree that we can often do better than just not regulating industries. Much care should be taken to craft helpful regulations, and perhaps some kind of technology or institution can be developed to inhibit regulatory capture.

michaelkeenan··on Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children
> as a parent you just want your kids to be happy

I think this isn't universal. "Tiger mother"-style parenting[1] doesn't seem optimized for happiness, and whatever impulse is behind punishing or occasionally murdering your children for premarital sex[2] doesn't seem happiness-focused either.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiger_mother

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Honor_killing

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →