> Variants (SNP/ InDel) generated with this method were compared with a normal dataset using Archer’s analysis pipeline to distinguish noise from a true call. The normal dataset was created with sequencing data from seven young, healthy individuals.
1,124 karma · joined May 3, 2017
> Variants (SNP/ InDel) generated with this method were compared with a normal dataset using Archer’s analysis pipeline to distinguish noise from a true call. The normal dataset was created with sequencing data from seven young, healthy individuals.
This is an observational study, and you may be analyzing it as a designed one. There was no randomization, no large scale matched control group per se—that wasn’t the intention. The intention is to analyze a specific population, and compare it to the existing literature on prevalence of mutations. That’s how these things are done, you have to use the citations given to understand the broader context of a study. One study is not useful on its own.
Also, there’s this—they did hypothesis tests against a control group:
> Variants (SNP/ InDel) generated with this method were compared with a normal dataset using Archer’s analysis pipeline to distinguish noise from a true call. The normal dataset was created with sequencing data from seven young, healthy individuals.
In seriousness, we can come up with lots of out-there scenarios. But this finding is intrinsically interesting enough to warrant discussion, critique, and further analysis.
Your critiques aren’t a failure of the system, or a “dunk” on the scientific establishment. This open, democratic dialogue is _the entire point of the scientific publication process._
I didn’t have the sense there was a value judgement (more/less severe), so much as that CHIP is “typical” mutation seen in the wider population, associated with aging (itself a fascinating field of research), whereas something novel / nonstandard is causing CH mutations (space?? That’s the implication).
On sample size, I read it as “this is interesting preliminary work that is surprisingly robust for the sample we have, and thus intrinsically notable.” But the passage you cite and the surrounding discussion indicates that this is far from conclusive—it’s a promising / interesting direction for more research to find out what’s the “there” there, if anything.
These things _could_ be coincidental, but such a high rate of consistency is strong signal to investigate further. This paper propagates that surprising result, which is also a unique analysis because of the lack of data the authors acknowledge. Without publishing this, others would have no access to even this preliminary finding.
This isn’t the “gotcha” you think it is.
You seem to be reacting to this article, which is a popular summary of the findings. I don’t even think it’s a misleading article—it conveys the qualitative conclusion (elevated rates of nonstandard mutations), and answers to the questions you posed are available in the full scientific study…
Since WA was released I’ve found it befuddling. It’s clever and cool…but what do I use it for?
I see the same problem here: lots of solutions (hook in your web app! Ask questions in natural language!) but not a lot of use cases. Why do students need WA to understand the difference in time scales for historical events? What’s the value added?
> What's the deal with there being a million edits on this page in one day? > Articles get edited a lot, for all kinds of reasons… The fact that a page is being edited doesn't itself mean something crazy is going on. It usually means someone is replacing a colon with a semicolon.
Maybe in principle, but 1 million edits?? That’s like 12 a second. Not impossibly large, but it feels disingenuous to claim “something crazy” isn’t going on. I doubt many other pages get edited 12 times a second for 24hr straight.
I do have an intense hate of crypto. Not sure why you want to ignore tulips — speculative financial instruments seem like a very valuable comparison to crypto… For my part, I object to (a) the sheer narcissism of the crypto community, which claims crypto is better but fails to address the basic use cases needed to gain any practical traction in the real world (fast transactions, insured deposits), and (b) the way that crypto is hyped and ends up with normal people being taken advantage of (celebrity endorsements then a crash, NFTs).
Crypto doesn’t seem to solve any problem, but it sure has contributed to fucking over a lot of regular people
> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading
It’s a really neat delve into the dungeons of procedurally generated adventures, and led to me getting hooked on Brogue [1]
Specifically, the process of positive reinforcement and challenging assumptions is a cornerstone of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy movement in psychology and counseling.
CBT has been shown to be as effective as medications at treating a wide range of mental health issues — depression, anxiety, obsessive compulsive, substance abuse, and so on.
Anecdotally, this type of reinforcement is hard, but worth it. By definition you are trying to retrain your brain to be wired to better habits than it’s trained to now. You’re violating your comfortable response with a decidedly different one. But after you’ve practiced enough, these methods can provide real relief for mental health.
But also as you said there should be an entire intake / triage conversation to understand things like family psychological / medical history, and to make informed decisions before trying any medication.
That’s not easy either…but it’s the best I’ve got at a certain point
The side effects of Wellbutrin are on average lesser than SSRIs, but be aware / mindful that SSRIs are a very wide class with varying side effects, targeting different symptoms. It can take some experimentation before you find the right fit, in terms of both relieving your depression and minimizing side effects.
In my experience, a psychiatrist will generally start with their “preferred” / go-to SSRI, but a good doctor should be attentive to your specific symptoms of depression, and your reaction to the side effect profile. Then you can start tinkering to see what works.
I've had great luck with antidepressants. They don't "solve" the problem, but they give me a bit more space to operate and work on my mental health. As others have said, symptoms of SSRIs can be managed.
Mindfulness meditation--clearing your thoughts and focusing on breathing--for 15min a day can feel transformative after a couple months. I've fallen off that, but I'd like to pick it back up.
There's lots of little things that can contribute to better mental health. Meditation, exercise, diet, sleep: all are factors. But it's not worth suffering through, and it's worth giving medication a shot (in my opinion).
Medication is not a commitment for life, it's an experiment to see if you can find something to help your symptoms.
I do _highly_ recommend sustaining a therapy relationship, and simultaneously working with a psychiatrist. I haven't found therapy very transformative, and it certainly hasn't solved my problems. But it does give me some support, and that's yet another helpful factor in getting by.
That said, as someone who uses notation for math regularly, I want to keep using notation. It’s a helpful tool, and it is an efficient and precise language.