HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mikegagnon

217 karma · joined May 20, 2011

I am a software engineer at Twitter. I am developing PuzzleCode.org, a programming video game for non programmers. I also run HellaSec, my part-time security-consulting gig.

http://mikegagnon.com

submissionscomments
mikegagnon··on Is It Nuts to Give to the Poor Without Strings Attached?
> "However, giving money to people on the street is not helping."

Recall, my goal isn't to solve their problems by giving them small amounts of money. I think to solve their problems we need to make society-wide changes. Under our current form of society, there will __always__ be people on the bottom.

My hope is that they can use my donation to temporarily boost their happiness. Similar to how when I spend $2 on a cupcake it temporarily boosts my happiness.

> "It's enabling."

My thesis is that I am not enabling their poverty. If we stopped giving them money, they (in aggregate) could not work themselves out of poverty --- because there isn't room for everyone to make money in our society. Recall, unemployment is non-zero.

> "Basically every city has some sort of program to help the homeless work themselves back into society in general."

I think these programs are important. But I don't think they should be the only mechanisms by which we contribute charity to impoverished people.

> "However, they do require the people participating in them to be fully "bought in". When you give a dollar to someone "down on their luck", you are really giving them just enough of a life-rope to keep from entering these programs (which require sobriety as a matter of course)."

It sounds like you are essentially saying that the homeless should be helped __exclusively__ through these programs. I disagree. Not everyone will benefit from those programs; not everyone is even elligile for admission. For instance, you point out non-sober people won't benefit. I don't think people are universally capable of curing themselves of addiction. Some people are unlucky and do not have the "will power" to overcome addiction. This comes back to my point about the possibility that free will might be an illusion: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience_of_free_will

> "You're not helping them."

I am helping them. They smile when I give them money, and then they use it in whatever way they think will improve their life.

> "They need to bottom out and seek help of their own free will. That's how the road to ending their homelessness truly begins."

I am glad you made that point because I think it illustrates the core of our disagreement. It seems you strongly believe in the existence of free will. You believe that people have a "choice." Whereas I am skeptical that free will exists.

I think it is plausible that impoverished people could literally have zero ability to "make choices" that could bring them out of poverty. I am lucky; they are not. I get to eat complimentary delicious food at work, whenever I want. I want to share my wealth directly with the unlucky.

mikegagnon··on Is It Nuts to Give to the Poor Without Strings Attached?
I am aware of one experiment that has shown that basic income can work: http://mondediplo.com/2013/05/04income

I don't think that's the real issue stopping basic income. I think the real issue is that the money has to come from somewhere --- specifically, the money would necessarily come from the high earners in society. And they would have to agree to basic income since in our current form of democracy the high-earners have a disproportionate influence on the law.

However, the world's economy has been changing, such that it might actually behoove high earners to donate a portion of their earnings to basic income. Specifically, as automation decreases the need for human labor, then profits go up and employment goes down. This has actually been the trend since the 1970's. And if employment goes down too much, then there won't be enough spending money in the population's hands to fuel further earnings and economic growth.

There is an excellent, short book by a couple of MIT economists that analyzes the economics of modern automation and makes the case for guaranteed income. "Race Against The Machine," by Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee.

mikegagnon··on Is It Nuts to Give to the Poor Without Strings Attached?
I regularly give small amounts of money directly to impoverished individuals I see on the street.

You raise some points that I've heard before, and I would like to address them all, and explain why I think it is rational for me to give money the way I do.

(1) "I would say that is a horrible waste of capital" to give money to meth addicts.

I give a dollar to whoever asks me for money. I can't tell who is a meth addict and who is not. I am sure much of my charity goes to alcohol, tobacco, marijuana, meth, and other drugs. I just consider that a cost of doing business. For every dollar I give out, some subset of that money goes to __non-drug use__. I think that is a good use of my capital.

(2) "Due to their lack of will power to 'succeed' rather than lack of opportunity."

There's a couple of things to say to this sentiment.

First, I often hear the notion that impoverished people have the opportunity to bring themselves out of poverty. That's not true. The world's economic system results in non-zero unemployment. Meaning there are more people who want jobs than there are available jobs. Thus there are inevitably many people who want to work but can't get it. The only way they can survive is through charity --- from either friends, family, strangers, the government, charities, etc.

The last point I'll make might be the most controversial, but it is also at the core of why I give money directly to impoverished people.

I am skeptical that "will power" exists in the literal sense. As in, I am skeptical that free will exists as much as people tend to intuitively believe. It seems to me that humans are just moist robot automatons whose actions are the result of their current physiological state and response to the stimuli on their senses. Some interesting scientific research has shown that humans can perceive more free will than they actually have. There is also some interesting philosophical arguments that suggest free will could be a complete illusion. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience_of_free_will

So I think it's possible that people who "lack of will power to "succeed"' are simply __unlucky__. And I happen to be lucky. I am smart, tenacious, hard-working, have relevant job skills and I happen to live in a society where those variables are rewarded with wealth.

It therefore makes sense to me to give people small amounts of money when they ask for it. It just might be the case that I am lucky and they are not.

I do not expect this money to solve any of their problems. But maybe the person I help will buy a tasty snack and their happiness will go up in those moments. Or maybe that person will buy a cheap ukulele and teach himself to play --- which happened the other day with someone I regularly give money to.

mikegagnon··on “People simply empty out”
> People aren't working in factories to put bread on the table, people are working in offices to pay for their next new car or big screen TV.

People are still working in factories to put bread on their tables. There is a huge amount of poverty in the world.

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty

mikegagnon··on Be a sociopath—or just act like one
I find the article repugnant; it glorifies selfishness.

'How to apply [rule #1] to your own life: Ignore "suggested donation" pleas at museums, always help yourself to more food and drinks at dinner parties and recline your seat all the way back when flying."'

I wish this article were meant as satire, but I don't think it is.

mikegagnon··on Be a sociopath—or just act like one
I find the article repugnant; it glorifies selfishness.

> How to apply [rule #1 ]to your own life: Ignore "suggested donation" pleas at museums, always help yourself to more food and drinks at dinner parties and recline your seat all the way back when flying."

I wish this article were meant as satire, but I don't think it is.

mikegagnon··on How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Worst New Warplane
I agree. I think Military Keynesianism is a bad economic policy.

I have seen lots of articles that discuss wasteful DoD spending. But I see very few that discuss __why__ the DoD spends money this way. And why it continues. This type of spending is not a new phenomenon.

To me these "why" questions are the most important and intellectually interesting aspects of these issues. But they are often ignored.

mikegagnon··on How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Worst New Warplane
There is always a debate about how much to spend and what to spend it on. I believe these issues are what primarily distinguish republicans from democrats.

I agree that Military Keynesianism is not the best way for the government to stimulate the economy. That does not change the fact that it is the de facto economic policy of the United States.

Here are some relevant analyses from inside and outside the Pentagon.

- Spinney's "Defense Power Games" http://www.dnipogo.org/fcs/def_power_games_98.htm * Chomsky's -

- "The Pentagon System" http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Chomsky/PentagonSystem_Cho....

mikegagnon··on How the U.S. and Its Allies Got Stuck with the World’s Worst New Warplane
The United States economy is based upon Military Keynesianism.

The federal government does not analyze spending the same way we do because __spending benefits the economy__, which is part of the government's responsibility. They intentionally spend money to stimulate the economy.

So when the military spends $1 trillion on planes, they are really trading $1 trillion for planes plus economic stimulus.

In other words, the planes don't literally cost $1 trillion. Rather the cost of the planes = $1 trillion minus the economic benefit of spending.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_Keynesianism

mikegagnon··on A Visit to Disney’s Magic Kingdom
This work does a great job espousing the Visual Information-Seeking Mantra: "Overview first, zoom and filter, then details-on-demand," a cornerstone of effective visualization . http://www.infovis-wiki.net/index.php/Visual_Information-See...
mikegagnon··on DOJ Elevated Its Charges Against Swartz Because Internet Rallied on His Behalf
In the American justice system the judge is part of the judicial branch and the prosecutor is part of the executive branch.

Prosecutors have a huge amount of discretion in their jobs. They can choose if they press charges and if so what charges to press.

In this case, there are allegations that the prosecution abused its power by retaliating against free speech.

The prosecutor allegedly said something along the lines of: Aaron Swartz was foolish to exercise free speech because it then went "‘from a human one-on-one level to an institutional level.’ The lead prosecutor said that on the institutional level cases are harder to manage both internally and externally"

I presume by "one-on-one" prosecution, the prosecutor meant it was one prosecutor against Aaron Swartz. But by publicizing the case, it aroused the interest of the "institution" (i.e. the higher ups), who then decided to throw the book at Swartz.

mikegagnon··on Obama to release FISA court opinion that ruled NSA surveillance unconstitutional
I don't think the world is so black and white.

If you pay taxes to the federal government are you complicit with all of the government's actions? Well sure, but what other option do you have? You could not pay taxes and go to jail, or you could move somewhere else where there isn't an imperfect government--- say Antarctica.

Similarly, what are you going to do if you decide not to work for some "complicit" organization? Move to Silicon Valley and work at a startup? Is that any better? Is there any company that is morally and ethically perfect?

Governments, industries, populations, etc. are all part of an inter-related system called The World. If you think this system is imperfect and should be improved, then exiting the system won't solve anything. Rather, you can work within the system and do what you can to make it better.

mikegagnon··on DC, Maryland: Speed Camera Firms Move To Hide Evidence
By cropping every photo, DC hearing adjudicators should now throw out every alleged traffic violation (regardless of what the photographs purport to show).

It is simple why: 1. "DC hearing adjudicators have been throwing out citations whenever another vehicle was visible, creating the possibility of a spurious radar reading" 2. The accused to do not need to prove their innocence; rather the court has to prove the guilt of the accused 3. It now becomes impossible adjudicators to know if the another vehicle interfered with the radar 4. There is now __always__ reasonable doubt that the accused is guilty (since the camera system always crops photos) 5. The accused should always be found not guilty

It is really a detestable perversion of justice for prosecution to systematically hide evidence.

Why doesn't the prosecution just make their lives easier by throwing out all cases where there are other vehicles in the photo?

mikegagnon··on NSA director heckled on stage at Black Hat security conference
A half hour before the keynote Moxie encouraged attendees to disrupt the talk https://twitter.com/moxie/status/362596265034399746

   "Ubiquitous surveillance prevents millions from speaking 
   freely. BlackHat keynote attendees, let's not let Gen. 
   Alexander speak freely today."
I anticipated the protest to be effective, since black-hat hackers have somewhat of a culture of booing presenters who they morally object to. See for example an undercover reporter that was booed out of DEFCON in 2007. http://www.zdnet.com/blog/ou/undercover-nbc-dateline-reporte...

I think the thing that made this disruption ineffective is the majority of attendees weren't black-hat hackers. They were mostly corporate professionals. See Black Hat's own demographic survey http://www.blackhat.com/docs/bh-us-12/sponsors/bh-us-12-spon...

It's therefore not really surprising that most of the audience wanted to hear the general speak, and was annoyed by the disruption.

If, on the other hand, the general were speaking at DEFCON I think he probably would have been almost unanimously booed off the stage. But the feds are staying away from DEFON this year (for that reason).

So in retrospect, I think the disruption was a miscalculated PR move for the hacker community.

mikegagnon··on Michael Hastings Sent Panicked Email Hours Before Car Crash
The low-level details of exploits always sound like they require a miracle to pull off.
mikegagnon··on [dead]
> Unless you have a real emergency and need assistance, it's best to avoid the police whenever possible, even if you've done nothing wrong.

You are assuming everyone's objective function is to minimize harm to themselves.

If you want to deter the police from using unreasonable force during an arrest, you can do that by filming them.

mikegagnon··on License-Plate Readers Let Police Collect Millions of Records on Drivers
Exactly.

Too often I hear people say "I don't mind personally." But it does affect everyone, since it chills political speech which hurts democracy.

mikegagnon··on Man faces 13 years in jail for scribbling anti-bank messages in chalk
Is the United States becoming less free, or has the US always been like this and I'm just noticing now?
mikegagnon··on The Strange Case of Barrett Brown
I believe a "no contest" plea is a formal declaration of (2). See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolo_contendere
mikegagnon··on Spark: Open Source Superstar Rewrites Future of Big Data
The article discusses the challenge of supplanting entrenched software such as Hadoop. I am actually a bit more optimistic about the ability to swap out Hadoop with technologies like Spark.

At Twitter we don't program using Hadoop directly; we mostly use either Scalding or Pig, languages that compile down to Hadoop code. https://dev.twitter.com/blog/scalding http://www.slideshare.net/kevinweil/hadoop-pig-and-twitter-n...

I believe this is how many other companies use Hadoop as well.

The benefit here is that it's possible to write new backends for Pig and Scalding that compile down to Spark or anything else. And then you have backwards compatibility with all your old big-data code.

mikegagnon··on Containers, Not Virtual Machines, Are the Future Cloud
> There's plenty of reasons why someone might want a virtualized OS; customization.

True, using today's off-the-self software it is easier to customize your environment using full virtualization compared to containers. But it isn't an inherent limitation of the container approach. Containers do however, provide inherent cost savings compared to full virtualization.

I expect that in a short amount of time, usability for containers will continue to improve. See for example docker: http://www.docker.io/

> What if my application is built to run on Debian but yours is built to run on CentOS? With container based virtualization we have to be put on different nodes. With VMs, we can share a node.

With the cost savings afforded by containers, I expect developers will generally choose to write applications that are portable enough to work inside containers.

> This is why VMs exist. This is why they will continue to exist.

Virtualization is popular because it is a feature-rich, economical way to host. Containers are more economical and I expect will win in the end.

mikegagnon··on Ask HN: How do you get a “PhD required” job without a PhD?
Are you an expert in the field? If yes, then apply for the position(s). If you are rejected for lack of Ph.D., then move on. It's not good to work in an organization that values credentials over expertise.

If you are not an expert in the field, then become an expert. One way to become an expert is through a doctoral program. Other ways include self-study, apprenticeship, real-world work experience etc.

mikegagnon··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
I think you should assess and rate your own legal page using the same standards you apply everywhere else. If there is no ToS (as you point out here), you should say that.

If nothing else, it's a usability issue. I assume that tosdr.org has a good ToS, so if I want to see what an A-rated ToS looks like (according to your ratings) I should navigate to your page and your browser extension should tell me.

mikegagnon··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
Awesome idea. This is the first Chrome extension I have ever found worth installing. Thanks!

I think one issue with a service like this, is that your rating of TOS provisions might not match with my own. Which is why it's great that you link your rankings to discussions of provisions and their rating.

mikegagnon··on Terms of Service; Didn't Read
> If you install this extension, you might actually be making yourself MORE bound to crappy terms of service, since you will not be able to make the case that obviously you didn't read them terms and therefore should not be held to some non-standard provision.

I estimate the likelihood of me ending up in court over a TOS violation extremely low. In the history of the Web, how many times has a consumer been the recipient of a lawsuit over a TOS violation?

However, the likelihood is very high that I will encounter TOS provisions on the Web that are objectionable to me. I would like to know what these provisions are, even if I am forced to click accept because I want to use the service anyway.

I am not a fan of maintaining ignorance for the sake of plausible deniability.

mikegagnon··on Don’t Hash Secrets (2008)
The article makes the point that it is insufficient to use good crypto algorithms / implementations. You must also use it correctly.

"A component can only be secure under certain well-defined circumstances, not for any use that happens to look similar."

mikegagnon··on Rand Paul: Big Brother Really Is Watching Us
> One thought is this: how about making it a felony not to disclose information that an agency is clearly violating the constitution.

The obligation to whistle blow is usually an explicit part of "honor codes," such as "I will not lie, cheat, or steal, nor tolerate those who do."

The US military uses this honor code in various contexts, see for example US Navy's Bootcamp http://www.bootcamp.navy.mil/recruits.asp and Officer Candidate Guide, US Army National Guard http://dmna.ny.gov/arng/ocs/forms/ocs_guide.pdf

In practice however, I believe authority usually interprets these honor codes as "snitch on your compatriots when they compromise authority", not "snitch on authority when they compromise your compatriots."

mikegagnon··on US entertainment industry to Congress: make it legal for us to deploy rootkits
When I read those excerpts from this report, I assumed it was written by some extremist lobbying group that doesn't have any real power. Then I read this statement from Congressman Mike Rogers (Chair of CHPSCI, House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence):

“It is already clear to me that this report is going to make a very important contribution to the discussion about the grave danger that IP theft poses to our economic well-being. In particular, all should carefully read what the report has to say about Chinese economic espionage. I heartily agree that Congress and the Administration need to act quickly to help American companies defend the hard work and innovation that is the life-blood of our economy. That must begin with getting cyber information sharing legislation signed into law."

https://intelligence.house.gov/press-release/chairman-rogers...

The report and Congressman's statement came out on the same day.

mikegagnon··on Atari Breakout - Google image search
Plasma Pong was actually what I was thinking of when I wrote my comment. :-) The author of Plasma Pong (Steve Taylor) was my roommate when Atari shut down his game.

As far as litigation is concerned, I would expect that bigger companies would tend to get sued over trademark issues. After all, isn't that where the money is at?

mikegagnon··on Atari Breakout - Google image search
I'm surprised Google made this game under the name "atari breakout." Atari is very protective of their trademarks.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →