12,886 karma · joined February 11, 2019
I've been a programmer, and do have some actual Engineering education(Rose-Hulman, Purdue), but again, I'm not an engineer.
Odds are you aren't either. If you don't have a Professional Engineering License from your state, you're not an Engineer either, and you should stop claiming the title. It's stolen valor!
I'm currently deep into the territory of the crank or lone genius... more than likely I'm just a crank... but hey, I'm retired, and eccentric old man vibes suit me just fine. (I also look the part)
Socials: - bsky.app/profile/mikewarot.bsky.social - github.com/mikewarot - x.com/mikewarot
Interests: Hardware, Open Source, Programming, Research, Science, Technology, Writing, Travel
---
No person should ever have to blindly trust a computer program to do the right thing.
Blog: mikewarot.blogspot.com
I've been programming since 1979. I have made spur, helical, and bevel gears in a job shop setting. I have assembled computers from scratch, selecting clock generators, CPUs, logic gates etc.
I can fix ANYTHING given sufficient time and budget. I've repaired cesium beam atomic clocks, magnetic amplifiers, and an assortment of undocumented industrial control systems.
I've written programs that track equipment inspection, monitor the calibration of large water meters, and control the gluing of cardboard boxes, to name the interesting highlights... I did all of that before 2000.
I was a system administrator for 15 years, as time went on, less and less broke, and they eventually didn't need me.
I made gears for 5 years, bevel, spur, helical, splines, etc. Now I'd like to get back into programming. I did the Advent of Code in 2020, in Pascal... you can see the carnage on my github account: https://github.com/mikewarot/Advent_of_Code_in_Pascal
Currently working on getting BitGrid, a vision of bringing Petflops to the masses, brought into the real world using LLMs to help get past analysis paralysis.
email: chezmike at gmail
The whole hugging face incident could have been completely prevented. The underlying security problem we've faced for the past decade is that Linux/Windows/MacOS, etc are all not fit for purpose in an age of persistent internet connections and mobile code. The only way out is an OS built around default deny instead of ambient authority.
More people need to know what a data diode is, and how to use it, myself included. I've finally got the resources together to start figuring that out, 2 Raspberry Pi B+ computers, the old kind without wireless. The data diode itself is trivial, I'll probably end up with a 6N137 optocoupler between 2 serial ports. The hard part is the proxies for all the protocols, and the digital fountain to spray the data across the connection with ECC.
At this point I intent to do it all in Free Pascal/Lazarus, but I'll suck it up and use C++ if I have to.
You do need to modify it's default exclusions... I lost some movies I shot with my DSLR that way. 8(
The price was low enough that I left it running.
Today I learned about "foldering"[1], which uses the drafts folder of email systems as a "dead drop" between multiple participants. It goes back to at least 2005.
Back when I was in IT, circa 2010, I learned that several of the users of our systems routinely relied on the "deleted items" folder of Microsoft Outlook as a filing system, with multiple gigabytes important files stored there. 8(
Our customs are routinely ignored by everyone else.
That in turn creates the escalation pressure on the nuclear powers that could easily wipe us all out. Given the vast corruption and incompetence of the current duopoly, it wouldn't take much.
Even AI curing cancer with a public domain one shot cure could be the destabilizing force that causes the first tear, then it's game over. 8(
All of this lead to idiots put in charge of the world's second largest, and likely most reliable nuclear arsenal.
Now it's just a matter of surviving 2 more years of idiot roulette.
Given the enormous burn rates that these LLM companies have, surely they could have put everything in an air-gapped network, with some data-diodes proxying out the logging information. It's not rocket surgery. [1,2,3]
I think someone involved in this needs to be prosecuted, the threat of prison time might be a strong enough incentive.
It would also be good if there were legislation requiring that a State Licensed Professional Engineer sign off on the testing systems for LLM training over a given threshold.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JBIR8dKX_UA
[2] https://www.elonx.net/spacex-stories-how-spacex-used-tin-sni...
[3] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19770014245/downloads/19...
I'm retired, with long Covid, so personally, I'm going to be here until I age out, or get kicked out for banging on about data diodes one too many times.
Good luck with your future endeavors.
Since there's no statutory legal liability for the product of one's work, nor state licensure, the term Engineer isn't appropriate, and never has been. (But that's a pet peeve of mine, apparently not shared by the majority here)
You can't easily discuss or legislate things that don't have solid definitions.
It was quite an engaging read, and lead to a series. You'll learn lots about the infrastructure of civilization along the way.
If you burn liquid sodium in steam, you end up with sodium bicarbonate particulate of just about the right size to offset global warming.[2]
[1] https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20250000498/downloads/Re...
A most rational stance. One we should enforce here in the US.
Edit: Yes, I'm arguing that Software Engineer should be a licensed profession, but programmer shouldn't, and would be a fine substitution in the cases where you didn't need rigor.
--
If I were an engineer, there's no way I would trust any interface to a control system for a water purification plant that connected to the internet and allowed for ingress of control. Just as an example.
The OPM hack of 2015[1] is the worst case, in terms of national security, that clearly proves no Engineers were involved in the design of their computer system. Ingress of control should be absolutely prohibited, and it wasn't. I don't know why that database was ever put into a computer, instead of filing cabinets in a vault, nor why it was ever connected to any other system, and not completely air-gapped in said vault, with manual controlled exfiltration of data upon request.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Office_of_Personnel_Manag...
While it's easy to lay this at the feet of AI getting better at hacking. I see it as an primarily an IT issue. We've collectively ignored the lessons of history, and made do with patch jobs over poorly chosen operating systems instead.
--
We need air gaps, data diodes, and capability based operating systems. Now that I'm retired, when I have the energy, I'm working on the data diode part.
This weeks lesson for me, personally, as I try to build an open source data diode, is that the Waveshare RP2350-ETH is a horrible choice for a proxy/data source/sink, as the CH9120 ethernet interface can't do promiscuous mode. It might still be sufficient to build a data diode that can mirror a website, with << $50 component cost. Time will tell.
#1 Hording: If you've got a house full of crap, and you're deeply ashamed of it, you're not going to be having visitors over, ever. You're also not going to mention it on surveys.
We, the American public, have been collecting shit at a prodigious rate. Many of us pay rent for stuff that won't fit in our home. It's why the storage industry is so reliably profitable.
#2 Paranoia: Otis Toole[1] kidnapped then killed Adam Walsh. His father publicised his kidnapping, and fueled a moral panic that sent American parents deep into paranoia. Kids used to be free range, and were often collectively instructed to "go outside to play, and come inside when the street lights come on". After that event, we're afraid to even let them walk to a friends house a few doors over.
The end of the fairness rule, and the rise of fear based media like Fox news certainly didn't help in the rise of distrust.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ottis_Toole#Murder_of_Adam_Wal...
You're burning through Billions of dollars of investment, and you can't be bothered to spend a bit of resources keeping it completely offline?
WTF?
You can start really cheap with just basic hand tools, there are lots of bench size machine tools, like mills and lathes, that come onto the market as their owners age out.
Know that if you do get a mill, lathe, CNC, etc... fixtures, jigs and cutting tools will cost at least as much as the tool itself. All the things like vices, t-slot hold down kits, various milling and lathe bits add up fast.
According to google:
When you assign one dynamic string to another, Free Pascal does not duplicate the actual characters in memory. Instead, both variables point to the same character buffer in the heap, and the runtime increments an internal reference counter. A physical memory copy is only triggered when one of the string instances is modified (written to)
Free Pascal strings are as close as you get to magic, compared to C/C++.
Russel Reynolds taught me the nature of software development. He was the Operations Manager at Will County Generating Station, which burned coal and turned it into power. He saw computers as a tool, and one that had to be as practical and unobstructive as possible. In the 1980s, he sought out hand-held computers for recording the inspections of fire fighting equipment. He tried running them with gloves on, spilling coffee on them, dropping them on the concrete floor. I wrote the software to record the inspections. He'd pull in a person from the staff, back in the day when most people didn't have computers, and explain to them that They weren't being judged, I was, and if anything went wrong it was MY fault, he then told them what he wanted them to do, and I had to watch. I learn huge amounts about software usability in a very compressed timeframe.
Jack Woermbke taught me that you don't every upgrade software unless you actually have to. He taught me you only change one thing at a time, so you can actually know what broke things, or fixed them.
The folks at Live Marketing taught me how tradeshows work, how marketing works, and how to keep folks who have to use computers happy and productive.
Norman Teiber taught me how to make gears, and gear shaped objects, of all sorts at his job shop, Allied Gear, sold in 2019.
My friend Jim has shown me how to repair old radios, test equipment, and the like. We've repaired TVs from the 1940s, Test Equipment and ham radios of all vintages, and even a few Cesium Beam atomic clocks.
Jim Hoover from Fermilab taught me that the world isn't as it seems, you can't just take the news at face value, back in the early 1990s.
The bevel gear generator setup was some formula calculations running in version 1 of TK!solver, which would have been a $5000 upgrade to get the latest version, so they ran them under MS-DOS in DOSbox, and saved the grief.
Without that software, they would have to pay Gleason $500+ to do the calculations for each new gear setup.
There are strong and reasonable reasons to keep very old systems alive in offline production environments.
That's news to this progressive from Indiana, a deep red state.
Interesting screed, but I mostly don't buy it.
I'm deeply thankful for DanG and the other moderators who keep the noise down, and actively push to keep discussions from bogging down in AI slop, cheap posts, and off topic rants.
= magical equals, which maintains the relation for the rest of the runtime
note: once you use it on a variable, you can't redefine it later, that's an error
:= normal assignment, which only fires once
The demo was pretty fun to watch.[1][1] http://web.archive.org/web/20201014024057/https://www.youtub...
The customer asked "what happens if I disconnect this right now?" during the upload. It was a corner case I hadn't considered. It only took a few days to make it bulletproof.
---
The authors don't seem to consider the case of very slow or intermittent Internet.
I'd be worried about corruption in the download, and check for that. I'd also make very sure the watchdog hardware was on and the code respected it.
It seems to me you need 3 buffers for the OTA code, not 2. There should be a way to keep the last version that runs for X seconds in addition to any new updates, where X is quite large, perhaps a whole day.
38400 bits per second, 8 bits per character, no parity, 1 stop bit