HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mildmotive

265 karma · joined October 11, 2021

submissionscomments
mildmotive··on Apple kills plans to scan for CSAM in iCloud
How is having a hash-based scanner a step forward for privacy compared to not having one?
mildmotive··on Spotify CEO renews attack on Apple after Musk's salvo
> You can always Jailbreak your device?

No, you can’t. Apple has tight control over what gets installed on the iPhone, all the way throughout the boot chain.

Jailbreaking is about finding vulnerabilities to somehow acquire root, and many times exploits are not persistent after a reboot. The keyword here is “vulnerability”, something that Apple is eager to patch using security as an excuse, which is hard to argue against. But Apple could provide its users the ability to flash their devices with a warning that if they do, they’re on their own, but Apple wont do that for the aforementioned reasons by countless people in this thread! They are locking down the platform on purpose, and neither privacy nor security are adequate excuses.

Jailbreaking shouldn’t be a thing, because users shouldn’t be living in jails, they should live in fortresses.

Jailbreaking is incredibly bad UX. You are forced to use closed source software to “jailbreak” your phone, a jailbreak which may or may not be persistent after reboot. And only if you have the right iOS versions. So users are forced to stay on vulnerable iOS versions and not upgrade and pray to God that a new exploit is made for their version. Because if they upgrade, Apple wont let them downgrade again, which makes the users miss the opportunity of using a newly created exploit. It’s a cat and mouse game, and it makes users more vulnerable to malware.

mildmotive··on “Twitter will be forming a content moderation council with diverse viewpoints”
> They didn’t even make a joke. They just called trans woman a man. It was hate speech, pure and simple.

It’s not a crime nor hate speech to acknowledge someone’s biological sex. That’s what we do in sports and when we select partners for example. Most, if not all heterosexual men would not consider a “trans woman” to be an actual woman. Our way of selecting partners is proof of that. To punish a natural, and biologically based viewpoint that most of humanity hold and follow is tyrannical and unsustainable.

mildmotive··on Privacy and freedom should be the legacy we leave
>Citation needed.

That parents are generally the most trustworthy individuals in a child's life should be common sense. I may not agree with every parent’s ideology or beliefs, but I will stand for their right to have a parental role in their own children’s lives. You seem to believe that this right should be revoked if their ideas on homosexuality don’t align with yours.

>who they interact with

Parents have a responsibility to make sure that their child is not interacting with people who might hurt them, or be a negative influence on them.

>and what ideas they're exposed to

Citation needed. I’m sure religious parents teach their children about homosexuality, they just mention it’s a sin rather than saying that it’s a person’s valid choice. They teach the moral standards that they believe are the truth and will benefit their child.

You want to impose your standards of morality instead, which I’m saying is certainly not within your or the FSF’s right.

>people who homeschool their children are viewed with some suspicion

Really? I’ve never heard this opinion before. Homeschooling is perfectly fine, and parents that I’ve heard do it let their children interact with other children who’re homeschooled as well. They are thought together, at least sometimes.

>they're still people who exist in society - not property

Don’t lie. Don’t straw-man what I said. Parents have many rights over their children, but that does not mean that anybody here is likening them to a watch or a pair of slippers. These sorts of dishonest responses are getting tiresome.

mildmotive··on Privacy and freedom should be the legacy we leave
Because that’s not where children grow up to be socialized into such a lifestyle.
mildmotive··on Privacy and freedom should be the legacy we leave
>Abusive parents also exist. Rather more commonly than pedophiles too, I'll wager.

Saying that “parents can be abusive” isn’t an argument against giving parents in general authority over their children. Generally, parents are the most trustworthy individuals in a child’s life.

Besides, if you widen the definition of abuse enough then you can turn 50% of parents abusive. Lots of deception has been done around the word “abuse” by silently widening the definition and then labeling people abusive to make it seem like they’re something they’re not.

mildmotive··on Privacy and freedom should be the legacy we leave
I’m fairly certain that most “gay teens” don’t come from ultra-conservative households.
mildmotive··on Privacy and freedom should be the legacy we leave
>we ought to respect minors enough to allow them secure and encrypted communications with one another, without the prying eyes of bigoted parents

”bigoted parents”? Who are you refering to, FSF?

It’s the parents’ right to raise their children to adhere to any religious beliefs or ideologies, even those you do not agree with! Regardless, it’s not your job to dictate how parents should raise their children.

Although a relationship of trust and respect of privacy should be established between a parent and their child, this should not be taken to an extreme. The internet can be quite wild, it’s neglectful to let your child consume whatever content they come across and speak to whomever they like. It’s a parent’s job to set healthy limits to these things. This does involve keeping a healthy culture of openness in the home, which contradicts the notion of privacy (from their “bigoted parents”) that you’re advocating children should have.

I am a privacy advocate myself, and am against mass-surveillance by the state. Here is the problem though: pedophiles and groomers do exist. The way we mitigate this problem is not by giving the tyrants more power, it’s by empowering parents by providing them with the tools to limit exposure to these threats. This gives power to the (bigoted lol) parents to filter out the bad and keep as much good as possible.

The companies that are bribing tyrants to partake in the surveillance system should have their leadership thrown in prison. The companies that provide solutions for us to protect our children should be rewarded and praised.

mildmotive··on Moore’s Law is dead – Long live the chiplet
I only partially agree, an interpreted language can act as a hinderance when doing optimisations, for various reasons.

But how we write the code also matters of course.

Furthermore, competency also costs money. I’m not saying this to be mean to people abusing REST calls.

mildmotive··on Moore’s Law is dead – Long live the chiplet
It’s offloading the cost to the customer. It is way cheaper to develop in some famous interpreted language than creating a set of robust compiled binaries. As long as customers can pay up for newer hardware we will keep seeing clunky UIs that can barely handle 20 list items of variable size without noticeable lag on a modern computer.

I don’t even blame the companies for doing this. The benefit to cost ratio of using idk C++ for everything is just too bad.

mildmotive··on The PS5 Has Been Jailbroken
As long as there are poorly regulated countries to dump the e-waste in arbitrary limitations are working just fine.
mildmotive··on Zero Trust SIM
Twitter does lock you out and force you to give them your phone number, even if you technically can register without one. I’ve seen them do so almost instantly after registration.
mildmotive··on Russian airlines ordered to stop selling tickets to Russian men aged 18 to 65
You’re making some good points. But I think the main argument still stands, that we should be careful not to view the Russian people as being all victims.

I concede to what you’re saying about the censorship. However, do note that this can act as an argument for his point as well.

mildmotive··on Russian airlines ordered to stop selling tickets to Russian men aged 18 to 65
The same logic can be elsewhere too, given enough support.
mildmotive··on Russian airlines ordered to stop selling tickets to Russian men aged 18 to 65
I don’t believe that’s what he said. He basically just pointed out that we should be careful not to speak of the Russian people as if they’re all innocent prisoners of this evil regime. It’s not a very accurate representation either.

I’m quoting him: “we are talking about the nation that invaded another country, targeting civilians, raping and murdering”. Did Putin himself do all of this? No, it was a significant part of the Russian people that did. An even larger portion of the Russian people supported these crimes. They (the people referred to here) are not innocent.

Edit: Just as a disclaimer, I do question the 70% stat. I don’t know where that comes from or if such a number can even be reliably acquired given the censorship that’s going on in Russia.

mildmotive··on Apple’s iPhone 14 Redesign for Repair
> Apple strives to do right by its customers, and to be a good company

Meanwhile, millions of people accidentally turn on iCloud without understanding the consequences, due to Apple’s UI decisions.

Apple need to do way more than this to show that they really strive to be good.

mildmotive··on EA announces kernel-level anti-cheat system for PC games
Honestly, I’ve never heard of Escape from Tarkov before, let alone know how they’ve implemented their mitigations.

However, I do believe that we’re able to create an entire subfield within CS just to serve the purpose of implementing server-side anti-cheat if we wanted to. Games companies can implement rather sophisticated solutions to fight this issue more effectively while putting less emphasis on controlling every consumer’s computer. It’s all about what our values are.

mildmotive··on EA announces kernel-level anti-cheat system for PC games
This kind of anti-cheat would contradict the idea of having control over your own computer. It also wont end there in terms of invasiveness.

Instead, they should focus on non-invasive mitigations such as:

- Server-side anti-cheat.

- Pay-once or subscription models to deter cheating.

- Allow gaming coffee shops to authenticate themselves and give their customers privileged access to competitive worlds/instances. Because it’s much harder to cheat at these coffee shops already.

- Shadow-ban repeat offenders or apply punishments without them realising that they’ve been detected.

- Use bulk-banning to avoid giving cheaters a fast feedback loop which would otherwise make them understand what works and what doesn’t.

mildmotive··on San Francisco decriminalizes psychedelics
Sweden needs healthy, sober and clearminded men and women.
mildmotive··on I ran the worlds largest DDoS-for-Hire empire and Cloudflare helped
> As the infrastructure provider for over 20% of all www traffic traversing the internet today, CloudFlare is in a position to enforce it's beliefs on a global scale.

> Who interprets what qualifies as hate speech?

Exactly the issue. We should not give “activists” a free pass on this one. I wonder now which one(s) of them will commit the crime of actually DDoSing KiwiFarms. We probably will never know.

Vigilante “justice” is problematic because it leaves room for people to harm others without proper evidences of wrong doing. Mind you, I’m no way denying that Kiwifarms are reprehensible, but there are people out there claiming that KF is literally causing people to die, which I’m wondering where is the evidence of that? If someone is suicidal, one of the better ways to help them is to (among other things of course) make them understand that they have power over their circumstances by telling them that they are responsible for their actions. Claiming that some internet bullies can cause you to kill yourself is not helpful, nor is it true.

mildmotive··on macOS now scans for malware whenever it gets a chance
Apple preventing “side-loading” is an essential part of controlling the platform, and it’s making them tons of money. Apple wont let go of that, at least not willingly.
mildmotive··on Twitter’s child porn problem ruined its plans for an OnlyFans competitor
> Twitter cannot accurately detect child sexual exploitation and non-consensual nudity at scale

Who would’ve thought?

Well, maybe Twitter will still insist on turning into cyber-pimps. We can only wait and see. In the meanwhile it might be a good time for serious accounts to start moving to other platforms.

mildmotive··on Edible insects role in transmission of parasitic diseases to humans (2019)
>Meat is murder

So are bugs. It’s also worse because you have to kill more of them.

mildmotive··on Housing is at the root of many of the rich world’s problems (2020)
> The only countries that can do something are singapore and china, who are rationally treating housing as a basic need similar to food.

So why are people in China paying hefty loans for apartments that haven’t even been constructed yet? And now due to the housing bubble popping, construction has halted in so many parts of China that there is an epidemic of Chinese people who are refusing to pay their mortgages, and banks are refusing to let go of people’s money because fractional-reserve banking. China sure do have a serious housing crisis that’s arguably worse than that of the west.

mildmotive··on Reverse-engineering a 1960s hybrid flip flop module with X-ray CT scans
> Cloud software then generates a 3-D representation from the X-rays.

Paying possibly hundreds of thousands of dollars for a machine and still not being able to operate it independently of the producer because a significant part of the software is “on the cloud” is not a good thing.

mildmotive··on Vodafone and Deutsche Telekom to introduce persistent user tracking
> I thought the GDPR didn't allow signing away of privacy? Because if it does, then it's utterly useless - every webpage comes with a 100-page terms of service these days.

If that was the case Europeans wouldn’t have been able to use services like Facebook or iCloud.

> In fact the European Court of Justice declared that illegal

For example, Sweden did it shortly after an ISP Bahnhof advertised to its customers that it would not save logs. What seemed at the time to have fuelled this whole thing was mostly entertainment companies pushing these policies against European countries to crack down on piracy. Obviously an unsuccessful project. Many of our politicians traded our freedoms for the sake of the entertainment industry not losing money (supposedly). It didn’t serve its purpose, rather it just gave the government(s) more power over the people.

mildmotive··on Vodafone and Deutsche Telekom to introduce persistent user tracking
I think once you sign a contract with one of these providers you’re basically signing away the rights to your personal information. GDPR wont protect you from state actors trying to spy on the people, but it will allow you to ask a company to delete all personal information about you. The problem is that doing so will effectively end the service for you. If all mobile carriers start enforcing predatory contracts then I don’t know if GDPR will be very effective here.

Something additional will be required to stop this tracking. As it stands right now some European countries have started forcing ISPs to save logs, that’s actually worse. We must make sure that it’s well understood that the public does not want these policies. The public must also deny any party their vote if fixing this is not in their agenda. Politicians are getting away with slowly eroding our freedoms without many people noticing or speaking about it, that has to change. We need to let them know that they have zero support from us if they decide to continue in this trajectory.

mildmotive··on Supreme Court Overturns Roe vs. Wade
The reality is that the vast majority of abortions are not done because of rape or incest.

> smaller proportions of women in 2004 than in 1987 said that having a baby would interfere with their job or career (38% vs. 50%), that they were not mature enough (22% vs. 27%), that their husband or partner wanted them to have an abortion (14% vs. 24%), and that they and their partner could not or did not want to get married (12% vs. 30%). In both surveys, 1% indicated that they had been victims of rape, and less than half a percent said they became pregnant as a result of incest. [1]

The large number of unborn children that have been killed because of them being perceived as an economical burden, or other personal reasons cannot be ignored. But you ignore all this injustice and make it seem like abortion is all about dealing with rape and incest, while these in reality only account for ca 1% of all abortion cases.

I’m saying killed because we still have a large portion of abortions happening in the second (10-15% worldwide [2]) and third trimesters.

The point here is that a woman’s freedom does not override her child’s right to live. But you seem to think otherwise.

[1] https://www.guttmacher.org/journals/psrh/2005/reasons-us-wom...

[2] https://www.uptodate.com/contents/overview-of-second-trimest...

mildmotive··on Whistleblowers coming forth to expose foul play by UST, Terra operators
In my experience it depends on how you open the tweet. When I click Twitter links online, scrolling works. The moment I switch tweet, scrolling becomes restricted again. Trying to scroll through someone’s profile is also very restricted, I can only scroll past maybe 3-5 tweets? I’ve now clarified in my OP that this happens in most cases, but not always.

Yes, it’s PC in my case. On mobile it allows me to scroll through someone’s profile but scrolling through replies to a tweet seems to be limited (a huge “please sign in” overlay is displayed eventually which I cannot close).

mildmotive··on Whistleblowers coming forth to expose foul play by UST, Terra operators
> The truth is that Twitter is public, free

I don’t think that’s completely true.

> easy for everyone to look at

No, it’s not if you want to stay anonymous. If you’re not logged in you can’t scroll all the way down (in most cases). If you try to, it’ll stop you and ask you to log in. As you probably already know, Twitter do require you to give them your mobile number to have an account. If you try to sign up without one, they’ll instantly lock you out of your new account and force you to give them your number.

> easy for anyone to respond to

No, because you cannot reply anonymously and you need an account which is in one way or another linked to your identity. Circumventing this is very difficult for the average person.

> The power of centralization, network effects, easy UI, and low expectations for well structured posts is hard to defeat.

And it can be done while giving the users the ability to stay anonymous, but Twitter doesn’t do that. Twitter wont even let you use RSS, likely because that would prevent them from gathering as much data about you. Twitter may not be as bad as Facebook, but it’s still bad. The fact that people feel like they have to use it to gain an audience is unfortunate. I hope it starts dying out like FB and gets replaced by something that’s more open and less hostile to anonymous users.

Edit: Clarified that scrolling is broken in most cases for unauthenticated users.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →