HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

minikites

2,811 karma · joined December 2, 2011

submissionscomments
minikites··on Illinois Is the First State to Have High Schools Teach News Literacy
>trust in establishment institutions are at record lows

Yes, because one political party in particular has spent 40+ years working very hard to destroy trust in public institutions (you only mentioned private companies, but it's true in general for both). A media literate populace threatens that work. Their motivation for destroying trust isn't to replace it, but to make people think there is no truth, there is no way to determine right from wrong. There absolutely are ways to do these things, it just threatens their views and their power.

>But if you can accept that this is how many earnestly see the world, you don't have to psychoanalyze the comments here and come to a derogatory view of those writing them.

This is why I want media and information literacy to be more widespread, so the general public can understand what is happening and how things have changed since the days of Walter Kronkite. It's why I want education in all subjects to be more widespread and why people arguing against this do not.

minikites··on Illinois Is the First State to Have High Schools Teach News Literacy
I think this is a well informed take on the issue, unlike so many of the other negative comments here that inadvertently prove the need for media literacy classes.
minikites··on Illinois Is the First State to Have High Schools Teach News Literacy
How much bias is already being created by the status quo curriculum? Are you positive this change would make the situation worse?
minikites··on Illinois Is the First State to Have High Schools Teach News Literacy
I'm surprised to see such negative reactions to this effort. Information and media literacy is sorely lacking in the present day USA and we could be doing much more to educate future generations on topics like this to help them make sense of an increasingly complex world of information.
minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
>Pretty sure quality of life is up by pretty much every measure for "low wage workers" both locally and globally.

Wages are stagnant and certainly haven't kept pace with productivity. They can buy more TVs because electronics are cheaper, but costs for basics are going up. Metrics don't capture "having to pee in a bottle" because of work demands.

>You could have made this statement at any point in history, and people might agree with you. If this is the only way it ever has been, why do you think it doesn't have to be this way?

Was it true in 2500 BC that they had the resources to feed everyone on the planet consistently? 1500 AD? We can feed everyone now, yet people go hungry in the wealthiest nation in the world. Has it been true at any point in history since the industrial revolution where we could provide healthcare and advanced education for everyone in an industrialized nation? It works for many of them, but not the wealthiest one. Are we doing everything we can to solve these problems? I understand life is about prioritizing and understanding tradeoffs, but food and healthcare are among the most basic needs for a healthy individual and education is one of the basic needs for a healthy society.

>There is no known solution to ingroup/outgroup tendency, sociopathy or naked self-interest.

So why do we structure society to encourage and reward these behaviors instead of trying to mitigate their effects?

minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
>progress to benefit the vast majority of us who do make it

So what level of sacrifice should be required of those that don't make it? Going back to the AIDS example, government involvement was delayed because of bigotry, because it only affected people who didn't make it. Our economy is currently propped up by low wage workers both locally and globally who aren't making it. We don't do a good job at taking care of the sick and the poor. We're doing a terrible job at taking care of the environment. As you both have said, none of this is new, but it doesn't have to be this way. We know how to solve many of society's problems and we choose not to do so. If the core reason for these things is "human nature" and we shouldn't try to change, I don't think I have the defeatist attitude in that case. My attitude comes from seeing solutions that we aren't even trying to do, not that we -shouldn't- try.

>The good guys are winning, by a lot.

I don't see the good guys winning. The good guys currently have the high score, but the bad guys are on the upswing and scoring points on the good guys, who are just standing around.

minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
>And yet in reality, somehow the world moved towards a much better place despite those things.

It's not "somehow", you're glossing over the very real losses and very avoidable tragedies (fed by bigotry and fear) that happened during the AIDS crisis, which is my whole point. Progress isn't free and by ignoring the real losses and avoidable tragedies we repeat the same mistakes. That's why we have to confront the uncomfortable parts of the past and present. If we only focus on the superficial elements of success and progress, we make problems more difficult to actually confront.

minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
>I do think living with such a negativity bias is very disempowering - and not to mention not fun. I don't mean to be stupid and blindly optimistic (I manage risk for a living among other things) but like I said, living with certainty that everything will be terrible will ruin your life.

I think it only seems overly negative -because- so many people are blindly optimistic and assume things just get better naturally with no action required on our part. That's why I have such a negative outlook, I can envision the immense work we need to do to address climate change (and many other issues) and I'm seeing such a small amount of work being done that it's basically a rounding error. Watching people reject even the small amount of work required to personally address COVID (a free shot) does not fill me with hope that we can make big changes.

>But the world is inherited by those who DO do those things - everything we have, everything we are, everything we're investing in - is there because someone in the past believed that the future is worth the work

I think this is the disconnect between us. The future is worth the work, but we refuse to work on the future. We instead work harder to prop up the unsustainable present.

minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
>Sure, it's possible that THIS is the high point and it'll all go down-hill from here, but that's like being a broken clock - if you think every thing will kill you, you will eventually be right.

It's not about present society being a global maximum, it's about present society being a local maximum. The lessons from history are often that things can and do get worse, sometimes for generations, before improving again later. It is absolutely possible (and I would argue probable) that life will get worse for a long while before improving.

minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
Our society is not structured in a way to value or measure this, our society is optimized for wealth generation and extraction. If a human activity can't be bought or sold, we don't value or measure it. For example, stay-at-home parents aren't accounted for in GDP calculations, but outside daycare providers are, so we structure society to encourage parents to work and pay for daycare instead of staying home.
minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
That's not the typical framing I see, it's usually "government regulations strangling private sector innovation" with the implication that there are no benefits.
minikites··on Life Improvements Since the 1990s
>(barring regulation that forces compromises to product efficacy)

Can you really not think of any benefits of regulation to correct for pervasive market failures?

minikites··on Instagram launches hate-speech 'limits' to hide abuse
So we should involve no humans at all? I think many people are clamoring for something instead of the status quo of nothing.
minikites··on TikTok overtakes Facebook as most downloaded app
There are plenty of arguments and issues with the politics and moderation of Facebook, but TikTok is more simple than Facebook, and it appeals at that level in the same way Instagram does.
minikites··on Google employees who work from home could lose money
>If employers can change compensation at will without employee consent then the employee agreement is truly meaningless and simply a tool for the employer to wield against the employee.

Welcome to the last 40+ years of corporate economics. The only power that employees can have against employers is through collective action. It's unfortunate that most people in tech see themselves as too good for labor unions.

minikites··on Google employees who work from home could lose money
Finding cheaper labor elsewhere further concentrates wealth. The only way to spread out the wealth would be to mandate the same salary across regions.
minikites··on Bring back hydrogen lifting gas
Good point. I remember a science demonstration where lighting a balloon filled with a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen caused a much more violent eruption compared to a balloon of pure hydrogen.
minikites··on Climate change: IPCC report is 'code red for humanity'
>the next Bezos/Musk via climate change technology

We have the technology and expertise now, we just choose not to use it.

minikites··on Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Gulf Stream
>If you create a large pile of government giveaway money but keep energy cheap

Why would we keep energy cheap? The economics of that also needs to change. I agree that we should also raise carbon-intensive energy prices, and do our best to structure it to penalize disproportionate users (e.g. construction costs for massive houses and buildings). I also don't understand how you could "take the money" for improvements like insulation and then still use more energy, unless you just mean fraud in general.

Change also needs to happen at a societal level. We need to tax extreme amounts of wealth, because that wealth came from society, so the burden is on them to help. On a global level, we could also do more to help developing and industrializing nations. Imagine a green version of the Marshall Plan.

minikites··on America is plummeting down the global vaccination league table
>Of course you can, to varying degrees. The farther from cities and the more resourceful you are, the more separate you can get.

Separating yourself physically from other people doesn't make you any less of a member of society, you're just lengthening the umbilical cord.

>Not getting vaccinated does not imply, legally or physically, that you intentionally spread disease. You are jumping to false conclusions.

It does imply that through negligence: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligence#Elements_of_neglige...

We have a duty to other people and other people getting sick through the inaction of an individual's refusal to get vaccinated is an easily foreseeable outcome.

minikites··on Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Gulf Stream
>In many cases, people are not willing to do the theoretically/physically best/most energy efficient solution because it’s much, much cheaper to not.

This is why we need to change the economics of the situation. If we raise taxes on the very wealthy, Jeff Bezos might not get to go to space, but we could insulate a few hundred thousand houses.

minikites··on Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Gulf Stream
>1/3 of emissions come China which has an autocratic leadership accountable neither to its people or the global community.

China is doing proportionally more to combat climate change than we are.

>70% of emissions come from energy consumption. 35% of all emissions is electricity and heat

There are so many "easy wins" here. Better insulation and other end user improvements (e.g. heat pumps), stricter efficiency standards and mandates, carbon taxes on the most polluting industries and generation methods (i.e. make it unprofitable to restart an old coal power plant to mine bitcoin), etc.

>I'm not suggesting to do nothing, but a smug mentality of "people are just not willing to do the obviously right solution because they are stupid" doesn't solve anything either.

There's not an obviously right solution to everything, but there are obviously right solutions to many things, and we are still choosing not to do any of them.

minikites··on Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Gulf Stream
We gave up on the space program after Challenger. We gave up on nuclear power after Chernobyl. We decided that we couldn't solve big problems as a society. Instead, we put that effort into generating wealth for a privileged few, prioritizing the economy above everything else, because we have nothing else.
minikites··on Observation-based early-warning signals for a collapse of the Gulf Stream
>And most of the time, when something does blow up, there wasn’t a clear or unambiguous difference between the thing that blew up, and all the things everyone was screaming about that did not.

History is not a linear function of progress. Conditions can and do get worse for people, sometimes for generations into the future. The stunning progress of the industrial revolution is the anomaly, not the norm.

We're in a car that's breaking down and we're hoping it will be cheaper to fix later if we ignore it now. We're seeing once-in-a-century weather events every few years. Sea level rise is currently impacting coastal communities. It's not going to go away if we ignore it and hope things get better in the future, we have to work on these things now. We've been refusing to make incremental changes for decades, so the only option left is drastic changes, and they're not going to get easier the longer we wait.

minikites··on Giraffes are as socially complex as elephants
Cephalopods are quite intelligent too, there's plenty of intelligence in non-mammals.
minikites··on America is plummeting down the global vaccination league table
>Compulsory getting a government-sanctioned liquid into my body is a completely different topic. "My body my choice" exactly. My part of space-time.

But you can't "choose" to be separate from society, that's my point. The people in question want to refuse vaccination but still participate fully in society, which is not how a societal contract works. If the consequences for not getting vaccinated had more impact on an individual's participation in society, I think we'd see fewer people "choosing" to not get vaccinated, because they would actually face consequences for that choice. Instead, people are able to refuse the vaccine, still participate fully in society, and the consequences are fully externalized onto those who are unable to be vaccinated.

minikites··on Ignoring WHO call, major nations stick to vaccine booster plans
I think it's reasonable to place more of the blame on people who choose not to help (refusing the vaccine) instead of the people who don't have the means to help (unable to get a vaccine).
minikites··on Ignoring WHO call, major nations stick to vaccine booster plans
>if we let the virus spread unchecked in the poorer countries

It's spreading unchecked now in the USA because people are refusing the vaccine. The scenario you describe is absolutely going to happen, but it won't be because of poorer nations, it will be because of selfish people in rich nations.

minikites··on Ignoring WHO call, major nations stick to vaccine booster plans
It's clear that a large portion of the USA will never get vaccinated, so we should be sending our vaccines to people who want them instead of letting them go to waste here.
minikites··on America is plummeting down the global vaccination league table
>The people I know that fear long term effects wear mask religiously and follow safety procedures.

This is not even remotely the common case. Overall, the overlap between anti-mask and anti-vaccination individuals is massive:

https://biomedicalodyssey.blogs.hopkinsmedicine.org/2020/09/...

The core of both is the same: anti-science and anti-society.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →